10 Viral Metal Bands That Didn't Stay Popular
Becoming a viral sensation requires a lot of luck, but staying relevant requires even more skill.
In the modern era of music, every new band and artist prays for *something* about their image or sound to go viral. It's a phenomenon which transcends all styles and genres, with sightings being dramatically exacerbated in more recent years, owing to the market domination of playlist culture. Reviews from last year’s Reading Festival even noted how the crowd for Willow dramatically slimmed down following her performance of megahit “Wait a Minute!”, with punters otherwise unaware or uncaring of the rest of her output.
While alternative music fans are traditionally more accustomed to album listens, it does not mean we are innocent of condemning a band to obscurity after getting our 15-minute fix of enjoyment (or 15 seconds if it’s Tik Tok).
After breaking into the zeitgeist with an eye-catching gimmick or song, the following groups tried to ride their momentum into the dream career of world-domination, and take their sound to the four corners of the globe. However, the inconvenient truth is success of that level is but for a chosen few, and after their time in the sun, these artists either clung on via the nostalgia market, becoming a life-long festival line-up filler, or were condemned to obscurity, and eventually fizzled out altogether.
10. Van Canto
German power metal outfit Van Canto made headlines in the late 2000s, thanks to their notable line-up of one instrument across seven members.
The group instantly became a roadie’s wet dream as they backed a single drumkit with a cappella vocals – which they would dub “rakkatakka”. The unique instrumentation grabbed everyone’s attention, possessing a definitive “seen to be believed” quality, which they then immediately combined with the alt music fan cheat code of “play the classics but do it weird”.
Breaking ground with their covers of Metallica, Manowar, Nightwish, Iron Maiden and more, Van Canto polarised sturdier metalheads purists. Still, they refused to be deterred and struck while their iron was hot, releasing four albums in five years to relatively decent responses from critics and fans at each venture (though it’s hard to properly gauge as 2008’s Hero scored both a 95% and a 0% on Metal Archives).
With the novelty waning away, Van Canto settled into the European festival scene, making a multitude of appearances at Wacken Open Air, Masters of Rock, and a trip overseas as part of 70,000 Tonnes of Metal. Their latest album, To the Power of Eight, was released quietly in 2021.
9. King 810
Do you like sadness in your music? Think emo bands like The Menzingers are too sappy? If so, then here's the band for you! Emanating from the upsettingly mistreated town of Flint, Michigan, King 810 are the nu metal/hardcore outfit that blew up in 2014, thanks to a sound and demeanour that drew more than one positive comparison to nu metal icons Slipknot.
Signing to mega-label Roadrunner on the back of a single EP, King 810 genuinely felt and sounded dangerous. With harrowing lyrical content cowled out by frontman David Gunn, along with a reputation for violent live performances, a bloodthirsty cult-like following, an affinity for guns, and a general disdain for authority, they were ferocious, without falling too far into cringe. Well, at least at first…
After the release of their sophomore album, King 810 slowly became something of a parody of themselves, with some fans and critics negatively noting their one-string bow of lyrical content and questioned whether their storied experiences about Flint were even legitimate.
Since they quietly split from Roadrunner in 2018, the group has continued mostly as a duo of Gunn and multi-instrumentalist Eugene Gill. The pair have had a steady stream of releases in the years since, including the brilliant follow my tears EP in January 2023.
8. Apocalyptica
Symphonic music and heavy metal are no strangers to each other at all. Some of metal’s biggest names have enhanced their sound with symphonic swells and stringed daliances, from Cradle of Filth, to Metallica, to Devin Townsend, to Dimmu Borgir, and beyond. Arguably though, no one has ever quite blended chamber music and heavy metal quite like Apocalyptica.
The Metallica-loving Finns first burst onto the scene with their collection of covers in the mid-'90s, gaining attention for their exclusively-cello sound. One person in particular who got drawn into the allure of Apocalyptica’s sound was famed Slayer/Fantômas drummer Dave Lombardo, who began collaborating with the group for their 2003 album Reflections.
This in turn sparked the idea to add a permanent drummer, which eventually came in the form of Mikko Sirén, and together, the group forged the path for themselves, collaborating with some of rock and metal's biggest names at the time in Corey Taylor, Till Lindemann, Ville Vaio and Adam Gontier among others.
The four-piece has slowed right down in the past decade, releasing three albums since 2010 and opting to revert back to a fully instrumental sound for their 2020 album Cell-0. They have also play the role of featured guest themselves, popping their heads in for the likes of Simone Simons, Sabaton and Darude.
7. The Native Howl
Another group to take two genres that probably shouldn’t go together and putting them together anyway, The Native Howl sought to bring together bluegrass and thrash metal for their 2016 banger "Thunderhead".
While you might cynically mistake their sound as bluegrass country but with double-kick drums, the union was something of a hit online, worming its way through YouTube and Facebook algorithms. They would self-coin their sound with the groan-inducing label “thrash grass”, a term which itself has spawned a micro-scene of its own, with the likes of DaysNDaze, Blackbird Raum, and Mischief Brew all being associated with the term. TNH then doubled down on the new micro-genre, with it becoming the namesake for their 2016 album.
Despite that initial early promise and multiple wins at the 2017 Blue Water Music Awards, you'd be forgiven for thinking the COVID years have been uneventful for the Leonard, Michigan natives. However, they in fact resurfaced in 2022 on the TV show No Cover, winning season one and a contract with Sumerian Records, meaning that The Native Howl is now labelmates with the likes of Slaughter to Prevail, Poppy, Animals as Leaders, and Between the Buried and Me.
The thrash grass revival scene is going to hit very different.
6. DragonForce
Icons of Guitar Hero 3, with the completion of their song “Through the Fire and Flames” being a sign of social hierarchy in schools, power/speed metal powerhouses DragonForce blew everyone away with the intricate noodling of duelling axemen Sam Totman and Herman Li.
As their legend grew, so too did their fortunes, with the band capitalising on their momentum and earning themselves a Grammy Award nomination for their 2008 album Ultra Beatdown, before going on to rerelease their first and second albums Valley of the Damned and the very brilliant Sonic Firestorm.
However, the band could never quite reclaim the same level of excitement brought by “Through the Fire...”, with the post-Ultra Beatdown years proving to be a whole new uphill battle for the band. Rumours began circulating that Li and Totman could not actually play their iconic hit (spoilers: they could), and their enigmatic frontman ZP Theart left the band in early 2010.
With their reputation bruised and a key part of their puzzle gone, the band’s recovery to get to 2023 has been its own success, with Marc Hudson joining the fray as vocalist and the group battling to become a reliable source of fun yet ludicrous power metal, in spite of the genre's popularity being in the bin in 2023.
5. Max Raptor
In 2011, Wandsworth teenager Barney Hall wrote into Kerrang! magazine one day, singing the praises of the then-recently released debut mini-album from Max Raptor – Portraits. The gesture won over the Max Raptor ultras, with the news quickly travelling to frontman Wil Ray, who in response pitched the idea of playing a show at young Mr. Hall’s home.
This was a mistake on Wil’s part.
Meeting the requisite and legally-binding parameter of 1,000 Facebook likes – thanks to significant backing by Kerrang!, Rock Sound, and an over-excited podcast fan page – Max Raptor did indeed play a live-streamed show direct from Barney’s bedroom, much to Wil’s clear chagrin.
Following the buzz of Portraits and the bedroom show, the group were a pretty hot commodity in the UK underground, scoring a support slot for Dinosaur Pile-Up, plus appearances at Y Not and Hit the Deck Festivals, before capping things off with the excellent full-debut effort Mother’s Ruin in 2013.
Despite all this though, the group couldn't break through that glass ceiling, and momentum eventually fizzled out for the act, with 2016’s self-titled effort suffering from a rather subdued response. A lonely social media post in August 2018 proclaimed a new album was in the making, but it has been radio silence from the band ever since.
4. Attack Attack!
Purveyors of the oft-maligned crabcore meme, Attack Attack! became the poster boys for the emerging American electronicore movement from the late 2000s; a polarizing scene that gave us The Browning, I See Stars, and Palisades, while the rest of the world contributed Electric Callboy, Crossfaith, and Enter Shikari. To say there were levels to this would be an understatement.
Attack Attack! were the talk of the town for a few years on the back of their debut, Someday Came Suddenly, bringing with them future Beartooth flag-runner Caleb Shomo and the ever-controversial future Of Mice & Men frontman, Austin Carlisle. The lead single for the album - “Stick Stickly” - would produce the parodical crabcore meme thanks to the group's very unique play style, which was somehow more ridiculous than the versions sported by blessthefall's Craig Mabbitt and Immortal's Abbath in the years prior.
It was a downhill slope for the band following the debut, with a revolving door of talent passing through the group, resulting in their breakup in 2013. However, AA! OGs Andrew Whiting and Andrew Wetzel revived the band in 2020, releasing tracks that have mashed together electronicore, J-pop, country and post-hardcore, which your writer can confirm is as bad as you think it is. The return EP, Dark Waves, was released in March 2023.
3. Issues
As eluded to previously, Attack Attack! were the catalyst for a wave of electronicore bands at the turn of the decade, with the movement quickly devolving from a ‘scene’ to ‘landfill’, much in the same way as mid-2000s indie. As we were wiping our hands clean of the genre though, a new fighter entered the fray in the form of Atlanta, Georgia's Issues.
Initially something of a phoenix-band for former Woe, Is Me members, Issues upset purists the world over with their infectious mix of metalcore, nu metal and R&B, spotlighted by clean vocalist Tyler Carter. The Black Diamonds EP in 2012 was wildly praised for Carter’s vocals, and the subsequent duality against the band’s heavy musicianship, which continued in the 2014 self-titled debut album.
The follow-up “acoustic” EP, Diamond Dreams, marked the beginning of the end in Issues’ musical quality. 2016’s sophomore album Headspace proved forgettable, and was followed by the departure of harsh vocalist Michael Bohn in 2018. While 2019’s Beautiful Oblivion teased an interesting direction, leaning more on neo-soul elements, Carter was booted from the band the following year, following serious accusations levied against him.
Since then, the band has been in stasis, with bassist/vocalist Skyler Acord now working as a live bassist for Twenty One Pilots and Woe, Is Me (sans Carter) reforming in 2022.
2. Okilly Dokilly
Okilly Dokilly was the Ned Flanders-inspired band formed in 2015 that sang The Simpsons lyrics to noisy electronicore - excuse me - to Nedal. All pretty standard stuff so far, right?
Their lead single and the song that kickstarted the hype for this absurd project was “White Wine Spritzer”, showcasing the respective Neds that came in all shapes and sizes – Red Ned, Stead Ned, Thread Ned, Bled Ned, and most appropriately of all, the ringleader Head Ned.
The song was fun enough and it’s easy to see why the act got popular, with major outlets such as Metal Injection and Alternative Press taking notice. The debut album Howdilly Doodilly wasn’t exactly an AOTY contender, but the occasional catchy lyric gave the project some validity (how else are you going to scream “nothing at all” over a breakdown?). Ultimately though, it did have a short creative lifespan.
An uneventful second album, an unsteady line-up, and touring plans ravaged by COVID led to the band folding in 2022. Before they left though, Okilly Dokilly attempted a Guinness World Record for ‘Most People Dressed Like Characters from The Simpsons in One Place’, and got a feature on The Simpsons itself, appearing in the end credits of the 2019, Season 30 episode, ‘I'm Just a Girl Who Can't Say D'oh'.
1. Nekrogoblikon
A symphonic melodic death metal group “fronted” by a goblin mascot who – in their debut music video – tries to impress a pornstar and ultimately slaughters his jock rival. Small wonder that this went viral.
But viral it went, and the world was introduced to California comedy metal band Nekrogoblikon, who are indeed “fronted” by John Goblikon the goblin. Mr. Goblikon was initially brought in as a one-off for the song “No One Survives”, taken from the 2011 album Stench, where yes, he plays a stereotypical high school dweeb who has a crush on the cute cheerleader and gets bullied by the captain of the football team. But after the aforementioned sensation that the music video became, he has since stuck around to be the mascot and quasi-hypeman for the band’s live performances, and is a regular in the group's music videos.
In the meantime, Nekrogoblikon have made the most out of their overnight success, launching their own music label and establishing working relationships with the likes of frequent Diplo collaborator Brandon Dermer, and Metalocaplyse/Dethklok creator Brendon Small. Their zany musical antics have continued too, writing a song about a giraffe in space, got self-referential for a song about trying to find a gimmick, and released their latest album The Fundamental Slimes and Humours in 2022.