There is no question about it - Buckethead, the white-masked, nunchaku-wielding, KFC-bucket-hatted giant that lives in a chicken coop and only speaks through his hand puppet Herbie - is the most memorable non-Axl member that GN'R have had since Slash left the band. That is, of course, partially due to his rather recognisable image. However, it is also because he is technically superb, and arguably defined the sound of Chinese Democracy more than anyone aside from Rose himself. Buckethead is best known as a shredder and is pretty much the fastest around, which is one reason why he has come in for criticism from some fans that prefer a slower approach. It's also why many question whether he would fit back into the lineup that he left in 2004, given the enduring presence of fellow speedster Bumblefoot. The fact is, though, that Buckethead is far more eclectic stylistically than he is given credit for. Check out his odd experiments on the intro/verses of Shackler's Revenge, his excellent performances throughout Madagascar and Prostitute, or his gorgeous album-stealing solo on Sorry for proof that Bucket can do the lot. There's also his wide-ranging solo career, which has seen him excel at practically every guitar style imaginable, or his genre-flipping work in bands like Bill Laswell's Praxis. He could complement the more blues-y styles of both Fortus and Bumblefoot immaculately. Most fans would welcome Bucket back into the fold. Some might even prefer his return to the next-to-zero-percent-chance of Slash rejoining. Either way, his presence would provide a much-needed boost to the new band, although the unsavoury nature of his departure (since forgiven by Axl) may have closed the door on any reunion. If you're reading this, Buckethead, come back. GN'R needs you. Oh, and bring your buddy Brain along too - he's still the best drummer the band has ever had.
