10 Best True Crime Podcasts Everyone Must Listen To
Some of the best to scratch your true crime itch.
Have you found yourself wondering just why true crime podcasts are so damn popular? There are a few reasons. Through true crime podcasts, you can learn about the psychology of serial killers, follow a missing persons' case, and even see the process of a wrongful conviction overturned.
True crime podcasts are so much more than dark tales of murder, blood, and gore (well, the good ones are at least). The best reflect on society and have something important to say, while some of them might even make you laugh. What’s certain is that true crime podcasts’ popularity is continuing to grow, and it doesn’t look like that’s going to stop anytime soon.
But which are the very best that you need to check out right now?
10. Jensen And Holes - The Murder Squad
The combination of an investigative journalist, Billy Jensen, and retired cold case investigator, Paul Holes, is pretty unique among the podcasts on this list. The reason it’s irresistible for true crime fans is that it invites them in to tackle missing persons’ cases and unsolved crimes.
Beginning in 2019, it combines old fashioned detective work with up-to-date forensic techniques.
Not only can you listen and learn about these infamous crimes, but listeners can actually help to solve cold cases and hopefully bring justice to those who have been largely forgotten about.
And it has worked! In April 2020, the podcast scored its first arrest. James Curtis Clanton was arrested and charged with first degree murder relating to the case of Helene Pruszynski, who was killed in 1980.
Listen here.
9. Drunk Women Solving Crime
There seems to be a connection with comedy and true crime – perhaps it’s to soften the blow of such traumatising stories. Drunk Women Solving Crime doesn’t just go for the heavy hitters such as serial killers and missing person though – this pod also covers more obscure crime stories, including a woman who hid her secret lover in the attic for a decade.
The hosts are Catie Wilkins, Hannah George, and Taylor Glenn, all comedians with impressive CVs of work on radio and TV.
As well as being a popular true crime podcast, DWSC is known for its live shows, having welcomed several other comedians and members of the public onto their stages on tours and at festivals such as the Edinburgh fringe. Guests often tell their own stories of being involved in crimes, giving a safe space to do so while also finding the humour in such stories.
Listen here.
8. They Walk Among Us
The foreboding name of this podcast is only matched by the spine-chilling tales that are researched and co-written by husband and wife Benjamin and Rosie. The cult podcast is dedicated to true crime from the UK and narrator Benjamin takes readers on a journey through the stories as they unfold.
They walk among us gives readers a snapshot of what could be happening next door or in the street behind them, making it one of the scariest true crime podcasts there is – especially for those who live in the UK.
TWAU has won two British podcast awards and in 2019, Benjamin and Rosie released their first book. It regales readers 10 of the most sinister true crime tales from the UK.
Listen here.
7. Criminal
Criminal is one of the calmer true crime podcasts and offers something a little different to many of the others on this list. It’s a great introduction to the genre, especially for those who don’t like things to gory or shocking. Episodes focus on a variety of different crimes and the circumstances surrounding them.
Hosted by the soothing voice of Phoebe Judge, episodes not only cover murder and missing persons, but animals on trial in episode one (yes, really), computer hacking, and domestic abuse. Often guests who are involved directly in the story come on to give their take.
Criminal has been going for 6 years and has over 100 episodes in its back catalogue – most of which are quite short. They have recently launched a sister podcast too called This is Love, where animals are the central focus. Criminal has no connection to the Netflix TV show of the same name.
Listen here.
6. The Teacher's Pet
Heading Down Under, the Teacher’s Pet is another of the top true crime podcasts from Australia. It’s hosted by journalist Hedley Thomas, who investigates the disappearance of Lynette Dawson in 1982 with a series of interviews with a mixture of law enforcement and family members.
The podcast not only covers the story of Lynette’s disappearance, but has a real sense of place. It puts your right in 1980’s Australia (more specifically the Gold Coast). While this sun-kissed idyllic place is undoubtedly a top holiday destination, living there at the time wouldn’t have been ideal – with rampant misogyny and teachers dating students not being out of the ordinary.
The accused moved a 16-year-old student into this home following Lynette’s death, later making her the stepmother to his children.
Chris Dawson, the former rugby player, high school coach, and husband of Lynette, is currently standing trial for the murder, so the story isn’t over just yet.
Listen here.
5. Bloody Murder
Remaining in Australia, Bloody Murder is hosted by comedians Tara Sariban and Barney Black. This one tells lesser known crime stories from Australia and around the globe.
Since the stories can get quite heavy, they’re broken up by True Crime Nerd Time (where listeners send in their recommendations for true crime books, documentaries etc.) and an ‘Aussie As’ at the end of the show. This is usually a hilarious crime related story that could only happen in Australia.
Like 99.9% of true crime podcasts, Bloody Murder never glorifies any criminal acts and always gives respect to the victims. The two comedians manage to balance this with a unique sense of humour and an obviously warm friendship. The podcast has built up a cult following on social media too.
Episodes of Bloody Murder come out twice a month.
Listen here.
4. In The Dark
Another award-winning true crime podcast, In the Dark has had a genuine real-world impact. It’s a sterling example of investigative journalism by Madeleine Baran and holds the United States justice system to account.
Series one was launched in 2016 and dealt with the disappearance of Jacob Wetterling. This case remained unsolved for 27 years, but the killer confessed not long before In the Dark debuted. The second series is focused on Mississippi resident Curtis Flowers, who was tried for four murders it was unlikely he committed… six times.
In the Dark was a part in what led to one of Flowers’ convictions being overturned by the US Supreme Court. In both series, Baran uncovers a number of errors by police and law enforcement, as well as prosecutorial misconduct.
During the Covid-19 pandemic, In the Dark has released a limited run series following lives of those who live in the Mississippi delta.
Listen here.
3. Casefile
Since its beginnings in 2016, Casefile has lived up to its tagline, “Fact is scarier than fiction”. Beginning with cold cases or solved criminal cases in Australia, it has branched out to cases which have taken place in the UK and USA too.
Part of the mystery of Casefile is its host, an anonymous Australian that fans are no closer to unmasking after more than 144 episodes. The multiple award-winning podcast is not for the faint hearted, with a team of researchers digging up vivid details from murder cases that have gone unsolved for several years.
Casefile is one of the most successful true crime podcasts out there, with more than 275 million downloads and has been in the top podcast charts in more than 100 countries.
For those who know of any unsolved crimes they’d like more
answers to, you can submit a case to this podcast through their official
website.
Listen here.
2. Serial
Want to head back to where it all started for true crime podcasts? That’ll be Serial. Back in 2014, it was launched as an offshoot from This American Life, a US Radio Show.
Based on reporter Sarah Koenig’s investigation, Serial tells the story of Hae Min Lee, a high school student who went missing in 1999. Her boyfriend, Adnan Syed was convicted and sentenced to 30 years in prison.
While later series may not have received the same hype and interest as the original, Serial changed the landscape for True Crime podcasts and spawned many of the others on this list and beyond.
It has been a hit around the world and is the fastest podcast to reach 5 million downloads in iTunes’ history. The team who created Serial followed it up with S-Town, which is also well worth a listen.
Listen here.
1. All Killa No Filla
Hosted by comedians Rachel Fairburn and Kiri Pritchard-McLean, All Killa no Filla has built up a dedicated following on both sides of the Atlantic since debuting on Halloween 2014. In each episode, the presenters talk about the life and crimes of a particular serial killer, going through their upbringing, crimes, and the police work that led to them being captured (or not).
Despite being a comedy podcast, Rachel and Kiri give as much colour to the victims as they can and speak about them in a sensitive and respectful way. It’s clear that a lot of research goes into it!
Listening to a full hour (or sometimes more) on the life of a serial killer can be quite heavy, so the hosts often break this up with stories from their everyday lives – which is where a lot of the laughs come from. Tours of the UK and USA show that this is one of the most loved and funniest true crime podcasts out there.
Listen
.