Pink Floyd is my favorite band of all time. Many years ago, there was a Pink Floyd compilation that was released on two discs, a "best of," if you will. This bothered me for two reasons: 1) Floyd was never a singles artist, so to lump dozens of vastly different songs from unrelated concept albums together in one package was missing the point, and 2) there were many outstanding tracks from their backlog missing, while other, far inferior songs made the cut, such as selections from their last two lesser albums after bassist/singer/songwriter Roger Waters left the band. The collection even included "Jugband Blues," quite possibly the worst Pink Floyd song of all time, which can partly be attributed to the fact founding member Syd Barrett wrote it when he started completely losing his mind. So I decided to outdo the powers-that-be who came up with that godforsaken compilation, which shall never be named, and put together my own list of the songs that should have been included. You will notice overlaps in my choices, but I wanted to clarify my love for the hits as well. After all, I had to include, e.g., "Money." Also, you may note the absence of any songs from Ummagumma, arguably their worst album (though, like most of their records, the album cover is amazing). Half of that album is live anyway, and I wanted to concentrate on their studio work. Here they are, in chronological order:
1. "Arnold Layne" 2. "See Emily Play" 3. "Paint Box" 4. "Julia Dream" 5. "Point Me at the Sky" from The Early Singles These songs were recorded during the early years under Barrett, who holds the distinction of naming the band, which is a combination of the names of two blues musicians whose records he owned. The first two songs here were originally included in the band's first full-length album, The Piper at the Gates of Dawn (coming up next in this list), but were later removed because they wanted to stay true to their developing counterculture status. Also controversial were the singles' themes: "Arnold Layne" is about a transvestite (and, according to Waters, based on a real person), and "See Emily Play" is about, well, you'll have to hear it for yourself. I think "Paint Box" is my favorite selection here, not only because of its unusually sublime music a la The Beach Boys' classic Pet Sounds but also because of its instantly identifiable lyrics. The song opens, "Last night, I had too much to drink..." and tells the sorry tale of a poor loser down on his luck with life and the ladies. Later, the narrator laments the bar scene ("Trying to impress, but feeling rather empty/I had another drink") and then uncomfortable first dates ("So what can I do?/I can't think of what to say/She sees through anyway"). "Julia Dream" begins innocently enough but then devolves into an almost nightmarish scenario, with Waters and company hissing threateningly in the background while an ominous organ underscores the drama. And "Point Me at the Sky" soars (quite literally, toward the end) with surreal, out-of-this-world, overlapping melodies set to a twisted fairy tale.
6. "The Scarecrow" 7. "The Gnome" from The Piper at the Gates of Dawn Well, here it is: the band's first studio album. The material is extremely different, even more experimental than their later work when Barrett left the band and Roger Waters took over. "The Scarecrow" is a fun little ditty that would be at home on a children's record or an entry in the diary of a madman. Not many songs can boast that duality; for this reason alone, I included it here. "The Gnome" is also deceptively childish, even beginning like a toddler's picture book ("I want to tell you a story..."), but it's actually a disguised critique of society and our selfish, single-minded ways.
8. "Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun" from A Saucerful of Secrets In my opinion, this is one of the worst Pink Floyd albums. (This is the one with the aforementioned "Jugband Blues.") This sci-fi gem, however, became a standard at live shows and a favorite with fans. It's one of the first songs that Waters wrote completely on his own, and his writing talent is later capitalized on the hugely successful Dark Side of the Moon, Wish You Were Here, Animals, and, of course, The Wall. Waters' gift lies with inventing original, ironic lyrics, yet surprisingly, this one only features a few lines that are mumbled incoherently, except for the title.
9. "Green Is the Colour" 10. "Cymbaline" from More Believe it or not, Pink Floyd actually used to compose music for avant-garde, independent foreign films, such as this one, right after Barrett left. I guess they were simultaneously looking for work and a musical direction in which to take the band. Both of these songs were beautiful ballads, but "Cymbaline" is probably the prettiest song in the bunch on this album, most telling in the chorus with a soft-spoken, lilting flute line, which was very uncharacteristic of the band, especially then. Musically, they were starting to grow and stretch beyond Barrett's silly limericks and mad nursery rhymes.
11. "Atom Heart Mother" 12. "If" 13. "Fat Old Sun" from Atom Heart Mother The title track, which is also the opening number of the album, is a gorgeous, nearly 24-minute opus with almost as many movements as an orchestral piece. I think my favorite bit though is the haunting middle, with its eerie chorus of moans and melancholy chords that would fit right at home in a chilling cemetery scene. "If" was the first song that made me pay attention to who was writing what. I noticed that it was the strongest entry on this album and discovered that it was the only one completely written by Waters. This is when my love of the band shifted from the whole to the bassist, who had a way of penning a great line and memorable melody (think "Another Brick in the Wall"). Powerful, moving, and yet quiet, Waters notes: "If I were a swan/I'd be gone/If I were a train/I'd be late/If I were a good man/I'd talk to you more often than I do." I included "Fat Old Sun" just for the miracle that is David Gilmour's guitar, whose amazing solo at the finale eclipses the vocals, as they trail away.
14. "One of These Days" from Meddle A mostly instrumental freakout that was the hallmark of most of their live performances at the time, "One of These Days" was simultaneously inspiring and frightening. How frightening? The end of the title's phrase is, "...I'm going to cut you into little pieces." Yikes! Gilmour has gone on record to say it's Pink Floyd's most collaborative song, and you can hear it, in every joyous, unnerving minute.
15. "The Gold It's in the..." 16. "Wot's...uh, the Deal" 17. "Stay" from Obscured by Clouds This is another film soundtrack and remains one of my favorites; it was hard choosing just a few songs. I consider "Wot's...uh, the Deal" to be one of my anthems. In fact, it was my "handle" when I started using e-mail for the very first time freshman year at college. "The Gold It's in the..." is another partial song title that I've actually heard on the radio a few times, though I can almost guarantee you've never heard it before, unless you're a diehard Floyd fan such as myself. Apparently, the movie was about quitting everything you're doing and joining the gold rush, so that's what the song tried to illustrate in its fun, jumpy manner. "Stay" is not the classic American song that's been featured in movie trailers, restaurant commercials, and the Dirty Dancing soundtrack. Instead, it's a heartbreaking, beautiful song (as most Floyd songs are) about a one-night stand: "Stay/and help me to end the day/And if you don't mind/we'll break a bottle of wine/Stick around/and maybe we'll put one down/'Cause I want to find/what lies behind those eyes." It's in searching for what "lies behind those eyes" that Floyd transcended their own limited boundaries of pop music.
18. "Time" 19. "Money" 20. "Us and Them" from Dark Side of the Moon Honestly, if you haven't heard these songs by now, you've been living in a cave. Yes, they're overplayed on classic rock radio stations everywhere, but they still deserve a place in this collection. After all, they're probably the three biggest singles of Floyd's entire four-decade history, not including The Wall. This album is likely the most famous concept album ever made and has stayed in the top five best-selling albums of all time for decades. The band wanted to attack life, its highs and lows (okay, mostly its lows), with all the important issues: time, money, and war ("Us and Them") being the most obvious, but also death ("The Great Gig in the Sky"), insanity ("Brain Damage"), and even perfectionist workaholics ("Breathe"), with lines like, "Run, rabbit, run/Dig that hole/in the sun/When at last the work is done/Don't sit down/It's time to dig another one." Nick Mason's playful yet intricate drum work in the intro of "Time" is a wonder to behold, and keyboardist Richard Wright adds a delightful flourish to the battle-scarred epic "Us and Them." Waters wrote the words and music to "Money," and its classic bass line has been aped by countless bands since. This is the concept album by which all others are measured.
21. "Shine on You Crazy Diamond" 22. "Welcome to the Machine" 23. "Have a Cigar" 24. "Wish You Were Here" from Wish You Were Here This was a concept album about the poor state of the music industry. Since that time, not much has changed. As most know by now, the nine-part "Shine on You Crazy Diamond" ultimately became an ode to the band's founding member, the final part of which was inspired when Barrett dropped by a recording session and was virtually unrecognizableso much so that Waters originally didn't know who he was. Barrett's hard-living (and hard-partying) ways had left him a shell of his former self, hence the title of the song. "Welcome to the Machine" is about creative bands being forced into the soulless production of rock singles instead of taking their time to craft an audible work of art. The album's titleand title songagain refer to Barrett, who was a music genius and not necessarily in this business for the money. After their huge commercial and critical success with Dark Side of the Moon, the band's record label wanted Floyd to quickly pump out another hit. Disillusioned with record execs and the whole music/marketing scene, Waters answered by penning an entire opus aimed at the very hand that was feeding him. His classic, twisted sense of humor is best showcased in "Have a Cigar" (the only Floyd song, incidentally, that isn't sung by a member of the band), where a clueless record producer tries to woo the band after being impressed by their sales ("The band is just fantastic/That is really what I think/Oh, by the way/which one is Pink?").
25. "Dogs" from Animals This is a long one, clocking in at over 17 minutes. Taking a page (almost literally) from George Orwell's Animal Farm, this concept album features the obvious metaphor that people are nothing but animals: fat, rich, white guys are "Pigs"; weak, cowardly followers are "Sheep"; and violent, war-mongering bullies are "Dogs." To be honest, I didn't really like this song that much when I first heard it (I was put off by its length), and you might feel the same based on one listen, but I'm tellin' ya, this song will grow on you more than any other Floyd tune; it's now one of my favorites. You'll especially be drawn back for repeated listens just to hear Gilmour's guitar interrupt the narrative with his trademark "Waa-Waaahh!!" I used to see a Pink Floyd tribute band when I lived in Baltimore, and whenever they played this song, the crowd went nuts, particularly at the "Waa-Waaahh!!" part. You'll know what I'm talking about when you hear it.
26. "Another Brick in the Wall (Part II)" 27. "Mother" 28. "Hey You" 29. "Comfortably Numb" 30. "Run Like Hell" from The Wall I realize I included a generous portion of The Wall here, but keep in mind that not only is this record a classic, it actually contains two albums' worth of songs (hence, all the Part IIs and IIIs listed throughout the song titles). Most non-Floyd fans love the first song I picked but don't realize it's actually the middle chapter in a trio of similar melodies. Also, I don't believe most people understand the message of the song. Even Waters himself, who practically wrote the entire two-record album single-handedly, admitted it's not a rallying cry against all forms of public education. It was merely critiquing certain sarcastic teachers who took their troubles out on their students, instead of just doing their job and teaching them ("We don't need...no dark sarcasm in the classroom/Teachers leave the kids alone"). I know I had more than a few teachers like that in high school. I love the inclusion of real kids singing the chorus, one of the first times this was ever done in rock music and has often been imitated sincepoorly (think "We Are the Youth of the Nation" by P.O.D.). I also love the irony that the kids are chanting "We don't need no education" in grammatically incorrect fashion, almost making it an oxymoron. "Hey You" is one of my favorite songs of all time, probably my second favorite Floyd song (I'll get to my first later), and it serves as the turning point in the entire two-record concept album. Unfortunately, it was discarded from the movie version because it ran too long, but without this song, the rest of the story structure collapses. In case you don't know, The Wall is about a famous rock singer named Pink who locks himself in a hotel room before a concert. He's had too much applause, too many shows, and too much dope and is ready to end his life. Trapped in the dark abyss of depression, he finally realizes he has a problem and needs to ask for help if he's going to get out of it. That's what "Hey You" is about. It's his initial cry for help, like a baby lost in a crowd looking for his mother (hence, the inclusion of "Mother"). The first song on the second record of The Wall, "Hey You" splits the album perfectly into two neat parts: before he seeks help and afterwards. "Comfortably Numb" was originally credited just to Waters for writing it, but he needed a bigger climax to illustrate the high Pink feels from his drug overdose. He asked Gilmour to write a guitar solo for the end, and he came through in superb fashion. I still get goosebumps listening to it; it elevates the song from great pop to work of art. Waters, who was notorious for his obsessive control of the band in its later years, was so impressed that he gave a co-writing byline to the guitarist just for the solo. "Run Like Hell" is perfect for an arena rock show and probably the greatest "dance song" Floyd has ever done, if you can call it that. It's also the only one. (The title of the Floyd compilation A Collection of Great Dance Songs is clearly tongue-in-cheek.)
31. "The Gunner's Dream" 32. "The Final Cut" 33. "Not Now John" from The Final Cut The title of this album unintentionally gained a double meaning: not only is it about war, but it became the last Pink Floyd recording with Waters. By now, his ego had blown up and interfered with the writing process of his bandmates, refusing to listen to their input. This album is virtually a solo one for Waters since he wrote every single line of music and lyric, right down to the forced guitar solos of Gilmour's, who used to express himself freely. You can hear him painfully holding back numerous times throughout. This, however, is one of my favorite Pink Floyd albums, not only because it's bittersweet, being the parting record of my favorite member of the band, but also because of its extremely specific concept: war. It's very easy to identify with, even if you haven't actually fought in a war (as Waters himself never did), because everyone has lived during times of war and heard stories of its atrocities, and some even have had to deal with the horror of losing a loved one in combat. This is also the only album to offer a subtitle, "A Requiem for the Postwar Dream," and is dedicated to Waters' father, Eric Fletcher, who died in World War II before he got to know his just-born son. This is why many songs written by Waters, especially in The Wall, deal with the loss generated by War, with a capital "W." Here is my favorite song I was talking about: "The Gunner's Dream." Floyd's greatest narrative is a mini-masterpiece. Based on the story of a gunner whose plane is shot down in action, the five-minute song manages to pack as much emotional firepower and intense melodrama as a two-hour opera. As the title character parachutes down to earth, he reminisces about his life, including flash-forwarding to witness his own funeral, knowing that death is near. In the aftermath, and not unlike Martin Luther King, Jr.'s famous speech, he poses a dream to mankind that would take someone made of granite not to be moved. The song also happens to include the most incredible saxophone solo of any Floyd tune, courtesy of Raphael Ravenscroft, which takes the melody to new heights. The title tune is also a deeply personal song for me, especially its haunting themes, which echo "Comfortably Numb" from The Wall, and its all-too-identifiable lyrics ("And if I/showed you my dark side/Would you still hold me/tonight?"). Also, it breaks my heart to be reminded of my angst-ridden, lonely teen life ("There's a kid who had a big hallucination...Could anybody love him?/Or is this just a crazy dream?"). "Not Now John" is undoubtedly the most vulgar Floyd song out there. The chorus alone drops the F-bomb not once, not twice, but thrice! This song also bears the remarkable distinction of a Waters-style rap. Yes, Pink Floyd made a rap song.
34. "On the Turning Away" from A Momentary Lapse of Reason This is not only one of the greatest Floyd ballads, it's undoubtedly the best song the band ever wrote without Waters. An ode to the poor, the lonely, the hungry, and the homeless, it reminds me of the famous poem etched on the plaque held by The Statue of Liberty: "Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free." Gilmour begins the song in a near Irish brogue but finishes in full-on rocker mode, backed by a gospel chorus and his glorious guitar. It's a slow build but worth the wait. And, of course, its message of giving to those less fortune than you is timeless.
35. "Take It Back" from The Division Bell At first glance, this song's lyrics read more like a Hallmark card: "Her love rains down on me/easy as the breeze/I listen to her breathing/It sounds like the waves on the sea." But the song is actually about Mother Nature and her gradual, almost inevitable destruction: "She might take it back someday." This was made more evident by the song's music video, where a man chops a tree until it literally explodes into flames. No one ever blamed the band for being subtle, but having been written almost 20 years ago, the song is eerily prescient. The environmental movement is perhaps livelier today than ever before. Thanks, Floyd! In truth, this is really just a primer of the band's massive catalog. There are many other songs I could've listed here, such as "Bike," "Echoes," and "The Great Gig in the Sky," that are just as worthy, but I invite you to buy the albums yourself. As I wrote at the start of this article, Pink Floyd is an albums band.
Michael Perone has written for The Baltimore Sun, Baltimore City Paper, The Island Ear (now titled Long Island Press), and The Long Island Voice, a short-lived spinoff of The Village Voice. He currently works as an Editor in Manhattan. And he still thinks Michael Keaton was the best Batman.