6 Biggest Beatles Mysteries
Paul isn't dead. But there's still a lot we don't know about the fab four.
In the space of just ten years, The Beatles would revolutionise music in a manner which is likely never to be repeated on the same scale. John, Paul, George, and Ringo would go from a group of local musicians trying to make their name around Merseyside into internationally renowned superstars regularly mobbed by adoring fans.
Even 50 years after the fab four went their separate ways, the indelible impact on popular music continues to be seen to this day. Their role in the shaping of popular culture has been discussed extensively, and the group are still the highest-selling artists of all time with nearly 280,000,000 sales worldwide.
During peak Beatlemania, and even in the years that followed, the group attracted a legion of adoring fans who have investigated and analysed even the minutiae of their activities extensively. Moreso than any other band in history, The Beatles have been chronicled to a point where fansites can tell you what they were doing on almost any given day during their time together.
Which is why you might find it surprising that despite the sleuthing of superfans the world over, several mysteries about The Beatles, and those around them, have gone unsolved in the years since the group's breakup.
6. What Happened To Carnival Of Light?
During their recording career, The Beatles released a total of 213 songs. However, in the years since their breakup, more than 100 further tracks have been officially released with countless others having been unearthed and released by fans.
Basically, if the band recorded something during the height of their fame, superfans will have managed to get their hands on it in the years since.
Which is what makes the case of Carnival of Light so intriguing. Recorded in 1967 when the group's interest in avant-garde compositions was at an all-time high, the song would only be played in public once, at The Million Volt Light and Sound Rave, though those who did hear it didn't exactly return with glowing reviews of the track with McCartney biographer Barry Miles stating:
The tape has no rhythm, though a beat is sometimes established for a few bars by the percussion or a rhythmic pounding on the piano. There is no melody, though snatches of a tune sometimes threaten to break through. The Beatles make literally random sounds, although they sometimes respond to each other; for instance, a burst of organ notes answered by a rattle of percussion.
So, maybe it is for the best that this highly sought-after track has never seen the light of day. I defy anyone who can honestly say that the White Album wouldn't still be one of the all-time best albums without similarly avant-garde track Revolution 9.
Despite that, over the years McCartney has confirmed that the track is in his possession so don't be surprised if Carnival of Light does get an official release sometime this decade.
5. John Lennon's Creepy Association With The Number 9
Throughout John Lennon's tragically short life there remained a few constants: he expressed himself through his art, he allied himself with strong women, and he had a strange relationship with the number nine.
Let's go right back to the start of Lennon's life. He was born on 9 October 1940, with his first home being number 9 Newcastle Road.
The coincidences would continue as John began his burgeoning music career: on 9 February 1961, The Beatles would make the first of their 292 appearances at the Cavern Club in Liverpool. Then exactly nine months later on 9 November 1961, future Beatles manager Brian Epstein would see the group live for the first time. The group would go on to sign their deal with record label EMI on 9 May 1962 and made their debut in the US on the Ed Sullivan Show 19 months later on 9 February 1964.
Lennon was completely aware of the many coincidences involving the number and would incorporate its significance in his life into his music. The Beatles' eponymous 'White Album' would mark the ninth studio release in the UK and included the divisively abstract avant-garde composition Revolution 9 as its 29th track.
The final coincidence relating to the number nine in Lennon's life was a tragically fatal one. After he was shot by Mark David Chapman he was rushed to Roosevelt Hosptial on 9th Avenue, Manhattan and announced dead on arrival.
4. Who Wrote In My Life?
In My Life is not only one of the greatest Beatles songs of all time but one of the best examples of popular music ever recorded. Don't just take my word for it though, Rolling Stone ranked it 23rd on their 500 Greatest Songs of All Time list back in 2004.
The nostalgic ballad in which Lennon sings wistfully about his childhood would be featured on the group's 1966 album Rubber Soul.
As with many classic compositions in the Beatles catalogue, the song was credited to Lennon and McCartney with the lyrics penned entirely by Lennon. The mystery around the song comes from who wrote the famous melody. In a 1976 interview, McCartney claimed that the song's tune was his work, claiming to have taken inspiration from Smokey Robinson and The Miracles.
I liked 'In My Life.' Those were words that John wrote and I wrote the tune to it.
In one of the final interviews before his death, Lennon would contradict his former bandmate's account saying that McCartney's melodic contributions were confined solely to the song's middle eighth.
The debate has continued amongst Beatles aficionados in the decades since, but a 2018 study may have finally shed some light on the mystery. Using techniques drawing on Lennon and McCartney's melodic tendencies, Mark Glickman, Ryan Song, and Jason Brown noted that it was highly probable that the majority of the song's melody was written by Lennon alone.
So while this Beatles mystery may have finally been put to bed, the next will likely never be revealed...
3. What Happened To Paul McCartney's Bass?
When Paul McCartney walked into a music shop in Hamburg in 1961 he had no idea that his frugality would find him an instrument that would eventually be forever associated with his legacy as a musician.
With the visit taking place before the group's commercial success, McCartney said that he chose the Hofner bass not because he particularly liked it but because he could not afford the more expensive brands:
I remember going along there, and there was this bass which was quite cheap. I couldn't afford a Fender. Fenders even then seemed to be about £100. All I could really afford was about £30 . . . so for about £30 I found this Hofner violin bass.
This model would go on to serve McCartney as his primary instrument throughout his early years with the group before Hofner presented him with an updated model in 1963. The instrument would then take a backseat as McCartney's reserve bass, last seen in the Revolution music video in 1968 until it was stolen a year later from Abbey Road studio during the sessions for the Let It Be album.
In the years since a series of conspiracy theories have clouded the possible whereabouts of the famous instrument. Hofner even offered an amnesty on anyone who could provide definite whereabouts or information about the bass.
Despite this, at the time of writing, we are no closer to knowing the true fate of one of the world's most iconic, and unfathomably valuable, guitars.
2. Who Is The Man On Abbey Road?
Of the many things that The Beatles innovated in modern popular music, one they perhaps don't get enough credit for is their advances in album artwork. From their sophomore effort, With The Beatles, featuring their seminally half-shadowed faces, to the later psychedelic extravagance of the Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band cover, the group never failed to bring the artwork to the forefront of the art.
However, perhaps the most iconic of the Beatles' album covers is that of the 1969 masterpiece Abbey Road. The photograph of the four members walking along the zebra crossing outside the studio the album is named after has gone on to enter music folklore.
Though much of the fan-sleuthing at the time was dedicated to whether the arrangement of the picture contained any clues relating to the conspiracy that McCartney had died and been replaced by a lookalike, more recent research has unearthed another question.
Who is the man in the background of the famous artwork?
According to most reports, the man unknowingly featured in the image was Paul Cole, an American tourist who found himself walking on Abbey Road after deciding not to go into a nearby museum with his wife. Cole would later recall that he thought the group looked like a "bunch of kooks" due to McCartney being barefoot.
However, the mystery may not be solved. A fan blog makes a number of great points as to why Cole may not have been the man featured in the image and that, in fact, several people have recognised themselves in the background of the famous artwork over the years.
With Cole's passing in 2008, it is likely that the definitive truth of who is featured in the photo will never be uncovered.
1. What Happened To Jimmie Nicol?
When Jimmie Nicol received a phone call from Beatles manager Brian Epstein asking him to fill in for an ill Ringo Starr on the Beatles world tour in 1964, he was just 24 years old. Nicol was chosen as he was a session drummer who had recently played on a Beatles tribute album, making him the perfect candidate to temporarily replace Starr for a number of gigs.
Imagine that you're going about your daily business when suddenly you get a phone call asking you to join up with the biggest group in music to tour the world on just a day's notice. After a successful audition, Nicol was forced to undergo a makeover, including having his hair cut into the famous mop-top style, and joined the band as they embarked on the tour.
Nicol would end up playing ten shows during his whirlwind period as a stand-in member of the fab four, including stops in the Netherlands, Denmark, Hong Kong, and Australia before a now-healthy Starr joined up with the rest of the group to play the remaining dates.
In the space of two weeks, Nicol had gone from total obscurity to unfathomable superstardom and then back to his regular life. Just one year after his foray with the group, Nicol declared bankruptcy and would later quietly retire from the music industry.
In the years since, details on Nicol's life have been scant, save for a rare interview in 1988 where he discussed his time with the group. The most recent information confirmed that the former drummer is still alive, and now living a secluded existence in Mexico.
Nicol's legacy will never be forgotten though. After all, it was his predilection for the phrase 'it's getting better' when asked how his time in the band was going that would later serve as the inspiration for Paul McCartney to write the song Getting Better.