15 Greatest Emo Albums Of All Time
Music to cry to.
Emo music, like its oft-derided fans, is frequently misunderstood. To the layman, it is something to be scoffed at, all eyeliner and self-harm, skinny jeans, bad poetry, lip rings and teenage tantrums.
All that stuff is important, of course, but there’s plenty more to the genre than that. From its roots as an offshoot of hardcore to its early 2000s heyday and inevitable backlash, then a retreat back to the cult underground, emo has been through enough trials and tribulations, moments of triumph and tragedy to inspire, well, a great emo song.
With more than three decades of history, emo has changed and evolved, built cultures and sub-cultures (and probably sub-sub-cultures), and flirted with the mainstream. It has also produced some extraordinary music.
Emo inherently lends itself to the album format, a chance to explore feelings at length, to wallow and grieve. The best of them conjure a mood which can transport us to days of adolescent anguish, or help us through contemporaneous woes. For all that the genre’s sincerity can be a little silly, a little embarrassing, at its best, it’s transcendent.
15. Panic! At The Disco - A Fever You Can’t Sweat Out
One of the most theatrical and outre groups the genre ever produced, Panic! At The Disco had no intention of being ignored when they burst onto the scene in 2005. The album was - and probably still is - divisive, with some emo veterans decrying the state of things that would allow a band so performative to thrive.
That’s all grist to the mill for Panic!, though, whose outsider status was played up to the max with a deliciously contrary album that flaunts just about every convention of the genre. With unconventional song structure, heavy use of electronic instrumentation, and even subtle autotune, this flew far too close to outright pop for the purists. The songs can’t be denied, however, with the camp spookiness of “I Write Sins Not Tragedies” surely one of the greatest hits the scene has ever produced, and “Camisado” a heady blend of old school angst and electronic blare.
The fey playfulness was off putting to some, but Panic!’s debut has earned its status as a classic album. They would later prove that their hearts lay with pop, but their emo credentials are hard to argue.
14. The Get Up Kids - Something To Write Home About
An explosion of energy from the off, The Get Up Kids’ second album is the soundtrack to a group of young men finding out that life doesn’t always go as promised. The band were barely into their twenties when they dropped their breakthrough release, and the album is imbued with that sense of disappointment and cynicism that comes from seeing the world as it really is for the first time.
This youthful ennui connected with their intended audience, with Something To Write Home About becoming a top seller for their label, and it’s not hard to see why kids latched onto it. From high tempo opener “Holiday” onwards, the record bludgeons listeners with sharp guitars and almost metal-leaning drumming.
“I’m A Loner Dottie, A Rebel” aches with the sincerity of youth, with a newly introduced synthesiser creeping shyly into the spotlight. Album highlight “Ten Minutes” weaves smartly between verses showing off the band’s chops and a colossal pop punk chorus which comes close to a message of positivity.
The Get Up Kids continue to bring out music, but this was their biggest moment, and for good reason. It’s a charmingly naive but masterfully and wisely constructed piece of work, especially by a band so young.
13. Dashboard Confessional - A Mark, A Mission, A Brand, A Scar
The third full length from Chris Carrabba is a bold statement for his ever-evolving Dashboard Confessional project. Moving away from the predominantly acoustic work of his previous releases, A Mark… sees Carrabba’s intimate approach and revealing lyrics complimented by poppier arrangements and slick production from Pixies collaborator Gil Norton.
Opener and first single “Hands Down” is a jolt of energy, with the none-more-emo refrain “won’t you kill me, so I die happy”. It’s undeniably in the pantheon of great emo smash hits, and the album continues to shift in styles and show off the scope of Carrabba’s ambitious project.
“Morning Calls” combines breezy pop with sinister undertones in its shifting guitar lines, while tracks like "Ghost Of A Good Thing" take us back to the one man and an acoustic days, with Carrabba harmonising with himself for maximum melancholy.
The album helped to propel Dashboard Confessional to the big time, and eventually a full line up beyond Carrabba would be solidified. For that blend of heartbreaking, brittle solo tracks and upbeat smash hits, though, this may be the band’s finest hour.
12. Brand New - Deja Entendu
First of all, “Sic Transit Gloria” boasts the best bassline in emo, if not ‘00s rock full stop. The sinister second single was something of a breakthrough for the band, with the vocal lines overlapping and overtaking one another in the verses, leaving no room to take a breath until the tension release of the chorus.
Deja Entendu is somewhat incongruous for an album released in the ‘00s emo boom, wallowing consistently in the darkness, eschewing the glam and power pop influences which some of their contemporaries rode to superstardom.
An album highlight is “Me Vs. Maradona Vs. Elvis”, a slow burning examination of inner turmoil and one of the few indie songs to name check legendary Argentinian forwards. "The Quiet Things That No One Ever Knows" is the closest the album comes to pop, and even here the band are in defiant mode, howling in unison over a hair metal-like riff on the chorus.
Brand New have since disbanded, and for somewhat unfortunate and unsavoury reasons. While many emo bands sing from the perspective of troubled minds, on Deja Entendu it actually sounds legitimate.
11. Jimmy Eat World - Bleed American
The Arizona band proved their hit making bonafides on this highly successful fourth album. Bleed American succeeds as an emo album precisely because it takes steps to move away from what the layman might categorise as emo - i.e self pitying, angst-ridden shoutalongs.
There are such numbers, of course, most notably the title track, which opens the album with punchy guitars and an anthemic, if slightly indecipherable, chorus for the ages. It’s the uplifting tracks that make this album soar, though. The uber-positive “The Middle” remains the band’s best known song, and for all its sugary pop there’s no denying the songcraft.
Working with fellow emo stalwarts from The Promise Ring and That Dog, as well as Blink-182 producer Mark Trombino, the blend of punky tunes like “Sweetness” and the more traditional “Your House” allow the band to keep a foot in both camps.
This is an album that unashamedly swings for a wider audience, but it works due to the band’s songcraft and deep, layered production more than anything like selling out. A winning record by a band who have stood the test of time.
10. Joyce Manor - Joyce Manor
The debut effort from one of modern emo’s best acts, Joyce Manor’s self-titled album is a raw throated, open hearted joyride. A masterpiece of efficiency, the California band need less than 20 minutes to leave a lasting impression with this thrilling record.
Joyce Manor combine the genre’s usual self-examination and revealing song writing with more oblique lyrics. Early highlight “Beach Community” has a sea shanty-esque meter befitting of its subject, and heavy howler “Leather Jacket” digs metaphorically deep in its study of tribalism.
Later on, the band turn world weary (though with the same love of speed and volume) on “Constant Nothing". Best of all is the closer “Constant Headache”, a relative epic at over three minutes long. It’s a relatable tale of unrequited longing with an anguished chorus and an honest to goodness dual guitar solo worthy of Thin Lizzy.
Joyce Manor have gone from strength to strength since, picking up considerable critical and fan support in the process, but nothing as yet tops the debut for raw power and quick fire bursts of bittersweet joy. The future of the genre is more than safe.
9. Jawbreaker - Dear You
The much-missed New York three piece bowed out with a change of pace. Made in the wake of frontman Blake Schwarzenbach's vocal cord surgery, the frontman’s voice is notably different, and the production and slower, gloomier songwriting combine to make an album fans were initially less than fond of.
In retrospect, it’s a great piece of work, distinct from the rest of their catalogue, but full of vital material. In lieu of purist punk rage are more thoughtful pieces like “Accident Prone”, a death wish of a song with a catchy yet distressing chorus.
Elsewhere the likes of “Million” see the protagonist barely keeping himself together, a notion given credence by Schwarzenbach's now-softer vocals. The singer’s frustration at not being able to perform as he would like is palpable, and actually adds to the timbre of the album.
The band broke up shortly after this, and tension creeps into the album at all times. The album was hard work in the making, and was a disappointment for the band in their major label debut (another bone of contention for fans). It was, and is, deserving of retrospective recognition.
8. Mineral - The Power Of Failing
On their landmark debut, Mineral keep things relatively simple to great effect. This is an album with a real through line and a consistent sound, of a piece in the best possible way. One of the definitive albums of ‘90s emo, this album feels of its era, but has simultaneously stood up to the test of time.
The guitar work from Chris Simpson sounds simply exhausting, as he drives tunes like “July” along with powerfully controlled strumming. The dynamic shifts are typical of the era’s most angsty-driven music, creating real tension and drama out of a pretty basic setup.
The vocals are raw, and indeed the album does not sound as though it has a great deal of budget behind it, but all that adds to the flavour. “Parking Lot”, one of the album’s highlights, is a mini epic, building from a quiet, confessional opening to a self lacerating finale in which the band sound on the verge of self destruction.
Self destruct they would, with sophomore effort EndSerenading being the band’s last. Their influence on big hitters like Death Cab For Cutie is undeniable, however, and their legacy is undeniable.
7. Rites Of Spring - Rites Of Spring
One of if not the first emo album, Rites Of Spring’s self titled debut is not for the faint of heart. There’s no sign of the glam and self pity prevalent later on in the scene; instead, frontman Guy Picciotto stomps and snarls over 12 gnarly, soul baring tracks, kickstarting a genre in the process.
A devotee of fellow Washington D.C punk band Minor Threat, Picciotto took the hardcore scene as a starting point and infused it with a greater sense of melody, as well as a focus on self examination in his lyrics, eschewing the political rage of his contemporaries.
The songs are made for the mosh pit, but for close listening, too: the likes of “Deeper Than Inside” and “Hain’s Point” bury tightly crafted guitar lines behind walls of distortion, waiting to be found. “Nudes” pulls things back even further, a relatively stripped down lurcher, Picciotto’s voice far back in the mix, shouting to make himself heard.
Rites Of Spring was a favourite of Kurt Cobain, who went on to influence much of the ‘90s emo revival - directly and indirectly, few albums can have done so much for a single scene as this.
6. The Promise Ring - Nothing Feels Good
Who says emo has to be depressing? The Delaware band’s sophomore effort is a bittersweet ray of sunshine, an album capable of hypnotising you through waves of wailing voices and insistent repetition.
Sonically, it’s a gorgeous piece of work, with piles of guitars, a deliciously ‘90s gurgly bass, and a crispness to the whole thing. Harmonies fly in and out of every deceptively simple song, adding a choral feel to a band not averse to religious content in a generally nontheistic genre (“B Is For Bethlehem” is the catchiest praise song ever written). The songs burrow into your mind through minimalist lyrics - “Is This Thing On?” and “Perfect Lines” are made up of about eight lines apiece.
This is the album to play to the emo-averse, but that’s not to say it doesn’t appeal to the emo purist. The relative cheer of the music belies a weariness and melancholy beneath the surface. The Promise Ring hide their feelings in plain sight, and the darkness hits all the harder for working its way above the glossy surface.
5. My Chemical Romance - Three Cheers For Sweet Revenge
Or: emo goes Hollywood. On the one hand, it’s remarkable that My Chemical Romance made it so huge. They demand a level of commitment from their fans. MCR enthusiasts don’t tend to be casual: you’re all in, from the demeanor to the dress code. It’s a way of life.
On the other hand, of course they made it to the top. Lead single “I’m Not OK (I Promise)” is a wry encapsulation of the entire genre in five words, and is built to be screamed along to like few songs this side of “Livin’ On A Prayer”.
Better still is opener “Helena”, a perfectly structured rollercoaster of a song with an anthemic, half speed chorus. In their appearance and their music, MCR were never afraid to embrace the theatrical, and they inject every song with life and energy - they believe in it, and they’ll make you believe too.
They would go bolder still with their follow up, 2006’s The Black Parade (a rock opera, as was the style at the time), but it can’t match the hook laden joy of Three Cheers. It hits the sweetest of spots for the disillusioned teen, while being completely knowing and in on the gag at the same time - a deft balancing act indeed.
4. Sunny Day Real Estate - Diary
This is music designed to put you on edge. Sunny Day Real Estate, arguably the key band of early ‘90s emo, did not make songs for zoning out or easy listening. This is a serious record, replete with great riffs and musicianship, and no end of tension.
That it’s still great fun, and more to the point so deep, says a lot about the craft that the band put into their debut. Opener “Seven” is a journey in itself, with the jagged but pretty intro quickly shifting gears into something breathless and desperate, then morphing into a heavy guitar chug towards the end.
Centrepiece "The Blankets Were the Stairs" takes the quiet/loud dynamic to its most contrasting, with a featherweight verse dropping into a monstrous stomp of a chorus. Holding it all together is singer Jeremy Enigk, whose mournful but stringent vocal stylings are among the best in the genre.
Diary is thick and muscular, but with no less introspection and thoughtfulness than its title would suggest. It aims straight for the gut, but it offers a great deal for the head and heart alike.
3. Texas Is The Reason - Do You Know Who You Are?
A great one-and-done band, Texas Is The Reason secured their place in the emo pantheon with 35 minutes of super tight, punchy rock by a perfectly in synch band. It didn’t catch fire at the time and the group quickly broke up, but Do You Know Who You Are? sounds better with every passing year, a perfectly structured and played record.
The band sound more outgoing than your average emo outfit, with tunes like “There’s No Way I Can Talk Myself Out Of This One Tonight” and “Nickel Wound” sounding like bar room classics, sway-along drinking songs. Garrett Klahn sings like it’s his last breath, and the harmonies have an in-the-room feel to them.
They play great songs as a unit, with a raw, heartfelt feel. Best of all is closer “A Jack With One Eye”, with its snakey riff and gradual build. It caps off one of the most unsung albums of the decade brilliantly.
Like other cult acts of the era, they have reunited on occasion for live shows, but Texas Is The Reason have as yet resisted the pull of returning to the studio. Perhaps they’ve said all they have to say in their debut, a concise but dynamite statement of intent.
2. Weezer - Pinkerton
The Weezer of the 21st century would be downright frightened of the band who made Pinkerton in 1996. Far from the milquetoast power pop act relying on novelty covers for relevance, Weezer were once a band capable of making an album so drenched in self-loathing bile and oversharing as to be genuinely uncomfortable.
Weezer’s Rivers Cuomo does not present himself in a positive light over Pinkerton, listing and dismissing the various women he’s sleeping with (“Tired Of Sex”), fantasising about young Japanese fans (“Across The Sea”) and finally breaking down altogether (“Falling For You”).
The frontman admits he was in a dark place at the time, and has found the album difficult to listen to in retrospect. The album would be a grubby chore were it not so perfectly put together, boasting hooks and choruses as sharp as those on their self-titled debut, but with a far more substantive and darker edge.
Now an established classic, the critical revulsion shown towards Pinkerton on its release all but guaranteed that Weezer would never make anything so daring again. Perhaps one day Rivers and co will descend into the darkness once more.
1. American Football - American Football
American Football’s debut album entrances you from its opening notes. Serpentine guitar lines, the warmth of the bass, the complex rhythms and counter rhythms. They are a band with incredible technical talents - that, you can tell right off the bat.
There’s more to the album than sheer chops, though, and as soon as vocalist Mike Kinsella starts things off on “Never Meant”, American Football have you gripped. The woozy, dreamy textures are complemented by lyrics more textural than narrative-driven. The whole album is one long heartbreak, but the specifics are down to the individual listener.
American Football aren’t afraid to go epic on “Honestly” and “Stay Home”, and the jazzy influences and unusual instrumentation add to the sense of scope and ambition. The album is the teenage experience writ large: emotional matters of the youthful heart blown up into something truly gigantic.
Breaking up shortly after the album’s release, it would be 15 years before they toured again, and 17 before another album dropped. Their return was a long time coming and more than welcome, but had they never picked up another instrument, their legacy would be more than secure.