8 Artists Whose Music Actually Got Better After They "Sold Out"

Sometimes a musician "selling their soul to the man" works out pretty well for music fans, too.

blondie debbie harry
wikipedia

If you choose to believe the millions of music fans who stop listening to an artist the moment they try to "go mainstream," selling out is the biggest crime a musician can commit. But not only does selling out allow more people access to their music, it can sometimes make their music better. Because the spoils of selling out, when put in the right hands, can grant artists a wider umbrella in which to create music the way they want to, without as many strictures in the recording process.

Kirk Hammett, lead guitarist and chief spokesman for sellouts, put it best when he lamented that after moving away from the metal genre and becoming a world famous hard rock band, fans were pissed that Metallica suddenly got too big and now "their favourite little band doesn't fit in their pocket anymore." It's a valid response, though one that would probably play better coming from someone who wasn't involved with St. Anger.

For the purposes of this article, we'll use the term "sellout" to mean anyone who made the leap into the mainstream, typically by way of signing with a major label. And for some of these artists, that was the best decision they could have made.

8. Green Day

Green Day Basket Case
Reprise

Though Green Day is still seen in the eyes of millions of punk connoisseurs (the most pretentious kind of connoisseur) as the band that released the world conquering Dookie before promptly becoming the world's biggest sell outs. For all of the punk purists (...ugh), Green Day is only as good as their sophomoric odes to masturbation and male prostitutes.

First of all, depending on your definition of selling out, it's quite possible that Green Day sold out before they even released Dookie, by signing with a major label. As a punk band raised in the DIY world, isn't that the most egregious sin? But fine, let's use the conventional wisdom of the average fan and say that Billie Joe Armstrong and his crew officially became unfaithful to the punk ethos by writing and recording a ballad that would be used at graduation ceremonies and in TV retrospectives for years to come. "Good Riddance (Time of Your Life)" turned Green Day into a mainstream pop-rock band. Which is not really the worst thing. Did anybody really want them to keep churning out more Dookies? (Eh? EH?)

Could you imagine a bunch of 40-year-olds writing punchy songs about the joys of fondling yourself? No, but a hard-rocking, ambitious concept album denouncing George W. Bush and detailing, song by song, the effects of his kind of thinking on impressionable youth? Oh hell yes!

While Dookie is certainly the best punk album Green Day ever made, American Idiot is without the doubt the best rock album the group released. And before it somehow became a broadway show (which is where the real selling out begins), American Idiot stood dignified as a singular, highly relatable album about the indignities of politics, the detachment of modern youth, and most of all, the importance of learning more than three power chords.

7. Nirvana

FILE - This Dec. 13, 1993 file photo shows Kurt Cobain of the Seattle band Nirvana performing in Seattle, Wash. It's been two decades since the Nirvana frontman took his own life yet he remains on in the thoughts of those he influenced and entertained
ROBERT SORBO/AP

John Lennon, Bob Dylan, Kurt Cobain. When discussing musicians who have the most integrity, who were the most true to themselves and their music and who would never dream of selling out, those three names always seem to pop up. And yet, all three of them did "sell out" in one form or another.

Dylan used his music and image to sell Chrysler cars during the 2014 Super Bowl, Lennon's career only launched in the first place because he and his bandmates underwent a drastic makeover, and Cobain...well, let's talk about Nevermind.

When Nirvana released Bleach on the indie label Sub Pop in 1989, it was seen as a stirring addition to the garage rock canon. Raw, punchy, and devoid of any sort of glossiness, it was the band's "real" defining moment in grunge. Except that it was, according to the guy who wrote the record, not very good. At all. Kurt Cobain stated that he hated Bleach for the most part, because he felt he was pressured into sounding like the grunge artists of the day and make a rock record. So he had to suppress his pop sensibilities when it came time to writing the songs, a mistake which he corrected with their follow-up, Nevermind.

He much preferred the songwriting style employed on the album that catapulted them straight onto every magazine cover in the world for the entirety of the early 90s. Dave Grohl called Nevermind "children's music," meaning it was incredibly simple and straightforward pop stuff. So either way you look at it, Nirvana made better music as sellouts.

If you're a fan of Bleach and hate the pop sensibilities of Nevermind, then you like a band whose lead singer sold out his own ambitions to conform to the grunge scene. If you like Nevermind or In Utero, then you like a band who embraced the pop song structure and gained mainstream success because of it, which is the tried-and-true definition of a sellout. Hooray for winning an argument on a technicality!


6. Sex Pistols

sex pistols
© Bettmann/CORBIS

John Lydon, the ringleader of The Sex Pistols, has proven time and time again that he was a very lucky winner in the game of circumstance. He become an unlikely figurehead for an even less likely movement and, had it not been for some rock solid timing, there's no way he and his band of miscreants would have made the peculiarly lasting impact that they did.

Despite the harshness typically thrown at 90s groups like NSYNC and the Backstreet Boys for being a part of the pop music machine, it was actually the Sex Pistols who were the first "manufactured" boy bands to come into the national spotlight. Because the Sex Pistols didn't start with Johnny Rotten or Sid Vicious or Steve Jones, it started with their manager, Malcolm McLaren. McLaren pulled together a group of kids who had a specific look and attitude--he particularly gravitated toward Lydon's sneering rudeness--and molded them into the type of band he wanted them to be: raw, obnoxious, and with only the tiniest modicum of musical ability.

This band wasn't about music, it was about creating controversy for the sake of controversy, and using the rebellious act as a way to sell records to kids who also didn't know how to sing or play an instrument. It was all a sham, really. They just kind of lucked into becoming the poster boys for punk because they fit neatly into the lines that McLaren had drawn. Never Mind the !*$% might be a classic punk album, but it was created in nearly the same fashion as Backstreet's Back.

5. Blondie

Blondie Debbie Harry
Wikipedia

Oh yeah. Blondie sold out big time. She started her career as a punk chick with a hankering for the new wave scene. And what should no true punk ever, EVER do? Write a damn disco song. Yet, that's exactly what happened with the inclusion of "Heart of Glass" on Blondie's third album, Parallel Lines.

At first, Debbie Harry wanted nothing to do with new producer, Mike Chapman, because he was an Los Angeles guy, and she was a New York gal. She no doubt feared the overly-produced reputation of the LA scene. Yet, somehow, she was pleased with the production of songs like "Heart of Glass," even though the sound completely betrayed her punk roots.

Parallel Lines is an inarguable masterpiece, and gave the band their first taste of critical and commercial success. It was straight-up pop-rock, as well, and ditched a lot of the arty flourishes they employed on their first two albums. More amazing than the resulting album, though, is the fact that an underground band from New York could turn into a pure pop act before everyone's eyes and escape the transition unscathed.

4. White Stripes

white stripes
V2 Records

Before selling out and signing to a major label for their fourth studio album, the White Stripes were the undisputed king and queen of the garage rock revival, excelling at scuzzy blues rambling and barebones instrumentation. Although that description could fit nearly any White Stripes release, those facets of their style were most evident in the early albums. There was also the fact that Jack and Meg had grown into competent musicians over this span, figuring out the key to writing tightly-crafted rock songs while keeping the signature, sleazy guitar licks to a minimum. And yes, tracks like "Hello Operator" and "Hotel Yorba" are still among the best the band has ever produced, but in terms of overall album quality, those first three can't hold a candle to Elephant, which is nearly flawless. Then again, that's part of what drove the chants of "sellout" in their direction to begin with.

The Stripes were becoming too polished and perfect for their fans, who'd grown too fond of the sloppiness to accept something as solid as Elephant. Critics who chided the duo for cashing in on their gimmickry eventually caved, with many of them offering revised (and improved) reviews after a few years. That's the thing about being labeled a sellout: Sometimes it makes journalists sell out a little bit themselves.

Their next album, Get Behind Me Satan, went into more experimental territory and revisited previous album's general unevenness. But they struck gold on a handful of songs, regardless of the genre they fell under. There's the more straightforward rock of "Blue Orchid," the old-school country fiddlings of "Little Ghost," and late-Beatles simplicity of "Take, Take, Take."

If Elephant was the first consistently powerful White Stripes album, then Get Behind Me Satan was definitive proof that they were still capable of creating a beautiful mess.


3. R.E.M.

R.E.M. Michael Stipe
Wikipedia

As guitarist Peter Buck describes their major label debut, Green was an experimental album that featured "major key rock songs" for the first time, largely due to instructions from Michael Stipe "not to write any more R.E.M-type songs." The result is incredibly haphazard, but so remarkably satisfying.

Following their move to the big-time, they also released Automatic For the People, which is universally considered, at the very least, a top 3 album in the band's extensive discography. The only album that could stand as an objectively better album is their official debut, 1983's Murmur, though we all know how easy it is for bands to capture lightning in a bottle with their first go-round, since they have, hypothetically, an almost unlimited amount of time to write and record it.

But from that album to 1988's Green, it's hard to find an album that surpasses their major label introduction.

2. Modest Mouse

Modest mouse Whale Song video
Epic

There is perhaps no better example of a band that came up with a firm grasp on the DIY ethos of indie rock and never unclenched, even while gaining a huge amount of exposure quite suddenly. Modest Mouse never really sold out, even though fans couldn't stomach the idea of "Float On" becoming a song that everybody knew. Because not everybody was supposed to know about Modest Mouse.

But that was the reality presented to fans once they heard Modest Mouse was crossing over to a major record label. And though it's hard to argue that the band did indeed become world famous for the angular licks of "Float On" a few years later, there was a brief spell where Modest Mouse was still a hidden gem tucked away on a major label.

That period is represented with the best album of their unique career, The Moon & Antarctica, a sterling example of how to retain your indie cred in the face of convention.

1. The Beatles

the beatles
Apple

"What?? How dare you!!" "You're a complete and utter imbecile!" "I hope John Lennon comes back to haunt you and torments you by playing the Two Virgins album on loop!" Those are just a few of the comments I expect to get from readers by the time I've finished explaining how The Beatles were one of the first bands to sell out.

Despite what your parents might tell you, The Beatles didn't arrive fully-formed as the mop-topped foursome who played cheesy pop songs and drove all the repressed girls crazy with their snazzy suits and odes to holding hands. That version of The Beatles wouldn't exist until manager Brian Epstein got his hands on the group. Prior to their courtship with Epstein, the Fab Four were stereotypical greasers, rocking jeans and leather jackets. They spent their nights playing in German strip clubs and, no joke, stapling condoms to the wall and setting them ablaze because...that's a sure way to get women to hold their hands?

But under Epstein's tutelage, the boys underwent a drastic makeover, performing with a "gee shucks" attitude and synchronizing their appearances and onstage movements. Then came the classic, early Beatles tunes. Then came worldwide exposure. Then came the massive discography that is one of the most celebrated in the history of pop music.

So just know that pretty much every song you've ever heard from the Beatles came after they'd already sold out.


In this post: 
Green Day
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Jacob is a part-time contributor for WhatCulture, specializing in music, movies, and really, really dumb humor.