Metallica: 10 Best Hard Rock Songs

From the Black Album onwards, what are their absolute best?

Metallica BLACK ALBUM load reloadq
Wikimedia Commons/Blackened Records

Metallica has been one of the most interesting bands to watch since the 80's. When they started out of the California Bay Area, their sound was no nonsense speed metal that went right for the jugular. Each subsequent record seemed to be another stellar addition to the thrash metal canon. Then the 90's happened...

When the band shifted gears into hard rock territory on their self-titled Black Album, fans felt betrayed that their favorite metal band was going soft all of a sudden.

What those fans were missing out on was the debut of Metallica as complex songwriters, whose knack for writing melodic hooks gave them an extra musical layer. Even when the band "sold out" in the late 90's, some of those records still feature cuts that could make anyone throw their horns up in the air with pride.

Though the band's thrash output remains some of their most timeless work, this was the period where we found out the band were capable of so much more. It no longer had to be confined to the 8-minute epic riff collage anymore.

After finding their identity, Metallica proved that they were a band that were not capable of writing just great metal songs, but songs that transcended the genre itself.

10. Hero Of The Day

I'll meet the hardcore metalheads halfway here with the band's more commercial release Load. While the album has a lot more bright spots than you might remember, the drastic shift towards alternative rock was a bit too much for most fans to stomach.

On the flip side, when Metallica decides to just write a simple song, you get gems like "Hero of the Day." The opening guitar strains are very pretty and almost...*gasp* inviting on a Metallica track. Whereas most of the band's early work cut right to the chase when hitting you over the head, this song plays it cool as it shows the struggles that afflict anyone who is down on their luck.

Just the way James Hetfield croons as he talks with his mother about the pain that he feels going through life seems genuinely heartfelt. In addition, this is most likely the only Metallica song to be written almost entirely in a major key. For many metalheads, major keys are no good unless your name is Iron Maiden, but this song does an exquisite job at marrying the heavy side of the band's sound with a more rootsy hard rock approach.

Though this may be a prime candidate to show Load's flaws, "Hero of the Day" is probably one of the most mainstream Metallica releases that could get non-metalheads initiated.


9. Low Man's Lyric

Out of all the experimentation happening the two Load-era albums, "Low Man's Lyric" may just be the weirdest track across both albums. The ballad starts off with a clean guitar as usual, but then we hear what sounds like a bagpipe drawing out the main melody of the tune.

Instead of letting the guitar carry the tune, the glue that holds the track together is a hurdy-gurdy, which has just the right timbre to drape this song in a dark melancholy. The lyrics that James writes on this track are absolutely soul-crushing, as we hear the tale of a homeless man who depends on drugs to get him through his hopeless existence.

Once he makes his way back to his relatives, the song takes a dark turn into havier territory, as if our hero doesn't feel stable with his family. Just when you think our protagonist may find solace with his folks back home, he finds that the only place he feels comfortable is back on the streets clamoring for his next fix. While most Metallica ragers just make you want to annihilate the world around you, this song is one of the most tragic stories the band would ever pen in their 90's period.


8. Until It Sleeps

After The Black Album sold 80 bajillion copies around the world, diehard Metallica couldn't have been prouder. Sure, the band had stripped down their sound, but now metal was more of a household name than ever before. At this point, there was no reason to believe that Metallica's next album would be anything but spectacular.

Than "Until It Sleeps" was released as a single and metalheads got scared as hell for what was to come. But...why? From a pure musical perspective, this song seems like the logical next step from the band's more hard rock predecessor, with a slinky bass riff and demented chorus melody. Yeah, the band may have cut their hair, but that didn't mean they had forgotten how to write great songs.

The song's detuning also gives it a unique character, with all the band's previous records almost always being done with traditional tunings. Instead of being the dark sign of selling out, this was the point where Metallica became all the more intriguing.

They may have been pulling from more alternative sounds, but the idea of Metallica doing a song that sounds like Alice in Chains is the kind of unusual pairing just crazy enough to work.


7. Turn The Page

When it came out, Garage Inc. was heralded as a good placeholder album in between regular releases, but diehard fans were still feeling burned by the band's perceived missteps on Load and Reload. After combing through it though, this collection of cover songs may be one of the most overlooked highlights of the band's entire career.

It may not have the most original tunes on it, but the band's interpretations of rock staples through their hard rock lens makes for some breathtaking performances.

While many single out their version of "Whiskey in the Jar" when talking about this record, their run through Bob Seger's "Turn the Page" is nothing short of perfection. The track perfectly captures the loneliness that comes with being a traveling musician moving from town to town, meeting more and more people that you'll forget in two weeks.

The way Kirk Hammett uses his guitar to mimic the original's saxophone line is one of the most understated feats of brilliance he has laid down. Suddenly, this subdued little song from the classic rock era has become a little mini journey through the life of the traveling loner at the end of the bar.

Just when the song leaves you on a high, it's time to turn the page yet again.


6. Enter Sandman

There are two schools of thought when it comes to "Enter Sandman:" either it is a jaw-dropping feat in Metallica's catalog or a travesty that afflicted metal's greatest band. While the metal side of the spectrum has certainly seen much heavier offerings from this band, the song checks almost every box in terms of being a hard rock classic.

For starters, the riff dominating the track is probably the greatest rock riff to come out of the 90's. Though bands from the grunge era had their fair share of great licks, this little musical piece has an undeniable eerie presence to it.

As more and more bits get layered, it starts to feel more and more like a train about to hit you. Hetfield's lyrics are also some of the best on the Black Album, as he offers up a demonic twist on the typical lullaby scenario.

To give credit where its due, this was very risky for Metallica to open up their record with this new change in style. Instead of just easing you into the change in direction, the riff just announces itself with a defiant sonic statement. You were either gonna love it or hate it, but you'd have to be a pretty staunch thrash defender if you thought this song wasn't the s**t.


5. I Disappear

Ahhh yes...the song that launched a thousand Napster lawsuits. During the late 90's, the band were asked to contribute a song to Mission Impossible II, but things started to spiral when demos of the song were found being pirated on Napster. This eventually led to Lars Ulrich starting a legal dispute with the company, which turned him into one of the most hated men in the music industry almost overnight.

It's really a shame that "I Disappear" was dragged through the mud, because the basis of the track still holds up as a highlight of Metallica's darker period.

Even though fans weren't really feeling the more alternative side of the band's sound, this felt like the perfect amalgamation of all the band's experimental tracks but done with a more Metallic ethos. While the riff may be nothing spectacular, the little wah stab from Kirk ingrains itself in your brain and refuses to go away.

The chorus melody is also incredibly well-written, with Hetfield settling into a more subtle vocal tone before returning to his trademark growling style. There are probably a lot of Metallica fans who just saw this song as another nail in the band's coffin, but this type of hard rock fun is still a blast to listen even with all of the Napster hooplah.


4. Fuel

When many fans were getting burned by Metallica's first delve into hard rock on Load, people were still itching for the band to knock it out of the park once again. Even though the band's followup was still a bit rough around the edges as well, everyone could agree that it definitely started on the right foot with "Fuel."

Rather than having the more downtempo songs of their previous effort, this song starts off like a smack in the mouth with a groovy-as-hell riff at a perfectly driving tempo.

Though the speed may have gone up a notch, the tune is still rooted in a more hard rock shuffle than your typical thrash rager. People may have been a bit disheartened, but the entire song is the ideal soundtrack to the motorcycle-fixated biker dude who surrounds himself with fast cars.

Just from the opening riff, this song demands to be played loud while you're revving your engine, about to go from 0-90 at the green light. Out of all the songs to come from this era, "Fuel" has been given the most praise as one of the band's greatest heavy-hitters.

Reload had much more sonic detours in store for Metallica fans, but "Fuel" was the one track that showed us our favorite metal band was still in there somewhere.


3. The Unforgiven

No matter what era you came from in Metallica's history, the Black Album is still one of their greatest works despite the more commercial shift. The songs may have been a bit more downtempo and sounded bigger, but in what way is that a bad thing?

Being the first ballad off the record, "The Unforgiven" is one of the best arranged cuts that the band had ever composed at that point. By turning around their typical heavy chorus soft verse dynamic, the band hit upon a demented groove that seems perfectly suited to tell this story of sorrow from a broken man.

This song is also the point where James' vocal chops became more noticeable. After getting proper vocal training, the subtle nuances in his performance make it come through mix, almost like you're seeing the real Hetfield beneath the tough guy veneer.

Kirk Hammett's solo is also one of his best, even if it was painstakingly put together after his original solo was rejected by producer Bob Rock. Instead of just being another shredding opportunity, there is so much taste in his phrasing which makes the solo absolutely timeless.

In just a few minutes, Metallica took the ballad-esque elements they had touched on on "Fade to Black" and turned them into an emotional roller coaster of a song.


2. No Leaf Clover

For many fans, Metallica already seemed to be up to some weird stuff when they put out a new record filled with cover material. After announcing a new album, fans weren't met with all-new music but a live performance of the band with an entire symphony orchestra.

At this point, we've definitely come a long way from the band's thrash metal beginnings, but the music created is truly awe-inspiring. The band's older material is given a healthy dose of musical professionalism injected into it thanks to the arranging of Michael Kamen, but the brightest spots are when both worlds can work in conjunction with each other.

One of the only originals to come from the S&M concert, "No Leaf Clover" is the one instance where Metallica fully conjoined the musical sophistication of their work with the heavy bombast of their more punk-leaning side.

On the surface, nothing too flashy is happening with the guitars, but they are just where they need to be to create a dense mood, with Hetfield detailing the life of a man growing up to be a successful musician.

It could have come off as a well-orchestrated piece of self-indulgence, but "No Leaf Clover" stands as not only a great hard rock song, but one of the best songs the band has ever written period.


1. Sad But True

The biggest complaint that hardcore Metallica fans had with the Black Album was the band's drastic shift towards more commercial material. Even with all the negative backlash that the band had to sift through, no one could deny the heaviness behind "Sad But True."

If metalheads had had their way, the original version of this tune would have been a fast-paced mess. Once Bob Rock got his hands on the tune, the song went from a maniacal uptempo riff to a brutal hard rock stomp. The song is also one of the darkest on the lyrical front, with Hetfield speaking from the perspective of the dark side of you that you don't want to confront.

The new production also helps the song immensely, with the guitars being layered 7 times over and Lars' drums sounding like they are cannon shots every time he hits the snare.

I will conceit that the tempo is certainly a change of pace, but the hard groove is still more than worthy of getting legions of fans headbanging in succession. It's no secret that the Black Album was divisive among the thrash metal faithful, but "Sad But True" was the best of both worlds by providing a hard groove for rock fans while staying just gritty enough for the metal crowd to raise their horns.


Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97