Ranking Every Opeth Studio Album From Worst To Best

Our ranking, your response, with plenty of fair judgements along the way.

Opeth band
CC BY-SA 4.0

Ever since the release of their debut LP, 1995's Orchid, Swedish quintet Opeth have reigned as arguably the best at what they do.

Be it their first few melodic death/black metal collections; their mid-period progressive/folk metal gems; or their more recent treks into 1970s prog rock/jazz fusion bizarreness and grandeur, mastermind Mikael Åkerfeldt and company consistently excel at blending characteristically remarkable songwriting with equally distinguished and malleable instrumentation.

Along the way, they continuously infused a huge array of influences – from metal icons like Celtic Frost, Morbid Angel, and Iron Maiden to lighter fare like Jethro Tull, Camel, Nick Drake, and Joni Mitchell – into their irresistible concoctions. Beyond keeping their music adventurous and intriguing, this risky proclivity for boundless diversity blew the doors wide open for how multifaceted metal could be in a general sense.

Of course, such a polygonal and significant career results in a catalog that’s immensely difficult to judge. Nevertheless, the following tally – which considers overt quality, personal preference, and originality/evolution in equal measure – offers our strongest attempt. Ranging from very good to flat-out masterpieces, these are Opeth's 13 studio albums ranked worst to best.

13. Orchid (1995)

The goal of any artist is to perpetually equal, if not outdo, their prior work, so saying that Opeth’s first album is also their worst is more of a compliment to the group than a knock against the LP.

After all, the band improved in every way afterward, but that doesn’t mean that Orchid is rendered unlistenable or irrelevant in hindsight. On the contrary, its innovative and poised venture into the worlds of black, thrash, and death metal – with sprinkles of folk, jazz, and classical throughout – remains quite praiseworthy and pleasing.

For one thing, songs like Under the Weeping Moon and Forest of October successfully incorporate the DNA of stylistic kings like Metallica, Mercyful Fate, and Slayer in Opeth’s distinctly intricate structures. Elsewhere, opener In Mist She Was Standing and Requiem throw in some now-trademark acoustic guitar arpeggios and jazzily warm respites, while Silhouette is an atypical piano instrumental full of classical importance and dexterity.

Most importantly, the album sees Åkerfeldt already displaying extraordinary range as both a hellish screamer and heavenly singer. Thus, Orchid lingers as a prophetic and enjoyable starting point that can’t help but be immediately outshone.


12. Morningrise (1996)

Morningrise arrived just a year after Orchid, with the same crew – vocalist/guitarist Åkerfeldt, guitarist Peter Lindgren, bassist Johan De Farfalla, drummer Anders Nordin, and producer Dan Swanö – reteaming at the same studio (Sweden’s Unisound).

It would be the last time that the latter three would appear on an Opeth record, which is bittersweet since Morningrise doubled down on the potential set forth by its predecessor. More melodic, confident, daring, and varied than Orchid, their sophomore sequence showed growth in multiple areas.

Sure, the preliminary three tunes (Advent, The Night and the Silent Water, and Nectar) don’t shake things up drastically; yet, they’re noticeably more refined and ambitious, especially in terms of their rhythmic complexities and eccentricities.

That said, it’s the last two tunes that truly elevate Morningrise above Orchid. Specifically, Black Rose Immortal reigns as a sundry suite that, at twenty minutes in length, remains Opeth’s only side-long epic. It’s succeeded by closer To Bid You Farewell, the band’s debut acoustic ballad and one of the greatest bits of songwriting in their catalog.

Although it, too, was bested by its follow-up (which included a new line-up), Morningrise surely saw Opeth take some major steps forward.


11. Heritage (2011)

The initial entry into Opeth’s post-2010 exploration of vintage jazz fusion, folk rock, and prog rock richness, Heritage found the quintet completely and controversially abandon their trademark death metal singing and musical ferocity.

It’s also their last album with keyboardist Per Wiberg – whose head can be seen symbolically falling from the tree on the cover – and the first in a spiritual trilogy that also includes Steven Wilson’s Grace for Drowning and Storm Corrosion’s self-titled debut. Thus, this 10th studio album is consequential for a number of reasons.

Despite being highly likable and commendable overall, though, Heritage is easily the weakest of their recent run. It’s possibly their biggest case of style over substance, too, since several songs – I Feel the Dark, Slither, Nepenthe, and The Lines in My Hand – are either too simplistic or too meanderingly impressionistic to sufficiently entice.

That’s not to say that they’re bad tracks, but rather that they don’t do enough with their potential, so they come across more like demos and scraps of ideas than fully developed compositions. Luckily, a few other pieces – The Devil’s Orchard, Famine, and Folklore – are true gems, and Opeth would rebound brilliantly with their next "observation" (as Åkerfeldt puts it).


10. My Arms, Your Hearse (1998)

My Arms, Your Hearse is where Opeth truly started tapping into greatness. A narrative work revolving around a ghost who begrudgingly watches his lover carry on without him, it saw the band move from Swanö’s Unisound studio to Fredrik Nordström’s Studio Fredman.

More importantly, it marked the start of their classic line-up via the swapping of De Farfalla and Nordin for Martin Méndez and Martin López, respectively. (Of course, Méndez doesn’t play on the LP since he didn’t have time to learn his parts. Instead, Åkerfeldt also plays bass, so this is technically the only time Opeth recorded as a trio.)

Naturally, the collection continues where Morningrise left off, but every aspect – the musicianship, the songwriting, the vocals, and the fluidity between tracks and movements – is exponentially enhanced. In fact, selections like When, The Amen Corner, Credence, and Karma still contain some of Opeth’s sturdiest melodies and/or instrumental passages.

Undoubtedly, My Arms, Your Hearse was a huge advancement, and it’s commonly regarded as one of the top progressive metal concept albums of all time. Really, its only flaw is its retrospective role as a steppingstone to Opeth’s vastly superior fourth outing.


9. Sorceress (2016)

Sandwiched in-between the best and second-best entries in Opeth’s latest phase, Sorceress is a much better journey than Heritage in terms substantive configurations and overarching cohesion. However, it’s even less significant since it’s the most by-the-numbers chapter of the stylistic tetralogy.

It certainly outdoes Heritage when it comes to its instrumental bookends, as the guitar-driven Persephone and the piano-driven Persephone (Slight Return) are lovelier pieces than Heritage and Marrow of the Earth, respectively. As their titles suggest, they connect melodically to give the whole thing a wider scope as well.

Expectedly, there are a handful of other obvious standouts, such as the luscious acoustic ode Will O the Wisp (which is directly inspired by Dun Ringill by Jethro Tull); the madcap hecticness of Chrysalis; the spitefully cultured and symphonic The Seventh Sojourn; and the elegantly emotional A Fleeting Glance.

Even so, those songs are pleasing as they play but lack the lasting impact of Opeth’s previous triumphs. Couple that with some moderately generic 1970s heavy metal throwbacks – The Wilde Flowers and the title track – and Sorceress is at least a tad unremarkable.


8. In Cauda Venenum (2019)

It’s the band’s newest venture and their first to be recorded and released in both English and Swedish. Whereas Heritage was a bit too abstract and noncommittal, and Sorceress was a bit too familiar and forgettable, In Cauda Venenum (Latin for Poison in the Tail) is wonderfully wicked and gratifying from start to finish.

The ambiently gothic prelude, Garden of Earthly Delights, sets the stage well with its foreboding choir, wavering synths, and spooky voices. Then, Dignity erupts into a multifaceted behemoth peppered with diabolic harmonies, regal chaos, and bittersweet interludes. It’s as magnificent as it is malevolent.

Although subsequent tunes like Heart in Hand, Next of Kin, and Continuum fit into similar categories, the album has more tricks up its sleeve. For one thing, Lovelorn Crime and Universal Truth are gorgeously repentant experiences with plenty of scrumptious nuances. In contrast, the intensely playful The Garroter and Charlatan incorporate modern darkness with quirky vintage jazz fusion detours.

If not for an earlier post-death metal magnum opus – which we’ll get to soon enough – In Cauda Venenum would undoubtedly be Opeth’s finest hour in over a decade. It’s surely their most engrossingly macabre.


7. Watershed (2008)

The quintet’s ninth studio collection signifies the debuts of guitarist Fredrik Åkesson and drummer Martin Axenrot (who replaced Lindgren and López, respectively, due to the former’s growing disinterest and the latter’s growing mental health concerns).

Although it continues in the same vein as 2005’s Ghost Reveries – with Jens Bogren once again co-producing alongside Åkerfeldt – its lack of focus and proper pacing makes it the first Opeth release since Morningrise to come off as merely a set of songs instead of as a larger-than-life statement.

Nevertheless, it’s a superb ride, with a charming acoustic duet, Coil, opening the disc. It still stands as the only instance of Åkerfeldt sharing lead vocal duties (thanks to the sublime voice of Axenrot’s then-girlfriend, Nathalie Lorichs). Later, the similarly remorseful Burden and Porcelain Heart expertly juxtapose fury and fragility.

Elsewhere, the devilish The Lotus Eater offers a tremendously cool jazz fusion break halfway in, while Heir Apparent soars with peculiar changeups. Admittedly, the final duo – Hessian Peel and Hex Omega – aren’t quite as fetching, yet they still impress enough to cement Watershed as an excellent effort.


6. Deliverance (2002)

The follow-up to Blackwater Park, Deliverance was intended to be a double album that fully captured the band’s hellish and heavenly sides. Unfortunately, label Music for Nations felt that that was risky, so Åkerfeldt split it up into two sequential records: Deliverance and Damnation.

Unsurprisingly, Deliverance houses some of Opeth’s most unapologetically brutal music, such as its bookends: Wreath and By the Pain I See in Others. Despite being torrents of destruction, each one packs enough intricate variety to be addicting.

To be fair, though, it’s the pieces in-between that truly make Deliverance a masterclass in the genre. Specifically, the title track faultlessly weaves between gripping savagery and soothing melodies before concluding with the most mesmerizing syncopation in Opeth’s catalog.

From there, A Fair Judgment feels like an evolved take on Morningrise’s To Bid You Farewell (thanks in part to the contributions of Porcupine Tree mastermind Steven Wilson, who returned as producer).

Likewise, acoustic interlude For Absent Friends builds upon Orchid’s Requiem (while paying homage to Genesis in its title) prior to the penultimate Master’s Apprentices offsetting its intimidating rage with angelic harmonies.

All of that – and more – turns Deliverance is a tour de force of alternating techniques and temperaments.


5. Damnation (2003)

Whereas Deliverance (which was issued several months earlier) contained glimpses of peacefulness amidst its perpetual anger, the simultaneously recorded Damnation saw Opeth totally forgo their heaviness. Obviously, it was a controversial move, yet Åkerfeldt knew that the uncharacteristically brief and benign sequence would be worth the risk.

Of course, that’s putting it lightly, as its eight concise tunes are overwhelmingly affective, serene, and meticulously penned and performed. Producer Steven Wilson takes a more active role, too, particularly in terms of his backing vocals and keyboard coatings.

The material is so awe-inspiring that it’s difficult to choose any favorites. But, if push comes to shove, the breathtaking guitarwork, keyboards, and verses of Windowpane are a clear highlight. The divine bellows of Death Whispered a Lullaby; the askew rhythms of Closure; and the unfiltered sorrow of Hope Leaves and To Rid the Disease place them on the same level.

Even the finale, Ending Credits, does a brilliant job of conjuring 1970s great Camel as it evokes the finality of My Arms, Your Hearse’s Credence. Afterward, Weakness acts as a chillingly abstract coda that further drives Damnation into your soul.

As exaggerated as it may sound to say, it’s nearly a perfect album


4. Blackwater Park (2001)

In virtually every way imaginable – sales, touring opportunities, critical response, public recognition, etc. – Blackwater Park was Opeth’s breakthrough album. With the help of a new overseer and a new label (Steven Wilson and Music for Nations, respectively), it also saw a significant refinement of songwriting, instrumentation, and exploratory production.

From the moment opener The Leper Affinity erupts into irresistibly sleek wrath, it’s clear that the quartet is operating with newfound precision, daringness, and flexibility. It seamlessly traverses between light and dark passages with ease, making it an instant classic.

Luckily, the same can be said about Bleak, The Drapery Falls, Dirge for November, and The Funeral Portrait (all of which display praiseworthy adventurousness). Meanwhile, Harvest and Patterns in the Ivy remain two of their best acoustic compositions, while the closing title track acts as a direct precursor to the depravity of Deliverance.

Clearly, Blackwater Park is rightly celebrated for its influence on the genre, and it arguably inspired the heavier direction of Wilson’s Porcupine Tree project post-Lightbulb Sun. Beyond that, it’s just as frequently and understandably – if also debatably – cited as not only Opeth’s masterpiece, but as the greatest progressive metal album of all time.


3. Still Life (1999)

Track by track, Blackwater Park may be the better accomplishment; however, there’s something truly special about the Shakespearean storyline, painstakingly sculpted arrangements, and catchily morose melodies that make Still Life the superior cumulative experience.

Its theologically critical plot centers on the intersection of ill-fated romance, religious persecution, and sacrificial revenge; as such, the group’s guitarwork, vocals, and lyricism ingeniously shift to reflect indignation and penitence. Plus, now that they finally get to play together, López and Méndez continuously innovate as a flawlessly aligned rhythmic duo.

There’s a tad less diversity here than on later recordings – or even on My Arms, Your Hearse – yet the predominant formula that most songs follow is so powerfully sophisticated and seductive that it’s hard to complain.

Indeed, The Moor, Godhead’s Lament, and especially White Cluster segue impeccably around their ferocious cores and tender asides. Along the way, Benighted excels as a noble ballad full of entrancing, Camel-esque tranquility; subsequently, Face of Melinda is a pristine instance of an unassuming cause leading to an explosive effect.

Perhaps more than any other Opeth record, Still Life is most rewarding when heard all at once; only then can its breathtaking gracefulness and gutturalness be wholly appreciated.


2. Pale Communion (2014)

This one will surely be the most controversial placement on this list, but it’s extremely deserved. After all, if Heritage found Opeth unevenly but admirably dipping their toes into the aforementioned retro templates, successor Pale Communion found them diving in headfirst and without a moment of miscalculation.

Eternal Rains Will Come alone is a knockout of lively atmosphere, riveting verses, and densely colorful musicianship (due mostly to the presence of Wiberg’s replacement, Joakim Svalberg). Cusp of Eternity is almost as absorbing, whereas the multipart Moon Above, Sun Below is fascinatingly sinister and solemn.

There’s also the dreamily regretful Elysian Woes, the punchily flamboyant Goblin (whose title and techniques pay tribute to Dario Argento’s favorite soundtrack maestro), and the radiantly folksy River. As the cherry on top, Voice of Treason foreshadows In Cauda Venenum with its mischievous orchestration; it then bleeds into Faith in Others, which is a clear contender for the quintet’s most devastatingly beautiful track.

Many Opeth devotees easily dismiss Opeth’s LPs after Watershed due to their abandonment of death metal attributes. That’s particularly tragic with the immaculate Pale Communion since it’s the only one of the four to rival, if not surpass, many of their earlier “classic” albums.


1. Ghost Reveries (2005)

As the embodiment of their past, present, and future, Ghost Reveries is ultimate Opeth album. It combines the viciousness of its forebearers with the vibrant complexities of its follow-ups and then decorates it all with mediaeval majesty. The fact that it’s the swan song for both Lindgren and López – and the introduction of Wiberg – only adds to its magnitude.

Ghost of Perdition kicks things off with arguably the most drastic dynamic swings of any Opeth tune. It ebbs and flows between robust demonism and reserved delicateness, all the while establishing the record’s inconsistent plot about man wrestling with guilt after committing matricide. Later, The Baying of the Hounds and The Grand Conjuration perform comparably malleable magic.

In-between, Beneath the Mire escalates with razor-sharp eccentricity prior to the lovingly golden mysticism of Atonement. Next, Reverie/Harlequin Forest is a mind-blowing cycle of disparate segments that paves the way for the symphonic and warmly calming Hours of Wealth. The narratively unrelated and relatively simple Isolation Years caps it all off with heartbreaking remembrances that stay with you long after they’re gone.

Opeth have gone through many phases over their twenty-five-year history, and every one of them is epitomized on the superlative Ghost Reveries.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Hey there! Outside of 'WhatCulture,' I'm a former editor at 'PopMatters' and a past or present contributor to 'Kerrang!,' 'Consequence,' 'PROG,' 'Metal Injection,' 'Loudwire,' and more. I've written books about Jethro Tull, Opeth, and Dream Theater, too, and I run a creative arts journal called 'The Bookends Review.' You can also find me talking about horror on YouTube (as Hairless Horror / @hairlesshorror)! Oh, and I live in Philadelphia and teach academic/creative writing courses at a few colleges/universities.