13 Problems Only The Smiths Fans Will Understand

These charming men.

There's no doubt about it: The Smiths are one of the greatest bands of all-time. Though they produced just four albums over the course of their relatively short time together, the impression that they left on the musical world - and their fans - proved incalculable. Fronted by that iconic and infamous crooner known only by his last name, Morrissey, and powered melodically by the legend that is Johnny Marr, The Smiths crafted four of the best albums of the 1980s across a period of near immaculateness. If you happen to be a fan of The Smiths, chances are that you don't take it lightly: there are few "casual fans" associated with this particular band; Smiths fans tend to give themselves up to the cause entirely, dedicating countless hours to the music, picking apart the deft lyrics, looking for hidden meanings, depths and - yes - new jokes. Morrissey's idiosyncratic lyrics - backed by Marr's gorgeously memorable tunes - rendered the Smiths as a kind of eternal gift. As is the case with being a fan of pretty much any band, being a Smiths aficionado comes with its own set of positives and negatives - not to mention a sense of sheer "elitism" for those folk who have given their entire lives to Morrissey and everything and anything he stands for (not recommended). To understand the 13 things mentioned in the following article, then, you'll have to be well acquainted with the band, its personnel, and their phenomenal discography... True fans, onwards...

13. The Best Songs Aren't Always On The Album

Though The Smiths are renowned for their near-on perfect musical canon, having produced - arguably - four flawless albums in the space of four short years, it might come as something of a surprise to lesser fans that some of the band's greatest and most iconic songs aren't actually contained on said albums; The Smiths relished the act of releasing certain singles away from the constraints of their main albums. Which means that classic tracks such as "Heaven Knows I'm Miserable Now," "This Charming Man," "How Soon Is Now?," "William, It Was Really Nothing," "Panic," "Ask" and "Shoplifters of the World Unite" weren't actually included as tracks on any of their four major works. They were released individually, as singles, and were later collected up in various compilation albums (such as Louder Than Bombs). Insane!

12. Being Annoyed When People Say The Smiths Are "Miserable"

One of the most commonly irritating things about being a fan of The Smiths stems from the fact that people who aren't all that familiar with the band's music tend to think that they're an inherently depressing bad. There's a strange connotation that the uninitiated seem to rally around: Morrissey is sad, and lonely, and melancholic, and everything he sings about is sad, lonely and melancholic as a result. That simply isn't so. The music of The Smiths is, in fact - for the most part - hilarious. Sure, there are a few sad numbers ("I Know It's Over," to name one) - as you'd expect from any band - but there are nowhere near as many as the nay-sayers would have you believe. The majority of Smiths songs are ironic, snarky and jovial ("Frankly Mr. Shankly"/Girlfriend In A Coma"), whilst the rest are generally upbeat, cheerful and life-affirming.

11. The Names Of Andy Rourke & Mike Joyce

Even casual fans of The Smiths know who Morrissey is, and most people are probably well aware of Johnny Marr. Only true Smiths fans, however, will have bothered to learn the names of bassist Andy Rourke and drummer Mike Joyce - the two unsung heroes of the band, both of whom are rarely afford the credit they deserve. After all, The Smiths wouldn't have been The Smiths without these guys. Bassists and drummers are usually written off - no matter how famous a band they're in; think of poor Ringo - as inessential additions when compared to the people who sing and play lead guitar. But Rourke and Joyce's contributions to The Smiths are particularly noteworthy, given that they developed the music and rhythms - alongside Johnny Marr - in the studio to assure that unforgettable Smiths sound.

10. Who Craig Gannon Is

The Smiths Craig Gannon Did you know that The Smiths had a "second guitarist?" If you happen to be a true fan of the greatest alternate rock band of the '80s, chances are that you did. His name? Craig Gannon, the guy who temporarily found himself as part of the band's iconic line-up during a particularly turbulent period. Gannon, in case you care, was involved with two bands - Aztec Camera and The Bluebells - prior to his work with The Smiths. So how did he end up as a sort-of member of The Smiths, reduced now to that of a mere pub quiz question? The strange little incident occurred when Andy Rourke was fired from the band and Gannon was hired to fill his position as a bassist. Two weeks later, Rourke was back in, and Gannon - kind of unnecessary now - was kept around as second guitarist. He played on a number of famous tracks, including "Panic" and "Ask," and even toured with the band for a bit. By 1986, he was gone. Kind of harsh, but at least he got to be one of The Smiths for a while. Not many can say that.

9. What "Frankly, Mr. Shankly" Is Really About

One of The Smiths' most inherently funny songs, "Frankly, Mr. Shankly," appears - on the surface, at least - to be a work of pure fiction, chronicling the turbulent relationship between a bitter young man and his money-grabbing boss. But unlike some of the more ambiguous Smiths' songs, "Frankly, Mr. Shankly" actually served as a sarcastic tirade against a real-life person - somebody who was making Morrissey's life a misery. True Smiths fans will know, then, that "Frankly Mr. Shankly" was conceived as a means of poking fun at then-head of Rough Trade Records, Geoff Travis. Morrissey, ever the comedian, penned the lyrics to address the rubbish deal that the band had with the company. The lines "I didn€™t realise you wrote poetry/I didn€™t realise you wrote such bloody awful poetry" referred to Travis' insistence of showing Morrissey his own naff poems.

8. Never Settling On A Favourite Album

If you're a Beatles fan, you probably know which of their many fantastic albums is your favourite. Same for fans of The Rolling Stones, or The Who, or Pink Floyd. But with The Smiths, it's a little more difficult. As all diehard fans will know, each one of the band's four albums are - in their own way - pretty perfect. There's no filler; there's nothing notably unnecessary inherent to the entire album canon. Which is another way of saying: it's impossible to pick your favourite. As it stands, then, most Smiths fans will find themselves on an endless cycle of changing their minds with regards to their favourite of the four. One day it'll be The Queen Is Dead for sure, whilst the next it's almost certainly Strangeways, Here We Come. But what about Meat Is Murder? Isn't that the best? Then again, it's hard to argue with the sheer brilliance of their debut. You might as well not bother thinking about it.

7. That The Majority Of Morrissey's Solo Stuff Is Actually Great

There's a tendency for lesser Smiths fans to write off all the stuff that Morrissey did when the Smiths ceased to exist as a matter of principle: surely Morrissey couldn't have written anything good without Johnny Marr to inspire him? But a true fan of The Smiths - and indeed of Mozza - will have likely approached Morrissey's solo career with an optimistic attitude. The truth is, of course, that the majority of his post-Smiths stuff is fantastic. Which true Smiths fan could really deny the brilliance of albums like "Vauxhall and I" or "Your Arsenal?" Of songs as memorable and replayable and wonderful as "Suedehead" or "Every Day Is Like Sunday?" Truth be told, Morrissey went about creating some of his best ever work in the wake of the band's disintegration. Even if his newest stuff hasn't been all that great, the early to mid '90s saw him working at the peak of his songwriting powers. Really.

6. That "Oscillate Wildly" Isn't That Bad

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6rIPcbJ7jBw "Oscillate Wildly" is one of a very small number of Smiths tracks that tends to get a bad rap from lots of folk because... well, it's just this strange, contextless little instrumental - one that is neither memorable nor offensive. It's just there. It doesn't feature any vocals by Morrissey. It doesn't really even sound like anything Johnny Marr would write. It's odd. The title of the track is an obvious play on words regarding Morrissey's favourite writer and personal hero (Oscar Wilde, in case you missed that one for some reason), which is probably the most interesting thing about the whole track. Still, lots of casual Smiths fans tend to write this off as some kind of horrific abomination intent on spoiling the Smiths canon. In reality, it's not even worth getting all that worked up over. A true fan knows that Oscillate Wildly is just fine. Fine.

5. That "Golden Lights" Is The Smiths' Worst Song

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=idM2F62BbaA Every Smiths fan - of both casual and diehard varieties - share a mutual dislike of one song by their most beloved band. In fact, it might just be the only truly skip-worthy song that The Smiths ever put out. Heck, it almost certainly is. "Golden Lights," then, is actually a cover of a song by Twinkle, recorded at Morrissey's request because... well, because he's Morrissey, isn't he? But this was entirely unnecessary, and is actually kind of pretentious. It's also sort of unlistenable, in the sense that no Smiths fan - in their right mind - would actually sit through this song more than once. There's just no need, given how awesome everything else that the Smiths produced in their short time together is. Why waste your time with a cover of "Golden Lights" when you could listen to "Reel Around the Fountain" for the seventy-seventh time instead? You just wouldn't. You wouldn't.

4. Not Knowing Whether To Defend Morrissey Or Deride Him

Morrissey is outspoken and sometimes it seems as though he sets out to say controversial things on purpose. Indeed, the man can lay claim to some of the most outlandish quotes of the past century, all of them primed to provoke cries of "What?!" Choice cuts include: "You can't help but feel that the Chinese people are a subspecies" and "I wish that Prince Charles had been shot. I think it would have made the world a more interesting place." C'mon, Morrissey! Granted, Morrissey wouldn't be Morrissey if he didn't go about saying things like that - and indeed, he has been laying claim to such verbal obscurities for near-on twenty years - but sometimes it can be... well, a little annoying. As far as Smiths fans are concerned, it goes like this: on one hand, he's an icon and a musical genius; a true unique, if ever there was one. And on the other hand... well, he's slightly insufferable. It's a very confusing position to find yourself in.

3. Old-Fasioned Cultural References Are A Must

Morrissey's lyrics are, above all, uniquely realised. The way that Mozza compiles lyrics is both highly strange and yet innately beautiful at the same time: essentially, he builds poetry around bits and pieces that he's heard, read or seen, either in other songs, famous works of literature, or on old TV shows or in classic movies. But it's the literary references that form the heart of Morrissey's lyrics - especially when he purposely misquotes them or turns them inside out. The literary references in The Smiths' songs ensure that they are incredibly dense; there is arguably no other band in the history of music whose tracks echo the classic works of literature to the extent The Smiths do; it's almost as if Oscar Wilde accidentally found himself transported through time to the '80s, and somehow found himself fronting an alternate rock band. As a result, the band's songs feel opaque in the best possible way, each one a treasure trove.

2. "Please, Please, Please Let Me Get What I Want" Is 1 Minute, 53 Seconds Of Utter Heaven

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eu4k5sTzxIw Granted, you don't even have to be a fan of The Smiths to understand why "Please, Please, Please Let Me Get What I Want" is a gift from the musical gods. Coming in at just under two minutes, this song almost strikes you as being a tad short at first - but then it sinks in, and you realise it needn't be longer. So this might well be the most beautifully rendered pop song ever written (that's right - it's a pop song!), and certainly ranks up there with the likes of "God Only Knows." The fact that it was originally released as a B-side seems like pure blasphemy in retrospect; it's beautiful melancholy is unparalleled. As Alex Kapranos of Franz Ferdinand once said: "It makes the hairs on the back of my neck stand up, probably the best reaction you can get from any piece of music." Fans of the Smiths wouldn't argue with his take on the song - no matter how many times you listen to this, its power never diminishes.

1. Why They Can Never Get Back Together

Some things are best left alone. The Smiths, with their near-perfect and beautifully concise little discography, are one of those things. Sure, the world would pretty much collapse onto itself if Morrissey and Johnny Marr ever announced that they'd let bygones be bygones and were going to reunite for a tour or a one-off gig, but even the truest of Smiths fans knows - deep in their hearts - that it just wouldn't be the same. The fact that the band haven't played together for over twenty years only adds to their iconic and legendary status - for them to pull a Fleetwood Mac would reduce some of the stature that they've gained over the years for resisting the temptation to play a few shows for the sake of some added cash, or getting back into the studio to record a load of forgettable, sub-par material, for lack of anything better to do. Would it be momentarily brilliant? Probably. Does that make it right? Absolutely not. Like this article? Are you a Smiths fan and do you relate to any of these points? Let us know in the comments section.

Contributor

Sam Hill is an ardent cinephile and has been writing about film professionally since 2008. He harbours a particular fondness for western and sci-fi movies.