35 All-Time Best Genesis Songs

Despite their tremendous success, I still feel that overall Genesis haven't been given the respect they deserve in the music community.

This year marks the 45th anniversary of the debut album of the prog-rock/classic rock band Genesis, so I thought it might be a good time to revisit their catalog and select their best tracks. Genesis are my second favourite band of all time, just behind Pink Floyd, and despite their tremendous success, I still feel that overall, they haven't been given much respect in the music community. Maybe it's because some people claim drummer-turned-lead-singer Phil Collins "sold them out" in the '80s by penning a bunch of poppy, 3-minute tunes to get radio airplay, but I still feel the band managed to keep their integrity. As Collins once noted, the band always wrote short, three or four minute songs; they just weren't very popular, so he gathered the band must have gotten better at writing them over the years. Last year, I found a list on the Internet of this band's best songs, and not only was it just 10 tracks deep, it didn't even include any selections from the '70s, which made me question whether the author knew anything about the band's prog-rock roots or even realised that Peter Gabriel used to be the bands leader. So I've decided to rectify that with the following list, in chronological order, of what I feel are the band's 35 best tunes. You will note I didn't include the band's last studio album Calling All Stations, the only one with singer Ray Wilson, because true fans know that album doesn't count.

35. "The Silent Sun"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cp4b4tcZ7Rc Singer Peter Gabriel, keyboardist Tony Banks, rhythm guitarist/bassist Mike Rutherford, lead guitarist Anthony Phillips, and drummer Chris Stewart met at Charterhouse School in Surrey and sent a nameless demo to "old boy" Jonathan King, who had once attended their school and was in the middle of a triumphant visit after writing and recording the hit single, "Everyone's Gone to the Moon." King thought they showed promise with his guidance, but he wasn't thoroughly impressed after the band sent another round of songs. Realizing they were losing him, Banks and Gabriel decided to write a song that was tailor made to his interests. His favorite band at the time was The Bee Gees, so they wrote "The Silent Sun," a Bee Gees pastiche that King lapped up, even claiming the sound was "before The Bee Gees." (It was definitely before their disco heyday of the late '70s though thankfully, "The Silent Sun" is far from a disco song.) King wanted to name them Gabriel's Angels, but the group, luckily, rejected it. They settled on Genesis, and while they were still in school, they recorded their aforementioned debut album, From Genesis to Revelation, a little-known concept album about the Book of Genesis and the rise of man that was released in 1969. King decided not to have a band name on the cover and ended up immensely regretting this decision, as record shops didn't know what to do with it, so they dumped it into the religious bins. The album went nowhere fast but started the humble beginnings of a band that would eventually sell untold millions around the globe. As for the song itself, it undoubtedly has a lovely melody, but "The Silent Sun" is a trifle. I mostly included it here because it was the band's first single, though it didn't have much impact, as far as radio play and audience appreciation. It did, however, get the attention of King and eventually land them a record deal, so, in that regard, it remains an important part of their history.

34. "The Knife"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uBYPPjLJO5U With its pulse-like, stabbing rhythm, courtesy of Banks' organ, "The Knife" was the sound of Genesis finding its way. Dark and aggressive, it was a far cry from the plaintive pop of "The Silent Sun." An attack against war and its enforcers, the song was on the opposite end of the sonic spectrum of their former Bee Gees takeoff. "Some of you are going to die," Gabriel warns in the chorus. Compare that with, "Baby, you feel so close" from "The Silent Sun." "The Knife" became a live favourite, so much so that it served as the closer on the band's first live album, simply and self-explanatorily titled Genesis Live, and you can clearly hear fans in that early '70s audience demanding the song's title just before it's played.

33. "The Musical Box"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7X_3yOUKSOc From the aptly titled Nursery Cryme (the first Genesis album to feature Phil Collins and guitarist Steve Hackett), this twisted nursery rhyme would make Pink Floyd's Syd Barrett blush. Consider the story: a girl beheads a boy with a croquet mallet and then is sexually assaulted by his aged spirit from a magical music box. Well, the music is certainly catchy! Moving on...

32. "Watcher of the Skies"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=57HicYcY4Ow This song introduced Genesis fans to Gabriel's infatuation with sci-fi opuses, and even though it's about aliens coming down to examine the destruction of Earth (not unlike Roger Waters' "Amused to Death" two decades later), it was too original to simply be labeled "space rock." Also a live favourite, it was the first song selected for their aforementioned live album.

31. "Supper's Ready"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=szJq1lwnkNw This is not only the band's first epic number, which would become a trademark, it's probably their most famous. At 23 minutes and split into seven parts, it's presented more like an orchestral movement than a rock song, and it's the template for which many other prog-rock bands would imitate. Still, you can't beat the original. My favorite section is probably "Willow Farm," when Peter Gabriel would don a flower man costume and prance across the stage like the host of some children's T.V. show. Gabriel proved that rock doesn't always have to take itself so seriously.

30. "Dancing With the Moonlit Knight"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r0Spl1cOf-o From one of my favorite early Genesis albums (and favorite albums period), "Dancing With the Moonlit Knight" begins with Gabriel singing a cappella and ends with the band blasting you at full force. Even Steve Hackett has said the whole album is mad. I was listening to these divinely strange sounds in the mid-90s when grunge had fully taken hold of America, and when a friend in college asked me to borrow my headphones to hear what I was listening to, I had this track cued up. He sort of stared blankly into space, not knowing what to make of it, and then he calmly took the earpieces off. Even though Pearl Jam and Soundgarden were all the rage at the time, he turned to me and said, "This is the real alternative music."

29. "I Know What I Like (In Your Wardrobe)"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y1tFQMjc-IE This is the band's first successful single, and it's still catchy over 40 years later. Written about a groundskeeper with a severe case of Peter Pan syndrome, the rebellious lad simply doesn't want to grow up or listen to any career advice, preferring to tend to his monotonous job of mowing people's lawns. The irreverent attitude of the protagonist is something teens today can still identify with. The song was based off a surreal painting by Betty Swanwick, which also served as the album's cover, and the band actually added a lawnmower in the corner to fit the song's lyrics.

28. "The Cinema Show"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G501Ii0X0NE "The Cinema Show" is another story song, this one more musically nuanced, as it was augmented by a 12-string guitar and, perhaps taking a page from Jethro Tull, a flute solo. As for the lyrics, Romeo and Juliet are preparing for a date at the titular show with Romeo all but predicting a sexual conquest that night, but as with most of the band's lyrics in this era, things aren't always what they seem, with the chorus making oblique references to T. S. Eliot's epic poem "The Waste Land." The masterwork of the song, though, is Banks' extended keyboard solo in the finale, which segues nicely into the final song of the album, "Aisle of Plenty," a reprise of sorts of "Dancing With the Moonlit Knight," which was the first song, serving as bookends to this underrated album.

27. "The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5pteh5hdZlg From the band's first and only double concept album, The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway was also notorious as the last Genesis album to feature Gabriel. The title track begins the story of Rael, a New York Puerto Rican who may or may not be hallucinating most of the strange images he experiences, including the titular phrase. Attempting to rescue his brother John throughout the album, Rael eventually realises he's one and the same person and is suffering from a split personality. Anthemic in sound and ambitious in scope, the album perhaps bit off more than it could chew, as it was mostly greeted with confused shrugs at the time, even from diehard fans of the band. Today it is considered a seminal classic, influencing everyone from Pink Floyd to Green Day, the latter of which created a rock opera starring someone with a split personality 30 years later with American Idiot.

26. "Counting Out Time"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YXUmKw4pFdc A somewhat lesser appreciated Genesis tune, "Counting Out Time" is significant for being one of the band's first purely pop performances, even more so than the sing-along "I Know What I Like." Bolstered by a bubblegum backbeat, the song would probably get confused with The Archies' "Sugar, Sugar" if it weren't for Gabriel's brilliantly twisted lyrics about Rael coming to grips with his newfound sexuality: "Honey, get hip/It's time to unzip!"

25. "The Carpet Crawlers"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2yUN6CsuVPw This song will always affectionately be held close to the fans' hearts, not least of which because it was rerecorded with both Gabriel and Collins on vocals in 1999 but also since it was played at the band's last series of concerts in 2007. Describing a motley group of persons struggling to reach an outer chamber while chanting, "We've gotta get in to get out," it not only adds to the concept album's unique narrative, it personifies the everyman struggle of living day to day and trying to achieve any goal, however insignificant.

24. "Ripples"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gJa9gEUa0To This song was also played at their last tour in 2007, somewhat surprisingly since it wasn't a major hit. It describes a woman who gradually ages and, as she looks into the ripples of a pool and sees her beauty melt away, realises she'll never again regain her youth ("Sail away, away/Ripples never come back"). Despite the unusual selection at the show, I don't believe it was mere coincidence the band played the song seeing as how their youthful prime is long behind them.

23. "A Trick Of The Tail"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MWxaidVIjXk This song was instrumental to the band's history as it was the first single released with Collins on lead vocals and also the first one to feature in a music video. While the cheesy video hasn't aged very well (a miniature Collins hops around the keys of a piano like Jerry from a "Tom and Jerry" cartoon), the song's clever story, based on William Golding's novel "The Inheritors," is about an enlightened beast who leaves his kingdom and is captured by the world of humans, only to be displayed in a freak show. The beast promises his captors gold in exchange for his freedom, and as he leads them to his enchanted world, he disappears just as they briefly glimpse a golden spire.

22. "Your Own Special Way"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ykaEysI4KYA Written by Rutherford, this is probably the band's most effeminate song. That may be why some people believe Collins wrote it. Its bouncy, seasick rhythm and Collins' playful vocal delivery add to the enchanted atmosphere of the song, and the romantic lyrics melt this cynic's heart: "You have your own special way/of turning the world so it's facing the way that I'm going."

21. "Blood On The Rooftops"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EeZRdd_1b4g Even if this song was just the exquisitely played guitar intro by Steve Hackett, I would include it on this list, but as if that classical guitar piece wasn't enough, Collins pours his heart out in a bittersweet reflection of wistful memories combined with the tragic news of the day, his sweet, nostalgic lyrics ("We always watched the Queen on Christmas day/Won't you stay?") juxtaposed with the ugliness found on the nightly news. (Just read the title of the song.) It's one of Genesis' most beautiful songs.

20. "Many Too Many"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vUEAx1ngnf0 The title of this album is in reference to Hackett quitting the band, leaving just the remaining Banks, Collins, and Rutherford. Written by Banks about the unfortunate glut of rock stars who overpopulated the charts, this song's subject is somewhat reminiscent of the Eagles' "New Kid in Town" released only two years prior. Banks realised he wasn't as lucky as he thought, as there were new musical acts being discovered every day, and he and his band could and would be easily replaced. Of course, the number of rock acts since has only multiplied, but Banks can take some consolation in the fact that the band persevered for another 20 years after the song was written.

19. "Follow You Follow Me"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vRD49AFxJVI After the band plugged away for almost a decade, "Follow You Follow Me" was the first Genesis song to reach the American Top 40 and UK Top 10. Banks noticed that it was also the first one to garner attention from their female audience, as more appeared in droves at their concerts after the single was released. I know many people feel this is where this formerly progressive-rock band tipped over the edge into selling out, but consider this pop gem again. Upon repeated listens, you begin to hear things you may have not before, like Rutherford's layered guitar work in the background, Banks' uplifting keyboard solo, and Collins' off-beat, bossa-nova rhythm. Yes, the lyrics are very simplistic, but sometimes you don't need numerous polysyllabic words to say something deep. It's so earnest and heartfelt, especially when Collins abandons the lyrics entirely at the song's finale and just starts chanting the melody like a child, it can bring a tear to my eye.

18. "Duchess"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J3fLoF-Jus0 Similar in theme to "Many Too Many," which was also written by Banks, "Duchess" is the simple story of the rise and fall of a female pop star. Banks has since admitted that the titular character was always meant to be a not-so-thinly-veiled stand-in for Genesis itself. At the beginning of the song, the musician plays with her heart and isn't worried about audience expectations, but once she becomes famous, she wants to give the people more of what they want. This, of course, backfires, and soon there comes a time "when nobody call(s) for more." Banks admitted in the late '90s that the band was basically experiencing the last verse of this song.

17. "Misunderstanding"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bmFRvpwVSwo Written by Collins, this song was originally supposed to appear on his debut solo album Face Value, but the band plucked it for Duke instead. Collins claims he also offered "In the Air Tonight," the monster hit for which he is probably most well-known, to the band, but Rutherford and Banks have sworn they don't remember that happening. If it did, you can rest assure they are kicking themselves. Regardless, "Misunderstanding" is still a pleasant tune about a...wait for it...misunderstanding between a man and his would-be date. Backed by a bouncy, Beach Boys beat, complete with "Whoos" in the background, the band was furthering their stake on the pop market.

16. "Turn It On Again"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HPmqWsvnQkM A screed against television, "Turn It On Again" was ahead of its time, as it was recorded decades before reality TV and other depressing fare passing as "entertainment" these days. Somewhat ironically, given the song's condemnation of the boob tube, PBS at one point used it as the theme for the channel's logo. Still, staring blankly at the screen is "just another way of passing the day."

15. "Abacab"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QbjfesCI254 Named after the song's early structure, with parts labeled after certain letters of the alphabet (A to B to A...get it?), "Abacab" is an art-rock masterpiece, complicated enough to feature multiple chord changes but still commercial enough to get stuck in your ear for days€”and in a good way. With its noodling keyboard work, syncopated percussion, and beautifully biting guitar riffs, it's no wonder they named the album after this hit.

14. "No Reply At All"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qi5y5aDiqlE This is one of the few Genesis tunes to take advantage of a horn section (courtesy of Earth, Wind & Fire), something Collins heavily relied on throughout his solo career. In that respect, you could say it sounds more like a Collins song than a Genesis one, though the jam band Phish chose to play it at the ceremony when Genesis was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 2010. As its name implies, "No Reply at All" is about miscommunication, and my favorite part is the bridge (which is rarely a favorite part of any song), as Collins loudly pleads with his lover while Banks tickles the ivories in a moving crescendo.

13. "Keep It Dark"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gQkiqQ7zZBQ Despite sounding at home on a pop radio station, this song was fittingly darker. It's about a man who is abducted by aliens and taken to a bright, happy world, and when he is returned to his family, he lies about being captured by money-hungry robbers since he realises no one would believe the true story (hence, the title of the song). More interestingly, the music sounds like the three members of the band are in heated competition with each other. Backed by Rutherford's repeated guitar riff, the melody is suddenly interrupted several times by something that resembles Collins having a percussive fit, only to have Banks' keyboards noisily drive the song back into the original groove. It's a strange and unforgettable experience.

12. "Man On The Corner"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=htTTrXB025E If this song sounds like a solo Phil Collins track, that's because it was completely written by him€”words and music. It's also fairly straightforward compared with other Genesis tunes, but it's no less meaningful. Backed by haunting synths, Collins observes the lonely life of a homeless man yelling on the street, trying to get anyone's attention but failing. A similar sentiment would be echoed several years later on his hugely successful solo hit, "Another Day in Paradise," this time featuring an elderly woman seeking help in a big city but finding none.

11. "Mama"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z1LOWEufAH0 The band's most successful single in the UK, "Mama" was also probably how Norman Bates from Psycho serenaded his mother. Collins has never sounded crazier before in his career, laughing maniacally before collapsing into a weird sneer. The song tells the sordid story of an insane man who's got a major mother complex. And who could forget that driving, pounding gated-reverb drum that opens the song? Producer Hugh Padgham, who would go on to produce their multiplatinum Invisible Touch coming up next on this list, said he was "tired of hearing records that sounded like they were recorded in cardboard boxes." He maintained that when you went to live concerts, the drums are so loud, "you almost can't stand it," and he wanted to replicate that experience on an album. Mission accomplished, Hugh.

10. "That's All"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bCUXR3ept00 Here's a song with probably more simplistic lyrics than "Follow You Follow Me" ("I could say 'day,' and you'd say 'night'/Tell me it's black when I know that it's white"), but damn it all if it ain't catchy! Armed with an incredibly hooky chorus and Collins' charismatic snarl as he angrily delivers each line to his ex like a spiked martini, "That's All" was a rare feat: a pop song with edge.

9. "Invisible Touch"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pW68T84RLHw I know that the artistic merits of this album were lauded by Patrick Bateman, the titular psycho in American Psycho played by a pre-Batman Christian Bale, but I don't care. He was mostly right. The first side of the album alone was in regular radio rotation (the first four songs I selected here), but even if a single second never hit the airwaves, this album was the firmest testament of this trio's pop talent during their '80s heyday, which is right when I started really paying attention to music. In fact, this was the first rock album I bought, unless you count the Rocky IV soundtrack, and I don't. The danceable title track, which is also the opening number, is a standout tune, of course, and was a nice precursor of what to expect on the rest of the album. To this day, it remains the only Genesis song to reach number one on the American charts.

8. "Tonight, Tonight, Tonight"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1MWe2_WYcEs Long before The Smashing Pumpkins stole the title of this song, Genesis let everyone know in the '80s that being addicted to drugs was akin to "coming down like a monkey." Heavier and moodier than the first song, with a nice patchwork of percussive rhythms and eerie themes from Banks' keyboards, "Tonight, Tonight, Tonight" continued the pop sensibility of the album while highlighting the nobler cause of fighting drug addiction.

7. "Land Of Confusion"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zU9lv_WqK6k This was my favorite song of all time when I was a kid, and that was before I saw the groundbreaking video with all those freaky looking puppets (since I didn't have MTV). Even though I was too young to understand all the sociopolitical ramifications of the lyrics ("You mean Superman is actually a reference to Ronald Reagan?"), I was certainly aware of the song's powerful message: We've only got one world, so let's not screw it up, okay?

6. "In Too Deep"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=okgJc3qYkhg This is one of the most romantic breakup songs I've ever heard. Collins' vocals are at his silky smooth best here; I honestly don't think he's ever sounded better (and this is coming from someone who owns every Genesis and Phil Collins album). Maybe it's because the song happens to be set in the perfect key for his alto vocals, but it's just an incredibly moving performance, especially the final line, "Now I want to spend my life just caring 'bout somebody else."

5. "Throwing It All Away"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0yIHmMlUofw With its near Rastafarian rhythm and cheerful guitar riff, this is one of the happiest sounding "I-got-dumped" songs you'll ever hear. For me though, this song will always spark up late '80s nostalgia of sitting on my bed playing Nintendo with this tape in my stereo as I sang along to Phil and the boys: "Now who will light up the darkness, and who will hold your hand?/Who will find you the answers, when you don't understand?" Try to resist it. It's impossible.

4. "No Son Of Mine"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GsUpBsbJy4Y I'm a little embarrassed to admit that I used to think this song was autobiographical, but it's hard to blame me from the earnestness in Collins' voice as he tells the sad story of a son who runs away from his home and abusive father and then, years later, tries to reconcile with him again, only to have the father angrily shout the title phrase back at him (sort of the antithesis of the famous prodigal son story from The Bible, where the father welcomed his wayward son with open arms). Personally, this song will be most remembered for that elephant-like moan in the beginning.

3. "Jesus He Knows Me"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EprQGmZ3Imw Years before parodying televangelists was clichéd, Genesis sank their satirical teeth into the hypocritical world of TV preachers ("Won't find me practicing what I'm preaching"). Collins admitted that when he first saw a preacher on T.V. pleading for viewers to send him money and "touch the screen" in order to be healed, he naturally assumed it was a comedy routine, but then he realized that the guy was serious because it went on for too long. Inspired, he helped pen this song: "God will take good care of you/Just do as I say, don't do as I do."

2. "I Can't Dance"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g8hSzRsSwIU Truth be told, I wasn't a big fan of this song when I first heard it. It's mostly a joke song, and even a few members of the band have basically said as much. Banks must've thought so, with the numerous ridiculous sound effects spewing from his keyboards (some sounding like cutlery hitting a wall), but I couldn't make a list of the most noteworthy€”pun somewhat intended€”songs of Genesis without this track, if nothing else because it introduced the world to the signature, walk-like "dance" of the band, made especially famous on their tours. As you probably know (if you're a fan), the song is a parody of T.V. commercials, specifically ones hawking jeans and the dumb models parading around in them who "can't dance...can't sing." (Sorry Collins detractors, Phil wasn't talking about himself.) Besides the silly music, the lyrics are still humorous two decades later ("I never thought so much could happen just shooting pool").

1. "Hold on My Heart"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DL9gl3TWwKE The original title of this ballad was "Holding My Heart," but Collins deemed the song sounded "too medical." Luckily, he changed it, and it became yet another chart topper, one of the last in their long oeuvre. Many people actually confused this with a solo hit by Collins, because he was the one who normally waxed nostalgic about romantic love affairs, but Banks' soothing, overlapping keyboards that have almost become a Genesis trademark give the song away. Over 25 years, Genesis went through many different incarnations and two and a half lead singers (I'm not counting that Scottish guy on Calling All Stations as a full person), but the quality of their quintessential progressive rock has always stayed consistent. Any band that can go from the experimental, 23-minute "Supper's Ready" to the catchy, radio-friendly "Invisible Touch" without losing its integrity is definitely one for the history books.

Contributor

Michael Perone has written for The Baltimore Sun, Baltimore City Paper, The Island Ear (now titled Long Island Press), and The Long Island Voice, a short-lived spinoff of The Village Voice. He currently works as an Editor in Manhattan. And he still thinks Michael Keaton was the best Batman.