8 Rock & Metal Bands That Drastically Switched Genres

A change of heart.

Linkin Park
Warner Bros.

A band’s genre is a huge part of their artistic identity. It can define not only the band’s sound, but the type of following that they accumulate throughout their careers in the music industry.

There are many reasons that a band can choose to stray from their genre, they may wish to tap into a wider and more lucrative market, or they might just want to evolve their sound in an industry that's constantly changing.

Whatever the reason, a change in genre can actually benefit a band, exposing them to a new audience while also maintaining their old one. But on the other hand, it can also have the reverse effect, as a weak and generic genre change can leave existing fans feeling alienated, while also failing to add any new followers to the cause, often leading to a hasty retreat to more familiar ground.

Both of these reactions have been felt by countless bands over the years, some are very prominent, but some may surprise you…

8. Slayer

As one of the "big four" of Thrash Metal, Slayer built a reputation on the fast-paced riffs, hard drumming, and aggressive vocals that are synonymous with the genre. After treading this water for fifteen years, Slayer decided to try their hand at something new in 1998.

Diabolus in Musica was the band's eighth studio album, and was their first and only endeavour into Nu Metal. Coming at a time when when the genre was at the height of it's popularity, guitarist Jeff Hanneman said that when writing the album, he was looking for something to beat, but nothing was heavy enough to even bother contesting, which resulted in the Thrash icon putting his own unique spin on the genre.

Though the album did have it's positive reviews, the majority were negative, and sure enough, by the time their next release, God Hates Us All, came around, the band had returned to where they belong, the brutal lands of Thrash Metal, and have stayed there ever since.


7. Korn

A Nu Metal trailblazer, Korn was one of the most popular acts of the late 90’s and early 00’s. They stayed true to these Nu Metal roots from 1994 to 2010 too, with their album record between these dates being absolutely astonishing.

This included the critically acclaimed Follow The Leader, which is one of the most influential Nu Metal albums ever recorded, which was home to arguably their most famous track Freak On A Leash.

This made it all the more surprising when their 2011 release The Path To Totality had the very prominent inclusion of Dubstep. It’s understandable why they decided to go in this direction, as Dubstep was a very big deal in the musical mainstream at the time, and although the ambition to try and break this market was admirable, it did not pay off for the band with the album receiving mixed reviews at best.

Chalking it up to experience and moving on, the band made their triumphant return to Nu Metal in 2013 with The Paradigm Shift, which critics and fans preferred considerably. This obviously made sense to the Californians, who’ve stuck to their roots ever since.


6. Suicide Silence

Suicide Silence was a name synonymous with the genre of Deathcore in the years following their founding in 2002. The band, from Riverside, California notched up three popular Deathcore albums between 2007 and 2011 before the tragic demise of lead vocalist Mitch Lucker in 2012.

Following the shocking event, the band reluctantly found a replacement in Hernan “Eddie” Hermida, and released their fourth studio album You Can’t Stop Me in 2014, sticking to their Deathcore roots.

In 2017, however, the band decided to take a different musical direction for their fifth studio release. The band’s self-titled album ditched Deathcore completely, and instead decided to focus on a Nu Metal sound, reminiscent of the Metal mainstream in the 1990’s. The reviews for the album were negative from both fans and critics alike.

While still remaining reasonably heavy, the album didn’t live up to the intensity of its predecessors, leaving much to be wanted from the ambitious but ultimately weak release.

As if the general panning of the album wasn’t bad enough, the bands attendance figures for live shows also dropped drastically, as did their album sales, more-so in the first week of release, where sales figures took a 69% drop from those of the previous album.

Although nothing is confirmed, it would not be at all surprising to see the band return to their Deathcore roots with their next release.


5. KISS

KISS have mostly been a Hard Rock band throughout their career, with the odd falter into Disco-Rock with Dynasty and Unmasked, and Glam Metal with Lick It Up, Animalize, Asylum, and Crazy Nights. But perhaps their most unusual genre change came in the form of Carnival Of Souls: The Final Sessions.

The 1997 release was the seventeenth studio album for the band, and saw them move into Grunge territory. The album was a critical failure, and although the single Jungle did amount to some minor success, the album as a whole failed to capture the raw, harsh Grunge feel that made the genre so popular to begin with.

What’s worse is that it also failed to harness the catchy song-writing that made KISS so enjoyable to listen to, serving only as a weak farewell to drummer Eric Singer and guitarist Bruce Kulick.

The following year, original members Ace Frehley and Peter Criss returned to the band, as did their old Hard Rock style with the album Psycho Circus which was a critical and financial success overall.


4. Avenged Sevenfold

Avenged Sevenfold are one of the most recognizable bands in modern Metal, proving that once in a while, it’s still possible for Metal to break into the mainstream, but it’s doubtful they would’ve got there without a drastic change in genre.

Starting out as a Metalcore act, the band’s first album Sounding the Seventh Trumpet was released in 2001 and was generally well received by critics, and it was more of the same for their second album Waking The Fallen, also falling under the Metalcore banner.

Although pioneering the genre, a change was in order for their third album, City of Evil, which hit the shelves in 2005. This time sporting a Heavy Metal/Hard Rock sound, the album saw a more prominent use of clean vocals, allowing the band to appeal to a much wider audience. This translated to profits for the band, as the album was both a financial and critical success.

It was more of the same for their fourth and fifth albums, which paved the way for their sixth album Hail to the King, the band’s most successful album to date, taking mainstream Rock charts by storm, which would not have possible without their change in creative direction.


3. Bring Me The Horizon

Another band that made their name in Deathcore, Bring Me The Horizon were once the hardest working band in the genre. Despite their original releases Count Your Blessings and Suicide Season being sub-par at best, the band quickly gained a large teenage following due to the apparent charisma of frontman Oliver Sykes.

This following only increased when the band took a turn into Metalcore with their 2010 album There is a Hell, Believe Me I've Seen it, There is a Heaven, But Let's Keep it a Secret. Taking a much less heavy approach, the band found a market for wider audience which brought them almost to cult status among teenage audiences.

Obviously seeing a connection between softer music and wider audiences, the band changed musical styles once again with 2013's Sempiternal, utilising a unique blend of Post-Hardcore and Electronic Rock. This obviously worked for the Sheffield natives, as the album was critically adored and financially successful.

Furthermore, the band got softer still with their 2015 release That's The Spirit, ditching almost every heavy aspect to their music, and moving almost fully into Alternative Rock. The changes over the years actually ended up giving the band a more mainstream platform for performance, gaining them high profile places on the line-ups for Reading and Leads, and the Download festival respectively.


2. Linkin Park

Linkin Park are one of the most successful pioneers of Nu Metal. Their first two studio albums were critically acclaimed and landed the Californians a great deal of mainstream success, with songs like One Step Closer and In The End remaining as passionately loved today as they ever were.

But in their later releases, the band started to move away from this particular style of music. With the 2007 release Minutes to Midnight, the tone was switched to a more radio friendly brand of Alternative Rock. The album received mixed reviews, but it did allow Linkin Park to gain exposure from a wider audience, with the song What I’ve Done even going on to feature in the original live action Transformers movie.

By the time their fourth studio album rolled around, the band had taken yet another step away from heavy music, with A Thousand Suns treading new waters in the genre of Electronic Rock. Sales figures for the album were excellent, debuting at the top of the Billboard chart, and the critical reception for the album was considerably greater than that of their third.

The Electronic Rock genre remained a consistent theme from their fifth and sixth studio albums, but for 2017’s upcoming release No More Light, the band looks to have once again taken a change in genre, to a softer and more generic Rock sound, as evidenced by the singles Heavy and Invisible.


1. Pantera

Pantera were generally known for blending the intense heaviness of Thrash Metal with the funky bass riffs of Groove Metal, but things weren't always this way for the cowboys from hell.

It's surprising to learn that Pantera actually found their roots in the world of Glam Metal, with their first three albums positively drenched in glitter-riddled cheesiness. The albums Metal Magic, Projects in the Jungle, and I am the Night, which saw legendary guitarist Dimebag Darrell appearing under the alias of Diamond Darrell, are some of the worst in Glam Metal history.

But all that changed when the band released the album Power Metal in 1988. Now fronted by the controversial Phil Anselmo, the band made the change to Heavy Metal, taking a much more serious approach to their work. Regardless of this though, there was still something missing, which was stopping the band from becoming truly great.

In 1990, however, Cowboys From Hell came along and debuted the style that Pantera are still loved for today. After finding their sound, the band ran with this throughout the remainder of their career, recording the albums Vulgar Display of Power, Far Beyond Driven, The Great Southern Trendkill, and Reinventing The Steel.

In this time period, the band gained financial and critical success galore, and cemented themselves as true legends in the world of Metal.


In this post: 
Linkin Park
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

WhatCulture contributor with a love of heavy metal and horror.