Every My Chemical Romance Single Ranked Worst To Best
At the height of their fame and infamy, MCR produced a wealth of hit singles, but which is the best?
2013 through 2019 were dark days for My Chem fans.
The band, who had been in the middle of recording the follow-up to 2010's Danger Days, announced their break-up seemingly out of the blue.
Though band members Gerard Way, Frank Iero, Ray Toro and Mikey Way went on to have moderately successful solo careers of their own, fans yearned for a return of the four-piece and the release of their elusive scrapped album, The Paper Kingdom.
Rumours of a reunion periodically sent the internet spiralling into hysteria, with the 2016 re-release of The Black Parade (including several unreleased tracks) in particular making fans a little too hopeful. Though unsubstantiated claims of an imminent reunion rapidly dwindled, Killjoys wouldn't have to wait long for their dreams of a My Chemical Romance reunion to become a reality.
Halloween of 2019 will certainly go down in history books as one to remember, with the rock legends surprising fans by announcing a reunion show, which was shortly followed-up with a tease of new music in the form of an ominous track titled "An Offering".
With speculation rife about whether everyone's favourite emo band are gearing up to release a new record, now is the perfect time to rank all of My Chemical Romance's singles, from worst to best.
Please note that while Conventional Weapons, the band's scrapped album released between The Black Parade and Danger Days, was technically released as a series of singles, this list focuses on songs released to promote a studio album.
19. Headfirst For Halos
Throughout their career, My Chemical Romance have managed to seamlessly combine razor-sharp punk riffs and lyrics with pop sensibilities, catapulting them from underground emo legends into the mainstream in the course of a few short years.
While, later in their career, MCR's punk and pop songs sat comfortably side-by-side on album track listings, Headfirst For Halos represents an early attempt to fuse the two genres into one song.
A deceptively upbeat melody betrays darker subject matter, with Way singing about the tribulations of self-medicating and the temptation to "blow my brains / Against the ceiling".
As danceable as Headfirst For Halos is, it's one of the less memorable songs on this list, and one of the rawest sounding cuts from the band's debut album.
18. Under Pressure
While the idea of My Chemical Romance and their contemporaries The Used pairing up to cover David Bowie and Queen's seminal duet Under Pressure is certainly exciting, this 2005 cut just doesn't match the heights of the original.
A straightforward cover, the emo legends' take on the rock classic doesn't do enough to differentiate it from the original, with McCracken's vocals in particular leaving something to be desired.
Still, Under Pressure is a beautiful song, and the guitar work on offer here proves Ray Toro and Frank Iero are more than worthy of sitting alongside Rock and Roll Hall of Famer Brian May.
17. Desolation Row
Unlike Under Pressure, My Chemical Romance's take on Bob Dylan classic Desolation Row (recorded for Watchmen's soundtrack) is a welcome reinvention, the band transforming a slow acoustic number into a rousing punk song worthy of its subject matter.
In fact, MCR's take on Desolation Row is so different from Dylan's that it hardly seems like a cover, and is almost a brand new song in its own right.
Sounding more like Green Day than anything else released by the New Jersey behemoths, Desolation Row is an interesting glimpse into the direction MCR might have followed if they decided to finalise Conventional Weapons, instead of scrapping that ill-fated record to head back into the studio and write Danger Days.
16. Bulletproof Heart
Given the sheer number of theatrical songs on Danger Days, it's a bit unusual that the low-key, stripped-down Bulletproof Heart was released as a single.
The song is certainly a bop, with a minimalist verse bouncing into a power pop chorus and a showcase of classic rock-style riffs. However, Bulletproof Heart leans a little too much on its influences, and doesn't do as much to advance the alt-rock genre as later songs on this list.
A welcome respite from the excesses of the concept-heavy Danger Days, Bulletproof Heart just doesn't really work too well as a single.
15. Na Na Na...
A rowdy and raucous single, Na Na Na was a definitive statement that the band were moving away from the dark themes that marked their previous outings, in favour of sugarcoated pop punk and a tongue-in-cheek aesthetic.
The music video - which included Danger Days' opening spoken-word track Look Alive, Sunshine - even panned to a shot of the band's Black Parade outfits lying in waste in the desert, proving that the Black Parade were, indeed, dead.
As infectious as Na Na Na (Na Na Na Na Na Na Na Na Na) is, it launched an album that would come to be seen as something as a mis-step for the band. Though the change in direction has since been welcomed, many fans lamented the departure from the neo-gothic aesthetic and musical style they had fallen in love with on previous records.
14. Sing
A big lighters-in-the-air ballad, Sing hones in on My Chemical Romance's trademark us-against-the-world mentality, boasting a chorus so bombastic the song was even featured on Season 2 Glee soundtrack, bringing it to a mainstream audience.
While the writing is tight, it's a bit hard not to wince at the overtly cheesy lyrics and the misplaced synths, Sing's power pop/alt rock fusion not always paying off.
Particularly suffering from a bloated middle eighth with a contrived connection to Danger Days' overarching concept, Sing is nonetheless an inspiring ballad that has become a fan favourite from the band's fourth record.
13. Fake Your Death
Admittedly losing some points due to its inevitable association with the band's untimely break up, Fake Your Death has been just about listenable since the band's reunion, and continues to send many fans speculating over what the band's scrapped fifth record The Paper Kingdom would have sounded like today.
A nice nostalgic piano ballad, Fake Your Death's title seemed to promise a reunion from the band - which, of course, finally materialised last year, the four-piece planning a string of stadium shows before the outbreak of COVID-19.
Accompanied by a music video comprised of clips from those of previous singles, Fake Your Death is a haunting meditation on how to carry during even the darkest of moments, a message particularly pertinent during these troubling times. Let's hope for new music soon.
12. The Kids From Yesterday
Really the song that should have ended Danger Days (seriously, what's with Vampire Money?), The Kids From Yesterday seems, in retrospect, to anticipate the band's breakup.
A beautiful, harrowing song (featuring the best implementation of synths in the entirety of Danger Days), The Kids From Yesterday sees Way speculating about whether the band's best days were already behind them.
Seeming to effortlessly capture the tone Sing failed to achieve, The Kids From Yesterday is not just one of the best songs on Danger Days, it's amongst the most moving ballads of the band's entire discography. If we really live forever in the lights we make, with bangers like this My Chemical Romance are bound to enjoy a very long afterlife indeed.
11. Teenagers
A strange fit for The Black Parade, Teenagers is a fun glam rock tune that injects some much needed humour and lighthearted relief into their darkest album.
Brimming with irony (the band of course being aware the majority of their fanbase comprised of teenagers), it's the song's rhythm that makes it so infectious, the jaunty track a rare example of the band just letting loose and having fun while still managing to craft a timeless classic.
Thematically a fitting follow up to I'm Not Okay, the track that catapulted My Chemical Romance to worldwide fame, Teenagers might share more musically with the band's take on Desolation Row than anything else on The Black Parade, but it doesn't suffer from this in the slightest.
10. Planetary (Go!)
Who would have thought, back when My Chemical Romance released their straight edge punk rock debut I Brought You My Bullets... back in 2002, that just eight short years later they'd be releasing electro-dance tracks more influenced by Japanese synth-pop than anything released by Black Flag, Queen or The Smashing Pumpkins?
Planetary (GO!), left-field even for an album as experimental as Danger Days, is infectious, arguably more punk (in its own, 22nd-century way) than any other song released by the band.
Certainly the band's most unique song, it's also their most memorable, and is without a doubt the highlight of their much maligned fourth record.
9. I Don't Love You
Given that the majority of bands and solo artists, no matter their genre, seem to specialise in love songs, it's amazing to think that romantic love is a theme My Chemical Romance hardly touched during their fifteen year career.
Even when MCR did dip into music's most tried and tired genre, though, they managed to put their own signature dark spin on the theme, such as in The Black Parade's signature heartbreaking ballad, I Don't Love You.
Singing about the difficulties of living in and leaving an abusive relationship, I Don't Love You is a haunting song drenched in nostalgia, arguably capturing the record's themes of isolation more than any other song on The Black Parade.
8. The Ghost Of You
Accompanied by its cinematic World War Two-inspired music video, The Ghost Of You features sparse verses followed by an explosive chorus that seems to come out of nowhere, making this a song best enjoyed on full blast with headphones on.
Helping to elevate My Chemical Romance from a simple punk rock outfit to a world-conquering tour de force, The Ghost Of You anticipates the theatrics that would become a staple in the band's following records. Aided not just by its bombastic structure but Gerard's refined storytelling prowess, The Ghost Of You is a spiritual follow-up to Vampires Will Never Hurt You, and helped pave the way for the masterpiece that is The Black Parade.
7. Thank You For The Venom
Although it made huge strides in advancing My Chemical Romance from post-hardcore underdogs to world-famous rock giants, MCR's sophomore record Three Cheers For Sweet Revenge didn't abandon the band's punk rock roots entirely, with Thank You For The Venom in particular espousing the genre that made their debut album so successful.
Still the best MCR song to mosh to, Thank You For The Venom features some of the most accomplished lyrics of the band's discography. "I wouldn't front the scene if you made me", Way sings, apparently anticipating the fame (and infamy) Three Cheers... would bring the band.
Given the experimentalism elsewhere on the record, it seems Gerard and co. were already planning on how to reinvent themselves to avoid being pigeonholed, but Venom is a welcome pure punk rock song and a true highlight of Three Cheers....
6. Helena
A song about Gerard and Mikey Way's grandmother who passed away while the band was on tour, the explosive opener to Three Cheers... is a rousing statement about death, loss and perseverance in the face of adversity, themes that would not just characterise the band's second record but go on to characterise the rest of their career.
An understated intro makes way for a rousing punk verse, but despite the heavy riffs and theatrics the song's lyrical content ensures it remains tender throughout, an unlikely marriage of eulogy and rock which the band would go on to capitalise while writing their next record, The Black Parade.
As formative as Helena was on My Chemical Romance's future music, it's a brilliant song on its own right, and remains one of rock's best opening tracks of all time.
5. Famous Last Words
If Helena is the perfect song to open a record, Famous Last Words - My Chemical Romance's heaviest track to date - was a fitting closer for The Black Parade, a final theatrical bow-out book-ending the journey the record took fans on while immediately demanding a re-listen.
"I am not afraid to keep on living / I am not afraid to walk this world alone" has essentially become the band's manifesto, a defining statement the band would struggle to recreate in both Sing and The Kids From Yesterday.
Musically, Famous Last Words is so good that the band went on to reproduce it twice, with Conventional Weapons' Surrender The Night and Burn Bright more or less emulating its structure, attempting to capture the same heights The Black Parade's final proper song effortlessly reaches.
4. I'm Not Okay (I Promise)
Arguably My Chemical Romance's most famous song (bar one), I'm Not Okay (I Promise) defined a generation, doing for MCR what Smells Like Teen Spirit did for Nirvana before them.
A piece of pop punk perfection that seems somewhat out of place on the dark Three Cheers... album, I'm Not Okay gave MCR the singalong they needed to propel them from a small-label emo band to a worldwide phenomenon.
The jewel in the already weighty crown that is the band's second record, MCR sidestepped fans' expectations by capitalising on the pop riffs that briefly surfaced above the murky waters of their debut I Brought You My Bullets....
It might not be the best song on Three Cheers..., but by catapulting MCR to fame, I'm Not Okay more than deserves its high spot on this list.
3. Honey, This Mirror Isn't Big Enough For The Two Of Us
A slice of fast-paced blitzing punk, the first true song on My Chemical Romance's debut album I Brought You My Bullets... introduces fans to the dark and mysterious world the band crafted throughout their first three records.
Combining Gerard Way's trademark storytelling prowess with raw, no holds barred musicality, Honey This Mirror Isn't Big Enough For The Two Of Us is guaranteed to get listeners pumped for any occasion.
While MCR diverged from their punk influences over the years, their last record having more in common with The Killers The Misfits, Honey This Mirror... is indicative of why, out of all of their contemporaries, MCR managed to crawl out of the obscure New Jersey emo scene and achieve worldwide fame.
Still one of the band's best songs almost twenty years on, Honey This Mirror... is an unforgettable opener to an equally unforgettable album.
2. Vampires Will Never Hurt You
Compared to the band's later releases, I Brought You My Bullets... stands out as an exceptionally raw record, featuring moments of great noughties punk energy somewhat held back by poor production value.
While a number of the fast-paced punk songs might be unrecognisable to fans of Three Cheers... and The Black Parade, Bullets nonetheless offers some glimpses into the theatricality that would come to characterise My Chemical Romance's later career.
Effortlessly distilling the tone of an entire horror movie's soundtrack into five and a half heart-stopping minutes, lead singer Gerard Way maintained that Vampires Will Never Hurt You was his favourite MCR song to play live.
And really, it's not difficult to see why. An early example of Way's signature storytelling, the band's very first single is a high energy track MCR have only since surpassed once.
1. Welcome To The Black Parade
As soon as that G note strikes, emo fans the world over reach for their eyeliner and military jacket and get ready to sing.
Welcome To The Black Parade, the band's only Number 1 single in the UK, transcended the alt-rock culture and emo scene to become a pop culture phenomenon, still routinely played at night clubs throughout the land.
It's been said that this one song contains more ideas than many bands have in their entire career, and its influence still looms large over alternative rock today.
Channelling My Chemical Romance's Queen influences, Welcome To The Black Parade is a perfect distillation of MCR's theatricality and ambition, the centrepiece of a record so big it almost broke the band.
Though it is likely Welcome To The Black Parade will never be topped by MCR or any of their countless imitators, the song remains a cultural touchstone, a call to arms for all the Killjoys who have since lost their way to cast their mind back and remember, for a beautiful five minutes, when MCR were the most important band in the world.