Arctic Monkeys: Ranking The Albums

2013 was a monumental year for Sheffield’s finest rock stars...

Arctic Mokeys 2013 was a monumental year for Sheffield€™s finest rock stars. On its release, their scintillating fifth album, €˜AM€™, skyrocketed to number one, becoming the fifth successive commercial approval of a band, who in style and attitude, are as individual as they come. Sitting in high positions on many publications€™ €˜Best Albums 2013€™ lists (apart from a rather spiteful omission from indier-than-thou hipsters, Pitchfork Media), €˜AM€™ was the sound of a band at the peak of their powers and their funky, resplendent best. Performing the album to hoards of screeching fans on a sell-out UK tour, the Brylcreem€™d lotharios of soul-exposing rock had one of the best years of their young careers. But aside from all of the hype where does the current, hormone heavy vibe of the Monkeys sit alongside their former incarnations? Which begs the further questions- 'Is €˜Humbug€™ really the sore thumb that every claims it is?' Or 'Does their debut stand up to the test of time?' And most importantly, just why DID Alex and Alexa part ways? No fear! All will be answered (except maybe the last one) as we rank, from worst to first, every Arctic Monkeys album since the beginning of time! That's five, by the way...

5. Suck It And See (2011)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M7tiGZqfmvA Many fans (those with no ears, perhaps?) welcomed €˜Suck it and See€™ as the band€™s return to form after the €˜crushing disappointment€™ of €˜Humbug€™. Wrong. Whilst this album is far from being bad per se, it€™s the Arctics€™ back catalogue€™s equivalent of Ringo Starr; tight and valuable but the ultimate weak link where greater musical genius abounds elsewhere. It wasn€™t just the fans, however, that placed their hopes of the Arctics€™ salvation at the feet of €˜Suck it and See€™. The critics who simply didn€™t get the sensual brilliance of its difficult predecessor also pined for a reversion to a more basic sound and less puzzling lyrics. In actuality, what we got was a kind of €˜Humbug€™-lite. The music retained the kaleidoscopic, psychedelic quality of the band€™s third album but sanded down its menacing edge with a melodic aesthetic and a sun-kissed, desert-rock vibe influenced by their continued relationship with Josh Homme. Whilst its bashful romantic lyrical content is a rejection of Turner€™s former dalliance with highly-sexualised, innuendo-imbued musings, the darkness and slightly impenetrable nature of €˜Humbug€™ occasionally lunges back into view, with the eloquent front man picking his phrases and words more for their euphonic quality than any profound sort of meaning. After all, just what IS a €˜telescopic hallelujah€™? Populated by gorgeous, lilting numbers in the form of €˜Black Treacle€™ and €˜Reckless Serenade€™, it€™s easy to place €˜Suck it and See€™ as the mellow middle ground between the obsessive, obscure sexuality of €˜Humbug€™ and the obsessive, blatant sexuality of €˜AM€™, a sort of ante-chamber in which the group experimented with, but never fulfilled, the unchained caterwauling so prevalent on the latter. A beautiful record brimming with mature, sensitive song-writing and possessing a rock-n-roll clout, and one that only occupies last place due to the sheer quality of its fellow long-players. Best Tracks: €˜Reckless Serenade€™, €˜The Hellcat Spangled Shalala€™, €˜Black Treacle€™

4. Favourite Worst Nightmare (2007)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kd26Ty07sAo If the Arctics€™ debut album was an exercise in art reflecting reality, follow-up €˜Favourite Worst Nightmare€™ consciously expands on this idea whilst simultaneously commenting on a year spent under spotlight and scrutiny. €˜Who The F**K Are Arctic Monkeys?€™, the provocative title track of a five-song EP that bridged the gap between their first two long-players, showcased a band intimidated by the media furore that surrounded them and is an impassioned attempt to defend their principles. This self-analysis and contempt for the press finds itself onto €˜Favourite Worst Nightmare€™ on tracks such as €˜Teddy Picker€™ and €˜If You Were There, Beware€™ to signpost the band€™s growing disillusionment with fame and recognition. Here, the bite that Turner displayed on the band€™s debut becomes more pronounced and less couched in humour, gunning down silver-tongued hipsters (€˜Brianstorm€™) and want-away band members (€˜Old Yellow Bricks€™ is commonly believed to be about ex-bass player, Andy Nicholson) in an articulate hail of rapid-fire verse and brutal disdain. Sonically, the LP€™s sound mellows its predecessor€™s punchy punk into a more effervescent, reverb-laden territory that hinted at the band€™s diversifying listening habits and is the product of the new effects pedals that Turner and Jamie Cook purchased with the first album€™s profits. Elsewhere, new bass player, Nick O€™Malley, manages to establish a fluid rhythm partnership with drumming powerhouse, Matt Helders, and between them, create the tribal beat that permeates wounding record highlight, €˜Do Me A Favour€™. An angry but accomplished-sounding effort from the boys of High Green, Sheffield. Best Tracks: €˜Do Me A Favour€™, €˜Fluorescent Adolescent€™, €˜505€™

3. Humbug (2009)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m6Je6OnzdFI Up until 2009, Alex Turner was music€™s foremost purveyor of the real but on this record, things took a turn to the abstract. Widely looked upon as the band€™s €˜moody€™ phase, the dark spirit that pervaded the album€™s heart replicated itself when it hit the road, with each and every live performance punctuated with floppy hair, faces-to-the floor stage routines and a fed-up Turner barely acknowledging his die-hard fans. It was a time of transition for the Monkeys and many failed to accept their embracing of a more ominous sound and surrealist outlook, but those people missed out on one of the group€™s finest albums of their career. If you think that Turner has only recently removed taxi-ranks and knackered Converse from his lyrical arsenal in order to focus on man€™s most unsolvable mystery, woman, then you€™re sorely mistaken. €˜Humbug€™ marks the true point where he traded in shy romantic propositioning for fully-fledged sexual bravado. Slinging sleaze in every other sentence, €˜My Propeller€™ is a saucy invitation to awaken a sleeping appendage and €˜Dangerous Animals€™ a brooding, impatient cry to get down and dirty; filthy odes no doubt inspired by Turner€™s blossoming romance with Alexa Chung. Yet, whilst the meanings of certain €˜Humbug€™ songs are easy to unravel, it also signalled the beginning of Turner€™s oblique and cryptic lyricism, found on the poetic, evocative likes of €˜Potion Approaching€™ and €˜Fire and the Thud€™. There€™s even an element of the carnival to the record and closer, €˜The Jeweller€™s Hands€™ closely resembles Dylan circa-Highway 61 in both image and sound but it is in fact straight-talking romantic paean €˜Cornerstone€™ that takes the plaudits for album highlight. An innovative, somewhat darker album that divided the opinions of the critics and those of a loyal fan-base. But the Arctics were never as delightfully contrary as this again. Best Tracks: €˜Secret Door€™, €˜Cornerstone€™, €˜Dangerous Animals€™

2. AM (2013)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x0JVrxwj7GY It€™s all too easy to point out that in the years since their debut album, the Arctics have morphed into the kind of band that they ridiculed on €˜Fake Tales of San Francisco€™. They€™ve flirted with leather jacket and shades looks and spewed tales that sound at home in grimy €˜New York City€™ despite being conceived by minds born in a town closer to €˜Rotherham€™. But where the band failed to see this irony in their €˜Humbug€™ phase, they lapped it up on last year€™s €˜AM€™. The record is all smiles and sultry swagger; a horny, flamboyant beast trapped inside a 12€ slab of wax. Here, nothing is off limits in a sexy Monkeys menu that serves up a starter of hyperbolic handclaps before meandering through a falsetto-infused main course, all finished off with lashings of ill-begotten desire. €˜AM€™ may find Turner reducing his scope to issues of the heart (alongside the issues of a number of other choice organs) but this results in an intensity of emotion and breadth of detail unrivalled on any previous release. Gone is the sweetly poetic tinge of €˜Suck it and See€™, replaced by an unquenchable thirst for fornication; the primal bed-surfing, head-spinning €˜R U Mine?€™, voyeuristic dreamscape of €˜Arabella€™ and virile nastiness of €˜Knee Socks€™. Such is Turner€™s preoccupation with these erotic topics that he departs entirely from social commentary, unless of course, it€™s a comment that can be made through the steamy lens of a prowling, unsatisfied masculinity. Fittingly, the band turns in its heaviest sound to date to match Turner€™s perpetual potency but also showcases its diversity in its sound-tracking of more sensitive pieces such as €˜Fireside€™ and €˜Mad Sounds€™. €˜No. 1 Party Anthem€™, €˜AM€™s€™ slow-burning centrepiece feels like the seedier, hungrier older brother of shy and speculative early tracks like €˜Dancing Shoes€™ in its tone and meticulousness and is the perfect demonstration of Turner€™s development as a song-writer, as well as mirroring his growth from awkward teen to id-feeding phantom. A timeless record that takes explicit influence from a heavier rock lineage ranging from Black Sabbath to the Black Keys, €˜AM€™ is the band€™s best offering since their raucous debut. Best Tracks: €˜R U Mine?€™, €˜No.1 Party Anthem€™, €˜Arabella€™

1. Whatever People Say I Am, That€™s What I€™m Not (2006)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wuPwomMwW00 Despite being a hardened Arctics€™ acolyte from the very beginning, even I raised my eyebrows when, mere months after its release, NME placed this record fifth in their countdown of the Top British Albums of All Time. Perched above such masterworks as €˜London Calling€™ and €˜Revolver€™, it appeared that NME had severely misplaced its enthusiasm for the nascent band and given the Monkeys a position far above their station. But, eight years after the group dropped their debut, this accolade actually seems rather justified. It remains Alex Turner€™s best album in terms of lyrics; his savage put-downs of crass friends, po-faced bouncers and stubborn girlfriends tussle with eloquent dissections of nervous nights out on the pull, every line delivered with a lucid wit since unequalled. Indeed, on an album seeping with the identifiable follies of youth, Turner evokes all of the fine detail and knowing satire of a William Hogarth painting, intensifying (but never exaggerating) the beer-soaked realities of the Sheffield working classes. The music itself is informed by the urgency of contemporary garage-rock revivalists such as The Strokes and The Libertines but also manages to reverberate with the ragged attack of The Clash and melody of The Smiths. A cornucopia of colloquialism and tales of youthful, lusty abandon, €˜Whatever People Say I Am, That€™s What I€™m Not€™ is the Monkeys€™ most innocent and best album to date. An era-defining document deserving of every piece of glowing praise it gets, there€™s a certain romance to it that€™s just not present on any of their other albums. Best Tracks: 'A Certain Romance', 'From The Ritz To The Rubble', 'Still Take You Home'

Contributor
Contributor

A 22 year old English Literature graduate from Birmingham. I am passionate about music, literature and football, in particular, my beloved Aston Villa. Lover of words and consumer of art, music is the very air that I breathe.