7 Musical Comebacks That Failed Spectacularly

Sometimes it's best just to leave your legacy inside a glass case.

What it must be like to be a celebrity who has suddenly fallen out of favor with a once-adoring public. The confusion, the despair, the isolation. They probably go through at least three of the 5 Stages of Grief. There also tends to be a fair amount of desperation that seeps into their hearts the longer they've been forced into the shadows. For some reason, that desperation reeks a lot more when it's coming from a musician. Though there's no scientific term for this, it's theorized that former music stars' grasp of reality just gets shakier with each passing day that they're not in the studio recording. Let's call it "Songpoxia." (There, now it is science.) And make no doubt about it, it's almost impossible to keep these musicians out of the spotlight for very long, regardless of how potentially sad the outcome is. Because, in their own minds at least, there's a big comeback on the horizon. A wonderful, Johnny Cash-like resurgence is just an album or a tour away. Who cares if they haven't been relevant in over a decade? The time to re-shine is now! Give them all credit for trying, because sometimes these left field comebacks are outrageously successful. Most of the time, though, they serve as cautionary tales that no one ever seems to heed.

7. Ma$e

Ma$e reached the height of his popularity as a part of Puff Daddy's Bad Boy Records and was never more relevant than he was when dancing alongside Diddy in the music video for "Mo Money, Mo Problems." If that sentence doesn't depress you, you're probably the type of person who watches Schindler's List twice in a row. But Ma$e left the music industry in 1999 to pursue "a higher calling," becoming a minister so that he could lead his fans away from the "path to Hell" he thought he'd put them on. But evidently G-O-D was satisfied with Ma$e's penance after only five years, because that's how long it took him to leave the ministry and go back to music, although this time he rapped clean and awkwardly inserted Christian messages into his songs. Dubbed the "Bad Boy gone clean," Ma$e and his return album, Welcome Back, couldn't replicate the success he had as a "Bad Boy still dirty," and went back into the shadows almost immediately, largely due to some contractual issues between him and Diddy. It was a short-lived, spiritually unsatisfying return. He's been toiling away on mix tapes ever since, though he's supposed to be releasing a new album in 2015. Hopefully this comeback will stick.

6. Kiss - Sonic Boom

Kiss were true titans of rock music during the 70s. No one can dispute the fact that they put on one of the best live shows of all time, regardless of how stupid Peter Criss looked in that cat make-up. But eventually, a band thinks they need to evolve to roll with the ever-changing tide in the music industry. (Though Alice Cooper would beg to differ.) They proceeded to make a bunch of terrible career decisions. Toward the end of the 70s, they tried releasing four, individual solo albums (on the same day) in place of one, cohesive group album. In the 80s, Kiss washed the make-up off their faces and went all Mr. Big with it, switching into full-on power ballad mode. But no attempt to recapture the glory (and money) of their heyday was more egregious than their 2009 "reunion" album, Sonic Boom. With only two members of the original line-up willing to put the make-up back on (Paul Stanley and Gene Simmons, who, to be fair, are the only members people even remember), the album was only okay, underselling almost every previous album they'd released, including the godawful Music From "The Elder". They made another record with the new line-up in 2012 called Monster, which moved even fewer copies. (Damn you, digital music!) But it seems they've finally caught it quits again--for now--and have chosen to focus on their recently acquired share of the Arena Football League. That, sadly, is not the set-up to an awesome punch line.

5. Vanilla Ice

Vanilla Ice is to rap music what vanilla ice cream is to rap music: bland and wildly unnecessary. And you can dress it up any way you want, but underneath all that flash (and chocolate syrup) there's still just a bowl of boringness. When he was finally, mercifully pushed out of mainstream consciousness in the mid-90s, Ice took it hard. Real hard. And how do you bounce back from something like that? You get hard yourself. In fact, you get...Hard to Swallow. Ice was somehow even less nuance than Fred Durst when it came to mixing hardcore rap and metal. The response by critics could be generously called "lukewarm." The response by consumers was worse, with most wishing they've never heard his "edgier" version of his biggest hit, "Ice, Ice, Baby" which he repurposed for Hard to Swallow. From there, a life of reality TV participation and guest spots in box office failures was just a few years away.

4. Ashanti

In the middle of the 00s, every hardcore rapper had to have a duet with a sweet little R&B songstress. Those were the rules. Abide by them or suffer the fate of DMX. It also happened that more than half of the time, that sweet little R&B songstress was Ashanti, who went around collecting guest spots like they were limited edition Beanie Babies. Over the span of just a few years, she collaborated with Ja Rule, Fat Joe, Big Pun, Ja Rule again, Fabolous, Method Man, Ja Rule again, Nelly, and a posthumous 2Pac. Ashanti was the girl to soften your gangster style. Unfortunately, her solo career never entirely took off and she faded away without many people noticing. To get back in the limelight, she went back on tour in 2014 with (who else?) Ja Rule, but the duo was mostly overlooked in favor of another rap/R&B couple: Beyonce and Jay-Z, who were in the middle of their mega-selling On The Run Tour. During her suspiciously long time away from the recording studio, Ashanti also tried her hand at acting, landing her first role as a series regular on Army Wives. Unfortunately, the show was cancelled the very next season. Because apparently she doesn't get to be the focal point of anything ever.

3. Limp Bizkit

Should Limp Bizkit ever have been allowed to have a music career to come back to? The answer to that is certainly debatable, though it's much harder to argue that Fred Durst and his crew of fellow hooligans shouldn't have just let sleeping does lie once the frenzy surrounding "Nookie" died down. They've tried to recapture some of that original, um, magic (?) over the last decade or so, but have never been able to elbow their way back onto the mainstream radar. Not even close, actually. He was booed and heckled off stage in a 2003 supporting Metallica. The Unquestionable Truth Part 1 in 2005, but it was so poorly received that they didn't bother with the intentioned sequel. Their 2011 album, Gold Cobra, was actually not terribly received by critics, but their record label apparently felt differently and dropped them like a piece of flaming meatloaf that should have never been picked up with your bare hands in the first place. They're now a part of Lil Wayn'e record label, Cash Money Records, which is currently embroiled in a hot mess of lawsuits and infighting. So that should work out well.

2. Dru Hill

Long before Sisqo was celebrating the butt cheeks of the summer of '99 with the "Thong Song," he was a member of Dru Hill, a popular R&B/soul group that specialized in baby-making music. They had such a good thing going that Sisqo decided to leave his group mates high and dry immediately following their hugely successful sophomore album. But, as we all know, the Sisqo train wasn't meant to roam the tracks for very long. (Two years, to be exact.) So, out of the kindness of his heart and from the bottom of his empty wallet, he decided to get the gang back together in 2008. They made this wonderful announcement live on a Baltimore radio station. Not ten minutes later, one of the members, James "Woody" Green, makes his own announcement, which is that he would be leaving the group to "follow God's calling." Sisqo freaked out and left the studio immediately, yelling "I wish you would've told us this YESTERDAY." The other group members got physical with Green. It was a beautiful disaster. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4toUG-tZItU

1. Guns N Roses

The granddaddy of all failed comebacks, Axl Rose and his bandmates (which he insists on referring to as Guns N Roses, despite a lack of anything that resembles that band) were supposed to make 1999 their year with an epic album called Chinese Democracy. Flash forward nearly a decade and hundreds of delays, dozens of rotating band members, and a lead singer who was quickly reaching Howard Hughes levels of reclusiveness, and there was finally a new "Guns N Roses" album. Granted, it had a personnel list longer than an iTunes user agreement, but hey, they got the thing done and now people could hear a truly visionary record! But there were more lawsuits than there were tracks on the album, with everyone suing everyone else over anything that could be remotely attached to the record. It made things messy and delayed the album even more. Surprisingly, none of this helped with the album's publicity. By the time people got around to listening to the album, they were either too fatigued by all the surrounding drama or simply couldn't appreciate Rose's self-proclaimed brilliance. Major retailers ended up selling the album at a bargain bin price to try and move their excess copies. There are currently no plans for a new album.

Contributor

Jacob is a part-time contributor for WhatCulture, specializing in music, movies, and really, really dumb humor.