Queens Of The Stone Age: Ranking Their Game-Changing Albums

The face of modern rock music would not be the same with Josh Homme's little world-slaying pet project - but of all their drastically different albums, which is the best?

With Queens of the Stone Age, Josh Homme achieved real longevity in the wake of stoner-rock cult concern Kyuss, transposing that band's grungy style into sleeker, sleazier jams for his own band's eponymous debut. Over the last sixteen years (and with an ever-changing line-up), Homme has taken to creating some of the most iconic hard rock albums of modern times, and in doing so has inspired a wealth of other contemporary guitar groups to scale bigger and bolder heights. Although the Queens have never fully revolutionised their sound, every one of their six studio albums is a distinctive entity, each possessing its own sonic identity, stylistic breadth, and channelling of disparate influences to varying degrees. Charting the band€™s progression is equally fascinating and impressive, especially when considering the central role of Homme himself. After building QotSA into a unified gang during the early noughties, the band€™s most recent material finds the hulking frontman facing his more personal demons, and consequently producing some of his most soulful work to date. Having had almost a year to embed itself fully in the consciousness of fans, it€™s worth examining ...Like Clockwork against the band€™s five previous studio albums and considering how they stack up against one another in terms of how they hold up in terms of long-term qualities. From the "weakest" to the strongest, here are the albums of QotSA in all their crunchy, crazed glory.

6. Era Vulgaris (2007)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E38DwXwpms0 It seems ever so slightly fruitless to denounce an album as €œmessy€ when ugliness is so inherent to its signature aesthetic. After taking to desert highways in Songs For The Deaf and haunted forests for Lullabies To Paralyze, Josh Homme€™s merry brigade seem to have psychologically ground out the sludgy, cracked Era Vulgaris in a disused factory. It€™s all there in the production: the guitars sound as if they are caked in grease and flecks of debris; the grooves and riffs revolve as if being churned from great hulking machinery, and Homme€™s own elocution plumbs even grottier depths. This rickety, scattershot approach allows for some pretty fun outings: €˜I€™m Designer€™ is a herky-jerky traipse through some of Homme€™s sleaziest sorcery, with cynical lyrics twisted through inside-out hooks and groaning guitar tones. Elsewhere, singles €˜Sick, Sick, Sick€™ and €˜3s and 7s€™ offer rip-roaring examples of QotSA€™s garage-tinged riffery at its finest. The issue is that amid all the sweat and scuzz, more than a few duds are belched out along the way. €˜Battery Acid€™ is the album€™s nadir: a work of disjointed glam-grunge which coughs along past its welcome; €˜Suture Up Your Future€™ fails to fully capitalise on the clanking ache of its opening moments; and as an opening statement, €˜Turnin€™ on the Screw€™ is strung along for far longer than its components can adequately manage. In all honesty, there€™s nothing truly appalling about Era Vulgaris. But when weighted against the other works in QotSA€™s canon its issues with consistency, engagement, and musical force can€™t help but seem conspicuous. Highlight: €˜Make it Wit Chu€™ It€™s the clear anomaly among its peers, but the scratchy genes of Era Vulgaris cause the understated bliss of €˜Make it Wit Chu€™ to sparkle that bit brighter. That bouncy, snare-happy rhythm propels some of the most supple guitar dynamics of QotSA€™s career along on an earworm-happy route, culminating in a pleasant old-school hook, and some nice twangy soloing. The result is laidback, lithe, and - yes - quite lovely.

5. Lullabies To Paralyze (2005)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7RBMwelVYn0 There€™s always been an occult appeal to QotSA€™s music, revealed in certain touches of varying perceptibility, from snaky backtracked messages (€˜God is in the Radio€™) to chant-like choral vocals (€˜Fairweather Friends€™). Lullabies To Paralyze serves up an hour of these macabre tendencies at their most uninhibited, though not every effort has the same degree of success. While the hooks and guitar tones are as muscular and impressive as ever, there are numerous points at which Lullabies merely sounds like a less gripping sequel to Songs For The Deaf. There is swagger in abundance, but Lullabies lacks the conceptual tautness, the dexterous grasp of variety, and the contagious gang mentality of its predecessor. Nick Oliveri had been ousted from the band by this point, Mark Lanegan€™s contributions are much sparser and sparer, and Dave Grohl€™s sticks were taken up by new mainstay Joey Castillo. As for diversity, there are still shifts in tempo and tone through Lullabies, but somehow, without the whiplash swerves of the album€™s precursors, the impact of such deviations doesn€™t quite hit with the same brusque power. When they arrive, the unhurried jams can waver between sleazily entrancing (€œYou Got a Killer Scene There, Man€€) to gruelling (€˜Someone€™s in the Wolf€™). What saves Lullabies are its moments where the malevolent glee is dialled up to its full potential, and Homme and co. just relish the chance to cut loose and embrace the theatricality. Single €˜Burn the Witch€™ is an established fan favourite, which is flavoured with just the right amount of ham. The breakneck thrash of €˜Medication€™ is absolutely intoxicating and the circling jig of €˜Broken Box€™ is loose and limber, buddying falsetto croons with some biting choruses from Homme. In moments such as these, QotSA manage to sound at their most vital, and it€™s thankful that it€™s a formula they adhere to for the most part. Highlight: €˜Everybody Knows That You Are Insane€™ It€™s always a pleasure to hear a tempo change as electrifying as it is surprising. €˜Everybody Knows That You€™re Insane€™ starts life as a roiling, wailing dirge, before it plummets into that fierce, frenetic mantra of its title. The band indulge their guitar heroics on this one, but with the brute force of that turning-point and a hair-raisingly powerful solo; it€™s a mesmerising thrill ride all the way through.

4. Queens Of The Stone Age (1998)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZaVlYh7Je9Y Emerging from the shadow of cult stoner-rockers Kyuss was always going to be a strange transition for Homme, but it€™s a move he pulled it off with style - and then some - in the form of QotSA€™s eponymous 1998 release. The desert-cooked jams concocted by his previous band remained a key touchstone, but Homme sculpted his new material into tighter, more compact statements. These more instantaneous offerings take collective shape in an album dressed in a heat-haze of sleaze, bookended by tales from toilet stalls and suggestive subject matter. Homme took on the lion€™s share of instrumental duties himself, assisted by studio drummer Alfredo Hernández. As a consequence of this heightened autonomy, Queens Of The Stone Age has a markedly singular focus, and gathers a steady momentum as it rumbles through the valleys and landscapes of Homme€™s id. The buzzword here is €œbass€: this is the most low-slung QotSA record to date. The bass arrangements holding these tracks together may not possess the same vitriolic, jabbing intensity which Nick Oliveri brought to the table, but the grooves mined by Homme€™s rumbling four-stringer are menacingly hypnotic, especially on mammoth cuts such as €˜You Can€™t Quit Me Baby€™ and €˜Mexicola€™. The issue which holds back Queens Of The Stone Age from being classed as one of Homme€™s major musical achievements is the album€™s relative lack of tempering. Although most are enthralling in their sedate wooziness, there are several instances where the arrangements spin into uninteresting tangents or overly repetitive codas. €˜Hispanic Impressions€™ is all in good jest, but its clunky charm wears off faster than its three-minute runtime should warrant. Elsewhere, €˜Avon€™ is agreeable but slightly flat, and the final two minutes of €˜Walkin on the Sidewalks€™ could easily have been shed without much complaint. Other than these criticisms, however, Queens Of The Stone Age stands as an impressive and intriguing debut; one packed tight with riffs and brimming with promise. Sixteen years on from its release, it€™s still a formidable starting block. Highlight: €˜If Only€™ The Queens have come a long way since 1998, but few of the band€™s cuts are as cool and peppy as the infectiously likeable €˜If Only€™. Boasting the catchiest riff on the album, it nimbly thumps through its cropped verses before upshifting to one of those gloriously simple but so-darn-effective refrains that Homme would go on to master for Rated R. It may be built of relatively basic components, but sometimes of course, the simple pleasures are hard to beat.

3. Songs For The Deaf (2002)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rVV_3Z1mp_c Songs For The Deaf is so huge, it€™s hued in something of a legendary status. It€™s the most ubiquitous record in the Stone Age annals, backed by three of the group€™s most successful singles to date, and in terms of size and scope it€™s their most ambitious undertaking. In the bluntest terms, Songs For The Deaf is a goliath of a record; a twenty-first century riposte to the hard-rock stalwarts of decades past. In 2002, the Queens were a twenty-first century rock-and-roll gang, and their third album represents everything ecstatic about such an ethos. Songs For The Deaf encapsulates the sound of a tight-knit assembly of musicians in perfect telepathy, producing the kind of crunching, muscular rock-and-roll which is so compulsively listenable that it begs for (and rewards) repetitious consumption. Grohl and Homme trade their career-honed talents like veterans of the game, Oliveri€™s unpredictable volatility adds both excitement and tension and Lanegan€™s gravelly persona is a perfect narrator for the long, ominous drives through €˜A Song for the Dead€™ and €˜God is in the Radio€™. Another of the album€™s primary signatures is its deployment of fake radio excerpts which stitch the album€™s disparate components together in a surprisingly deft fashion. Between numerous songs, listeners are treated to parodic snippets of radio chatter, from K-L-O-N (Los Angeles) to Dave Catching on W-A-N-T, and the result is an experience made to mimic a hefty drive across southern California. These skits (which feature a number of DJs and various associates of the band) have been described by Oliveri as jibes aimed at commercial radio stations, and consequently, arguments have been made that Songs For The Deaf is a satire album. How far one chooses to define it as such a thing is subjective, but it€™s fair play to posit that QotSA have their cake and eat it in this regard: the songs are not only cutting indictments of commercial radio, but also are staggeringly great rock songs in their own right. There€™s not a single cut on here which could authentically be described as €œweak€, even though there are one or two which dip slightly from the towering heights scaled elsewhere. But this is barely a quibble, and besides, on an album which succeeds so well at maintaining a sense of breathless fun, there€™s not a hair out of place. Songs For The Deaf is an incredibly entertaining album; one bursting with personality and varied without being too scattershot. And you don€™t get many albums which promise all this - and more - to the pound. Highlight: €˜God is in the Radio€™ €˜God is in the Radio€™ might not be as bruising as some of its peers, but although its roar never fully bursts forth, the way it prowls and struts is as hypnotically sexy as anything else QotSA have ever laid down. Mark Lanegan leads from the front over a stomping, crunching riff, culminating in that visceral refrain (€œyou come back another day / and do no wrong€), and topped with not one, but two of Homme€™s most staggering guitar solos to date.

2. ... Like Clockwork (2013)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DhaIb30mJiQ&list=PLozlBbCIaUbFnIzPZAJvq2Z55rqYk3QsK € Like Clockwork has its detractors in numerous critics, and even a smattering of loyal Queens fans. It€™s understandable as to why it€™s considered disappointing in certain contexts; it doesn€™t engage with the same balls-out viscera of their other career highlights. The fire of their early-noughties work is diminished, the exuberant energy reined in, and there€™s less of a crazed glint in Homme€™s songwriter eye. But none of this really matters, because in spite of these shifts in dynamic, € Like Clockwork is QotSA€™s richest album to date, and their most rewarding to allow to flourish with repetition. It has the meatiest backstory and most integral creative history, it is the band€™s leanest and most concise album to date, and the emotional beats are layered so tightly that it€™s positively revelatory. The biggest clue arises in the fact that, in spite of the impressive roster of guest contributors, € Like Clockwork is decidedly Homme€™s record: a confessional, forthcoming, and musically taut sequence of songs which gel together fluidly. Above all, there is a clarity to € Like Clockwork, which allows for the richest overall listening experience of the band€™s catalogue. What Homme and his bandmates attempted with this album is brave, uncompromising, and powerfully candid. Particularly in the closing two songs, Homme sounds like a man transformed by his recent experiences: a brush with a near-death experience, and a debilitating bout of depression and creative block. Perhaps as a direct result, his singing here is more earnest, his cadences more tortured, less cocksure, and the manner with which he does away with his sardonic shield and goes for broke is beguiling. Perhaps this alleged maturity is more apparent because it is borne from the back of Era Vulgaris, whose brash clutter sounds fun, but is ultimately devoid of direction. On € Like Clockwork, Homme has more to say, more on his mind, and he articulates himself (and his musical mettle) with a revelatory profundity. And that is why € Like Clockwork deserves to be commemorated. Highlight: €˜I Appear Missing€™ Atop the plaudits already bequeathed to its parent album, there is further room to call €˜I Appear Missing€™ one of Queens€™ greatest ever recordings. To begin with, its major draw resides in its absolutely walloping groove, but after repeat listens (and with the context of € Like Clockwork weighing heavily behind it), its emotional intensity boils to the surface. As one of the first songs Homme wrote while spiralling into hospital-confined depression, it€™s startlingly revealing in its lyricism and delivery. The full six-minute version builds and builds to a climax of searing, awfully moving squalls, and Homme€™s voice takes on a cracked, utterly broken edge. The more one listens, the more his wails of €œI never loved anything until I loved you,€ circle heavily in the mind, attaining an indelible level of anguish never before offered by QotSA€™s music.

1. Rated R (2000)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9gH0-3c1RCw €œRestricted to everyone, everywhere, all the time.€ So goes the little rating label in the corner of Queens of the Stone Age€™s sophomore LP. It€™s a tongue-in-cheek nod to Rated R€™s unadulterated brand of hedonism, and its inherent thematic content of sex, drugs, and just about everything else conceivable that is associated with both of those topics. With this in mind, one would think caution is rightly warranted, but on musical grounds, this is one of the most essential listens of the decade. Where QotSA€™s debut is relatively stable and focused in style, Rated R is fuelled by a mischievous urgency. The instantaneous hooks which had already been showcased were paired with an increased characteristic of playfulness, and a much more wholehearted penchant for trippy structures and elaborate instrumentation. From the off, Rated R is presented in an unapologetic burst of frenzied character; with €˜Feel Good Hit of the Summer€™ laying the groundwork for an album which comes across like a lazy grin, a sly wink, and affirmation that you€™re in good (if unhinged) hands on this musical adventure. Given its spring-loaded, topsy-turvy sequencing, Rated R is constantly surprising in how well its individual parts flow together. One explanation is that not only do QotSA embrace their own flamboyant tendencies (the opening three minutes alone should convince listeners as such), but they follow through and invest every available second with vivid colour. €˜The Lost Art of Keeping a Secret€™ amalgamates lackadaisical grunge-rock with a sharply melodic sensibility, chased by the sedate pairing of €˜Leg of Lamb€™ and €˜Auto Pilot€™. Within the album€™s first ten minutes, the effect is already intoxicating: with QotSA running at full tilt, the variation comes across as logical rather than alienating, and the group fully initiate listeners into their sonic dream-space with the heady heights of €˜Better Living Through Chemistry€™: a twisted, mind-boggling jam of epic proportions. When the hangover begins to creep in, we€™re presented with the legitimately profound €˜In the Fade€™, on which Mark Lanegan makes his first (and possibly finest) appearance among QotSA€™s ranks. €˜Tension Head€™ comes slamming in like a screaming hangover (€œI€™m feeling so sick,€ Oliveri repeatedly howls), before a brief moment of peace is granted in the sublime acoustic waves of €˜Lightning Song€™. It€™s left to €˜I Think I Lost My Headache€™ to tee things up with a bizarre, brilliant combo of robot-rock and parping free jazz. Just recounting all these individual moments of gold is enough to make one hungry to hear Rated R all over again. Its attention to detail is of such a high calibre (without ever sounding fussy) that it hits home on both micro and macro levels. Here we are granted a glimpse of Queens of the Stone Age at their most charmingly madcap, and Rated R is their open invitation to join them for the ride. Take it. Highlight: €˜Feel Good Hit of the Summer€™ There are more accomplished, affecting, and impressive songs to be found on QotSA€™s sophomore LP, but in terms of what best captures the album€™s appeal in excelsis, there€™s just no other choice. €˜Feel Good Hit€€™ takes every strand of its parent album€™s DNA - hedonism, ridiculousness, squalling heaviness, and mind-numbingly catchy mantras - and crushes it all into two minutes and forty-three seconds of pure carnal mayhem. With no disrespect to the band€™s eponymous album, €˜Feel Good Hit€€™ is QotSA€™s proper real statement to the world, marking the moment when Queens of the Stone Age transcended from bearers of solid riff-rock, and instead became their own institution: a flagship rock troupe for the twenty-first century, packing oodles of charisma and bags of wild, sonically entrancing ideas. Which is your favourite and why? Get stuck into the comments and let us know!

Contributor
Contributor

Film and Literature student, keen bloggist, and aficionado of most things music, film, and TV. I've also been told I should stop quoting pop-culture as often as I do in everyday conversations.