10 Careless Mistakes That Got Serial Killers Caught
The most vile, wretched, and prolific serial killers of all time, brought down by... a traffic stop?
Serial killers walk among us.
Some are outcasts of society that look "the type" while others blend into society so perfectly that their own families are none the wiser. All of them are the stuff of nightmares. Their unfathomable acts leave a scar on history and many of them continue their rampage without ever being identified by police.
Thankfully, every so often, these monsters are apprehended and put away for good. What's perhaps more shocking is that these animals, especially those that are so meticulous in their crimes, are caught through their own simple mistakes.
From leaving behind evidence, traffic infractions, and burying bodies in the backyard, the worst of the worst had their reigns curtailed for embarrassing reasons.
10. The BTK Killer Was Tricked Into Sending A Floppy Disk To Cops
BTK — three letters that terrorized Wichita, Kansas, for over 30 years.
In 1978, a Wichita news station received a letter from an individual claiming to have killed six people since 1974. The writer suggested a nickname for himself based on the way his method of execution: bind, torture, kill.
The BTK killer taunted police and the press with his various murders stretching until 1991 — and then seemingly stopped. It wasn't until 2004 that BTK made contact with the police again, which inevitably led to his capture.
When BTK began sending letters once more, he asked law enforcement if they'd be able to trace him via a floppy disk. The police (obviously) claimed that they couldn't. After they received the disk, the BTK killer was arrested a week later.
No one would peg Dennis Rader for a serial killer. A family man, Rader was president of his church council, worked as a city compliance officer, and even led a Cub Scout troop. Had his arrogance and stupidity not gotten the best of him, there's a chance the BTK case would have stayed cold and Rader would be a free man today.
9. Ted Bundy Was Undone By Traffic Stops
Ted Bundy is perhaps the most infamous serial killer of all time aside from Jack the Ripper — and for good reason. No one knows for sure just how many people he killed throughout his life. He confessed to 28 but many believe his actual count could stretch into the hundreds.
Thankfully, he was doomed to the electric chair, but not before escaping custody twice.
Bundy was first arrested in 1975 when police found suspicious items in his car during. They took him into custody and linked DNA on the items to a missing girl. One of Bundy's would-be victims escaped his clutches prior and testified against him, handing him a 15-year jail sentence.
On trial for another murder, Bundy chose to represent himself which allowed him to be left alone in a room to prepare for court. Naturally, he took this opportunity to jump out of a second-story window and ran. He was rearrested a few days later.
Ever crafty, Bundy snuck out of his jail cell through an opening in the ceiling. Bundy continued his murder spree for another two months. What finally did him in? Another traffic stop and this time when he was driving a stolen car.
The arresting officer had no idea he cuffed one of the most prolific serial killers of all time until they got to the station.
8. The Son Of Sam Parked Illegally
While Bundy used stolen cars to commit his crimes, which eventually resulted in his downfall, David Berkowitz used his own vehicle as a getaway car during every murder. The Son of Sam killer would evade police remarkably well, that is, until a parking infraction sent him to jail.
Son of Sam killed six people and attempted to kill seven others, all with a revolver in seemingly random attacks. Although police were determined to catch him, Berkowitz was impossible to identify. Incorrect eye-witness testimony and no discernable pattern to the crimes left police clueless.
What's even more peculiar is that Berkowitz was a paranoid schizophrenic who also committed arson and wrote disturbing letters to his neighbors whom he viewed as demons. According to his ravings, one neighbor, Sam, had a demon dog that encouraged Berkowitz to kill.
Despite neighbors alerting police to the letters, Berkowitz still carried on without being labeled more than a potential suspect.
Thankfully, an eye witness reported someone resembling Berkowitz in the area prior to hearing gunshots. She told police that other officers had been in the vicinity writing parking tickets.
One vehicle was ticketed for parking illegally... The owner? David Berkowitz. When police waltzed up to his front door, Berkowitz happily confessed to being the Son of Sam killer and even admitted that he was on his way to committing another murder.
7. Israel Keyes Broke His Own Rules
Israel Keyes is not a household name when it comes to serial killers but he's perhaps one of the most horrifying examples of the modern-day monster.
Keyes was incredibly meticulous and calculating. For years (maybe even decades) he traveled around the country killing with no discernible victim "type". He would buy a one-way plane ticket then rent a car and drive thousands of miles before finding a victim. He hid supplies of "kill kits" in cities across the nation, digging them up on his travels even years after he buried them.
The abduction, kill, and dumpsites were often spread out to cover his tracks. If police even found the bodies — and to this day, there are potential victims still labeled as "missing" — there was no evidence or reason to believe that any of these victims were actually pieces of a larger puzzle.
This was not a man who makes "stupid" decisions. Keyes operated by a strict set of rules that allowed him to continue killing without suspicion. He wasn't a ghost — his serial killer profile just simply didn't exist in the minds of law enforcement.
Had he not broken his own rules, he'd almost certainly be adding to his victim count today.
Israel Keyes planned to abduct his next victim only if she had her own car. She didn't and he did it anyway. He was caught using the victim's debit card and her DNA was found in his car.
6. Albert Fish Wrote A Letter Bragging About His Crimes
Every serial killer is a bonafide monster, but child killers are inarguably the worst of the worst. Albert Fish, sometimes referred to as the Moon Maniac killer, was a sadomasochist who killed and ate nearly a dozen children.
Fish was a deeply disturbed man whose actions and interests are too grand and perverse to be summed up in a single entry. He ate his own feces and nearly 30 needles were found inserted into his groin when he was arrested — and these are tame examples compared to his many other hobbies.
In short, Albert Fish had been raping, potentially torturing and killing young children since his 20s. He claimed to have eaten many of his victims as well. Evading incarceration until age 66, there's a chance Fish has many more victims to his name.
In 1928, he abducted and murdered a ten-year-old girl. In 1934, the girl's mother received a letter that detailed how the girl was abducted, murdered, and eaten over a period of nine days. Why he wrote the damning letter — and waited six years to send it — is anyone's guess.
Although the letter was anonymous, he bluntly stated the exact date he abducted the girl after visiting the mother. Police traced the letter back to Fish and he was sentenced to death.
5. Dennis Nilsen Blocked His Drains With Human Remains
Some serial killers go to great lengths to dispose of their victims. Others, like Dennis Nilsen, simply try to flush them down the drain.
One of the worst serial killers in Britain, Nilsen died in prison in 2019. Between 1978 and 1983, he confessed to killing up to 16 young men. After luring his victims home from the pub, he would suffocate them and cut up their bodies.
At first, Nilsen tried to store the dismembered remains in plastic bags. Naturally, the smell became unbearable, so instead of taking the remains to a dumpsite — or even throwing them away in the trash — Nilsen tried to get rid of the evidence without ever leaving home.
As more and more pieces of his victims were discarded down his toilet and sink drains, the plumbing system became clogged. A plumber was called to alleviate the clog, only to find bits of flesh and bone in the drains. Police arrested Nilsen soon after.
4. Joel Rifkin Drove Without Plates
Once again, we have a case of a serial killer hitting the end of the line all thanks to a traffic stop.
Joel Rifkin killed nearly 20 women throughout the 1990s in New York. Targeting prostitutes, Rifkin would strangle his victims before dismembering them and scattering their remains across various dumpsites — leaving police unable to identify the killer nor many of the victims.
Rifkin was able to dispose of 16 victims without drawing attention to himself. He wasn't so lucky with his 17th.
After strangling the woman, he brought her back to his mother's garage where her body sat for three days. When we went to move the body, police noticed that license plates were missing from his truck. A horrid odor emanating from the rear of the truck drew suspicion and Rifkin was immediately placed in custody when police found the body.
3. John Wayne Gacy Hid Bodies Under His Own House
Newsflash: Clowns are creepy and if your neighbor enjoys dressing up like one, you're right to eye them suspiciously. Especially if their front yard smells like a rotting corpse.
John Wayne Gacy, the infamous clown killer, did indeed revel in his guise as Pogo the Clown to entertain sick children. He was a respected businessman, involved in local politics, and was seemingly kind enough to hire troubled youth to work for him.
Sadly, many of these young boys, as well as some male prostitutes, were raped and killed by Gacy in the 1970s. Believe it or not, he was actually given a prison sentence for sexually assaulting one of his employees but was released for good behavior before moving to the Chicago area.
Gacy's first dumb mistake was taking the boys to his home to rape, torture, and kill them. His second was hiding the bodies in the crawl space under his home. Gacy was investigated as the last person seen with a missing teen and evidence around his property — including an unsettling stench — warranted his arrest.
After confessing, police found nearly 30 bodies beneath his home and another dumped in a nearby river. Had he not confessed and used his home as a dumpsite, there's a chance the well-regarded community man could have talked his way to freedom.
2. H. H. Holmes Recruited Accomplices In Insurance Fraud
Often dubbed "America's first serial killer", H.H. Holmes was operating in the United States around the same time as Jack the Ripper was carving up the streets of London. While nowhere near as intriguing or prolific as Jack, researchers estimate that Holmes killed over 200 people.
Holmes would seduce women, have them make him the beneficiary of their life insurance policies, then murder them. His hotel, now known as the Murder Castle, had quite a few visitors and employees (employees who also had him listed as their life insurance beneficiary) disappear over time, as well.
A fairly intelligent man, murder was not the only crime he fancied. He also sold the bodies of his victims to medical schools. He stole other bodies to use in fake insurance schemes, collecting life insurance money for deceased individuals that never existed.
His undoing? Involving others in his mischief. Holmes convinced Ben Pitezel to fake his death to collect a life insurance payout — Holmes ended up killing him for real. Another associate who helped Holmes with this scheme ratted him out to investigators and Holmes was promptly arrested.
1. The Yorkshire Ripper Didn't Register His Car Properly
Although the United States had its fair share of prolific serial killers operating in the 1970s, England was haunted by its own now-infamous killer, The Yorkshire Ripper. Between 1975 and 1980, at least thirteen women were killed by the Ripper.
The Yorkshire Ripper was clumsy compared to other serial killers. Many of the crime scenes and bodies had evidence left behind including boot prints and tire tracks. Police went on a manhunt that included interviewing hundreds of thousands of individuals — including the Ripper himself, Pete Sutcliffe, nine times!
How was Sutcliffe caught? Falsely registered license plates.
Police picked up Sutcliffe as he was soliciting a prostitute in his car. Before he was carted away, he was permitted to take a leak behind an oil drum. The Yorkshire Ripper tried, and failed, to ditch a hammer and knife in this spot — police returned the next day and collected the murder weapons.