9 Successful Bands That Changed Their Vocalist
A journey of talent and turmoil.
The vocalist is one of the most integral parts of any band, with a singer often acting as their figurehead both on and off the stage.
It is certainly one of the hardest jobs in the music industry due to the sheer difficulty of the criteria. A frontman must have the full package: charisma, stage presence, a distinctive personality, and most importantly, a good set of pipes.
Once a singer with this winning formula is found, you’d imagine that it would be plain sailing from thereon in, but this is not always the case. Be it through creative differences, a strained relationship, or the bitter sting of tragedy, sometimes a band and their vocalist go their separate ways.
This can pose a huge risk to the act; losing a familiar and well-liked member can have a detrimental effect on a bands' popularity. This issue has been tackled head-on by some of the rock scene’s most popular acts, and it’s caused some considerable turmoil…
9. DragonForce
One of the biggest names in power metal, DragonForce has been amazing audiences with their speedy instrumental work for the best part of twenty years. Formed in London, the band helped pioneer the unique genre with their lightning fast guitar solos, earth-shattering drumming style, and retro video game-like sound.
They have also became easily recognisable for their fantasy influenced lyrics, conveyed beautifully by the tones of the band's original lead singer ZP Theart. Making his first appearance on the debut album Valley of the Damned, ZP recorded a total of four studio albums with the cult metal outfit, often receiving critical praise for his vocal range both live and in the studio.
So it came as sad news for fans when the South African decided to leave the group in 2010, citing his reason as an “insurmountable difference in musical opinion”, which led to the power metal outfit finding a replacement in 2011 in the form of Marc Hudson.
Hudson remains the bands' vocalist to this day, and has recorded three studio albums with them: Maximum Overload, Reaching into Infinity, and his debut The Power Within which was home to the single Cry Thunder, their most well received song since the days of Theart.
8. Killswitch Engage
Legends in the genre of metalcore, Killswitch Engage burst onto the scene in 1999. Formed in Westfield, Massachusetts, they came together following the demise of separate metalcore bands Aftershock and Overcast. Releasing their debut album in 2000, the five-piece became trailblazers in their genre, helped in no small part by the inclusion of frontman Jesse Leach.
Leach’s heavy and rough vocals provided the perfect front for the bold and intense style the band was running with. Leach unfortunately had to leave the group in 2002 due to issues with depression, and this turn of events lead Killswitch in search for a new vocalist. After a short search, they decided that Howard Jones was the right man for the job.
Sceptical of the metalcore sound at first, Jones quickly grew to love the Killswitch style, and the 2004 album The End of Heartache shot the band into new heights of stardom. Jones’ deep and soothing clean-vocal tones provided a much more melodic feel to the bands' overall sound, and opened a gateway for a wider audience. Jones’ tenure with the band came to an end in 2012, leaving to manage his type-2 diabetes, which had previously left the frontman in a comatose state.
This opened doors for another change in vocalist, and rumours ran rampant on who the new frontman would be - until it was announced that original vocalist Jesse Leach would be re-joining the group. Armed with new determination, and a considerably improved vocal range, Leach recorded on the 2013 album Disarm The Descent, which was a critical and financial success.
Leach continues to tour and record with Killswitch Engage to this day, and improves with each release.
7. Anthrax
As one of the Thrash Metal “big four”, Anthrax have built up quite the following over the years, but the iconic New York five-piece came from humble beginnings, being signed to a record deal only after gaining a reputation for astounding live performances.
This positive reception was due in no small part to vocalist Neil Turbin, who was beloved by fans of the band for his vocal range, hitting notes that other metal vocalists could only dream about. Although somewhat lacking in originality, their debut album Fistful of Metal was very well received by critics, drawing comparisons to acts like Judas Priest.
Turbin’s spot looked to be permanently sealed, but a series of long standing personal issues got in the way, and he parted ways with Anthrax in 1984. This opened the door for the band to join with their most famous vocalist, Joey Belladonna, in 1985. The acts' second album Spreading The Disease was Belladonna’s first with the Thrash legends, and it took them into a new, more punk-influenced area of sound. Joey remained the lead vocalist through albums like State of Euphoria, and Among The Living, which is their most highly regarded album to date.
This was until Belladonna was fired in 1992 following stylistic clashes, which allowed former Armoured Saint vocalist John Bush to take the helm. Bush's work with Anthrax is generally received with mixed feelings, taking a much more alternative, and darker approach.
Bush continued to work with Anthrax until 2005, when Joey Belladonna made his long awaited return to the group. For a while, the band was torn over which man would stay on as the vocalist, but Bush admitted that he was unwilling to commit to Anthrax.
Bush would however return to front the group once more, until he was replaced for a second time by Belladonna, who was reinstated for the “Big Four Show” on the European dates of the Sonisphere Festival.
6. Rainbow
Rising from the ashes of rock band Elf, Rainbow was the brainchild of former Deep Purple guitarist Ritchie Blackmore. Choosing to leave Deep Purple, Blackmore decided to record new material with Ronnie James Dio, who fronted Elf at the time. They released their first album under the name of Ritchie Blackmore’s Rainbow in 1975.
Taking huge influences from classical music, and penning a unique, and medieval lyrical style, the band managed to establish a sizeable cult following, embarking on their first world tour in 1975. Dio would only serve to further their success with his inclusion on the iconic albums Rising, and Long Live Rock & Roll, but Blackmore was not satisfied with their commercial success and aimed to take the group in a different, more mainstream direction. Not agreeing with this directional change in the slightest, Dio left the band in 1978.
After hosting a series of auditions, Blackmore decided that Graham Bonnet was the man to front Rainbow into pastures new. The album Down To Earth, featuring the song Since You’ve Been Gone, was a successful turning point - and the new pop-rock style gained Blackmore and co some considerable exposure in the mainstream. Bonnet did not stick around long to bask in this success, though, as he left to pursue a solo career after recording only one album for the band.
Joe Lynn Turner was then brought in as his replacement, and recorded the album Difficult To Cure, which generated mixed reviews but managed to reach #3 in the UK album chart. Turner remained the vocalist until 1984 when the band disbanded, with Blackmore leaving to reform Deep Purple. They were revived in 1995. Vocalist Doogie White was brought in to record the album Stranger In Us All, which was an average seller at best.
In 1997 however, the turmoil ridden line-up was finally put out of its misery with the band being laid to rest seemingly for good. But in 2015, Blackmore reformed the group with Lords Of Black frontman Ronnie Romero, who continues as the touring vocalist to this day.
5. Judas Priest
Judas Priest are undeniable legends of hard rock and heavy metal, and were formed in 1969 with original vocalist Al Atkins. The group would embark on several small tours while rehearsing at the house of Atkins’ mother in-law. After gaining some very reputable support slots, the band hit a financial jam, which resulted in the departure of Atkins in 1973.
Eventually, singer Rob Halford was recommended to them, and the bands fortunes would soon change forever. His first recording for the band came in the form of their debut Rocka Rolla in 1974. The release amounted to no financial success at all, leaving Judas Priest in an even graver financial situation than before. But as the following albums Sad Wings Of Destiny, Sin After Sin, Stained Class, and Killing Machine were released, people started to become increasingly aware of the vocal talents possessed by Halford.
Becoming one of the most recognisable, well-liked, and critically praised vocalists in the genre, Halford would record a further seven albums with the band, including huge financial and critical successes like Painkiller, British Steel, and Screaming For Vengeance.
Internal tensions caused Halford to leave the group in 1992, which led to the band replacing the popular singer with Tim “Ripper” Owens in 1996. Ripper’s vocal style was a lot like Halford’s, having spent a chunk of his career in a Judas Priest tribute band, and he racked up two studio albums during his time with the icons.
Although the albums were not as well-received as those featuring Halford, the band stuck with Owens until 2003, when Halford made his unexpected return, much to the delight of fans and critics.
He has been performing and recording with the group ever since.
4. Iron Maiden
One of the world’s most famous bands, Iron Maiden spearheaded the new wave of British heavy metal throughout the 1980's.
Formed on Christmas Day in 1975, their original vocalist was a man by the name Paul Day. Day did not last long, and was savagely axed due to his lack of charisma in 1976. Dennis Wilcock replaced Day, but caused more problems than he was worth, generating issues between band members.
Becoming frustrated with the band, he left to pursue his own ventures, lumbering Iron Maiden without a vocalist. Thus, the hunt for a new one began.
After a spontaneous meeting in a pub, Paul Di’Anno managed to gain himself an audition with the group, which went very well for the singer, who found himself fronting the trailblazers not long after. Di’Anno would record on their self titled debut album, which was released at #4 in the UK album chart.
Following this success, the singer also recorded on the second release Killers, in 1981, which was critically successful, but did not chart as well as its predecessor. During this time, Di’Anno developed a drug problem which soon became unmanageable; following this, the singer was dismissed and replaced by a young Bruce Dickinson, and the rest, as they say, is history.
Dickinson fronted the act throughout their most successful period and became the face of the band in the process, but decided to leave in 1993 to pursue a solo career. Blaze Bayley was eventually added to the line-up, but his vocal style was met with mixed-to-negative reception, as it differed too much from that of Dickinson. Eventually, Bayley’s tenure was terminated and Maiden began searching for his replacement.
After undergoing reluctant talks, Bruce Dickinson was eventually reinstated, and has remained the touring, and recording, face of the band from that moment onward.
3. Black Sabbath
The Birmingham natives of Black Sabbath were one of the key driving forces behind the music scene in the Midlands during the late 60’s and early 70’s, and they managed to transfer this success to the global stage with multiple hit records, mostly due to the charismatic, hyper-entertaining nature of original vocalist Ozzy Osbourne.
Osbourne is one of the most famous and influential frontmen in the history of rock, thanks to the range of his early vocal work and his outstanding stage presence. The manic singer fronted Black Sabbath to bucket-loads of success by featuring on the bands' first eight studio albums, which included Paranoid, Master of Reality, and Sabbath Bloody Sabbath.
However, Osbourne’s heavy reliance on alcohol and drugs resulted in little-to-no creative input from his standpoint, which ended in his untimely dismissal from the group in 1979. It was actually Sharon Osbourne who came up with the idea for her future husband’s replacement, suggesting former Rainbow frontman Ronnie James Dio, after a failed attempt to convince Ozzy to rejoin.
Dio’s vocal range eclipsed that of the man he replaced, and his debut Heaven and Hell was a complete overhaul of Black Sabbath's musical style, which was a fresh and interesting concept to follow. After recording the follow-up album Mob Rules, a critical failure, Dio would leave shortly after to start his own solo group.
Former Deep Purple vocalist Ian Gillen was brought in to record the album Born Again, and the band received yet another spell of critical panning, but despite this, the album was a financial success, and charted at #4 in the UK.
Following the departure of Gillen, David Donato, an unknown American singer, was added to the line-up, but management were unhappy with his work and he was soon axed. Glenn Hughes was then brought in for the album Seventh Star, which received mixed reviews, but the act did not find a consistent vocalist until the introduction of Tony Martin on the album The Eternal Idol.
Martin received praise for his “powerful voice” which brought a “new fire” to the band, and he would go on to record on the albums Headless Cross, and Tyr, remaining with Black Sabbath until the return of Dio in 1990. Dio recorded the Dehumanizer album with the band, which received mixed reviews but experienced large financial success.
But not long after he would quit the band, refusing to play a support slot for Ozzy Osbourne’s band during a supposed retirement show, citing Osbourne as a “clown”. This led to Tony Martin returning as the bands' singer for his second stint, but this line-up was scrapped in favour of a reunion with Ozzy Osbourne in 1997.
The reunion lasted until 2006 when the heavy metal godfathers re-joined with Dio once again, but legal issues with Osbourne led to the band touring under the banner of Heaven and Hell.
Upon the death of Ronnie James Dio in 2010, the original Black Sabbath line-up reunited and recorded the album 13, their final studio release. Ozzy remained the lead singer until 2017, when they called it quits after embarking on their final tour.
2. AC/DC
Formed in 1973 by Brothers Malcolm and Angus Young, this rock & roll band is arguably Australia’s greatest musical export. Starting life fronted by vocalist Dave Evans, the group chose to ditch the singer in pursuit of a different musical style.
Replacing him with vocalist Bon Scott, AC/DC released their debut album High Voltage, first to Australia exclusively, and then to global audiences. What followed was a rise to stardom, spearheaded by the album Highway To Hell, which propelled the band into the cultural mainstream. In 1980 though, tragedy struck the band and Bon Scott died young. It was revealed not long after that he had choked on his own vomit after a long and heavy drinking session.
The band was left in a difficult position, and even considered turning their back on the business, but on the advice of Scott’s parents they decided to go on and search for a new vocalist. Many names were thrown up in the air, including that of Slade frontman, Noddy Holder, but Geordie singer Brian Johnson was the man chosen for the job.
Johnson’s voice was almost identical to that of Scott, and his first studio recording, Back In Black, was the biggest financial success in the bands' history. Johnson continued as lead vocalist until 2016, leaving due to problems with hearing loss, so the remainder of the AC/DC Rock Or Bust world tour would require a replacement.
Much to the surprise of the music world, the group chose Guns N’ Roses vocalist Axl Rose. Though not a permanent member of AC/DC, Rose played every remaining date on the tour, and did his best to fill the boots of the Newcastle native.
1. Pink Floyd
Pink Floyd are one of the biggest musical acts that have ever existed.
Formed in 1965 with original vocalist Syd Barrett, the band wasted no time hitting the charts, notching up two charting singles in quick succession.
It was in 1968, however, that Barrett decided to leave the iconic rock collective due to mental health issues that were revealed to be drug-related in the years following his departure. It was because of this that bassist and occasional vocalist Roger Waters took the position of lead vocals and provided the soothing and relaxing tones that we all know and love today.
It was shortly after the vocal change that the band altered their musical style, going from three minute pop-rock tunes, to seven minute progressive masterpieces, with the groundbreaking album The Wall at the forefront.
This is easily one of the most important changes of vocalist ever to hit the music world, as it is arguable that Pink Floyd would not have reached their legendary heights without this change in genre, spearheaded by the exit of their original frontman.