The Smiths: Every Album Ranked Worst To Best
Running down the works of Marr, Morrissey, et al.
Only a handful of bands can claim to have had as much impact in such a short window of time as The Smiths.
Formed in 1982 in Manchester, the group released their first record in 1984, followed it up with a further three studio albums and a B sides collection, and called it a day in 1987.
In that half decade spell they helped pioneer a pristine, jangling guitar sound courtesy of Johnny Marr, and helped kickstart a revival of earthy, incisive (but incredibly witty) lyricism via the instantly iconic (if personally problematic) writing of Morrissey.
The Smiths wore their everyday Englishness on their sleeve in a time when most UK pop stars were still trying to be one of extraterrestrial figures, flashily monied, or just American. Their influence can be felt in the majority of mainstream ‘90s British rock, and way beyond, affecting bands across the pond as well.
With such a concentrated period of creativity, The Smiths didn’t last long enough to go downhill, so most of their music is at least pretty good, but (to paraphrase a lyric) some albums are better than others - here’s how they stack up.
5. The Smiths
The band’s first album is by no means a bad record - in fact, it’s very good indeed, one of the most assured debuts of the decade. So while this may seem like a lowly placing, we’re judging on a curve here, and compared to some of the rest of the catalogue, it drops points for a slightly stodgy pacing as well as the lack of variety found on the rest of the group’s releases.
Unusual for a debut particularly, The Smiths stacks most of its best tracks on the second side. After a bit of a languorous period, the album reaches its arguable peak three quarters of the way through - “What Difference Does It Make” is a much needed bolt of energy with one of Marr’s finest riffs and a charismatic performance from Morrissey.
Opener “Reel Around The Fountain”, while a great song, is a bit of a ponderous start to the record, and the succession of mid tempo tracks that follow makes The Smiths less immediate than the rest of the band’s work.
Loads of great songs here - “Hand In Glove” is another bonafide classic - but the band’s willingness to mix styles and genre later on means this album, while admirably cohesive, is the least engaging of the bunch.
4. Strangeways Here We Come
For a band often labelled miserbalists, most of The Smiths’ most beloved music is at least melodically upbeat even if Morrissey’s lyrics tend towards the pessimistic. The exception to this is their final release: appropriately enough, since it’s named after a prison, the sound here is far more claustrophobic and despairing even as the instrumentation gets more adventurous.
Opener "A Rush and a Push and the Land Is Ours" is one of Morrissey’s lyrically most interesting tracks, and the jaunty, offbeat track brims with energy. Things get more depressing on "I Started Something I Couldn't Finish", which brims with self loathing, and centrepiece "Last Night I Dreamt That Somebody Loved Me" has an intro which is overwhelmingly gloomy, quite unlike anything else in their canon.
It’s perhaps their most musically challenging record, and while you can’t quite hear the band breaking apart (they’d split before its release), the playing certainly sounds less lively than before, less energy of a band in their pomp playing altogether.
Its most lauded track, “Girlfriend In A Coma”, is memorable but perhaps a little too twee for this set of tracks - a fittingly melodramatic ending to a great band.
3. The Queen Is Dead
The Smiths’ most famous record often tops lists of the all time great British albums, but your overall enjoyment of it as a piece may depend on your tolerance for Morrissey’s twee instincts.
The likes of “Vicar In A Tutu” and “Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others” stray into music hall and outright comedy; the latter is musically impressive but makes for a bizarre album closer.
Elsewhere, though, The Queen Is Dead sees The Smiths at their most immaculate and ambitious, a widescreen sound with unforgettable imagery. The anarchic title track is one of their finest ever, a punky and angry song with the kind of rabble rousing performance Morrissey’s capable of at his best.
“I Know It’s Over” is one of the top ballads in their canon, a lengthy, sincere number whose sparseness stands out all the more on this busy album. “Bigmouth Strikes Again” kicks off side two with a bang, one of Marr’s standout tracks with a goofy but effective chorus.
And then there’s "There Is a Light That Never Goes Out", an all time classic with some of the band’s best poetry, the stuff of many a tattoo, MSN username, and funeral playlist. A timeless track.
2. Hatful Of Hollow
Ordinarily a compilation record comprising session tracks and a few singles and B sides wouldn’t be worthy of a place on a list such as this, but most odds and ends collections aren’t Hatful Of Hollow.
The 1984 release offers a mix of old and new; the latter includes some of the band’s greatest songs, and the live takes of pre-released tracks are in many cases the definitive version.
The session tracks, many recorded with John Peel, absolutely crackle with energy. They’re recorded perfectly and make the likes of “What Difference Does It Make?” and “This Charming Man” sound better than ever. Marr’s live playing particularly is superb here, so precise, such a fantastic sound.
The singles, meanwhile, along with their relevant B-sides, rank highly among any list of Smiths songs. “How Soon Is Now?” is arguably the band’s signature release; “William, It Was Really Nothing” sees Mozza at his playful, sexually ambigous best; and its B-side "Please Please Please Let Me Get What I Want" is a short but sweet wonder.
This collection could easily make converts out of doubters, so pristine and confident are the songs.
1. Meat Is Murder
The Smiths’ second album is difficult, but not for the reasons many sophomore efforts are. The band’s most overtly political record, it’s challenging, heavy, laser focussed, and packed with the finest tunes and lyrics of the group’s brief tenure.
Opener “The Headmaster Ritual” is right up there with the best Smiths songs ever recorded. A diatribe against authority abuse, with the backdrop of Manchester schools (run by “belligerent ghouls”, per one of Morrissey’s truly great lyrics) the target of the band’s ire. The percussion, riff, and wordless chorus are all absolutely on point.
Morrissey’s main target is the meat industry, though, and he goes in hard on the title track particularly. A ghostly number complete with wailing farm animals, it’s enough to put anyone off their chops.
“Barbarism Begins At Home” is another highlight, a rare Smiths funk track a la Gang Of Four, with its sparse lyric and aggressive playing used to illuminate the ugly, authoritative political scene of the time.