Fleetwood Mac Albums Ranked From Worst To Best

18 members and 17 albums, but which regime reigns supreme?

Fleetwood Mac Ranking
Warner Bros

In 1967 a disgruntled Peter Green was kicked out of what was considered to be a progressive band (John Mayall & the Bluesbreakers) after stepping into the shoes of a young Eric Clapton who was recently given the boot himself nonetheless!

As Peter reeled in his misery he refused to fold. He instead spread the word of a little project that he, Mick Fleetwood and another few fellas were conspiring to create. There was just one missing piece of the puzzle, a bass guitarist. They attempted to entice an up-and-coming guitarist named John McVie by partially naming the would-be band after him - to much success. They soon went to work and eventually conceived a little project named Fleetwood Mac.

It would be criminally understating it to say that the band was a success during its infancy. However, the recipe for success seemed to be the chopping and changing of personnel throughout their career with each new cog in the machine bringing new and unique types of dynamics to the group. Changing the bands style of music more times than a Chameleons colour palette.

After reaching global success in 5 separate decades, creating classic album after classic album and being nominated for (a measly) seven grammys, Fleetwood Mac cemented themselves as one of the greatest of all time with an incredible discography to boot.

17. Future Games

Future Games
HHV

Do you remember when Eminem said "I make elevating music, you make elevator music" on Rap God? One can only wonder if he was referring to this piece of musical driftwood because let it be known that this is one of the most uninspired and yawn-inducing pieces of media that has ever been recorded in the annals of human history.

There isn't much to say about this album as this album has nothing to say itself. Which is exactly how the band members must have felt when they were putting pen to paper for this dumpster fire. The songs aren't exactly incoherent and yes, they do make sense, but structurally formulaic writing does not equate to a successful album or even something that is appeasing to a human beings sense of sound.

The melodies are boring, the instruments aren't exactly out of the norm and its worst offence is that it feels like a simple copy and paste job, rehashing everything that came before with little to no inspiration. It should've been cast into the depths of obscurity or at least be looked back at to learn from its mistakes.

Even if you're curious, be forewarned, you'll be turned off as soon as you turn on. While others may argue against this and claim that its nothing more than alright, it'll never be a standout on merit, but everyone has a preference.


16. Time

Time Fleetwood Mac
Discogs

Time is one of Fleetwood Mac's most recent releases and given the reception it received, it wasn't hard to tell that time was no longer on their side.

Time hasn't been kind to this one. They should have taken more time when developing this one. There was a time when Fleetwood Mac actually tried.

Although the puns are intended to be humorous the unprecedented plummet of such an enduring and endearing band was not. As the decades continued to persist and music began to rapidly spiral into an image oriented industry. Not only was Fleetwood Mac's image stripped of everything that once made the now decadent band a magnum opus of the music industry, but what was more troublesome was the stripping of the band's once untouchable members.

By this time Stevie Nicks and Lindsay Buckingham (who may have once been deemed the epicentre of the band at it's peak) had gone their own way, Christine McVie had announced that this would be her last album with the band (and it shows) and Mick Fleetwood for whatever reason had taken over vocal duties on one track - the first ever time he's done that since the band's inception.

In all fairness, it's only logical to assume that by the time a band reaches it's 16th album and had already syphoned through a multitude of members that Time would be wearing thin for them.


15. Behind The Mask

Behind The Mask
Warner Bros.

When Behind the Mask was released in 1990. it shot straight to the top of the UK album chart, which may say something about the sneaky marketing to consumerism relationships in 1990 because in reality it should have been dead on arrival. Of course, people eventually listened to what they bought and as a result it was instantly buried and forgotten about.

This manifestation of misguided attempts aims at recapturing the essence of what made Fleetwood Mac a household name to begin with. There was just one problem though. The departure of a pivotal member such as Lindsey Buckingham may hinder the overall quality of the project, causing an oversaturation in the vocal aspect with very little taking place on the strings section of the spectrum. This still didn't tarnish the sales anywhere near as much as it did the legacy considering that the album somehow managed to fire itself to platinum status in the UK whilst going Gold in a variety of other regions around the globe.

With an underwhelmingly underdeveloped lack of polish to the album, this is one mask that should have been affixed to the face and left to disguise the disgrace that was hiding beneath it.


14. Mr. Wonderful

Mr Wonderful
Amazon

One of the most unsuitably named albums in the erratic dynasty is the follow-up to Peter Green's sophomore effort and conceptually it sounded like a hit. Instead we ended up with a monotone, cathartic mix as the melodic enchantment from the first album all but disintegrated, advantageously, this successive entry could've learnt from the minimal mistakes created by it's predecessor. It instead quadrupled them.

In the bands original outing not only did the music sound naturally diegetic as it was edited properly, but it also had the benefit of not sounding like it was recorded in a bar during the happiest of happy hours. The worst part of that metaphor is that it's more of a reference to the vocals recorded, disparagingly manipulated by the overtones of a drunken idiot.

Mr. Wonderful might be a pseudonym for something else, but it isn't exactly a disguise that hides the multitude of embarrassing moments that should've stayed in the rehearsal room; if not the giant waste container stationed at the back of the pub it was probably written in.


13. Heroes Are Hard To Find

Heroes are hard to find
Reprise

Heroes are hard to find but apparently albums that have gone too far under the radar are in even shorter supply. This album fits neatly into the obscure rapport that Fleetwood Mac have certainly solidified over the decades, but unlike it's counterparts "Heroes are Hard to Find" remains a more fastidious collection of precariously written tracks. Not the type to particularly transcend time but at the same time shouldn't have fallen into the pit of insignificance it's inhabited for too long.

Unfortunately though, the album suffers in a few departments with the most prominent flaw surprisingly not being the nightmarish album cover that encases it.

The cracks lie in the production mainly, as from one track to the next they tend to embody an horrific distortion disguised as vocals, Bob Welch left after it's release and maybe it was for the best as his spearheading of this project makes it feel like a black sheep in an array of albums that sound wildly different from one another. It still holds up far better than Welch's solo remake of Silver Heels (entitled Hustler) though.


12. Kiln House

Klin House
Amazon

They say something that transcends the test of time ages like a fine wine, on that note, it would be succinctly accurate to liken Fleetwood Mac's fourth album to a vat of recently picked berries. The glowing reviews written over 50 years ago are definitely not indicative of the albums diminished quality when compared to the modern day, let alone the greatness to come from future instalments.

It's clear that the band was going through a transitional phase, proven by the infrequent melding of an overtly diversification of instrumental dystrophy. Not to mention the frequent exits and subsequent entrances from a plethora of different artists coming and going quicker than passengers on an escalator. This problem would plague the band for a fair few years up until the 1970's when the band went through nearly a full reformation and decided to leave experimental products like this behind them. For better or...in fact, it was definitely for the best. Just look at the pattern of the rankings that succeed this one.

Fun fact: Although Christine McVie was not an official member of the band her artistry was exhibited in other ways, designing the front cover to this specific memento.


11. Mystery To Me

Mystery To Me
Amazon

The most evidential piece of the puzzle that marks a time of serious transition for the band, delving into more pop rock radio friendly symphonies, adding a lot more lyrically driven songs and painting a new picture for the public as the band headed into a new direction.

Mystery To Me is the pivotal album of Fleetwood Mac's renaissance era, prematurely embodying the spirit of future works and unforetold classics and nowhere is this more solidified than in the most glaring of vicissitudes as co-creator (Peter Green) had departed after gracing the last album with only a few chords on a singular track.

Even if it could be deemed as ironically harsh that the bands most successful period would initiate as the originators' time would conclude but with Christine McVie at the helm of this project after being relegated to only backing vocals and minimalistic writing duties in previous outings, it is not a mystery to me and neither should it be to you as to how and why the band managed to find its footing and become a runaway success in the years that followed.


10. Then Play On

Then Play On
Reprise

Delving into the more obscure and the less synonymous with the casual fans' rapport, which admittedly is a crying shame considering that in the same vein as it's lead vocalists, this album hits all the right notes. At least when it's not delegating the magic to the strummed chords that so meticulously intertwine to create something seriously impressive, but seriously underrated.

A gigantic step up from the abysmally underwhelming "Mr.Wonderful", Then Play On is the Cher to it's Sonny. It shares the same ensemble of members as the albums that came before and even though the original Fleetwood Mac album of the same name was an unmatched masterpiece at the time of it's release, it isn't unchallenged as this valiant effort proves.

There's a reason it's been remastered again and again and that's not only to gain increased sales numbers and boost a profit; it also has the power of longevity on its side. The lyrics, drums, keys and chords all retain the same quality as they did way back when, with none of it feeling extraneously contemporaneous or even a reflection on the sign of the times.

Then Play On is a stellar album that should be played on repeat by those that can appreciate its illustrious arrangement and niche nuances.


9. Penguin

Penguin Fleetwood Mac
Amazon

1973 was a time of real transformation and affirmation for Fleetwood Mac. Transforming the band into a more radio wave friendly troupe rather than the underground bar scene that people of the generation had come to associate them with. Removing the stigma against them from the bigger, broader record companies and affirmation through confirmation as this would be the year they opposed the inertia that plagued the band from the outset, with Green taking a walk due to personal problems and Mrs. McVie stepping into his role.

Penguin is a significant album for the aforementioned reasons as well as its almost psychedelically hypnotic, but tastefully symphonic sound.

Here we have the first Fleetwood Mac album with a heavy emphasis on its lyrical content, a subtle difference which serenely accentuates the music to never before seen heights within the band, it ignited a spark that had been dwindling since their initial record and more than anything it made the band feel like a breath of fresh air once again, succumbing to the changing times and precedence, overcoming the trials and tribulations which laid the framework for what was yet to come.

It even gave the band their first real logo and potentially a little bit of an ego in the process.


8. Bare Trees

Bare Trees
Reprise

On an album named Bare Trees it may strike you as ironic that the musical stylings are anything but bare, in fact they bear some of the richest fruits this side of the discography. Enriched with the addition of sublime percussion courtesy of Mick Fleetwood, the incomprehensibly rhythmic masterclass provided by Christine McVie - on only her second album with the band nonetheless - but it also left a subtly sombre note with Danny Kirwan ending his fairly lengthy tenure with the band.

Penning the titular song amongst others, he fortunately left in a blaze of glory rather than a subdued whimper as this swansong was the most adept piece of work in his arsenal.

This album isn't without it's fair share of flaws though it'd be a harsh critique to dispirit this albums merit on it's lack of hard-hitting lyrics as most instrumentals would work predominantly with or without words attached to them, but the reduction of mixing prowess overpowers the vocalists on every track, leaving the vocals of various band members feeling drowned out completely by the overzealous - even if magnificent - instruments.


7. Say You Will

Say You Will
Reprise

The last of the legacy left the high notes of previous masterpieces something to be desired as the troublesome twosome of Nicks and Buckingham seemingly hijacked the name of Fleetwood Mac. Say You Will feels more akin to a vanity based bickering project that comes across as more of an overzealous conversation between the two, rather than the once-beating heart of Fleetwood Mac that at this point left fans feeling like it had unintentionally flatlined.

Having said that, the album was not without it's highlights and certainly remains better than some of the groups' more disastrous experiments. Say Goodbye, the titular Say You Will and even the widely underappreciated Silver Girl were all tracks worthy of staking a place in the band's illustrious catalogue.

What really hurts this album though is the lack of Fleetwood Mac legends. As said before, Nicks and Buckingham dominate the album from start to finish and even Mick Fleetwood and John McVie are still around, but without the vocal stylings and songwriting prowess of Christine McVie the album feels like too much of a two dimensional product.

Say You Will is a unique album in the way that it fails to reach the heights of what came before it, but still contains the quality of a respectable swansong. Leaving on neither a bang or whimper, but instead on a rather neutral note.


6. Tango In The Night

Tango in the night
Amazon

The most conflictive entry in the entirety of the group's dynasty is undoubtedly Tango in the Night; an album that is well remembered but hasn't aged very well.

Let's look at the positive's first: Fleetwood Mac's best ever line-up are all present and accounted for. The symphonic brilliant pop simplicity really shone quite brightly in 1987 and certain tracks like Everywhere and Little Lies are still greatly overplayed at every Grandparents' surprise party across the nation. The production values were substantially head and shoulders above most of their work, with the album feeling almost spiritually lifting at times.

The negatives on the other hand are quite problematic.

The tone of the album is far too consistently all over the place, as one moment you'll be queuing mistimed notes into your "airbrush" to the exuberant melody of Little Lies, only to be greeted by the drearily misconstrued "Family Man". If you're not battling with the fact that they brought external writers into the fray for this release, combined with the shifting quality from one track to the next it's clearly evident that a good portion of these songs were simply not coming from the same place that they had been long for a long time.

The personal lives of the colourful personalities on display now felt monotonous, monochrome and monotone.


5. Mirage

Mirage Fleetwood Mac
Amazon

This is a difficult one to place, almost as much as it is to describe. One certainty though is the name of the album suits it perfectly, given that the majority of the time spent listening to it you'll tend to feel like you've experienced something though you're probably not sure exactly as to what.

Unfortunately this disparaging entry into the dynasty that is Fleetwood Mac simply feels undeveloped, underwhelming and undercutting of the albums that preceded it. The melodic tones, symphony's and vocals are all very much brought to fruition as would be expected, especially after years of finely tuned refinement and some of the songs stand alone as memorable records, classics even!

However, as a product, the whole album feels rather disjointed.

Songs like Gypsy, the Book of Love and Only Over You feel meticulously crafted and clearly exhibit that the passion is still there, but the creativity really takes a backseat on this one. Exemplified perfectly by the song Empire State. Yet another song centred around the city that never sleeps, but from a band with little to no association to the city. Leaving the crowds reluctantly raising their eyebrows in bemusement rather than their hands in applause.


4. Fleetwood Mac (1968) (Peter Green's Fleetwood Mac)

Fleetwood Mac 1968
Blue Horizon

It might come as something of a shock that a musical act such as this one with a long history of vocally driven masterpieces initially began life as an instrumental oriented band. The debut album in the band's pantheon of musical synergy confusingly titled "Fleetwood Mac" just like another album in the annals of albums they've produced, was a contemporary hit which over time has evolved into a bonafide classic very worthy of bearing it's namesake.

Reflective of the time it was produced and remaining within the zeitgeist of other albums at the time. Peter Green's Fleetwood Mac (as it's more colloquially known) hit all the right notes and struck all the right chords with listeners when the fresh sound was distributed through the airwaves all the way back in 1968 with "My Heart Beat Like a Hammer" and their version of "Shake Your Moneymaker" still peaking at the pinnacle of even some of the most esteemed tracks of the bands discography.

A discography that would only grow in strength as time transpired, rendering the albums' significance in this spot a testament to the longevity that it has endured over the generations and a masterclass in how to make music without even vocalising.


3. Fleetwood Mac (1975)

Fleetwood Mac (1975)
Reprise

Not to be confused with the eponymous album of the same name that was the launchpad for the band. Fleetwood Mac (sometimes referred to as The White Album), juxtaposing it's inconsiderate title, was probably just as revered for it's overabundance of universal acclaim as much as its misleading title would've caused accidental sales of their debut album.

One thing that the original album didn't have though were the musical stylings of the influential line-up that even non-fans of the band have become accustom to, featuring the debuts of the talented yet troublesome Stevie Nicks and Lindsay Buckingham. Marking a significant turn in the bands direction and one that would go on to define their legacy, rooting them into the echelon of pop music royalty, before solidifying them as part of pop culture indefinitely.

The sudden departure of Bob Welch before pre-production began looked like a problematic symptom of creative burnout, but when Stevie Nicks began penning songs such as the now apocryphal "Rhiannon" to the tear-jerking "Landslide" with Buckingham all the while proving his prowess on mainstays such as "Monday Morning" and "I'm So Afraid". Fans were left not only to rejoice, but celebrate as their worst speculative fears were put to rest, leading to the cultivation of a beginning to bigger and broader horizons.


2. Tusk

Tusk Fleetwood Mac
Warner Bros.

When you've already topped the charts on more than one occasion, released classic album after classic album and built a global fanbase that most acts don't even have the brain power to picture in their wildest of dreams, what else can you do?

Double the quantity and maintain the quality by releasing a double album of course!

In 1979 Fleetwood Mac were proverbially on fire from an increasingly hot streak that became a raging inferno with no deterrent. Tusk added fuel to this fire and etched the band's most famous line-up into the annals of music history and despite the line-up being brilliant beyond belief the idea of a double album starring so many prominent members wasn't the easiest prospect.

Needless to say though the band were at their untouchable best once again as they penned and subsequently recorded hit after hit.

"Sara", "Storms", "Tusk" and "Angel" were some of the tracks that made the album really standout, not only from other contemporaneous acts at the time but from prior albums recorded by the group. The range of dynamicity enveloped in each and every track exuded emotions in abundance, incurring thoughts and contemplation to the listener reflected by the lyrics and the chopping and changing between sombrous sobriety and voluptuous veracity.


1. Rumours

Rumours Fleetwood Mac
Amazon

No prizes for guessing that this would be occupying the top spot.

Often cited as the best ensemble of Fleetwood Mac band members, this seminal work of non-fiction included the now legendary line-up of Stevie Nicks, Lindsay Buckingham, Christine McVie, John McVie and Mick Fleetwood. Coincidentally being by far and wide the most astute demonstration of their talents, providing the listeners with orgasmic ear candy that the contemporaries, as well as the ensuing generations could, and most definitely would, listen to until the needle on their vinyl player snapped or their AirPods ceased to live.

Despite the plethora of instruments being sophisticated, the most instrumental facet of this classic is the surprisingly tense undercutting of band members from each other. This features in such songs as "Go Your Own Way", "Dreams" and "Gold Dust Woman" whilst never shying away from the personal admissions of band members after becoming entangled with media scrutiny exemplified in tracks like "Oh Daddy", "Songbird" and "The Chain".

Cementing Rumours as the epitome of a classic album, a melodic masterpiece which transcends the simpler time in which it was created and remains just as respected if not more after withstanding the test of time with little to no pressure.


Contributor
Contributor

My name is Callum Marsh, but people tend to either call me Cal or Marsh (very creative, I know). Contact: Callumarsh@gmail.com