Every Muse Album Ranked Worst To Best
The prog rock trio from worst to best.
Muse have been one of the most interesting bands of the 21st century. Beginning in 1994, this modern power trio is one of the most talented group of rockers to come out of England. In addition to their fantastic musicianship, Muse have always found ways to shake up their sound with each record. The band's eclectic taste in rock, electronica, metal, and pop have kept fans intrigued for decades now.
However, there is a definite order in which these albums fall. While Muse never released a flat-out reprehensible album, some of their records are easier to digest than others. Some may be very immediate with their aesthetic, but others may require a bit more of a settling-in experience to be fully appreciated.
In some areas, these records can be angry and forceful but can be wistful and reflective in others. But throughout all these switch-ups, Muse have always had a penchant for setting up a scene in their music in a way few other bands can. Since time is running out, let's take a run through Muse's back catalog to see where the highest and lowest hits land.
8. Simulation Theory
It may be a bit premature to call this Muse's worst record, but this electronic sci-fi experiment did leave a lot to be desired. Since Muse have always been on the cutting edge of what is going on in rock, this record saw them playing catch-up with the 80's throwback trends that have been going for a few years now.
The record is not all bad though. Songs like "Pressure" and "Dig Down" show that the band can still write a killer hook, and even the song "Get Up and Fight" has a stadium-worthy chorus.
However, these highlights don't make up for the fact that this album tends to sound a bit dull with repeated listens. Bringing in producers like Timbaland and Shellback seemed disconcerting, but nothing on this album is anything to raise pitchforks over. At the end of the day, this just seemed like a fun outing for the guys that just didn't seem to work in their favor in the long run. Not a perfect record, but still good for what it is.
7. Showbiz
This was Muse's starting point. Released in 1999, Showbiz saw the band still wearing their influences firmly on their sleeves. Each of these songs has a guitar tone ripped out of 90's metal and song structures that seem to be ripped out of Thom Yorke's songbook.
This tends to be a record that many naysayers point to when they dismiss Muse as Radiohead plagiarists. While this record does show the most Radiohead infatuation, Muse did a fantastic job fleshing out their sound in recent years to create something truly their own.
On this release, the band just sounds like they're not sure what Muse should be. There are definitely some ragers like "Sunburn" and "Sober," but other musical detours show up on the country-tinged "Falling Down" or the ballad "Unintended." The standout on this record has to be "Muscle Museum." Since the other songs sound a touch disjointed from one another, this tune helped lay the groundwork for the sound that Muse would perfect later down the road. This album is by no means the band's best, but it provides an impressive start to a stellar career.
6. The Resistance
The Resistance comes at an interesting time in Muse's career. They had been a household name for rockers for years and had seen some mainstream success with a song featured on the soundtrack to Twilight. So on this record, the band took the opportunity to experiment with musical theatricality.
Songs like the title track and "Uprising" have the spacey stylings many fans come to expect, but the album has loftier ambitions than that. Songs like "United States of Eurasia" shows them adopting a choral-like vocal approach that sounds like a modern-day Queen while "Guiding Light" is an overlooked gem coated in arena-rock bombast. The production on this record is also fantastic, giving songs like "MK Ultra" and "Unnatural Selection" the weight they need to become larger than life.
The reason it comes in so low is that the album doesn't have as much a replay factor as other Muse releases. While the album is great, terrific even, it does seem to wear out its welcome towards the end with the band's classical piece "Exogenesis Symphony." It may not be as essential as other Muse records, but a must for any serious Muse fan to check out.
5. The 2nd Law
Many fans may consider this to be Muse's worst release, but this album leaves a better impression with each passing listen. I can totally see why some fans were upset though. "Madness" fired off many alarm bells for fans of the band that they were selling out and going pop. Aside from the main single though, this is Muse's most eclectic collection of songs.
"Panic Station" has a Chili Peppers vibe, "Supremacy" is a track that could have been on a Bond soundtrack, and "Animals" helps blend electronica with rock quite nicely. This record also helps display the talents of the rhythm section to great effect. Dominic Howard's skills behind an acoustic and electronic drum kit is masterful while Chris Wolstenholme's bass tone varies from synthetic to snarling with each tune. Wolstenholme also flexes his muscles as a vocalist on "Save Me" and "Liquid State" to great effect.
Muse have always mixed it up with each release and this record shows the most varied sounds they've put on a single disc. While not everything sticks, I still respect the hell out of the direction they took on this outing and broadening their musical horizons for what they would do later down the road.
4. Drones
There are probably many Muse fans shaking their heads right now as to why this is so high on the list. Let me be clear: this album is not the best by a long shot. Drones does have a concept based around a tech apocalypse as a result of drone strikes. While this concept is interesting for sure, it does make for some ill-advised moments like the "Drill Sergeant" interlude into the song "Psycho."
Other than those moments though, this record does have a raw aggression to it that was missing from Muse releases at the time. Songs like "Psycho" and "Reapers" show the band at their most uninhibited musically, with the latter featuring Matthew Bellamy annihilating his fretboard with a tapping intro. The album has the right amount of slowburns as well like love song "Aftermath" and the choir-like vocals of the title track.
The production of super-producer Mutt Lange helped the band get back to basics and create fantastic singles like "Dead Inside" and "Mercy." In that respect, Drones is an album that is the best of both worlds by combining the epic size of their later material with the punk anger of their early days. What's not to love?
3. Absolution
This is the record where the public really got Muse. The sound the band created here was the perfect combination of space rock, metal, and straight-ahead rock. The record's flow is incredibly consistent as it jumps from piano ragers ("Apocalypse Please") to metal ("Stockholm Syndrome") to ballads ("Falling Away With You").
Given all the turns this album takes, you would think it would feel a touch disjointed in places. However, the album is able to juggle these styles at will while never losing its hookiness. Some of Muse's most successful singles appear on this album like "Time Is Running Out" and "Hysteria," the latter of which containing possibly the greatest bassline of the modern age.
The record also introduced an era of wild experimentation for the band. Tracks like "Blackout" hint at the band's more classical ambitions while "Thoughts of a Dying Atheist" has a swagger that feels like it was ripped straight out of David Bowie's glam period. Even songs like "The Small Print" calls back to the band's punk-leaning roots.
After searching over two records as to what the band's sound could be, Absolution was the first record where Muse truly sounded like Muse.
2. Origin of Symmetry
The group's second outing kicked down the door for mainstream rock. In the wake of Radiohead's ascent, many bands like Coldplay and even Muse themselves were being seen as slightly derivative. As a response, Origin of Symmetry shows Muse at their most visceral and angry.
This record is the closest thing to a punk album that the band have ever released from a sonic perspective. Songs like "Hyper Music" and "Plug In Baby" have a decidedly harsh assault that tears your head off from their opening notes. This album also shows more prog-rock styles creeping in on "Space Dementia" and especially the epic "Citizen Erased," which has since become a favorite amongst Muse devotees.
Since the band were still trying to grasp their sound, more sophisticated eclectic moments appear on the quiet acoustic cut "Screenager" and their cover of the old standard "Feeling Good." On the other hand, when you listen to songs like "New Born" and "Bliss," you can hear the true Muse identity falling into place. There is a certain sense of paranoia and dread in this record, but with an energy that makes you want to pump your fist in the air every time you listen.
1. Black Holes and Revelations
After four albums across 8 years, it had all been building to this. Across their previous records, Muse had been experimenting with their songwriting techniques, often to great effect. Here is where they took their space rock and prog rock ambitions and pumped them up to arena size.
The band's ability at writing slowburns culminated in their greatest ballad in "Starlight." Other songs like "Assassin" and "Supermassive Black Hole" bring together riffs that will leave many budding guitarists dumbfounded. We even see the band's early flirtations with electronic music on "Map of the Problematique," whose manic synths compliment the band instrumentation perfectly.
The record also contains what may very well be Muse's greatest epic, "Knights of Cydonia." This track shows how talented Muse are at arranging a song in such the way that makes the listener feel like they've just watched a movie in their mind. If you're into Muse or are even mildly curious about this band, this record has got you covered for any kind of track you'd want to hear. A masterpiece of the prog-rock genre along with being one of the greatest rock albums to come out in the 21st century.