9 Later Day Musical Crimes Perpetuated By Great Artists
Unforgivable moments of musical aggression.
It’s the question that has plagued rockstars for years: is it better to burn out, or to fade away? Should we do as The Who said and die before we get old, or do as The Who did and push on long past our Best By dates?
Musicians don’t have to embarrass themselves with age, of course. There are many bands and artists who have matured as the years have ticked on, reinvented their sound, added the timbre of wisdom and experience to their bag of tricks and brought out career best work in their dotage.
The longer you go on for, though, the more likely it is that you’ll slip up, and release a song or album that proves you’ve been left behind. In worst case scenarios, you can enter into an entire period of ineptitude, from which you may or may not be able to escape.
More often than not, these musical crimes are the result of poor decision making - scrabbling too hard to keep up with changing times, taking a job that you’re just not cut out for, failing to know when to call it a day. Pity the poor artists - but judge them, too.
9. Madonna - "Die Another Day"
It’s only fair, really, that one of the worst James Bond films gets one of the worst themes. Writing a song for the famous spy franchise is no easy feat. It’s a high pressure situation, in which your work is certain to be widely discussed and dissected long before it’s heard in its intended context. The pressure was on, and Madonna sadly did not rise to it.
While some people are ever eager to take spiteful digs at Madonna late into her career, the fact is she has managed to innovate and adapt through four decades, and brought out good stuff before and after “Die Another Day”.
There’s no excuse for this tune, though. The stuttering, clanging harshness of the techno background sidelines Madonna’s vocals, and the tune, such that it is, is instantly forgettable. Props to Madonna for doing something different than the usual booming operatic number, but “Die Another Day” doesn’t work as a Bond theme. It takes a conscious swerve from what you’d expect, which is bold, but ultimately misguided.
That’s not to say it works separate from its Bond context, though, because it doesn’t. Luckily, the film itself quickly outstrips Madonna’s efforts in terms of rubbishness.
8. Weezer - Make Believe
Purists will argue that Weezer’s musical crimes began after the Green Album, or even after the final notes rang out on Pinkerton. And while the band’s first two records eclipse the rest of their catalogue by an embarrassing degree, there’s stuff to enjoy on some of their mid period albums.
Things didn’t get truly dire for Rivers Cuomo and co until 2005’s Rick Rubin produced Make Believe, which was right around the time the band became more interested in producing music videos than music. Weezer went from a band capable of great, self-lacerating insight to bland, Steve Miller Band-aping songs about Beverly Hills.
Worst of all was “We Are All On Drugs”, a droning, smart alec attack on conformist culture. It’s tuneless and smug, reflective of a band whose once-great powers of observation had seemingly completely deserted them.
There was nowhere to go but up for Weezer, whose more recent work has been substantially better. Granted, they probably still should have split up some two decades ago, but odds are they’ll not be putting out anything quite as bad as Make Believe ever again.
7. The Clash - Cut The Crap
They’re one of the most influential bands ever to come out of the UK, but The Clash were a going concern for less than a decade. They packed a lot into that short career, though, managing to explode onto the scene, change music forever, and become dreadfully stale before reaching adolescence.
Cut The Crap, the band’s final record, is hardly a Clash album at all. Mick Jones and Topper Headon, 50% of the original line up (and the major technical talent in the group) were long gone, and Joe Strummer’s heart wasn’t in it. Manager Bernie Rhodes installed himself as producer, and the results speak for themselves.
With the exception of “This Is England”, the album is between forgettable and outright bad. The Clash were known for shifting their sound, but the prevalence of drum machines and instantly dated keyboards was a reinvention too far.
Strummer’s solo work more than rehabilitated his image in the wake of this disaster, and his untimely death in 2002 means he’s guaranteed legendary status in the world of music. As for Cut The Crap, it’s best to just pretend the band split up four years prior.
6. Michael Jackson - "Earth Song"
It’s important to be careful when talking about crimes and Michael Jackson, but if we’re focussing on the musical variety, the pomposity of “Earth Song” is hard to top. To say the King of Pop was in a turbulent period of his personal life would be to understate things somewhat, but it must have taken somewhat of a messiah complex to come out with something this lacking in self-awareness.
Jackson discovers environmentalism was the elevator pitch. The song is a near-seven minute(!) lecture from the star, who feels it’s his duty to give us all a dressing down for the reckless way we’ve abused the Earth and his natural resources. He illustrated this by shooting a video in four locations across three continents, which he presumably travelled between using some sort of aircraft.
As was his wont, Jackson works himself up into a frenzy over the course of the song, zealously shrieking at the fans to be more like him and to take the environment and animal welfare seriously (Jackson’s captive chimp Bubbles declined to comment). The song is perhaps most famous for Jarvis Cocker’s flatulent response to its performance at the 1996 Brit awards, echoing many a feeling across the world.
5. David Bowie - The Years 1984 -1995
You can’t make an omelette without breaking a few eggs; similarly, you can’t reinvent yourself every couple of years without coming up with a few duds. David Bowie has torn through personas more or less successful, but in the mid-’80s found himself in a creative quagmire from which he couldn’t wrest himself for the best part of a decade.
Bowie’s 1970s run is probably the greatest any artist has ever enjoyed. Classic albums follow one another with ruthless efficiency; he shifted styles time and again and pulled each one of them off, all the while producing albums for Iggy Pop and Mott The Hoople. The wheels were bound to come off eventually, and they did so in a big way with 1984’s Tonight.
Bowie went from setting trends to following, and then chasing them. Disappointing solo albums would be followed by Tin Machine, a hard rock project that sounded more fun to make than it was to listen to.
It wasn’t until his reunion with Brian Eno for 1995’s Outside that he righted his course. This daring, occasionally impenetrable electronic music set him up for the final two albums of his career (and life) - he ended on a high with some of the best stuff he’d ever done.
4. U2 - "Get On Your Boots"
U2’s list of embarrassing moments is a lengthy one, but they mostly revolve around the performatively worthy actions of frontman Bono. While they’re not the powerhouse they once were, musically they’ve stayed pretty consistent over a lengthy career, and have seldom made themselves look foolish.
One exception to this is “Get On Your Boots”, the first single and clear nadir of their otherwise quite good 2009 album No Line On The Horizon. For this, their 12th studio album, the lads returned to their old production team of Brian Eno and Daniel Lanois, plus their even older producer Steve Lillywhite, none of whom were able to dissuade Bono from this risible song.
Bono attempts to be arch, with lyrics he obviously finds hilarious and a puckish delivery he hasn’t been able to pull off since 1992. Musically it’s dross, ripping off Elvis Costello’s “Pump It Up” with the addition of a U2-by-numbers soaring chorus.
The rest of the album is reserved and experimental to a degree they hadn’t attempted in a good decade. “Get On Your Boots” was their attempt to create a big dumb rocker like the previous record’s “Vertigo” - somehow, they managed to come out with something even worse.
3. Gwen Stefani - "Hollaback Girl"
Nowadays she’s more visible as a fashion designer and TV personality than she is a musician, so much so that it’s possible to forget the impact No Doubt had in the ‘90s and early ‘00s. Even more damaging to her legacy, however, is her release of one of the most annoying songs of the early 2000s (itself one of the most annoying periods in music history).
“Hollaback Girl” can be dismissed as a daft, throwaway party anthem, but this would be too generous. It’s a perfectly infuriating blend of trifling and catchy, the kind of song that’ll play on loop in your brain no matter what measures you take to stop this from happening.
The sparse tune and faintly nonsensical lyrics belie a bitter edge - the song was written as a rebuttal to Courtney Love, who had dismissed Stefani as a “cheerleader”. It’s tough to see Love being too bothered by “Hollaback Girl”’s fruit spelling, boom-bapping onslaught, however.
No Doubt have toured off and on in the years since and even released a politely received comeback album, but we can say for sure that ska punk’s heyday is long in the past.
2. Pixies - Everything Post-Kim Deal
When a band loses a member, it can be a hard decision whether or not they continue. Queen with Adam Lambert was not a good idea; conversely, AC/DC went from strength to strength after the loss of Bon Scott. Pixies are an interesting example – because while Kim Deal simply left the band rather than passing away suddenly, they absolutely should not have carried on without her.
The thinking, clearly, was that Deal was just the bass player, but she was far more important than that to the band. While Frank Black was always the primary credited songwriter, Deal brought a great deal to the group with her vocals and ineffably cool vibe. Indeed, comparing the quality of Deal’s output with The Breeders to Black’s solo stuff would suggest she had a lot more involvement than sleeve credits would suggest.
Pixies have lumbered on since Deal tendered her resignation, producing three albums and a few indifferent EPs that did little for the band. Their status as an enormously important and influential group will never be challenged, but to see them adding needlessly to a once-spotless back catalogue is a little sad.
1. Dee Dee Ramone - Dee Dee King
The career path of heroin-riddled bassist in a legendary punk band to hip hop artist is a seldom-trodden one. Dee Dee Ramone’s life is nothing short of fascinating, and his brief reinvention as Dee Dee King is among the strangest moments of his life.
Dee Dee decided that the rap life was the one for him prior to leaving the Ramones (he’d show up to some of his final gigs with the band in Run DMC style regalia, to their chagrin) having learned about the world of hip hop in rehab. His first single, “Funky Man”, was the beginning of a new life for the former punk.
Or: his first single “Funky Man”, is among the worst songs ever recorded. It’s baffling from the off, with the newly monikered King introducing himself as “Dee Dee Ramone”, reminding you that he plays bass in a punk band. He proceeds to grunt and wheeze out lyrics which at best half-rhyme over a lazy beat before running out of steam.
Naturally, Ramone followed this with a full length album, which was mauled by critics, leading him to return to what he was good at. He makes Macho Man Randy Savage’s record sound like Illmatic.