Every Arctic Monkeys Album Ranked
Now that the moon dust has settled, could this be the definitive order?
Sheffield rockers Arctic Monkeys have been around the block a few times now. They've released six studio albums within a career that spans over ten years, taking the UK by storm at the tender age of 19 with the fastest selling debut album in British music history.
But was it their best?
Never ones to retread old ground, each album from the Monkeys has been wildly different to the last. You could say it's like comparing apples to oranges, but it's all fruit ultimately so we're giving it a try. Whether they're cartwheeling down sand dunes in the Humbug days or cruising through LA in the AM era, the common thread has always been the quality of their vision and storytelling.
As an avid fan who's followed them since their first single, it does feel like picking between your children, but I hope my unhealthy love for this band makes me somewhat qualified to try and settle the score, at least until the next album. Read on and risk anger, vindication or wholehearted bemusement.
6. Suck It And See
Suck It And See is by no means a bad album, but it shows an uncharacteristic lack of direction for Arctic Monkeys. Many fans were relieved to see tracks like The Hellcat Spangled Shalalala coming through with traditional song structures, catchy hooks and (despite the title) more accessible lyrics than the predecessor Humbug. But it wasn’t quite as simple as that.
Suck It And See sounds like it’s trapped between the smoke and mirrors of Humbug and the immediacy of Whatever People Say I Am That’s What I’m Not, trying to blend each ethos together with mixed results. Tracks like All My Own Stunts are still steeped in Humbug DNA whilst singles like Black Treacle and Suck It And See are Humbug’s antithesis, jangly Brit-pop infused summer anthems.
New ground is broken on Love Is A Laserquest as Turner turns the melancholic-lover dial up to 11, Library Pictures also pushes the envelope, a self confessed “nonsense poem” that reads like a fever dream from the Humbug writing sessions. It’s an interesting stopgap in the band's career, but as a whole the album amounts to a musical fork-in-the-road.
5. Favourite Worst Nightmare
It seems criminal to put an album with Brianstorm and Fluorescent Adolescent this far down the list but, Arctic Monkeys don’t make bad albums. Favourite Worst Nightmare came out swinging for the fences, unabashed and far from intimidated by the success of its predecessor.
Arctics made their return with lead single Brianstorm, Matt Helders managing to innovate once again on drums, conjuring a rolling thunder of toms that pummels the listener while frenzied guitars from Alex and Jamie jab with acute accuracy. Turner maintains his lyrical flair throughout the majority of the album, as Teddy Picker, Fluorescent Adolescent, 505 and many more all deliver classic lines that have stood the test of time. The album falters with tracks like Balaclava and D Is For Dangerous which don’t hit the same heights lyrically or musically and contribute to making it feel dated.
Unfortunately, Favourite Worst Nightmare has too many of these moments. The depth on display in tracks like 505 and Do Me A Favour is sold short by the likes of The Bad Thing, a track that was fine at the time but will stay in that era, arguably where it belongs.
4. AM
AM was seen as a return to form for a lot of the fans that dropped off after the band's second album. Recorded in LA, the hip hop influenced rhythm section went a long way towards making this one of their most impactful albums over in the US, and a return to sharp observational lyrics made things easy for fans that were bewildered by the likes of Crying Lightning.
Aesthetically, the band appear to be in their prime. Turner looking like the Teddy Boys of yore with his meticulously coiffed hair and more muscular frame, this was the Arctic Monkeys supersized to fit the American landscape. The almost-eponymous title of AM hints that the band themselves may see this album as quintessentially 'them' or some of their finest work, and that is largely true. The lead single Do I Wanna Know? was an instant classic when it surfaced. The steady metronomic kick/snare pattern from Helders forms a ticking clock while lyrically, Turner spends an evening pacing, listening to a song that reminds him of a potentially-requited love interest and spilling drinks over his settee, tying himself in knots well into the early am hours.
AM includes many of the band's stronger singles but around half of the track listing loses some sticking power. Tracks like Number 1 Party Anthem, Fireside, Mad Sounds and I Want It All hold their own at first, but over time they reveal themselves to only posses the style and not the substance of tracks that go the distance; art imitating LA life perhaps?
3. Humbug
The Desert record. It seems a right-of-passage or even a cliche for big guitar bands to go off and get freaky amongst the dunes, but Humbug had the substance to back it up. This marked the biggest reinvention (at the time) for the band, delving further than ever into the opaque, poetic imagery that Turner had flirted with on Favourite Worst Nightmare. Musically, they slowed down the frantic tempo of both the earlier albums, letting the guitars slither and gyrate around each melody and metaphor. Humbug was met with the biggest backlash to date from fans but the band stuck to their guns, performing a whopping 80% of the album at their Reading and Leeds set in 2009, only one week after its release.
Despite it's frosty reception, Humbug showcases some of Turner's most deeply personal and emotionally rich songwriting, like the memory-lane scavenger hunt of Cornerstone. The track describes revisiting old meeting places shared with a former lover, looking for details that spark a reverie of a happier time, or even a suitable doppelgänger that could quell the heartache and keep the illusion of a past relationship alive. It's a startlingly honest account of the grief and desperation an ended relationship can cause.
Humbug was somewhat of a conjuror's trick played on the band's fanbase, weeding out those that wanted another Mardy Bum and rewarding those who cared to look a little deeper - 'Humbug' does mean 'to deceive' after all...
2. Whatever People Say I Am That's What I'm Not
‘Anticipation has a habit to set you up, for disappointment.’ This first line tells you all you need to know about Whatever People Say I Am That's What I'm Not's contrarian spirit (if the title weren’t clue enough). Turner has his guard up high as the Monkeys begin wading into the music industry for the first time. He’s quick to point a finger or undercut a moment of sentimentality, keen to show that he’s always watching and won’t be taken for a fool.
What makes the album stand the test of time are the moments of tenderness that do seep through amongst the steely observations. The band had just begun and you can hear the naivety and originality of musicians who are brushing up against the limit of their capabilities (with the exception of the incandescent drumming from Matt Helders). Guitar tones are perhaps too distorted, power chords get a hammering throughout, the playing is imbued with the frenetic energy of kids that can’t quite believe their luck but daren’t say anything that might break the spell.
Despite this musical naivety, the lyrics couldn't be more insightful. Alex Turner's old head on young shoulders bemoans the tirelessly cyclical nature of British youth, nightlife and relationships. He's seemingly above it all before reminding us that he's often at the centre of these miss-adventures he so fervently deconstructs, a poignant thread that runs throughout and completes the album.
1. Tranquility Base Hotel And Casino
It’s one of the band’s most elegant tricks to date, setting this politically-charged, technology conscious album on the moon. By using the sci-fi trope of alien technology or surroundings passing comment on the human experience, Tranquility Base has enough distance from its subject to avoid being trite. It also allows the irony, satire and humour to thrive. “I’m a big name in deep space, ask your mates,” Turner quips on opener Star Treatment, a jazzy lounge-tune that chronicles the ups and downs of Turner’s lunar persona, a seemingly washed-up rockstar who’s taken residency at the Tranquility Base Hotel and Casino, permanently soused on martinis as he performs “two shows a day, four nights a week.”
One Point Perspective is pitch-perfect in its nostalgia-drenched instrumentation; you can smell the baking tarmac as Turner reads the riot act on an apocalypse that’s only just being prioritised, presumably back on earth. People "sing-song round the money tree" and cry some of the "hottest tears" they’ve ever cried in this delirious portrait of a planet ravaged by human folly. Lead single Four Out Of Five deftly pokes fun at how modern advertising sells us a lifestyle rather than a product, and perhaps this is why we as consumers are never satisfied past a "four stars out of five" rating, and even that’s "unheard of".
Tranquility Base proves to be a rational response to the madness of the moment. You get the feeling there’s a timeline where Trump isn’t president, global warming was taken seriously and Arctic Monkeys never made this album. It's the first time they've let go and created something escapist rather than firmly rooted on terra firma, taking that one small step into fully-fledged art-rock. If you ask me, it's one silver-lining to living in the twilight zone.