The Beatles: 13 Tracks To Forget
Even The Beatles missed a few...
There's no doubt that anyone with great taste in music loves The Beatles but nobody's perfect. Not even the Fab Four.
The Beatles' songs have left their mark on generation after generation of fans, but even they were capable of writing songs we'd rather they didn't.
Take the album for A Hard Day's Night, for example. It's a great record overall, but a song like When I Get Home just had no place on it whatsoever. Similarly, the Yellow Submarine soundtrack didn't need a lengthy mish-mosh like It's All Too Much.
Naturally, this isn't to say that The Beatles were terrible. Rather, like any band, they were only human. Not everything they touched would turn to gold and even they knew that.
The quartet of John, Paul, George, and Ringo went their separate ways in 1970 and had plenty to be proud of during the band's run. Still, if given the opportunity to go back and do it all again, perhaps it'd be better if certain songs were tossed in the bin.
13. Ask Me Why
"Ask me why, I'll say I love you, and I'm always thinking of you," crooned John Lennon at one point when recording the Beatles' Please Please Me album in 1963. This recording process is well-known in the band's history, taking place entirely on 11 February in a session that lasted over 12 hours.
Based on Lennon's vocals, it shows. The founder of The Beatles' voice is audibly cracking in the background. Though he allegedly had a bad cold that day, Lennon had a knack for singing through his throat rather than his diaphragm and thus thrashed his voice regularly.
Rickety vocals aside, however, Ask Me Why is sappy for The Beatles even by early 1960s standards. The entire song sounds like something Marvin Berry & The Starlighters would have sung in Back To The Future, or maybe a song that middle-aged couples would have danced to at the country club one night.
Yes, it's an album cut that shouldn't be held to the same standard as a single, but Ask Me Why is a sign that The Beatles were capable of so much more even early in their career.
12. All I've Got To Do
Here we have another instance of The Beatles doing a song that had potential, but just couldn't get the job done. All I've Got To Do was the second track off of the With The Beatles album, slowing things down after the fast and raucous It Won't Be Long. Let's just say thank the rock gods for the rest of the record, otherwise fans may have fallen asleep after this track.
Now, Lennon was influenced heavily by Smokey Robinson & The Miracles' soulful style, and it's clear he was indeed trying to channel that feeling in this song. The problem is that unlike Robinson, Lennon simply cannot channel that bluesy, jazzy feeling naturally. He may have been able to in other tracks, but All I've Got To Do is not one of them.
Needless to say, With The Beatles easily would have been just as strong an LP without this song.
11. When I Get Home
Ugh. There is nothing more than I would love to never have to listen to this song for the rest of my life. The second half of the A Hard Day's Night album features excellent tracks like Things We Said Today and You Can't Do That, but the lads royally dropped the ball with this song.
From the clunky harmonies that open the song's refrain to lyrics like "I'm gonna love her till the cows come home," this song is the worst kind of mess. It's glaringly obvious that this was just a filler track needed to help complete the 14-song quota.
The shifting from major to minor keys is a technique that can work under the right circumstances, but this wasn't one of those times. The sooner we forget about this song, the better.
10. Every Little Thing
Beatles For Sale was the first time the band really started to break out of its comfort zone. The record features great efforts like Eight Days A Week and I'm A Loser, but Every Little Thing cannot be placed into the same category.
What we have here is another sappy love song by Lennon that doesn't really seem to have a direction. Even the use of timpani in the chorus is overshadowed by the fact that the song is just, well, boring.
It's not even clear who or what Lennon is trying to channel in this song. When push comes to shove, it's just a number that doesn't work. Nothing more, nothing less.
9. You Like Me Too Much
There is no doubt that George Harrison may have been the most talented and also most under-appreciated member of The Beatles. His songs featured eclectic sounds and lyrics that made people think.
You Like Me Too Much, unfortunately, is one of Harrison's songs that falls flat. It is featured among the second half of an album that is very much hit or miss, in this case being the latter.
This song in particular is just a bit too Buddy Holly in that for an album released in 1965, it just sounds so dated. It's the kind of tune one would expect played at a sock hop circa 1958 and not in a year when the world's youth culture was really starting to change.
Sorry, George, but you went too white bread here.
8. What Goes On
Oh, Ringo. Poor, poor Ringo. It's great that he looked to get more involved on Rubber Soul by actually helping compose this tune, but it's just so goofy and off to the point where you kind of wonder why it was allowed on the record in the first place.
Rubber Soul, mind you, was an album where the band branched even further out of its comfort zone. Harrison broke out the sitar for Norwegian Wood (This Bird Has Flown) and McCartney the fuzz bass for Think For Yourself. These were songs that may have contained the same subject matter fans had grown to accept from The Beatles, but What Goes On was just a step back to what can only be described as the height of Beatlemania in 1964.
It's much like You Like Me Too Much in that it has a bit too much of a dated rockabilly sound to it, and the lyrics aren't strong enough to back up that retro feel. Even worse is that the guitar work is a bit choppy. Rubber Soul is a great album that should be heard from start to finish, but there wouldn't be anything wrong with skipping this track.
7. For No One
Revolver was the album that showed The Beatles were all grown up and far from another rock and pop group, but For No One is so out of place. Paul McCartney's slow-paced tune is just so dark and depressing and feels it would be better suited in an opera instead of on a rock and roll album.
The piano's tempo, muted percussion, and sad lyrics legitimately make this song sound like a funeral march. The use of the french horn is just odd as opposed to unique. It's a very tired-sounding song, fitting since 1966 was the same year that the lads performed their last live concert.
Even worse is that as the most musically talented of the group, McCartney surely knew he was better than this. No offence to him, but this song won't be missed at all.
6. Within You Without You
Here we have another case where Harrison just dropped the ball. While Within You Without You is a great track when considering that it was the result of Harrison diving head first into mastering the sitar, it just doesn't fit with the rest of Sgt. Pepper's concept.
Where the rest of the album has a running theme of classical and jazz incorporation, Within You Without You is just out of place. Its trippy sound and deep and philosophical lyrics just don't mesh with tracks like Fixing A Hole or even Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds.
Rather than this track, the band should have gone with the original choice Harrison made for his contribution, Only A Northern Song. That would later be featured on the Yellow Submarine soundtrack, but would have been just as well-suited for the band's most iconic record.
5. Your Mother Should Know
Sgt. Pepper and Magical Mystery Tour were signs that The Beatles were more interested in experimenting in the recording studio as opposed to on tour. The songs on the latter reflect that.
That is, except for Your Mother Should Know. This McCartney effort is, admittedly, very catchy. He even performed it live on one of his more recent world tours.
The problem is that when put up against tunes like I Am The Walrus and The Fool On The Hill, its weaknesses are exposed. It's just too simple in its piano-based structure and the repetitive lyrics make the song seem pointless.
It's just another case where McCartney had a song with great potential, but fell short. Then again, with the band's experimental tendencies in 1967, perhaps he was going for just that.
4. Revolution 9
Oof. I'm so sorry, ladies and gentlemen. I'm so, so sorry. I really didn't want to include Revolution 9 but compared to everything else on both discs of the White Album, there was no other choice.
The argument can be made that this isn't even a traditional Beatles song, if we can even call it that. It's just over eight minutes of wacky sounds, Lennon repeating himself and who knows what else. This was him fully embracing the avant garde movement introduced to him by Yoko Ono, who would go on to become his second wife. Just why it was included on a Beatles record is a mystery.
If you have the patience to sit through the entire track, more power to you. The fact remains that this should not have been released under the band's name.
3. It's All Too Much
Sorry, George, but you whiffed on this one too.
Harrison wrote this song and based it off of his experiences with LSD. Boy, does it show. The entire song is a loud, cacophonous mish-mosh and coming in at over six minutes long, it really is all too much.
The lyrics seem pointless and without direction. If Harrison was indeed trying to capture a bad acid trip in writing it, he succeeded. It is easily the weakest song featured on the film's soundtrack. The live-action Beatles made a a point of saying "Catchy tune, man," as the film ended, but perhaps they were just being nice. Maybe they were just following directions from someone off-camera.
Either way, the film would have been just as good without It's All Too Much, the perfect example of how less can often be more.
2. I Want You (She's So Heavy)
This could be one of the most polarizing songs in the Beatles' entire catalogue. There are people who love it and those who do not. I fall into the latter category.
I Want You (She's So Heavy) is so long and repetitive, not to mention pretentious, in its sole blues riff and dull lyrics. There is nothing overly unique about the tune, save for maybe the inclusion of an organ on top of the guitar, bass, and drums.
The point is that if a song is going to be over seven minutes long, it had better bring something strong to the table. Hey Jude at least has heartwarming and captivating lyrics and some key changes before its long refrain.
I Want You (She's So Heavy), on the other hand, might as well be a glorified jam session. With lyrics that repeat themselves again and again and again, it's probably the lone blemish on a fine Abbey Road album.
1. Dig A Pony
Putting Dig A Pony on here is somewhat painful because musically, it's actually quite good. The melodies are above average and catchy, unusual given the dark and dreary vibe of Let It Be as an album.
The sad truth is that strong melodies aren't very meaningful without strong lyrics to back them up. Such is the case with Dig A Pony.
The entire song features nonsensical lyrics that make absolutely zero sense. The imagery is strange and if there's a metaphor in there somewhere, it has yet to be found. It's almost as though Lennon was trying to channel Bob Dylan with quirky lyrics that just worked without making sense. In this case, that effort fell flat.
Even Lennon himself wasn't a fan of the song. Speaking to David Sheff of Playboy in 1980, in what would be one of his final interviews, he called the song "garbage."
Thus, solid melodies aside, Dig A Pony comes off more as a bland attempt at blues and can be skipped if so desired.