Every Nickelback Album Ranked From Worst To Best

All nine albums from rock's most divisive band.

Nickelback albums
Roadrunner

In the world of modern rock music, you'll be hard pressed to find a name bigger than Nickelback. With an arsenal of platinum-selling albums, world tours and fans across the globe, the once small time Canadian post-grunge band have defied all the odds to become global superstars.

With this incredible fame and fanbase has come a large counter movement, proving that the more popular you are, the more hated you can be alongside. Nickelback have a long-standing reputation as one of the most hated bands in rock music, even though they have sold ten of millions of records (clearly not everyone hates them, someone must be buying them).

Even though this large anti-Nickelback movement gains a lot of press, it doesn't prevent the band from soldiering on with their careers as they continue to write, record and tour with no signs of stopping.

In their 25 year careers, Nickelback have released a total of nine full-length studio albums, ranging from international super sellers to critical cannon fodder. In this article, we will count down every album in Nickelback's discography, ranking from worst to best.

9. No Fixed Address

Signalling a change in direction for the band, this was Nicelback’s eighth album and their most pop orientated effort to date. Although it sold well, the album received a less than favourable response from critics, with music journalists calling it a step in the wrong direction.

Thumping, stomp tinged radio rock tunes such as ‘Edge of Revolution’ brought some energy to the record, while less memorable inclusions like ‘Get ‘Em Up’, ‘Satellite’ and ‘Miss You’ sadly dragged the record down.

However, the reputation of Nickelback being slightly cheesy is epitomized by this album with its soppy love songs and basic, borderline generic mainstream rock style. Out of the eleven songs featured on this record, no more than four are objectively good.

All-in-all, this is the least memorable, desirable and enjoyable album in Nickelback’s discography.


8. Here And Now

Although this certainly isn’t a poor album, ‘Here and Now’ must settle for a low position on this list. Released in 2011, ‘Here and Now’ is Nickelback’s seventh album and follows on from 2008’s ‘Dark Horse’.

Featuring key songs such as ‘This Means War’ and ‘Trying Not to Love You’ act as the standard setter for the record. Sadly, additions to the album like ‘Gotta Get Me Some’ and ‘When We Stand Together’ fail to meet said expectation, forcing this album’s overall quality to drop in the process.

However, songs like ‘Lullaby’ are a little cheesy but in a guilty pleasure way as opposed to being cringeworthy.

In summary, ‘Here and Now’ isn’t a bad album by any means, but it does fall short when compared to prior Nickelback’s album collection.


7. Feed The Machine

Released in 2017, ‘Feed the Machine’ is the latest addition to Nickelback’s discography. After ‘No Fixed Address’, the band quickly realized that moving in the direction of a more pop focused sound was not what fans or critics wanted to hear, so ‘Feed the Machine’ saw them step back to their more familiar rock style.

Commercially, ‘Feed the Machine’ was a massive success, making into the top 10 of 15 different albums charts worldwide including the Canadian Billboard Chart, the UK Albums Chart and reaching #1 in the US Hard Rock Album Chart.

This success was fuelled by a number of great songs that came from this record, such as the title-track track and lead single. Other key songs from this album include ‘Must Be Nice’, ‘Song on Fire’ and ‘Coin For The Ferryman’, but overall it didn’t reach the height of previous records (especially from the early 2000’s era).

Despite this, ‘Feed the Machine’ is a good hard rock album that is easily approachable and highly enjoyable.


6. The State

Going way back to 1999 for our next entry, ‘The State’ is Nickelback’s second studio album. Still exhibiting the raw, post-grunge vibes established by ‘Curb’, this album managed to show the first signs of evolution in Nickelback’s sound.

Although the style of this record is still a long way from the ‘Photograph’ and ‘Rockstar’ sound that was to come, ‘The State’ presented a more marketable sound, establishing its own sense of identity in the process.

Tunes such as the opener, ‘Breathe’, keep the rough, gritty garage approach alive while ‘Leader of Men’ brings great, progressive rock vibes to the table. ‘The State’ certainly isn’t the most famous or successful album Nickelback have put out, but it is nonetheless a solid post-grunge release with plenty of character.


5. The Long Road

As Nickelback moved into the 21st century, they saw a huge change in their sound and overall style. This was mainly down to their maturing musicianship and also thanks to their big money deal with Roadrunner Records. Preceded by 2001’s ‘Silver Side Up’, ‘The Long Road’ had some huge boots to fill when it hit record store shelves in 2003.

Following on from a multi-platinum selling record is almost impossible, unless the follow up is also an international multi-platinum selling record. Despite this demanding expectation, ‘The Long Road’ blew fans away, still holds up today as an almighty commercial success today and remains a good, radio friendly rock record.

Tunes such as ‘Someday’ and ‘Feelin’ Way Too Damn Good’ showed the band’s progression but they hadn’t made the full switch to soft rock just yet. The widespread Nickelback hate that came with their radio fodder soft rock singles wouldn’t fully develop until their next record, ‘All the Right Reasons’.


4. All The Right Reasons

If rock teaches you anything, it’s that heaviness doesn’t necessarily equate to quality. With that being said, ‘All The Rights Reasons’ is considered to be one of Nickelback’s better albums despite the fact it follows a softer, more commercial narrative than all the material that preceded it.

With their post-grunge days having come and gone by the time 2005 came around, Nickelback worked on their brand and commercial viability to great success with their fifth album. Including huge hits such as ‘Far Away’, ‘Photograph’ and ‘Rockstar’ (although Rockstar’s full commercial success wouldn’t come to light until 2008), this album was always destined to be a commercial superhit.

Of course ‘All The Right Reasons’ is nowhere near being Nickelback’s best release, but it is still a fun easy going record with a great range of rock moods and approaches.


3. Curb

It seems almost impossible to consider the fact that Nickelback’s debut record is now 24 years old.

Released in 1996, ‘Curb’ was the band’s first full-length debut record and considering the successful career it spawned, the critical response was initially poor. Rolling Stone magazine awarded the album just 1.5 stars and said that the band’s ‘generic’ sound would get them nowhere, proving once and for all that music journalists can’t predict the future.

When the record was re-released in 2002, MusicOMH said that the album was ‘monochromatic and derivative’, and also said that the band’s ‘Silver Side Up’ success would only be momentary before Nickelback faded out of the limelight (see previous comment about music journalists and predictions).

Despite its damning reviews, ‘Curb’ would go on to earn gold certification in Canada and silver certification in the UK following its 2002 re-release. Key songs from this album included ‘Detangler’, ‘Where?’, ‘Falls Back On’ and the album's only single, ‘Fly’.


2. Dark Horse

Having an album sell platinum even once is merely a distant ambition for most musicians, but to have an album reach platinum status 15 times is beyond practically everyone’s wildest dreams. In 2008, Nickelback released one of their most commercially successful albums ever in their sixth record, ‘Dark Horse’.

After releasing three incredibly popular albums on the bounce, ‘Dark Horse’ was under a lot of pressure to perform in the eyes of the band, the fans and the critics.

In spite of the mammoth task at hand, ‘Dark Horse’ became an unrivalled commercial triumph, reaching the top five in 12 different albums charts across the world (achieving four #1 spots in the process). Some of these conquered charts included the US Billboard 200, the UK Albums Chart and of course the Canadian Albums Chart.

Music critics again took the opportunity to prove their stubbornness though as they slammed ‘Dark Horse’. Despite the fact ‘Dark Horse’ has sold over 5 million copies worldwide, rock critics still couldn’t muster positive words for Nickelback, with The Guardian awarding one star, PopMatters going 3/10, AllMusic awarding 1.5 stars and Metacritic with 49/100.

However, ‘Dark Horse’ was still Nickelback’s fourth straight platinum selling album in the US which allowed them to tour worldwide and maintain their superstar status.


1. Silver Side Up

Even though Nickelback have made some great records in their time, there could only be one winner. ‘Dark Horse’ and ‘Curb’ are both great albums from opposite ends of Nickelback’s spectrum, but they pale in comparison to 2001’s ‘Silver Side Up’. As an album that sold over 8 million copies within 12 months of its release, ‘Silver Side Up’ was one of the biggest rock releases of the entire decade.

‘Silver Side Up’ is mostly remembered as the album that gave Nickelback their first #1 single, ‘How You Remind Me’. From 2001-2005, ‘How You Remind Me’ topped the charts of nine nations including Ireland, the US Mainstream Rock Chart and the UK Rock and Metal Chart.

As a single alone, ‘How You Remind Me’ has sold 3 million copies since its initial release and achieved platinum certification seven times.

The success of this record doesn’t end there, as ‘Silver Side Up’ was included in Billboard US’ top 50 albums of the 2000’s and was certified platinum eight times over in Canada alone. Every song on this album is great though, not just ‘How You Remind Me’.

Less credited songs such as ‘Hangnail’, ‘Never Again’ and ‘Hollywood’ make this album a surprisingly moody and trudging release that has endured the test of time.


In this post: 
Nickelback
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Hi everyone, I'm a signed author and journalist. Despite my main area of expertise being rock music, I have an interest in loads of other subjects like films, TV series, sports and of course, wrestling.