10 Underrated Albums By Huge Bands

Massive bands, forgotten masterpieces.

Blur The Universal
EMI

Being in one of the world’s biggest bands looks (and almost certainly is) a blast, but it’s actually a lot of work. Gruelling touring schedules, public scrutiny, and most importantly, the need to keep the music coming. You don’t get to be megastars on the back of one or two albums - if you want to reach those heights, you need quantity as well as quality.

So while these bands are beloved by huge crowds the world over, it’s no surprise that some of their music falls by the wayside critically, commercially, or in the test of time. Even universally beloved and famous acts have those records that people just never seem to talk about.

While these rich and famous rockers hardly need an ego boost, it’s worthwhile shining a light on the lesser releases of these major acts. Sometimes they deserve to be elevated to the status of their biggest records; sometimes they even exceed the more frequently venerated material.

Even the best bands are liable to swing and miss sometimes, but these 10 records deserve a little more love, even if the groups themselves are doing just fine, thank you very much.

10. Arctic Monkeys - Humbug

The most impressive thing about Arctic Monkeys - aside from making it big with a name that bad - is their constant evolution. The band could’ve stuck to telling witty tales of being young and foolish, but instead they changed their sound from album to album, arguably culminating with fan favourite AM in 2013.

The albums that took them to that point, though, can sometimes feel forgotten, and that’s most true with 2009’s Humbug. Co-produced by Josh Homme, it’s the band’s first real effort at a proper shake up, and while some fans dismiss it, in retrospect it’s a total success.

It sees frontman Alex Turner at the peak of his powers, wit intact but yet to embrace the kitsch of later releases. “My Propellor” is a great statement of intent, showing off the band’s new weight, and the catchy “Dangerous Animals” culminates the band’s coronation from Sheffield MySpace upstarts to generational rockstars.

It also features some of the band’s best ballads - an underrated part of their game. "Cornerstone", in particular, might be their best written track, lush, lovelorn, biting and funny in equal measure. Cover to cover, it’s one of their best releases.


9. The White Stripes - Icky Thump

Unlike some albums on this list, Icky Thump was both critically and commercially successful on release, winning awards and selling strongly. The underrating of the White Stripes’ swansong has come after the fact.

While Jack and Meg’s duo remains well remembered for their mid-period, their final album rarely tends to get a look in retrospectively, and that’s a shame. The Stripes were running out of momentum after the disappointing Get Behind Me Satan, but Icky Thump pulled things back around at the last.

It’s as raucous as the band have been since their fiery debut, and with a boatload of weird new effects. Jack’s guitar squeals demonically on the title track and highlight "I'm Slowly Turning into You"; on “Conquest” they briefly transform into a Mariachi band with delightful results.

Indeed this is one of their most varied collections, ending on the subdued "Effect and Cause", which closed the book on one of the century’s most influential bands to date. It’s a strong finish and no mistake.


8. Led Zeppelin - In Through The Out Door

By 1978, the unthinkable had happened: it was no longer fun to be in Led Zeppelin. Personal tragedies and substance issues were catching up with the band, and the high tax rate had seen them flee the UK. In Through The Out Door, their final record, isn’t so much a band ending on a high as an increasingly ragged group trying to keep it together.

It’s a maligned album to this end, but often a fascinating one. With Jimmy Page’s addictions increasingly taking hold, the influence of Robert Plant and, particularly, John Paul Jones was far more prominent.

The latter’s virtuoso musicianship was a tool the band always leaned on, and never more than here. He gives the terrific “Fool In The Rain” a winning swing, coupled with a particularly strong vocal turn. "South Bound Saurez" also has Jones in a more prominent than usual position, exhibiting his jazz chops.

There’s plenty of room for more typical Led Zep fare - the Page drones on “In The Evening”, the epic "Carouselambra". The album was a huge seller but received sniffy reviews from those who felt that the group’s time had passed. Really, it had, but this record shouldn’t be dismissed.


7. Outkast - Idlewild

It’s worth acknowledging up front that this is, by some distance, Outkast’s worst album. It’s overly long for the amount of ideas it contains, and struggles to reach the heights that they’ve hit previously. This is Outkast, though, so an incredibly high bar to clear; and even when they don’t clear it, there’s still plenty of interesting stuff.

Idlewild is a companion piece/soundtrack to the film of the same name, but no knowledge of the movie is needed. The album continues the Speakerboxxx/Love Below trend of seeing Big Boi and Andre 3000 increasingly isolated from one another, off doing their own thing.

In Andre’s case, that’s getting increasingly spacey and weird on the charming "Chronomentrophobia", or showing off his pipes on "When I Look in Your Eyes". Big Boi, meanwhile, hones his tight songcraft, collaborating with Janelle Monae on album standout "Call the Law".

The pair do rap together like old times in stretches, but it was clear to fans that Outkast was basically over at this point. It’s an idiosyncratic, ideas-laden note on which to end things, which is totally appropriate.


6. U2 - Zooropa

U2 are a band who’ve been reborn time and again, though not always successfully. Following a downturn at the end of the ‘80s, they resurfaced with the irony-laden Achtung Baby, one of their biggest records. Chasing that vibe, they arched their collective eyebrow up further on Zooropa, to immediately diminishing results.

While Zooropa was then and is now well regarded, its status as a great U2 album has never quite been solidified, which is unfair. Their playful, experimental side comes out on the Edge-led “Numb” and lead single “Lemon”. They’re self consciously weird tracks, U2 doing mock-art pop, but the music’s great, and silly Bono is always better than sanctimonious Bono.

When the irony mask drops, Zooropa is no less great. "Stay (Faraway, So Close!)" may have been the album’s biggest track, but “Babyface” is perhaps its best, a gentle, romantic song the likes of which the band made sparingly, but very well.

Most intriguing, though, is the closer, “The Wanderer”, with lead vocals from Johnny Cash. It’s a dystopian future cowboy song with the ageing country star deadpan and incredibly charismatic, one of the strangest songs in their canon.


5. Blur - The Great Escape

Blur’s fourth studio album was a sensation at the time, hitting platinum sales figures and receiving rave reviews from journos riding the Britpop hype train. Like so much of that movement, though, in the bright light of day many of those fawning over the record took measures to recant, with even frontman Damon Albarn describing it immodestly as one of the only two bad albums in his canon.

And while it’s fair to say the Mockney charm was wearing thin by 1995, its diminished status is unfair. The most Britpoppy tracks - the sneering “Charmless Man”, the ubiquitous “Country House” - are musically bold and always lyrically enjoyable, with Damon Albarn following in the wry footsteps of Ray Davies and Andy Partridge.

More importantly, The Great Escape showcases the band’s restless evolution, with string-laden wonder “The Universal” one of their finest tracks to date, and "He Thought of Cars" a more restrained gem.

It doesn’t capture the zeitgeist like Parklife or hang together like their self titled follow up, and it’s messy in parts, but when it hits, it illustrates a band with a megabudget using it creatively (something longtime foes Oasis would struggle to do on Be Here Now a few years later).


4. Radiohead - The King Of Limbs

We’re admittedly grading on a bit of a curve here. It’s an album by Radiohead; it’s going to be swarmed on by critics and their devoted fanbase alike. By their standards, though, The King Of Limbs was received relatively coolly, criticised in some circles for doing little to take the band’s sound forward.

And, really, they’re right. This wasn’t an expansive, all-encompassing showcase like In Rainbows, nor did it reach the emotional depths of A Moon Shaped Pool. What it did achieve was a greater sense of fun and movement than any Radiohead album before or since.

Their reputation as miserablists is unfounded, but they shuck that off here more than ever. “Morning Mr Magpie” might be the most infectiously danceable song in their oeuvre, and “Lotus Flower” is a club banger by way of some intellectual Englishmen. “Little By Little” features the eerie Thom Yorke croon perfected on Kid A, but with booming bass and a playfulness the 2000 album steered clear of.

While it seldom tops the lists of the band’s best efforts, thanks to its short length and often joyful soundscape, it’s one of the most re-listenable records the band have made to date, even if it’s a relatively shallow experience.


3. Arcade Fire - Neon Bible

If Arcade Fire’s critical stock has fallen a little of late, they remain one of the biggest bands of the modern era. With a sense of destiny and scale, they swiftly transcended the indie landscape and became full fledged megastars with massive songs that fill festival grounds and stadia alike.

Their best record, though, is one of their smaller, and least appreciated. Sophomore effort Neon Bible had a tough act to follow in the universally acclaimed Funeral, and the band made the wise decision to shift things up just enough. The title track, "Windowsill", and “My Body Is A Cage” see the group ditch the anthem-rock for something more mysterious and dark. The former, especially, is a total outlier, a creepy little number that ranks among their best.

This restraint makes the big tracks even bigger. “Intervention” might be their most grandiose song yet, with Win Butler singing at fever pitch over shrill strings and backing vocals. And "No Cars Go" is a real winner, with a sense of momentum and freedom they’d take onto their hugely successful - but far less interesting - follow up, The Suburbs.


2. R.E.M. - Up

Debate rages on as to when R.E.M. passed their peak, but a common marker is the departure of drummer Bill Berry. It’s fair to say things were never the same without the original quartet, but the final years of the Georgia band yielded some great results, most notably this inaugural Berry-less offering.

Up is a strange record in the band’s varied canon. With their drummer gone, they made the smart decision not to rush his replacement, instead implementing drum machines and relatively percussion-lite tracks. The ethereal “You’re In The Air” and ambient opener “Airportman” are the clearest departures.

There are tracks that fit with the classic sound, though. The impossibly catchy “Lotus” could fit the glam-grunge vibe of Monster, and “Daysleeper” is up there with the best lush R.E.M ballads.

The sound would get gradually more pedestrian as the band reached their twilight (though they never made an outright duff album), but the decline doesn’t start here - it’s a curious gem made out of necessity.


1. The Rolling Stones - A Bigger Bang

When you reach 40 years and counting and are solidified as all time greats, as The Rolling Stones were in 2005, you’re not expected to deliver a great deal on your new album. Look like you’re making an effort, and it’ll be applauded by an audience of a certain age, at least.

With A Bigger Bang, though, the Stones went above and beyond. Or rather: they went backwards, giving up the attempt to chase a modern sound and reverting to their rock ‘n’ roll best. The likes of “Rough Justice” and "She Saw Me Coming" fit in with peak material, playful, swaggering, hard edged blues played brilliantly.

Better still, though, are the ballads. “Streets Of Love” was a reasonable hit at the time, and third single “Biggest Mistake” is a great country crooner. While the record falls down compared to their late ‘60s/early ‘70s run, it apes the tricks of their best LPs, mining a lot of variety from a small selection of genres and influences.

The Stones have seldom been a particularly experimental band, but by sticking resolutely to what they know works and upping the songcraft quality, they produced a remarkably good album this late in a career.


In this post: 
Blur
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)