Death: Ranking All 7 Studio Albums

A gentle stroll through an utterly perfect discography.

Death Band
Relapse

Ranking the seven albums by Floridian titans Death is difficult, because, well… every one is pretty much perfect.

From its formation as “Mantas” in 1983 to its tragic dissolution in 2001, Death was a juggernaut of ever-expanding inspiration that existed as the brainchild of frontman Chuck Schuldiner.

The outfit debuted as a duo on 1987’s Scream Bloody Gore – the album oft credited with inventing death metal as a whole – before refining their anarchic ingenuity the next year on Leprosy.

By 1993, Death had undergone a total audial makeover, transitioning from macabre aggressors to sophisticated experimentalists, with their intriguing journey charted through the increasingly progressive trilogy of Spiritual Healing, Human and Individual Thought Patterns. With Symbolic, the titans tapped into the then-burgeoning melodic death metal movement, crafting a harmonic high-point, before concluding their discography on the bravest possible note with the mind-melting unpredictability of The Sound of Perseverance in 1998.

Tragically, founder and driving force Schuldiner would pass away in December 2001 at just 34 years old, but his legacy as a heavy metal pioneer deserves to be known by as many people as possible. And that is why this list exists: to guide you through the genius of one of the most perfect metal acts to ever grace the Earth.

7. Leprosy (1988)

Despite its place at the very bottom of this ranking list, it is important to note that Leprosy is not a bad album by any stretch of the imagination. In fact, taking into account everything from the song-writing to the production to even the artwork, it actually stands as one of the best discs to come from death metal’s infancy.

Following on from their abrasive game-changer of a debut, Scream Bloody Gore, Leprosy saw Death refine the manic approach of their first outing: the musical content was far more skilled in balancing pure, unbridled heaviness with Chuck Schuldiner’s incomparable guitar godliness. The lyrical content also matured somewhat, shying away from the graphic horror, rape and occultism of Scream Bloody Gore in favour of more psychologically unnerving territory.

The reason Leprosy finds itself starting this list, however, is that it exists primarily as a transitional piece. As their second and final venture into straightforward death metal territory, Death’s 1988 release would never have been able to match the raucous, genre-defining explosion of their debut, while its maturations in music and lyrics would soon pale in comparison to the progressive nirvana that Chuck and co. would first discover on Spiritual Healing.


6. The Sound Of Perseverance (1998)

Among Death’s hordes of passionate loyalists, there seems to be a small gathering that harbours a distaste towards the quartet’s swansong, The Sound of Perseverance. And with the record standing easily as Death’s most experimental, it’s possible to understand why.

After spending much of the 1990s up to that point containing progressive themes and technicality into constantly fast and energised songs, The Sound of Perseverance boasted much lengthier entries, as well as cuts like “Spirit Crusher”, which often gave way to slow-burning interludes in lieu of the all-out adrenaline found on prior records.

However, to disregard the final album that Chuck Schuldiner would unleash under the “Death” mantle based solely on this is an overreaction, as the monumental disc also gave fans the most instrumentally confident and sophisticated release in the outfit’s whole discography. In an era where aural adventurers like Tool, Opeth and Dream Theater were rapidly climbing the ladder of success, The Sound of Perseverance was the balls-to-the-wall ride that Death needed to make in order to retain their status as the progressive band for those that love their metal raucous and indomitable.

Furthermore, the reimagining of “Painkiller” that closes out this record could be one of the best covers in rock history!


5. Scream Bloody Gore (1987)

The fifth slot of our countdown, Scream Bloody Gore, is just as much a fascinating musical history lesson as it is a frantic exercise in unmitigated, wanton destruction. Its backstory is one that tells of a then-twenty-year-old Chuck Schuldiner, who accidentally created the blueprint for one of the most successful and extreme genres in music.

Desiring to emulate his heavy metal heroes in Possessed, Slayer and Sepultura, the young guitarist would unintentionally create something similar but brilliantly different, with the wild vitriol of thrash and black metal complemented by insanely graphic lyrics and even a handful of swanky melodies.

Situated on the other side of the US to extreme Californian innovators like Metallica and Dark Angel, Death’s debut would even allow a death metal movement to spawn in its immediate aftermath, birthing such immense titans as Deicide, Cannibal Corpse, Morbid Angel and Massacre.

When compared to Death’s later albums, Scream Bloody Gore can, at times, feel slightly naïve in its initial, derivative intent. But let’s not forget that this record is history: the foundation upon which every other extreme band since, consciously or not, has formed themselves. It deserves to be put on a pedestal alongside Black Sabbath, Kill ‘Em All and Iron Maiden.


4. Spiritual Healing (1990)

In the wake of Death’s first two releases, death metal had suddenly become a massive movement in the band’s home state of Florida. Between Leprosy and its follow-up, Spiritual Healing, beloved powerhouses like Obituary and Morbid Angel had emerged, soon resulting in an underground scene angrily bubbling away on the US East Coast.

In order to stand out in a subsect that they had helped to cultivate with their early work, Death went more avant-garde on their third record, resulting in a technically-inclined yet still-aggressive opus.

The end result is an eight-track extravaganza that feels like “death metal ver. 2.0”, maintaining the subgenre’s guttural growls, low-end riffing and constant anger at its heart, but sneaking in tiny hints of prog with shifting time signatures and eclectic themes like drug addiction, televangelism, abortion and schizophrenia.

Thus, Spiritual Healing is a brilliantly bizarre and enigmatic beast: it’s too progressive to just be death metal, but it uses enough of the genre’s conventions that it’s not entirely progressive, either. Between the harsh elitism of Scream Bloody Gore and the conceptual intricacy of Human and beyond, there lies the magnificent limbo of Spiritual Healing.


3. Human (1991)

1991 wasn’t a great time for extreme metal. The release of Metallica’s hugely popular ‘Black Album’ (which still sells five-thousand copies a week, by the way) began the slow demise of traditional thrash, only for Nirvana’s Nevermind to give the angst of grunge a massive pop-cultural relevance that stole a lot of metal’s pissed-off teenagers.

With all that in mind, Human was exactly what the contemporary metal underground needed. In an era where the genre’s biggest players were growing sick of incessant speed and felt that they needed to slow down to diversify, Death slapped them all in the mouth simultaneously by making a disc that was taut, succinct, brutal, heavy and thrashing, but also intelligent and post-modern.

It would be easy to write a full essay about Human’s brilliance, but its best feature is doubtlessly its ability to pack so much technicality and godlike musicianship into blindingly fast songs that barely scratch four minutes (a trait that would continue through follow-up Individual Thought Patterns).

Mixed and co-produced by extreme metal overlord Scott Burns, Human is a masterpiece that singlehandedly gave credence to the “technical death metal” niche, while also signalling that Death had fully spread their wings beyond what was first thought possible.


2. Individual Thought Patterns (1993)

Individual Thought Patterns is easily one of the greatest death metal records of all time (not to mention Chuck Schuldiner’s favourite Death album), with so much working in its favour that it feels blasphemous to bestow it with merely a silver medal.

The line-up that Chuck gathered up for his fifth album is simply the best in Death’s history: King Diamond’s Andy LaRocque finds himself shredding alongside the frontman, bolstered by the rhythmic dream team of Steve Di Giorgio and Gene Hoglan on bass and drums, respectively.

The calibre of the musicianship on Individual… is off the scale, and can be felt in the rattling guitar shreds of “Trapped in a Corner”, the pummelling blast beats of “Overactive Imagination” and the gorgeous bass solo of “The Philosopher”.

Speaking of which, closing track “The Philosopher” stands as Death’s biggest hit, its melodic chorus and instrumental trade-offs signalling the harmonic emphasis that they would give their next album, Symbolic.

Individual… was the perfect follow-up to the progressive provocateur that was Human, continuing that release’s formula of packing prog into tight and fast death metal tracks while also upping the ante with the talents of some of the strongest metal musicians on the planet.


1. Symbolic (1995)

Symbolic is one of those once-in-a-generation metal albums that just gets everything right.

Released on the cusp of melodic death metal’s explosion thanks to names like Dark Tranquillity and At the Gates, Death experimented with far more harmonic heroism than ever before on their sixth album. With catchier riffs and choruses at their disposal (found on such heavy anthems as “Crystal Mountain”, “1,000 Eyes” and a grooving title track), Chuck Schuldiner’s extreme venture had finally found the perfect union of melody, brutality and intricacy that it had been building towards ever since Scream Bloody Gore.

While not as mathematically progressive as Human or Individual Thought Patterns, Symbolic still found itself able to balance its penchant for enticing hooks with conceptual wit, providing takes on political corruption, surveillance and the misanthropy of the ruling classes.

The instrumentals from a returning Gene Hoglan alongside newcomers Kelly Conlon and Bobby Koelble are all as efficient as ever, with production from Chuck and Jim Morris that lets every musician shine at their brightest.

Symbolic even witnessed Chuck himself evolve, adapting his now-signature higher register of screaming after years of deep death growling.

The quintessential entry in their résumé, Symbolic saw Death prove that they can master all forms of extreme music, even those with a slight whiff of the catchy about them.


In this post: 
death
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

I write for Metal Hammer, Prog and WhatCulture. I don’t have Facebook or Twitter, so you’ll just have to call me a stupid cuck to my face.