Iron Maiden: EVERY Album Ranked Worst To Best

Four decades of incredible music, but which album is best?

Iron Maiden Eddie
EMI

Iron Maiden are, quite simply, one of the biggest names in the music industry. Debuting in 1980, and immediately making noise on the scene, the band were instrumental in the rise of British heavy metal. More albums came in swift fashion, and Iron Maiden was soon a household name, and one of the most popular bands the genre had to offer.

Over the next four decades, the band have released a further 15 studio albums in what is a testament to their incredible longevity, and while they have had their ups and downs like any band, the former have far outweighed the latter, and they have remained as strong as ever.

With only bassist Steve Harris and guitarist Dave Murray present for all 16 of Iron Maiden's albums, there have been line up changes with almost every outing, however the band has still managed to keep its identity throughout, never selling out, and never valuing anything above putting out the best music they can.

With 16 albums in their back catalogue, of course some will have been better received than others, and are looked back on more fondly today. Which albums didn't quite live up to the lofty expectations and standards the band have earned, and which surpassed them into the realms of greatness?

16. Virtual XI

As far as Iron Maiden albums go, Virtual XI is at something of an automatic disadvantage as it doesn't feature Bruce Dickinson on the vocals. Instead, this album was the second to feature Blaze Bayley in the role instead and was, thankfully, also the last.

There are many ways to describe Iron Maiden, and forgettable isn't usually one of them, however this is exactly what this album is. With just eight tracks, there are none that particularly stand out. Futureal and The Clansman are without question the most popular, but going back to the studio version after listening to it live with Dickinson, there is just no comparison.

Not only do Iron Maiden miss their true lead vocalist, this album highlights the band's need for a third guitarist. Adrian Smith wouldn't rejoin the band for another two years, and there just seems to be some depth missing from what could have been decent Maiden songs.

It's not that this album is inherently bad, it's just not memorable, and nowhere near the level we've come to expect from the boys.


15. The X Factor

In 1995, three years before Virtual XI, came Blaze Bayley's debut album with the band, The X Factor. Though it is still a part of what is widely thought of as the darkest time in Iron Maiden's career, this album stands some way above Virtual XI.

The opening three tracks kick the album off incredibly well, with Sign of the Cross, Lord of the Flies, and Man on the Edge remaining popular among the fans even after Bruce Dickinson returned. However the rest of the album is never able to reach those same heights.

As with Virtual XI, there is nothing particularly wrong with this outing from the band, as they tried something completely different to what had come before. It just missed the killer riffs and energy that were usually expected from Iron Maiden. These 11 tracks are generally slower than a typical Maiden album, and focus on a lot of darker material.

For this, you could argue that Blaze Bayley's voice fit the bill perfectly well, but unfortunately, he will just never be able to compare to the Air Raid Siren.


14. No Prayer For The Dying

Just like The X Factor was a huge departure from the norm for Iron Maiden in 1995, so was No Prayer For The Dying in 1990. After the previous two albums, Somewhere in Time and Seventh Son of a Seventh Son, saw the band evolve into more of a progressive rock style, No Prayer looked to simplify the band's sound and revert back to what made them so popular in the early 80's.

This was something of a gamble, and one that didn't pay off. Adrian Smith left the line up as he didn't like the direction the sound was taking, and what was produced was severely lacking.

Though the album does feature one of the band's most recognisable songs in Bring Your Daughter... To The Slaughter, there is nothing else that really compares to the excellent hits that came before and after. The album is almost like a collection of songs struggling to break into the average as far as Iron Maiden goes.

Obviously, the band grew to be what they were for a reason, and trying to recreate the likes of Number of the Beast and Piece of Mind missed the mark, acting as nothing more than a regression for the band.


13. Killers

The bottom three Iron Maiden albums almost fall into place without much debate, but it’s in this entry spot that it begins to feel difficult putting such good albums so low on the list. The band’s second outing, released in 1981, was a huge stepping stone towards international acclaim the band enjoys today.

Iron Maiden were a very different beast forty years ago to what they are today. In 10 songs, Killers features two instrumentals, the shortest and second shortest songs in their entire back catalogue, and just two tracks stretching longer than five minutes. It may be a different Maiden, but it’s a very good Maiden

Bruce Dickinson was still a year away from joining the band, but Paul Di’Anno served his time admirably as the frontman, fitting the harder, grungier feel to their early work.

In terms of longevity in the band’s live shows, Killers hasn’t held up as well as most, with Wrathchild alone surviving to be played with the full compliment of six the band has been made up of since 2000. It’s a great album, but Maiden just kept getting better and better.


12. Fear Of The Dark

Two years after the underwhelming No Prayer For The Dying, the band released their ninth studio album, Fear of the Dark. With a similar style to their previous release, and just as far removed from the likes of Somewhere in Time and Seventh Son, Fear of the Dark saw an improvement from 1990, but still left a lot to be desired.

Opening with the fast paced, almost thrash style Be Quick or Be Dead, the album immediately separated itself from No Prayer For The Dying, and continued its strong start with From Here to Eternity, and Afraid to Shoot Strangers.

However, between track three and the final song on the album, the incredible Fear of the Dark that is still to this day one of the best the band has ever produced, little stands out. Instead there are eight songs that, compared to the rest of Maiden's back catalogue, are below average.

Wasting Love offers something slightly different, as one of the band's few ballads over the last forty years, but overall there are precious few tracks on this album that can be classed as some of their strongest.


11. Somewhere In Time

Iron Maiden’s sixth outing broke their impressive record of releasing five albums in consecutive years from 1980 to 1984. After a mammoth tour, the band took some time off, and Somewhere in Time didn’t come until 1986. Those extra months off did wonders for the band, as it allowed time to experiment with new instruments and equipment.

Thanks in large part to the use of guitar synthesizers, Somewhere in Time sounds completely different to anything that came before it, stepping more into the style of longer, almost prog rock tracks.

With only eight entries on this album, the majority revolve around the ideas of time and space, pushing Somewhere in Time toward the realms of a concept album. Its completely unique sound gave the world a handful of truly epic songs in The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner, Wasted Years, and Heaven Can Wait, though of all the tracks, only the latter two get any love from the band in terms of their set lists

This album proves that even after so many years of success, a great band can still change direction and surprise you.


10. Piece Of Mind

Much like Fear of the Dark, Piece of Mind has one particular track that stands above the rest. While on the whole a better outing than Maiden's ninth release, Piece of Mind was certainly helped by The Trooper, easily the best song on the album.

That's not to say the rest of the album is bad however, it just simply can't compete with the quality of the standout song. The first half boasts such Maiden classics as Where Eagles Dare, Revelations, and Flight of Icarus, though the second half doesn't quite keep up the same excellent standard.

The majority of Iron Maiden albums featured a new line up to the band, and while the greatest change came the previous year with Bruce Dickinson joining for Number of the Beast, Piece of Mind saw possibly the next most important change in the band's history. Enter Nicko McBrain on the drums.

Just like Paul Di'Anno, Clive Burr put in a great shift during his time with the band, but the gulf in quality between the two drummers can be seen as early as the intro to the first song on the album. McBrain has been behind the skins for Iron Maiden ever since, is one of the best drummers in the world, and immediately made a huge difference to the band.


9. Dance Of Death

In 2003, the band put out their second album since both Bruce Dickinson and Adrian Smith rejoined the line up and the Blaze Bayley days were put behind them. Dance of Death is something unique from Iron Maiden, and features some of their best, and possibly most underrated work.

The fast paced, breathless start of Wildest Dreams, followed by Rainmaker, gave no indication to the orchestral masterpieces that would appear later on the album.

Naturally, the first that comes to mind is Dance of Death, a nine minute tale of a supernatural meeting around a fire with the dead. There are few, if any other than Iron Maiden that could take a subject such as this and turn it into something so hauntingly beautiful. However, the titular track isn't the only masterpiece on the album, as Journeyman, the band's only acoustic song, shows another side to the band that is just as impressive.

The greatest aspect of this album however, is Paschendale. Iron Maiden are masters of telling war stories, and this epic about the battle of the titular battle is one of their best ever. Overall the album benefits from the angelic use of the strings wonderfully partnered with the band's typical, heavier sound.


8. The Final Frontier

Coming in 2010, with a title as suggestive as this, many expected The Final Frontier to be Iron Maiden's final studio album. It was getting longer and longer between releases, and Steve Harris had once stated his desire to reach 15 albums with the band, but ultimately their 15th outing was far from the end of the road for the band.

The Final Frontier is a complex album, and one of the most technically impressive, as the band flexes multiple muscles. While still able to bring a story of war with Mother of Mercy, Dickinson also tells of the experience of flying around the world in Coming Home. Then there are the two bonafide epics in The Talisman, and the haunting, chilling When the Wild Wind Blows.

As with a couple of Maiden's albums, the quality drops somewhat in the middle, with the likes of Isle of Avalon and Starblind unable to match the strong beginning of the titular track and El Dorado, and the final masterpiece.

Overall, the album was incredibly ambitious, and though not every track was able to leave a lasting impression, the ones that did more than made up for it.


7. The Book Of Souls

In 2015, 35 years after their first album and with the six members in their late fifties or even early sixties, Iron Maiden had no right to be as good as they were. Almost any other band's quality would have declined after nearly four decades, yet with The Book of Souls, the band were able to put out a simply stunning album.

Though not quite a concept album, the outing focuses on many of the same themes and ideas, before the simply stunning Empire of the Clouds closes out the mammoth album. There is truly nothing else like this track in music, it's almost like the band were able to put across an entire novel in 18 minutes.

The Book of Souls certainly had enough material to be spread over two albums, yet the band decided to keep the 11 stunning tracks, totaling over 90 minutes, together. The five year wait was more than worth it.

Without question however, the most impressive aspect of The Book of Souls is Bruce Dickinson. The first album since the singer recovered from having two cancerous tumours removed from his tongue, it's almost incomprehensible that he is still able to sound as solid as before. Truly an inspiration.


6. Iron Maiden

The album that kicked off the career of one of the biggest names in the heavy metal music business. Though the line up is almost unrecognisable to the band today, with only two current members featuring back in 1980, and guitarist Dennis Stratton making his only appearance for the band, if not for the success of their self titled album, the subsequent 15 wouldn't have happened.

Though Paul Di'Anno was ultimately overtaken as the band's strongest singer, and by some way, he perfectly captured the punk style that the band adopted in its early days, and of course Steve Harris added to the line up as something of a unique second string front man.

While some tracks are remembered more fondly than others, with Iron Maiden and Running Free still counted among the most popular the band have ever produced, there are no truly weak songs on the album.

Phantom of the Opera became the first Maiden epic at just over seven minutes long, Transylvania is still possibly the best instrumental Iron Maiden track to date, and the likes of Prowler and Sanctuary typified the no nonsense, full speed metal that made the album so great. Despite the less than perfect production quality on reflection, Iron Maiden has more than stood the test of time.


5. Powerslave

We now get into the top five Iron Maiden albums ever, and of course, these spots are reserved for the elite. Any of these if put out by another band could easily top a list like this, but such is the quality of Iron Maiden's back catalogue, the incredible Powerslave has to settle for fifth place.

There are several traits that have become synonymous with a strong Iron Maiden album over the years. The monstrous seven minute plus epics, of which Powerslave has more than a few, the galloping fast paced hooks, and of course, a strong, thrashing opener. Powerslave's Aces High may be the best of them all.

Though the greatest song on the release is up for debate, with possibly the titular song having the strongest claim, it is the final track that has become the most infamous.

At over 13 minutes long, The Rime of the Ancient Mariner, a retelling of Samuel Taylor Coleridge's poem of the same name, the song is a completely unique epic, a true journey that Iron Maiden, and only Iron Maiden could make work. All this without even mentioning 2 Minutes to Midnight and Flash of the Blade, two incredible songs that could have been the best on a number of other albums.


4. Seventh Son Of A Seventh Son

From the opening acoustic verse of Iron Maiden's seventh studio album, it was clear things were going to be different. Just how different however, didn't become apparent until the keyboard kicked in. Never before had the band utilised such an instrument in six albums and eight years, but this signaled their progression into something special.

Two years after Somewhere in Time took the band in a completely different direction to before, Seventh Son built on this, doubling down on the prog rock style and diving head first into their first true concept album.

Telling the story of the titular son, the album delves into the ideas of mystical powers and prophecies, as all the tracks harmonise together with the same themes. The absolute highlight in the 45 minutes full of highlights is the three song stretch of Can I Play With Madness, The Evil That Men Do, and Seventh Son of a Seventh Son.

The album indicated a whole new direction for the band, one that was so strong that when they decided to revert back to their previous style with No Prayer For The Dying, they put out one of their worst ever albums and lost Adrian Smith. So sure was he that the Seventh Son sound was the direction that the band needed to follow, he wasn't prepared to stay if they didn't. It would seem that he was right.


3. The Number Of The Beast

Though it may not take the top spot, The Number of the Beast is arguably the most important album in the band's history. After Paul Di'Anno was kicked out, Iron Maiden needed a new front man that would elevate the band, and they could not have picked anyone better.

In 1982, Bruce Dickinson debuted with the band on what was immediately, and easily, their best album yet. Next to the Air Raid Siren, with a stunning performance that more than earned him the moniker, the rest of the band upped their game for the technical masterpiece that was their third outing.

The titular song saw the band play around with different time signatures, Run to the Hills quickly became one of the iconic metal songs of the decade, and Hallowed be thy Name blew fans away as a harrowing tale of a man waiting to meet his maker. This was Maiden at their galloping, thundering best.

The Number of The Beast also fired the band into the public eye, not for the quality of their music, but for the perception that they were satanists. It's a shame that the more mainstream audience couldn't see past the album's title to appreciate heavy metal music at its finest.


2. Brave New World

18 years after Bruce Dickinson's first Iron Maiden outing came his first album with the band after his five year break. Not only was his return welcomed with open arms, Adrian Smith rejoined the band for the first time since Somewhere in Time in 1986.

This was the first time the band played with three guitarists, and it lent the album another level of depth previously impossible with just two. There is a reason this line up has lasted for 20 years and counting. The album itself is a majestic compilation of 10 songs showcasing what Iron Maiden are capable of.

The Wicker Man, The Mercenary, and The Fallen Angel are perfect examples of their faster paced, thrash heavy tracks, paired with the likes of Out of the Silent Planet, The Thin Line Between Love and Hate, and the titular track, as the slower, melodic epics.

The crowning jewel of the album however, is without question Blood Brothers, which has since become a staple of the band's live shows, and an emotional commentary on bringing people from all walks of life together under the Iron Maiden banner. Dickinson's return to the band was simply herculean, as he gave one of his strongest performances ever, on an album that musically is able to stand next to any from their extensive back catalogue.


1. A Matter Of Life And Death

To be considered one of Iron Maiden's best albums requires something special, but the distinction of the single greatest outing from the heavy metal legends takes something awe-inspiring, and damn near flawless. In 2006 with A Matter of Life and Death, the band truly delivered this and more.

If there is one thing Iron Maiden know how to do, it is tell a war story through their music. Though not quite a concept album, the band's 14th outing focuses heavily on the themes of both war and religion. Two incredibly powerful ideas that Steve Harris and Bruce Dickinson are able to base stunning, incredibly moving lyrics around.

Listening to A Matter of Life and Death from start to finish is a truly immersive experience, from the blistering opener Different World, to the handful of stunning epics that make up the latter half of the album.

The finest chapter on the album, and one of the greatest songs Maiden have ever recorded, is The Longest Day, telling the horrifying story of a soldier landing on the beaches in Normandy on D-Day in 1944. It is still immeasurably impressive how the band are able to capture such a harrowing, detailed experience in the eight minutes that ensure this album rests at the very top of the pile.


In this post: 
Iron Maiden
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

This standard nerd combines the looks of Shaggy with the brains of Scooby, has an unhealthy obsession with the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and is a firm believer that Alter Bridge are the greatest band in the world.