While a great show must have good writing, talented actors, impeccable lighting, innovative visuals and so much more, the key to the tone of a show is the music. Music can be used to raise the tension in a thrilling action sequence or build the emotion within a dramatic reveal; it can set the viewer's blood pounding or reduce them to tears. In sum, the best shows have the best and most powerful music, and Sherlock is no exception. Courtesy of composers David Arnold (Casino Royale, Quantum of Solace, and Independence Day) and Michael Price (The Lord of the Rings trilogy), we have been treated to many a brilliant and gorgeous score through Sherlock's past three series. Its theme tune has become almost as recognisable as its idiosyncratic visual style, and the soundtrack for Series 3 may be its best and most inventive yet, with its foray into electronic music, dubstep, and even a bit of Spanish flair. So, without further ado, here is a look at the show's all-time best music pieces, from Series 1-3. SPOILERS ahead, as I will be talking about key plot points of the show in connection to the music.
10. 'Sherlock' Theme Tune
All episodes It's only thirty-nine seconds, but what a fantastic thirty-nine seconds it is! The theme tune of a show defines its overall tone, and Arnold and Price succeed in striking that perfect balance between old and new that the rest of the show also excels at. The strings take us back to Victorian London where Conan Doyle's Holmes and Watson first solved crimes, while the percussion still keeps us in the modern day. The original theme tune, heard in the unaired pilot episode, had a much more modern style and instrumentation, matching the harder emphasis the pilot had on modernising the classic literary icon that is Sherlock Holmes. The now-official theme tune, though, and the show itself is a well-balanced combination of classic and modern Holmes, drawing in a new audience, yet never alienating fans of the Conan Doyle canon. The theme tune is remixed several times throughout the show, but the original remains the best version (although some may argue for the "Stag Night" remix in "The Sign of Three" more on that later). Without fail, though, a true fan can never get tired of hearing those opening drumbeats at the beginning of every episode, for within those thirty-nine seconds, you know you are at the start of something incredible.
9. The Game Is On
Series 1, "A Study in Pink" This composition could be called the second theme tune for the show, as it's repeated quite a bit, and no wonder - it's an absolutely brilliant piece of music. The first part - approximately the first minute in - is the music we've come to associate with Sherlock and John being on a case, creating an atmosphere of adventure. It's also become almost Sherlock's personal theme tune, as it's also the music that plays when he first introduces himself to John - "The name's Sherlock Holmes, and the address is 221B Baker Street" - and when he re-introduces himself, as it were, when he reveals himself to be alive in "The Empty Hearse." The second part is a bit gentler, but still full of movement, as we can almost hear the ticking of Sherlock's mind as his deductions of John fall into place. The last part is the most intense, with plucking strings adding urgency; it ends with sawing strings that epitomise impending danger, a perfect theme to up the tension in any scene, which is why it's used to even greater effect in "Which Bottle?" near the end of the episode. I'm assuming we can expect to hear "The Game Is On" for as long as the show runs, for, as Sherlock says in "His Last Vow," "The game is never over!" And aren't we glad of that!
8. Pink
Series 1, "A Study in Pink" "Pink" is the perfect reflection of John's emotional state as Sherlock whirls him into a world of crime and murder. The first part sounds ominous, as they enter the crime scene of the murdered woman, and then divulges into a slightly brighter, more rhythmic section as John witnesses Sherlock's brilliant deductions on full display for the third time (the first and second being when he deduces John in the lab when they first meet and during the cab ride to the crime scene). This theme is often used when John and Sherlock are on a case, particularly in "The Great Game" during the Connie Prince mystery; the increasing tempo and the resolute ending gives the satisfying feeling of "case closed." The major key then moves into minor when Sherlock abandons John at the scene; both the music and Martin Freeman's incredible acting give us the sorrowful image of a man who is tired of being left behind. "A Study in Pink" has much of the best music of Sherlock; as the show's first episode, it introduces many of the themes, such as "The Game Is On" and "Pink," that become a staple of the show's distinctive soundtrack. A bit like Sherlock when he first meets John, the show's composers and creative team are eager to show off to make us see just how incredible their work can be; the music for this episode alone is a testament to that.
7. Which Bottle?
Series 1, "A Study in Pink" The genius of this piece is that it combines sections of "The Game Is On" and "Pink" and increases the tension tenfold. Your heart rate can't help but go up when you hear those five sinister beats, duh-duh-duh-duh-DUH, over and over as Sherlock and the cabbie square off in a battle of wits. As ever, the music seems to mirror both Sherlock and John's emotional states: Sherlock's racing mind as he examines the poisoned pills, and John's racing heart as he watches Sherlock move to take one of them. Screeching violins bring the scene to its climax, broken only by a shot from John's gun. I'm sorry, but nothing can beat that for sheer thrill. This piece is like a shot of adrenaline the perfect soundtrack for a showdown with any of Sherlock's villains, whether it's the cabbie from "A Study in Pink" or Jim Moriarty himself. I suspect that's the reason it's used again in "The Great Game," for "Final Act," when Sherlock is poised to shoot the explosives Moriarty has lying at his feet. The scene itself is already dramatic enough; add this track on top of it, making the tension build and build, with a cut to black before Sherlock can shoot, and you have a perfect, nerve-wracking cliffhanger that kept us in horrible suspense until Series 2.
6. Irene's Theme
Series 2, "A Scandal in Belgravia" Forty-three seconds of pure magnificence. This is the first really romantic music in the show, which is fitting, considering Irene Adler is the first woman Sherlock has shown any interest in, romantic or otherwise. He composes this gorgeous violin solo after he discovers Irene's (apparent) death. Opposed to the havoc strong emotion wreaks on his intellect, Sherlock never puts his (rightfully complicated) feelings for her into words. However, the music perfectly captures the emotions he tries and fails to keep hidden away as they pour out in an elegy. What's interesting about the show and its soundtrack is the music's connection to Sherlock's emotional state. In Series 1, we see Sherlock at his most emotionally distant, particularly in "A Study in Pink" and "The Great Game" when he questions why a mother would be upset over her stillborn child and when he informs John he finds not caring about others very easy; consequently, the Series 1 soundtrack is more suspenseful or thrilling instead of emotional or romantic. But, when his intellect is nearly compromised by his emotions when he matches wits with Irene in Series 2, the soundtrack suddenly changes from suspenseful to searingly romantic. Considering how beautiful the soundtrack becomes whenever Sherlock's emotions come to the surface, I can only hope for Irene's return in Series 4!
5. SHERlocked
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yt6dFvb8kYw Series 2, "A Scandal in Belgravia" The soundtrack to one of the best, most brilliant, and most heartbreaking scenes in the entire show. The dialogue is perfect, the acting superb, the camerawork and editing amazing - add in an incredible soundtrack with the best dramatic reveal I have ever seen in television, and you have something truly remarkable. The genius of this scene cannot be discounted; it left me breathless the first time I watched it, and still gives me goosebumps every time I re-watch it now. The music is perfect, slowly building the tension with percussive beats that sound like a heartbeat; considering the sexual tension between Sherlock and Irene, and the overall tension in this scene, the beats feel as though they echo the pounding of both their hearts. As Sherlock prepares to defeat Irene once and for all, the gorgeous strings incorporate "Irene's Theme" into the climax of the scene, making the reveal all the more heartbreaking. Sherlock wins the intellectual battle; however, Irene wins the emotional war. In the end, Sherlock ultimately comes to her rescue, and we hear "Irene's Theme" once again as, perhaps for the first time, he allows sentiment to overpower logic in order to save her life. In sum, this is such a wonderful piece, with so much emotion behind it, perfectly fitting this episode with its exploration of Sherlock's heart.
4. Prepared To Do Anything
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uy_2B-diV18 Series 2, "The Reichenbach Fall" I don't think anyone was prepared for the last ten minutes of "The Reichenbach Fall." It's one of the most mind-blowing, what-the-heck-just-happened sequences in the show up to that point, rivaled only by the mind palace sequence in "His Last Vow" in the next series. I dare anyone to watch this part of "Reichenbach" without becoming emotionally involved, and the music that accompanies it just makes it that much more heartbreaking. The first time we hear "Prepared To Do Anything," Moriarty shoots himself, a mind-blowing act (literally) that sets off the chain of crazy events and make the last ten minutes of the episode feel surreal and almost nightmarish. The second time the track plays, we are dumbfounded as we listen to Sherlock and John's last conversation, wanting to ignore what the increasing tempo and dynamics mean. Then, when Sherlock jumps off St. Bart's rooftop, the music narrates his fall, the strings screeching higher as Sherlock drops towards the pavement, with a percussive impact when he hits the ground. Within the context of the show, it's an incredibly difficult piece to listen to, as it brilliantly captures the shock and heartbreak of watching Sherlock fall; without context, it's still an incredibly well done and suspenseful piece.
3. How It Was Done
Series 3, "The Empty Hearse" Series 3 was the series that surprised us all; the plot and overall tone of Sherlock went places it had never gone before, even making its audience question whether it had "jumped the shark," so to speak. The show's comedic turn took us all on a completely unexpected, yet very entertaining, ride; the music followed suit, ultimately making the Series 3 soundtrack the best one yet, starting with its fantastic first track, "How It Was Done." Perhaps it's lucky that Arnold composed for two James Bond films, as, during this first scene of "The Empty Hearse," we have an incredibly fun opening sequence where Sherlock turns into a bit of a James Bond figure. The energized and electronic- and rock-influenced track plays as Sherlock bungee-jumps from St. Bart's rooftop, crashes through a window, and - my favourite moment - kisses Molly (accompanied by an awesome guitar solo). Who cares if this isn't how it was actually done; I'm just grateful we were able to witness this scene on our screens, accompanied by the perfect soundtrack. It's almost a shame that Lestrade cuts Anderson off - I was more than happy to continue on with both the theory and the music!
2. Stag Night
Series 3, "The Sign of Three" In his introduction to "The Sign of Four," in a recent republication of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's works, Martin Freeman writes about his first thoughts on auditioning for a modern-day version of the Sherlock Holmes stories: "What would 'modern' mean, in TV terms? Deductions being rapped? Holmes and Watson bombing around London in a Lexus on their way to meet with Lestrade, a wheelchair-bound lesbian with a penchant for Class-As at lunchtime?" Unfortunately, we have no rapped deductions (yet), but we do have what is definitely a first for the Sherlock Holmes canon: a dubstep version of Sherlock Holmes' theme tune. The dubstep version is, by far, the theme tune's best remix, which is the first twenty seconds of "Stag Night"; like "How It Was Done," it's pure, unadulterated fun, one of those songs you can discretely (or perhaps not so discretely) rock out to. It then transitions into the tune that accompanies Sherlock and John on their drunken excursion to investigate the flat of the Mayfly Man, where the music is as distorted as their blurred vision and alcohol-addled minds. I don't know what Arnold and Price will have in store for us in Series 4, but "Stag Night" will be hard to beat for pure entertainment!
1. Addicted To A Certain Lifestyle
Series 3, "His Last Vow" After the ridiculous fun and hijinks of "The Empty Hearse" and "The Sign of Three," when "His Last Vow" first aired, it hit its audience hard. It was dark and gritty, completely throwing us off from the lighter tone we were still coming to terms with for Series 3. While the first and second episodes had had their dramatic moments, even the moment that should have been the most dramatic of all - Sherlock revealing to John that he is still alive - was lightened by a comedic sequence of John punching Sherlock in the face. "His Last Vow" took all the emotion and heartbreak we had been missing from the rest of the series and packed it into one episode, most poignantly in one particular scene when John first confronts Mary about hiding her true identity. This stunning piece perfectly captures John's conflicting emotions as he struggles to contain his grief and rage over Mary's deception and, to him, betrayal. John has now been deceived by the two people he loves most - Sherlock, about his death, and Mary, about her identity. Your heart can't help but break for John as the orchestra swells into beautiful, haunting strains that softly move into a minor-key rendition of John and Mary's wedding waltz, an ending designed to move the heart, which it does terribly well. And there you have it - your "Best of Sherlock" playlist. Of course, there are other phenomenal tracks I wasn't able to mention, like "Elegy" from "The Blind Banker," "The Lab" from "The Hounds of Baskerville," and "The Lie in Leinster Gardens" from "His Last Vow." What are your favorite music pieces from Sherlock? Let me know in the comments!
She is a student at the Ohio State University with a major in English and a minor in Film Studies. She loves watching 'Sherlock' and 'Doctor Who' and is an aspiring author currently working on her first novel about the Paris catacombs. Follow her on Twitter @sherlocked1058 or email her via coane.1@osu.edu.
View more of her musings on Sherlock and Doctor Who at 221bbc.blogspot.com.