9 Musicians You Probably Forgot Were Playboy Cover Girls

8. Mariah Carey

Though she didn't appear nude within the pages as the headline might suggest (there's nothing particularly "revealing" about her spread, unless you consider swimsuits to be especially tawdry), the 37-year-old singer still helped move quite a few copies of Playboy in March of 2007. Those with fond memories of Carey rollerblading in tiny jean shorts for her "Fantasy" music video were surely disappointed that this "sexy comeback" didn't involve her emancipating her Mimis.