20 Greatest Guitarists Of All Time

378697-jimi_hendrix1_super Who are the top 20 guitar players ever? If we were to make a list of say, the top 200 guitarists of all time, what criteria would we use to pare the list down to the top 20? Therein lays the problem for most people and lists, a proliferation of which can be found online. By nature lists are personal, subjective affairs. My list is going to be different than your list which makes sense because if they were the same why would you bother reading about it? Someone recently asked me to consider the question of who would be on my list of top twenty guitarists of all time. The question actually begat more questions than answers as I started to think about a list across a variety of genres, no easy task considering that my tastes lean heavily towards the hard rock/metal side of things. I then figured that I needed a list to compare my list to and discovered a resource that forms the backbone of how I've chosen to present these top twenty: the results of the 2012 Guitar World Readers Poll of the 100 greatest guitarists of all time. Armed with my list of 20 fav's and the aforementioned research I lined up my choices with the results of the poll and have ordered them as such. The number in brackets is where that guitarist ranks in the Guitar World Readers' Poll top 100. This device gets me out of having to rank my choices from one to twenty and truthfully, as I've written in other 'list' articles, I don't really care where my choices fit one to twenty and so this works well for me. It if annoys you please let me hear about it in the comments. As for the Readers' Poll results, let me go on record as saying that I don't necessarily agree with the ordering of some of the selections, particularly # 1, and perhaps you'll feel similarly. Here are Reverend Rock's 20 Greatest Guitarists of All Time as ranked by the Guitar World readers' poll:

20. Al Di Meola (76)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vuY0_JCHaF4 Di Meloa is an absolute titan in the world of Jazz Fusion and Latin Jazz guitar. A Berklee College of Music grad, Di Meloa hit the scene running with three seminal albums in '76, '77 and '78, €œLand of the Midnight Sun", "Elegant Gypsy" and "Casino" respectively. At the time Di Meola was the darling of Guitar Player magazine, a decisive factor in hearing about him - I was listening to Kiss, Judas Priest and Black Sabbath, not jazz. In 1981 he released what is possibly the best jazz guitar instrumental album of all time with Paco DeLucia and John McLaughlin. "A Night In San Francisco" is a 'cannot miss' if you're not familiar with our choice at # 20.

19. Ted Nugent (74)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=efd4lpHosWI The Nuge first tasted success in 1968 with the Amboy Dukes' psychedelic hit, "Journey To The Center Of The Mind". In '75 he began releasing albums under his own name that were ferocious in both sound and technical attack. Nugent put his chops on the line and delivered an intensity that raised the bar, creating masterpieces like "Great White Buffalo", "Catch Scratch Fever" and "Free For All". His heavy take on blues based rock helped form the sound of heavy metal - I would consider him to be a forefather in the same lofty category of Maiden, Sabbath or Priest. We'll leave Ted's politics out of this particular discussion and give a nod to the fact that regardless of what he believes in, he sure as hell isn't afraid to stand up for it.

18. Pete Townsend (65)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6ZBhgZBjiLE Is it just me or are Pete Townsend's accomplishments as a guitarist overshadowed by the legend of his band, The Who? Townsend's playing has always been big and ballsy, from his signature windmill power chord to smashing his instruments to smithereens he has never failed to make a statement. While band mate Roger Daltrey played pretty boy rock star to perfection it was Townsend's songwriting and aggressive attack and rhythms that propelled the band to a career of legendary status that sees the two continuing to perform live in 2013 despite of being ready for the home, numerically at least.

17. Yngvie Malmsteen (44)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dJXUXCQb97I Malmsteen's Rising Force was unleashed upon the world in 1984 during the first wave of virtuoso guitarists ala Randy Rhoads. Heavily influenced by classical composer Paganini, Malmsteen's technical prowess raised the bar for aspiring metal guitarists appreciably. Hailing from Sweden with devilish good looks a penchant for medieval puffiness Malmsteen's first foray in North America in 1982 saw him play in Steeler and then warm up the guitarist's chair for Steve Vai in Alcatrazz. The years '84 through '86 saw him release some of Metal€™s most technically beautiful and awe inspiring playing.

16. Carlos Santana (42)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xBG6IaSQCpU Carlos Santana was born in Mexico but raised in California. Playing guitar from the age of 8 he took instruction from famed Mexican guitarist Javier Batiz who is credited for helping a young Santana create his unique soloing style. Santana€™s emergence during the time of hippies and psychedelics was fortuitous and his Woodstock performance become legendary. Blending hard rock with Latin flavours and jazz fusion, Santana remains a staple on classic rock radio with a plethora of hits to choose from. Those with a desire for a broader historical perspective will find no lack of material to dig into from the €˜80€™s forward.

15. Keith Richards (40)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m-hDxTVvG-4 According to Rolling Stone Magazine, guitarist Keith Richards and Stones singer Mick Jagger co-authored 14 of the top 500 songs of all time. The publication is quoted to have said that Richards is responsible for, €œrocks greatest body of riffs€ and ranks as the 4th greatest guitarist ever. An enduring character because of his well-publicized run-ins with the law, substance abuse, and recovery, Richards does what few guitarists can do effectively €“ play sparingly and tastefully while driving the band rhythmically. Who expected the verbally incomprehensible Mr. Richards to be strutting his stuff at the age of 70?

14. Django Reinhardt (32)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QATIHWbN-sM In the summer of 2005 I had the great fortune to come across a book in the bargain bin of a store near our summer cottage. It was called €œDjango: The Life and Music of a Gypsy Legend€ by Michael Dregni. Having read the name in guitar magazines over the years I decided to fork over 99 cents and give it a read. As an added bonus, the accompanying CD sampler of Reinhardt€™s best known works was still in its sleeve inside the front cover. Django€™s story is as incredible as his playing and while it may take a little genre bending on your part to go back and listen, it€™s certainly worth the journey.

13. Slash (22)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0R661981EWs Few songs are identifiable within two bars of beginning but G&R's "Sweet Child O' Mine" is one of them. Those iconic 8 notes are merely highlights of what is possibly the greatest debut album of all time. Stylistically, Slash was the antithesis to '80's metal shredders like Malmsteen and Vai. His virtuosity lay not in stunning sweep picking and tapping but in this: Slash took the blues based lead playing of Hendrix, Iommi and Page and turned up the intensity. The entirety of Appetite For Destruction should be a primer for every aspiring guitarist.

12. Angus Young (21)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IlejfA5NCbQ Speaking of iconic opening bars of songs, how many is AC/DC€™s Angus Young responsible for? The lead riff from €œThunderstruck€ is instantly recognizable, a rock classic, as are many other Young riffs. AC/CD came out of Australia in €™74 following the formula of the day: play blues based rock louder and faster than anyone else. While continuing to play live and release new music, Young and his mates have never again reached the dizzying heights achieved with their 1980 release, Back in Black.

11. Zakk Wylde (18)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8wTj1iZkUcM Is there a more symbiotic relationship in rock/metal than the one between Zakk Wylde and Ozzy Osbourne? The argument could be made that one without the other would be a mere shadow in light of who they are together. Would Black Label Society still be a smokin€™ southern tinged metal outfit with moderate commercial success? Perhaps, but where would Osbourne be without Zakk? After the departure of the ill-fitting Jake E. Lee, Ozzy was desperately in need of a refresh. Enter Wylde, a young phenom with the chops, attitude and stage presence to resuscitate Ozzy€™s career through the €˜90€™s and beyond.

10. John Petrucci (17)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=535EHJnIcoM Let me go on record here as saying that I believe Dream Theater to be the best prog-rock band of the post classic era, meaning after €˜70€™s Genesis, Yes, Pink Floyd and Rush. Does that give me a prejudice towards the band€™s guitarist, John Petrucci? Possibly but there is a reason that I have seen the band live on every tour since the late €˜90€™s: album after album, tour after tour, Petrucci stuns me with his playing - I had the privilege of sitting only ten rows from Petrucci€™s fretwork magic at Toronto€™s iconic Massey Hall during their last tour. His impeccable technical prowess coupled with a majestic sense of melody forms much of what is unique and enduring about DT€™s sound.

9. Robert Johnson (16)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=82yNxiF-T4A While not the inventor of Delta blues, Robert Johnson is widely recognized as an innovator. His relatively small catalogue of songs were recorded in the late 1930€™s and can be found in their entirety on the excellent box set, €œThe Complete Recordings€ (1990) which won a Grammy for best historical recording . The Rock & Roll Hall of Fame inducted Johnson in its €œEarly Influencers€ category at their opening in 1986. During his short lifetime (dying at age 27) Johnson failed to attract much attention or sell many records, barely rising above the level of a street busker but his legacy lives on in the works of the likes of Clapton and Richards who are widely quoted in their praises of him. The popular legend that he sold his soul to the devil at a crossroads for fame and fortune is ironic considering how little of either he had in his short lifetime.

8. David Gilmour (13)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GvwRAe4gscc David Gilmour replaced the increasingly erratic Syd Barrett in Pink Floyd in early 1968. His soulful guitar style evokes raw emotion while suggesting colours, textures and nuances aurally. While band mate Roger Waters dominated late €˜70€™s post-Dark Side of the Moon releases, Gilmour soldiered on both as a solo artist and under then the Pink banner into the €˜90€™s. During the period he more than ably carried the Pink Floyd torch,releasing two albums, the excellent, €œA Momentary Lapse of Reason€ and the somewhat less well-known, €œDivision Bell€.

7. Dave Mustaine (12)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0sb1Xqk34O8 I have to admit to being fascinated by Dave Mustaine from very early on - since his early ousting from Metallica, his creation of Megadeth and his confession to being bad drinker who€™s been redeemed. I am amongst those that suggest that Mustaine has surpassed his former brothers in arms artistically if not in sales. Megadeth released some of the best €˜80€™s thrash ever recorded with a trio of albums between €™86 and €™90: Peace Sells€ but Who€™s Buying?€, So Far, So Good€ So What?€ and €œRust In Peace€. With their 13th studio album dropping this year Megadeth continues to tear it up behind the spider-chording off its front-man.

6. Randy Rhoads (11)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KxN0mQgQdPM Randy Rhoads was the frontrunner in introducing neo-classical influences to metal guitar playing. One could argue that without Rhoads€™ rise to prominence the way might not have been paved for the success of future shredders like Malmsteen and Vai. Many hold Rhoads singlehandedly responsible for Ozzy€™s rise from the ashes of Sabbath in €™79 to €˜80€™s metal prominence. When Blizzard of Oz came out in €™80 there was nothing else like it €“ who can forget the opening riff of €œCrazy Train€ or images of Ozzy carrying Rhoads on his shoulders as the guitarist€™s fingers attacked the fret board of his polka-dotted Jackson Flying V?

5. Dimebag Darrel (9)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=elYStmAaW2k The emergence of Grunge in the early €˜90€™s is well documented and the decade was certainly not kind to metal or its sub-genres. Hair metal bands were dropping like flies and established behemoths like Kiss were trying to figure out how to hold onto their fans and eroding market share. One band to carry the metal torch high through the €˜90€™s was Pantera, progenitors of €˜groove metal€™. Developing a style all his own that influenced a generation of players, Dime is one of the few guitarists to record many of his studio album solos without the benefit of a rhythm guitar. After splitting with erratic addict Phil Anselmo Dime created Damageplan with his drummer brother Vinnie. Tragically Dime was gunned down by a deranged fan during a Damageplan show in 2004.

4. Tony Iommi (7)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xtqy4DTHGqg What can I say about the man that he hasn€™t said himself in his excellent biography, €œIron Man: My Journey Through Heaven and Hell Through Black Sabbath€? With a new Sabbath studio album in the imminent future, the first with Ozzy since €™79, and Iommi battling lymphoma what does the future hold? A legend€™s legend, Iommi is a founding father of heavy metal and virtually all of his €˜70€™s work forms a canon of sorts in the heavy metal bible. The pinnacle of Iommi€™s work is found on the €™75 release, Sabotage, featuring €œHole In The Sky€ and €œSymptom Of The Universe€.

3. Jimmy Page (6)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Q7Vr3yQYWQ Some people say that Led Zeppelin invented heavy metal in the early €˜70€™s with tunes like €œImmigrant Song€ and €œWhole Lotta Love€. Whether that€™s true or not there is no denying that, for a time in the €˜70€™s, Led Zeppelin was the biggest band on the planet. While I appreciate the necessity of Jimmy Page being prominent in any great guitarist list I have to admit to being a little puzzled personally. Zep was a little before my time and certainly too cerebral for my adolescent, unformed brain. I know this probably borders on sacrilege for some of you but I€™ve never quite €˜gotten it€™ where Page€™s legend is concerned, and yes there is a comment section below.

2. Jimmy Hendrix (4)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M7alzhFMVqE The beacon of light that was Jimi Hendrix burned briefly in the late €˜60€™s. If you€™ve read from the beginning you may recall that I mentioned that I allowed the Guitar World Readers€™ Poll from €™12 to guide the rankings of my 20 favourite guitarists. Would I personally rank Hendrix below Eddie Van Halen? No, but I€™ve made the rules and now have to live with them. Hendrix surpassed so much of what was being done in rock guitar at the time and was a true innovator with his use of feedback and distortion. Hendrix€™s penultimate tune is, perhaps, €œAll Along The Watchtower€, an instant classic that raised the bar in for so many players at the time.

1. Eddie Van Halen (1)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z_lwocmL9dQ I€™m sure that EVH will lose little sleep over me disputing his position at # 1 and I would certainly include him in any discussion of the top four or five guitarists of all time. As a guitar album, Van Halen€™s debut in 1978 stands as one of the best ever and as a guitarist EVH never quite achieved the heights, at least in studio, of that album. Van Halen€™s releases during the David Lee Roth era established the guitarist€™s legend but that was later tarnished, at least musically, by a sudden early €˜80€™s infatuation with keyboards and the devolution of Van Halen into a bad hair metal band during the Sammy Hagar era. A comeback album with original singer DLR was released about a year ago to generally favourable reviews. I wasn€™t impressed. Thanks for considering these ramblings and pondering them amongst your own. Disagree with my choices or methodology? Feel free use the comment section below to let me know.

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Ross Ingall is a 52 year old ordained Canadian baptist minister who has been listening to hard rock and metal quite literally since each was invented. A second career pastor who attended seminary in his 40's, the Rev hosts Too Metal For Church on Metal Nation Radio. Writing both under his own name as well as the psuedonym/nickname Reverend Rock, Ross has been writing music articles on the web since 1999.