5 Most Overrated Songs By Decade

Blink 182 All The Small Things Throughout the years, I've often wondered what exactly makes a song a hit€”and wondered even greater why certain songs are hits in the first place. I think I should qualify what I mean by "overrated." None of the songs on this list are "bad" per se, but I felt they didn't deserve the lavish praise heaped on them after their recording nor the endless plays on the radio. In other words, there are plenty of worse songs out there, but none of them "earned" the success or were played to death like these five (in chronological order by decade):

Most Overrated Song Of The '60s: "My Way" - Frank Sinatra

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=egY8rUpxqcE Right away, this selection is going to turn a lot of people off, simply because it's so cherished, but that's precisely my point. This song is not only a "classic," it's considered Sinatra's defining standard, but have you ever sat down and really listened to it? The melody is slow, plodding, and predictable (it's really just a long crescendo), and it was based on an even older French tune. The lyrics aren't very admirable either. Frank brags about how he did everything his way, and we should all learn to deal with that. Well, good for him. Being selfish and stubborn isn't something to croon about. This Paul Anka-penned piece should have been one of Sinatra's B-sides, not the one by which all his other hits are judged. I'd rather hear "Come Fly Away" or "New York, New York" any day.

Most Overrated Song Of The '70s: "You're So Vain" - Carly Simon

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b6UAYGxiRwU Talk about dullsville. The music is instantly forgettable after you hear it, though the lyrics improve somewhat. It's a slightly clever nod to not trying to think about someone while you're clearly thinking about them: "You're so vain/you probably think this song is about you." Then again, the chorus doesn't even rhyme. But it doesn't matter how quasi-clever the lyrics are; the melody is so trite, all I hear in my head is Charlie Brown's teacher: "Blah, blah, blah...." On the flipside, Simon's "The New Jerusalem" from the Working Girl soundtrack truly boasted melodic surprises; it was downright operatic, not to mention inspirational since it's sung about the city so nice, they named it twice: New York. Rightfully so, it earned Simon an Oscar for Best Original Song.

Most Overrated Song Of The '80s: "Too Shy" €“Kajagoogoo

Where to begin? Well, let's start with that band name. How do you even pronounce it? And do you dare try? I don't care what '80s compilation you buy, whether it's downloaded off the 'net or bought in a brick-and-mortar store (if any are still around), it's going to feature this song somewhere. I understand that '80s synthesizers were always cheesy, but this '80s synth pushes Velveeta to new, lactose-intolerance limits. And that chorus: "Too shy shy!/Hush hush!/Eye to eye!" Say whaaaat? After being canned from the group, lead singer Limahl eventually went on to sing the memorable theme song to "The NeverEnding Story," which at least had a decent melody.

Most Overrated Song Of The '90s: "All the Small Things" - Blink 182

Don't get me wrong. I loves me some blink-182. Not only do I own six of their albums (seven if you count their latest EP), I even own the debut of Boxcar Racer, their experimental side-project. So you can trust me when I say that "All the Small Things" is a lesser blink-182 song. It falls prey to my usual complaint on this list: an unremarkable, somewhat lifeless melody, which is saying something for a fast punk band, but the biggest sin of all is the lyrics. The entire chorus, what's supposed to be the best part of the song, consists entirely of "Na-nas," what lyricists call "filler words" when they can't come up with real words (in the same family as "La-las," a la The Smurfs). This is the ultimate filler song, and when I first bought the album it came from, "Enema of the State," I actually used to skip this track, but then a funny thing happened: It became a massive hit. So huge, in fact, that it's probably the one they're most known for. (Peter Griffin even referenced it on Family Guy when trying to differentiate who sang it, Sum 41 or blink-182.) Over the years, I've come to begrudgingly accept this song's success and even leave it playing when my CD cues to this track, but for a real taste of what this band can do, listen to one of their earlier hits, "Dammit," which was also featured on the soundtrack to Can't Hardly Wait. The angry urgency of the music is perfectly balanced by the ironic lyrics of a relationship gone horribly, horribly wrong: "And you'll smile, and I'll wave/We'll pretend it's okay." And the chorus, as it should be, truly is the best part of the song: "And it'll happen once again/You'll turn to a friend/Someone who understands/Sees through the master plan." This "master plan" of trying to find true love through a minefield of rejection hit me hard in the chest when I first heard it in my early 20s. Despite being ensconced in the safety of a long-term relationship now, the younger me remembers how painful it was, and the song still resonates.

Most Overrated Song Of The '00s: "Need You Now" - Lady Antebellum

This may sound narcissistic, but in this case, I think it may be justified. When I used to be in a band, my singer once asked, "Have you ever listened to the songs on the radio and thought, 'Our songs are better than this!'?" And we both immediately suggested this late '00s "gem" by Lady Confederacy, I mean Antebellum. Can lyrics get any Hallmark-card plainer? ("I don't know how/I can do without/I just need you now") The only interesting lyric is the too-brief bridge: "I'd rather hurt than feel nothing at all." Yeah, I hurt alright...listening to this song. SLAM! "Need You Now" went on to win the Grammy for Song of the Year, hence its inclusion on this list. So what other, criminally overrated songs did I miss? Let me know in the comments below.

Contributor

Michael Perone has written for The Baltimore Sun, Baltimore City Paper, The Island Ear (now titled Long Island Press), and The Long Island Voice, a short-lived spinoff of The Village Voice. He currently works as an Editor in Manhattan. And he still thinks Michael Keaton was the best Batman.