Marilyn Manson: EVERY Album Ranked Worst To Best
We Are Chaos is one of Manson's best.
Since his debut album was released in 1994, Marilyn Manson has reigned as one of rock and roll's most controversial, iconic and unique figures.
Though perhaps more famous in the public eye because of his controversies, Manson has over the years released some of music's most daring and anthemic records, each one teeming with angst, rage and anti-establishment themes.
As a songwriter, he has been the voice of the downtrodden and the outcasts for nearly three decades, and though he's now in his fifties, he's still releasing albums that capture the true essence of what he and his music stands for.
Each album has a new sound, and though Marilyn Manson is really a band, it has over the years become something of a solo project, with only Manson himself being the consistent member.
With eleven albums under his belt, Manson is a true icon on the music world, blending rock with metal, synth and pop with often excellent results. Controversies aside, here are all eleven of Marilyn Manson's albums ranked worst to best, from the 90s classics to his most recent record, 2020's We Are Chaos.
11. Born Villain
Born Villain is by no means a bad album, but as far as Manson records go, it's easily the least daring and memorable of his discography. As noted in the introduction, one of the joys of listening to a new Manson album is the anticipation to see what he'll do next, and in that vain Born Villain is a bit of a let-down.
Rather than attempting a new, genre-fusing style, Manson instead leaned into the more reliable beats of his previous records, bringing solid anthems with songs like "No Reflection" and "Overneath the Path of Misery," both of which are dependable tracks that just don't stand-out, simply because we've heard it all before.
On top of that, it's also wholly disjointed, with the industrial sounds being followed up by slower, less accomplished ballads that for some reason just don't mesh. Also, there's the issue of the lyrics, somewhere Manson has rarely had a problem, but on this album (see "Pistol Whipped") he seems determined to bring out the controversy with little thought or care. Not a terrible album, but easily the weakest of Manson's discography.
Best Songs: Breaking the Same Old Ground, Hey Cruel World, No Reflection
10. Eat Me, Drink Me
Following his public divorce from dancer Dita von Teese, Manson released Eat Me, Drink Me, an album which paints a vivid portrait of a man in pain and grief. Like Born Villain, it is by no means a bad album, but for all its stronger tracks like "Putting Holes in Happiness" and the epic "If I Was Your Vampire," there are lazy tracks such as "Mutilation..." and "Are You A Rabbit?", both of which make the album seem confused and disjointed.
The production of the record is very strong, and its best songs really are great stand-alone tracks, but with its dark, personal tone and Manson's identity crisis taking up the bulk off the album, Eat Me, Drink Me does end up on the weaker side of Manson's back catalogue. "Putting Holes in Happiness" and "Heart-Shaped Glasses," though, are two seriously great, underrated gems that deserve to be dug up.
Best Songs: Putting Holes in Happiness, If I Was Your Vampire, Heart-Shaped Glasses
9. The High End Of Low
The High End of Low should have been a far better record than the one we got. Featuring the long-awaited return of Twiggy Ramirez, the lead single "Arma-goddamn-motherf*cking-geddon" promised fans a return to the more angst-ridden and controversial tunes that had domnated the band's earlier career.
Aside from the lead single, though, The High End of Low ends up suffering in much the same way as Eat Me, Drink Me. At the time of its production, Manson had gone through his next big divorce, and the songs often reflect that he was once more in a wounded, dark place. Songs like "I Want To Kill You Like They Do In The Movies" also did very little to help the album's overall image.
That being said, there are good moments in the album, particularly from the melodic and criminally underrated "Running to the Edge of the World" and the often clever fusion of metal, synth and country, but even the high moments of the record can't save it from its low points.
Best Songs: Running to Edge of the World, We're From America, Arma-goddamn-motherf*cking-geddon
8. Heaven Upside Down
Manson's second record working alongside Tyler Bates saw a great improvement on the artist's previous records. From the heavy and dark tones of "We Know Where You F*cking Live" to the disturbing but catchy "Kill4Me," Heaven Upside Down kept up the band's momentum that had been built up with The Pale Emperor.
The album benefits from being Manson's most tightly-wound creations, since it's only ten tracks long. There's no filler, no real missteps, and every song features a new sound and collision of genres.
But there is a problem that keeps it from being much higher, in that it never takes any risks. Featuring the same line-up and themes from the previous record, it never separates itself from The Pale Emperor, and seems more like a continuation of their more recent work rather than a new daring addition to their CV. It's a great listen, and is relentless in its intensity, but it misses out simply because the other albums have more to say.
Best Songs: Tattooed in Reverse, We Know Where You F*cking Live, Kill4Me
7. The Golden Age Of Grotesque
The fifth album of Marilyn Manson's career came at something of a crossroads. The first four records were all incredibly well accomplished, solidifying Manson as a band not willing to conform to the mainstream sounds of the time. But by the time The Golden Age of Grotesque came about, it looked as though Manson was running on fumes, unable to keep up the so-far solid run.
The Golden Age of Grotesque is polished, refined, almost pop-y at times, and received a lot more radio play than the band's previous records. With songs such as "Mobscene" and the awful "Doll-Dagga-Buzz-Buzz Ziggety-Zag," it seemed as though Manson was just messing around, almost parodying himself.
That being said, with nearly twenty songs, there are some true classics amongst the coal, including the moody, piano-infused title track, the angry "This is the New Sh*t" and the violent anthem "Use Your Fist and Not Your Mouth." There's a lot to love with the individual songs, and Manson deserves credit for trying new things, but as a whole the album is not up to scratch.
Best Songs: The Golden Age of Grotesque, Better of Two Evils, This is the New Sh*t
6. The Pale Emperor
As a nod to David Bowie's "The Thin White Duke," The Pale Emperor saw Manson return to the scene with a great new sound, finally finding a balance between the new, more polished sound of The Golden Age of Grotesque and the dirty, controversial sounds of Antichrist Superstar. This was also the album where Marilyn Manson really became a one-man show, with the band's line-up completely decimated.
With Tyler Bates in his corner for the first time, Manson created some of the best anthems of his later career, including the moody synth-rock anthem "Third Day of a Seven Day Binge" and the John Wick tune "Killing Strangers." Every song oozes that classic Manson menace, whilst showing the controversial frontman as a more mature but still twisted version of himself.
There are some slumps, such as the uninspired "Slave Only Dreams to Be King" and "Cupid Carries a Gun," but all told The Pale Emperor is a guaranteed future classic.
Best songs: Third Day of a Seven Day Binge, Deep Six, Killing Strangers, The Mephistopheles of Los Angeles
5. We Are Chaos
Manson's most recent record is nothing short of a revelation. A moody, mature, and incredibly tight album, We Are Chaos shows Manson at his most refrained, calm and collected. There are no pure anthems on the record, per se, with Manson here opting for a slower, more melodic tone throughout.
From the epic title track opener to the beautifully catchy "Don't Chase the Dead," it is clear early on that We Are Chaos might just be Manson's most grown-up and unique album to date. Toning down the controversy in favour of a more accessible and polished sound, there's no filler throughout the record - only continuously eerie, melodic and unforgettable.
It might not work for fans of the more old-school, fast-paced Manson albums, but its tone and lyrical power cannot be denied.
Best Songs: We Are Chaos, Don't Chase the Dead, Perfume, Half-Way and One Step Forward
4. Mechanical Animals
There's more Bowie in this record than any of Marilyn Manson's other projects, but it would be unfair to cast it aside as simply a synth-inspired homage to Manson's biggest influence. Polished, jazzy, and endless weird, Mechanical Animals focuses on gender relations, drug abuse, sex and glam rock, and balances its many themes with ease.
With some of Manson's most iconic tunes - "I Don't Like the Drugs (But the Drugs Like Me)," "Great Big White World" - the record shows Manson to be a lot more than the angsty, energetic rebel of his previous albums, but a committed and passionate artist with a lot to say about the world and people.
The themes pop, the fusion of genres shine with every track, and though it falls short of the next three spots, Mechanical Animals is nonetheless a truly great rock album.
Best Songs: I Don't Like the Drugs (But the Drugs Like Me), Coma White, Great Big White World
3. Portrait Of An American Family
This was Marilyn Manson's first album, complete with an actual line-up and a clear sense that music fans around the world were in the presence of something both new and game-changing. Easily the band's most disturbing record, Portrait of an American Family burst onto the screen with shocking lyrics, creepy industrial beats and literally zero filter.
Portrait has it all, fusing together rock, pop, disco, synth, and goth with striking effects. Behind the spooky imagery, serial killer-inspired names and shocking personas, it was clear that Marilyn Manson were more than just walking controversy - they were a band, with things to say and great music to offer.
The best songs are the rebellious anthems, which spoke to the outcasts and teens of the 90s in a major way. "Lunchbox" and "Get Your Gunn" in particular showed the band as more than shock-rockers, but relatable and wonderfully twisted musicians.
Best Songs: Lunchbox, Get Your Gunn, Dope Hat
2. Antichrist Superstar
Marilyn Manson's second album was the one that solidified their fame and image. With its dirty guitars, thumping bass, synth-pop undertones and Manson's croaky but melodic voice, Antichrist Superstar has all that his fans have come to love about him.
Featuring Manson's most famous song, "The Beautiful People," the record also includes the unfairly forgotten "Angel with the Scabbed Wings," the slow and moody "Dried Up, Tied and Dead to the World" and the superbly creepy "Tourniquet."
The backlash to the album's dark and violent themes was massive at the time, but that didn't slow its success one bit. Antichrist Superstar catapulted Manson to superstardom. No longer underground and niche, Manson and his band were on track to be the next big thing, and when an album is this good, it's not hard to see why.
Best Songs: The Beautiful People, Dried Up Tied and Dead to the World, Angel with the Scabbed Wings, Irresponsible Hate Anthem
1. Holy Wood (In The Valley Of The Shadow Of Death)
To date Manson's best album, Holy Wood (In the Valley of the Shadow of Death) took everything that made Portrait and Antichrist so good and meshed them together into the perfect rock album. A scathing assault on mainstream media, his critics and American culture, the record was in part a response to the Columbine Massacre, which was partially blamed on Manson's music.
Manson, never one to be turned away by controversy and critics, spends twenty tracks pointing out the true issues with society, and does so with a perfect blending of hard rock tracks ("The Fight Song"), atmospheric tone-setters ("GodEatGod") and anthems for the outcasts ("The Nobodies").
Holy Wood is Manson's most accomplished record from both a musical and lyrical standpoint, a moving, powerful, rebellious series of anthems that never let up despite the 80-minute runtime. It doesn't get any better than this.
Best Songs: The Fight Song, The Love Song, GodEatGod, Disposable Teens, The Nobodies, In the Shadow of the Valley of Death.