8 Underrated Albums From Your Favorite Artists

Great Bands/Great Songs/Overlooked albums.

Foo Fighters performs at the Democratic National Convention in Charlotte, N.C., on Thursday, Sept. 6, 2012. (AP Photo/David Goldman)
David Goldman/AP

Most artists become popular for their spectacular songwriting ability in their prime. These songs become etched in your brain and become an important part of who we are as fans. And more often than not fans can point to one album or one song as a band's defining statement.

But what happens to the rest of the band's discography? With one landmark album, it's typically downhill for some bands. There are different albums that fall into obscurity though. Every band has those albums that meet a deaf ear upon their initial release. These are albums where artists usually take risks or become too homogeneous for the fans to care anymore.

Among these albums, some truly remarkable albums fall through the cracks. Albums that were panned in their prime but are actually standout achievements in a band's discography. Whether it's bad marketing or too drastic a change in sound, these albums never seemed to get their proper time in the sun. So here's their time to shine. Here's a look back a bunch of great songs from great artists - but from records you probably didn't buy.

8. Linkin Park - A Thousand Suns (2010)

For most Linkin Park fans, this is where the band completely lost their way and sold out. What's this? Electronic interludes and a more synthetic sound? Nope. Hard Pass. I'm good with Hybrid Theory, thank you very much.

What those fans are missing out on is what might be Linkin Park's most ambitious album experience of their career. This record saw the band wanting to make a more conceptual record, centered around apocalyptic imagery brought about by missile attacks.

I will throw the haters a bone here and say that not everything on this album is golden. The interlude tracks seem to drag for a bit too long and not every song is a classic Linkin Park stomper. But the album is far from just electronic shenanigans. Some of the interludes help put the listener in that uncomfortable environment of life post-nuclear attack. Songs like "Robot Boy" show that world-weary sound while "Wretches and Kings" speaks of an anarchic rage hidden underneath the devastation. And "Waiting for the End" is probably one of their greatest singles.

For Linkin Park fans who didn't catch this one, give it a shot. There's a good chance you'll find something you like here even if it's not what you expect from Linkin Park.


7. The Who - A Quick One (1966)

This album falls in a period where the Who were in a weird position. They were right in the middle of their Mod days and fresh off their massive success with My Generation. But they were also not quite ready for their classic period with projects like Tommy or Quadrophenia. And this album really shows that identity crisis front and center.

Perhaps in an attempt to display a more equal effort, each member submitted songs to be used on the album. What ended up coming out is the group's zaniest effort and the sound of them having fun after that initial success. Pete Townshend's songs shine bright like on album opener Run Run Run and the adorable teen heartache on So Sad About Us. Bassist John Entwistle also stepped up with dark songs Whiskey Man and Boris the Spider, the latter of which will become your new favorite Halloween song after a few listens.

Even madcap drummer Keith Moon shows his sense of humor on the circus frenzy found on the instrumental Cobwebs and Strange. But the real standout here is on the final cut, A Quick One While He's Away. This album is the precursor to the rock operas Townshend would perfect down the road. This song has multiple movements, which no doubt inspired Billie Joe Armstrong when he was coming up with the lengthier cuts for Green Day's American Idiot at the turn of the century.

For a band that was destined to be musical storytellers, this baby step towards grander ambitions is intriguing to see.


6. Panic At The Disco - Pretty. Odd. (2007)

Panic at the Disco were already everyone's favorite emo band by the time they got to Pretty. Odd. By this time, every teenager could sing along to I Write Sins Not Tragedies and know exactly what you should do with that goddamn door. But this album was miles different.

The success of that song and album gave the band more freedom to experiment on this record, which principal songwriter Ryan Ross pounced on. He took this opportunity to make a record that was much more folksy and pulled from the Beatles' guide to writing songs. To say that this was a bit different is a tremendous understatement. But there's also something else of note: the songwriting is terrific.

This record is what Crosby Stills and Nash would sound like if they were born as millennials and had Paul McCartney writing their melodies. There are grandiose ballads on songs like Northern Downpour, peppy numbers like That Green Gentleman and full-on country tunes on Brendon Urie's solo cut Folkin Around.

These changes may have seemed like a turn-off for some fans at first, but this is the definition of an album that grows on you. With each listen, you can discover one more thing that is different. Emo boys and girls, be not afraid. This change in sound is more than just passable.


5. Foo Fighters - Echoes, Silence, Patience & Grace (2007)

The Foos had been on a hot streak with albums ever since 1997's The Colour and the Shape. However, the band had yet to shake things up on previous records; you could expect great rock ragers but not much substance underneath. This changed with 2005's In Your Honor, which featured an album of your typical Foo goodness but an extra disc with a somber acoustic mix of tracks. With this being a success, Dave Grohl made the decision to combine the acoustic and electric for their next record. The result: Echoes, Silence, Patience & Grace.

The record got a bit of buzz but was treated as just another solid entry from the Foo Fighters, aside from the colossal opener The Pretender. While that track is a standout on the record, other songs have an equal impact. Long Road to Ruin is one of the Foo's best singles, while Let It Die has a reflective spirit that seems directed at Grohl's ex-bandmate, Kurt Cobain.

The album shows the band's expertise of controlling dynamics. These songs may start slow, but they can build to something much more extravagant. This is no more apparent on the song But Honestly, which starts with just Grohl and a guitar, but explodes into one of the Foo's greatest riffs around the halfway point. Now you'll have something to seek out instead of just listening to The Pretender.


4. Tom Petty - Southern Accents (1985)

Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers were in a rough spot in their career once they came to making Southern Accents. Petty's previous effort, Long After Dark, had done good business with a few singles but Petty had expressed a distaste for the project. He decided that he would aim higher for the next album: a double CD based around the Southern United States.

It didn't exactly work out how Petty had planned. The band, including Petty, were strung out on drugs at the time and were not in any position to be producing a record. This made sessions come to a lurching pace, which resulted in a frustrated episode that ended with Petty breaking his hand.

After bringing in longtime producer Jimmy Iovine to the project, Petty decided to focus on making a solid album of tracks and ditch the double album idea. What rose to the surface is Petty's most inventive and anthemic tracks of his career. The opening track Rebels sets up shop nicely while Don't Come Around Here No More is an Eastern-inspired experiment Petty created with the help of Eurythmics mastermind Dave Stewart. The highlights of this record are the ballads that appear on the title track and album closer The Best of Everything, the latter of which Petty described as one of his personal favorites.

Amid a nightmarish development, Southern Accents stands up surprisingly well. Petty said it best by saying that the album was not what he intended, but is proud of what it has become.


3. Green Day - Warning (2001)

The pop punk darlings of the '90s had weathered pretty harsh times after their commercial breakthrough Dookie. Green Day suffered from somewhat of an identity crisis after their biggest-selling record, so they decided to experiment. This resulted in Insomniac in 1995, which had an angrier approach, and Nimrod in 1997, which was a hodgepodge of different genres, including the graduation tearjerker Good Riddance.

This culminated in the album Warning, which featured a folksy sound and a more refined lyrical approach from Billie Joe Armstrong. For most pop punk fans, this was probably where they felt the band had lost their way. But the album stands up as their most solid effort across the board.

Each song seems to have its own identity from the S&M fixation on Blood, Sex, and Booze to the Beatles-y Hold On, to the gothic circus atmosphere of Misery. This album also features Armstrong's first delve into politics in the lyrics to Minority. This showed that Armstrong had the ability to write political commentary in his pop tunes, which he would later refine on American Idiot a few years down the road.

Is this Green Day's undisputed masterpiece? I wouldn't say that. However, this album showed that the band of pop-punk brats were able to grow up and that they would continue to impress fans for years to come.


2. Pearl Jam - No Code (1996)

Ever since their debut album Ten, Pearl Jam's frontman Eddie Vedder was growing more and more wary of the tabloid circus of the rock press. This resulted in limited interviews, no music videos, and albums that became more and more experimental. These all came to a head with 1996's No Code.

Pearl Jam fans were met with songs that were perplexing to say the least. There were definite ragers like Hail Hail but much of the record ended up leaning more towards art rock than typical alternative rock. But don't let that dissuade you into thinking that it's not great.

Some of Pearl Jam's most intimate songs appear on this record like Vedder's self examination on Off He Goes and his recount of a stalker experience on the minute-long freakout Lukin. Hell, even guitarist Stone Gossard gets a turn on the mic on the song Mankind. Other rockers emerge on the tracks Smile and the explosive Habit.

Vedder said that No Code was the record that he wanted to get impersonal and distance himself from his audience. In doing so, it makes you feel like a fly on the wall during the sessions as Pearl Jam take on new creative endeavors every day to see what sticks.


1. Metallica - Reload (1997)

Metallica have been accused of selling out by the metal community for much of their career. From the ballad Fade to Black to the pop crossover of their self-titled Black Album, certain sects of Metallica fans have always been skeptical about the band's creative directions. And during the late-'90s, the sell-out cries reached a fever pitch with the albums Load and Reload.

While Load definitely had the sound of a band spinning their wheels across its 79 minutes, Reload feels like them refining the experimentation that they had touched on on the previous record.

The album kicks off with a bang in the instant classic Fuel, and it remains enthralling throughout. They have more electronic leanings on the sinister Better Than You and have their only featured artist with Marianne Faithfull adding to the track The Memory Remains. There is also an emphasis on storytelling, with Low Man's Lyric telling a tragic story of a homeless junkie, while Prince Charming shows the evil that is capable by every man.

I am of the belief that if you squeezed the best of Load and Reload onto one record, it would have been a worthy follow up to the Black Album. But of both of these records, Reload stands as one of Metallica's most moody records and one that is a great snapshot of a band trying to adjust themselves to fit the times.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97