10 Creepy Stories About Real Life Executioners
When you kill people for a living, you end up with some creepy stories.
Taking away another human being’s life is a disturbing thing to do for a living. Usually it’s considered a crime, but sometimes it’s the opposite: a punishment. And behind every execution is an executioner: someone who is paid by the state to kill in the name of justice. This job has existed throughout most of human history, and in many places it still exists to this day.
It’s not an easy job. It takes someone with thick-skin to be an executioner, and in some cases it takes someone very sadistic too. Most people who take the job suffer, whether it’s because of their own issues or through being shunned by their peers. And so this complicated, controversial job can lead people to do strange things and live strange lives.
With most executions, the spotlight is on the person on the receiving end. But if you take a look at the person who flicks the switch, swings the axe, or ties the noose, you might be surprised at what you find. The people behind the execution often have stories that are just as sinister as the person being executed.
10. Heinrich Schmidt
In most creepy stories about executioners, they play the role of the villain. But we actually feel sympathy for Heinrich Schmidt, who was an executioner with an unfortunate back story. Heinrich Schmidt was once a normal guy, a woodsman in the Bavarian town of Hof. However, on one ordinary day in 1553 his life changed forever – for the worse.
It was commonplace for townsfolk to attend executions, and on that day Heinrich Schmidt had been doing just that. He was standing in a crowd waiting to see an execution. The crowd were left waiting because there was one big problem; they had no executioner. Their tyrannical ruler, Brandenburg-Kulmbach Albrecht II, was furious at the situation and decided to pick someone at random from the crowd. He picked Schmidt to be the executioner, but Schmidt said no. So the prince gave him an ultimatum: execute these men, or you’ll be executed too. Schmidt eventually gave in and carried out the execution. But once he did, there was no going back.
His family became so isolated by the stigma that he couldn’t get any work other than as an executioner. And that’s how the rest of his life was, shunned by society and being forced to execute people.
9. Dick Bauf
Dick Bauf is another person who became an executioner under unfortunate circumstances. When he was just 12 years old, both his parents were charged with burglary and murder. The punishment was death, which put Dick Bauf in a bad position. Not only was he losing both parents at the age of 12, but 17th century Ireland’s child care system was seen as a near enough death sentence. His parents pleaded to have him not go into childcare, and it was agreed that he wouldn’t. There was one cruel condition to this though: he had to execute both his parents to be let free.
His parents agreed to this, and so the 12 year old hanged his parents. Because he was then seen as an executioner, he was unable to get any honest work and turned to pick-pocketing. He soon became involved in a circle of petty thieves, and later he became a highwayman. This led to him being a wanted criminal with a reward for his capture. When confronted with a group of men trying to catch him, he managed to catch them and decided to burn them alive and flee.
Despite all the heinous acts he'd committed, he was eventually arrested for the relatively benign crime of sleeping with a married woman. Despite trying to pay his way out of his sentence, he was executed by hanging just like his parents.
8. Simon Grandjean
The 17th century Dijon executioner Simon Grandjean and his wife learnt the hard way that people don’t take well to botched executions. They were assigned to execute Helene Gillet, a woman who was sentenced to death for murdering her baby. Simon Grandjean was set to behead her with a sword, but on the day he made a complete mess of the job.
The first swing of his sword only clipped her shoulder, and the second swing also failed to behead her. This made the crowd furious, and Grandjean retreated to a nearby chapel whilst the crowd pelted him with whatever they had to hand. His wife, who was his assistant, tried to save the situation by moving the prisoner beneath the platform so that she was shielded from the crowd. She then tried to finish the beheading with a pair of shears, but the crowd got to her before she could.
Both Grandjean and his wife were targeted by the angry crowds, and they were both killed in the attacks. The prisoner Helene Gillet got lucky though, as her injuries were minimal and the strange situation led her to be pardoned from the death sentence.
7. Johann Reichhart
It’s not surprising that some executioners can be twisted people, but Johann Reichhart’s story really seems dark. Johann Reichhart was an executioner in Germany at the time of World War II and was also a member of the Nazi party. His job consisted of executing people accused of war crimes, such people the Nazis deemed a traitor. He played a dark part in history, but what makes it worse is that he didn’t pay the full price for it. Whilst many Nazis received the death penalty, Reichhart managed to dodge this. Why? Because even though his death count was high, he didn’t kill anyone in battle or in a concentration camp.
Although he didn’t receive the death penalty, he was hired (with little choice in the matter) to execute other Nazi war criminals. He executed at least 21 Nazis before refusing to work anymore. This led him to be fined and imprisoned for two years, as well as being forbidden to vote or engage with politics. Throughout his career he killed over 3000 people, the majority of them being within the years of World War 2.
6. John Ellis
Being an executioner is certainly not the happiest job. Killing people for a living, whether or not it’s in the name of ‘justice’, would be tough for most people. Most executioners find that the work causes them some distress or trauma throughout and after their career. And for the early 20th century British executioner John Ellis, the job proved to be too much.
After the particularly difficult execution of Edith Thomas, John Ellis was traumatised. He quit his job shortly after and his mental health continued to suffer. He took to heavy drinking and later attempted suicide by shooting himself in the jaw. Things continued to get worse for Ellis, because at that time suicide was still a crime, so he faced a criminal trial for attempting to take his own life. He was sentenced to one year in prison. Eight years later, he committed suicide by cutting his throat.
5. Albert Pierrepoint
Albert Pierrepoint was one of the last British executors, and he remains notorious to this day. He conducted many well documented executions, so there are plenty of strange stories about him. But perhaps the creepiest story surrounding him is not about an execution, but about his popularity.
He was a man whose job it was to kill people. Yes, these may have been people who were deemed deserving of their fate, but it’s still not the most moral of jobs. And yet, he became a hugely popular figure, and for a large portion of his career he was deemed a hero.
He rose to prominence after the Second World War, when he executed around 200 people from enemy countries of war crimes. He became seen as a national hero, treasured by the British public. He found that so many people were offering to buy him a pint as a gesture to his ‘heroism’, that he decided to open a pub. And after all the executions he performed, he had the money to do it too.
His popularity as an executor allowed the establishment to thrive. He went on executing criminals unrelated to the war, and maintained his popularity. He even executed one of his pub’s locals, who he’d been friendly with. The pair were so friendly that they had their own private greeting, and even greeted each other with it on the morning of the execution.
Pierrepoint’s popularity took a slight knock when he controversially executed Ruth Ellis, but after retirement he still remained popular enough to make money from his memoirs.
4. Thomas Derrick
Thomas Derrick becoming an executioner was a very dark case of irony. He was a sinister guy, and had been found guilty of rape. And in Elizabethan England, the punishment for rape was the death penalty. However, in a corrupt deal with the Earl of Essex he got out of his punishment on the condition that he became the local executioner.
The job of executioner was unpopular, as people often looked down on you for it. And so even though it was corrupt and counterproductive, they knew that someone on death row was desperate enough to take the job in exchange for a pardon. This exchange didn’t work out too well for the Earl of Essex in the end though, as when he received the death penalty himself it was Derrick who executed him. He was just one of around 3000 people executed by the convicted violent criminal.
3. Henry-Clément Sanson
Henry-Clément Sanson was the seventh generation in his family to be a French executioner. He was a troubled guy. He became a heavy drinker because of the burden of his job, and began indulging himself in an extravagant lifestyle. This lifestyle left him broke, and he came up with a creepy way to make extra cash.
Using his family guillotine, he opened a musée des horreurs in his own home. This was a place where he showed off the guillotine he used to execute people, but to bring in the crowds he did something pretty twisted. He would have people pay him to decapitate a live sheep in his house for money. For a guy seemingly troubled by his job, it seems he also embraced the sadistic side of it. His money problems eventually got worse, and he lost his job because he had sold his guillotine, replacing it with an old axe for executions.
2. Jack Ketch
When you’re on death row, the only person you would dread more than an executioner is a bad one. 17th century British executioner Jack Ketch was definitely someone to be afraid of. He was so famous for his botched executions, that his name became slang for low life executioners, as well as being a synonym for death and Satan. He wasn’t the most popular guy.
He was so unpopular that crowds once attempted to lynch him for his poor attempt at an execution. This might seem extreme, but things can get heated when it’s a matter of life and death. These people might have been criminals, but watching anyone die and suffer more than they should because of someone’s incompetence is horrible. He was so incompetent, that it once took him eight attempts to chop off someone’s head. What makes this whole story creepier though, is that it was actually questioned as to whether he really was incompetent, or just sadistic enough to make the execution so much more painful and gory.
1. John Price
John Price was an English hangman in the late 17th and early 18th century. Despite working as an executioner in the justice system, he constantly got on the wrong side of the law. For him, even executing criminals himself wasn’t enough to put him off a life of crime.
His life of crime caught up with him in 1715, when after hanging three men he was arrested for the debt he had built up. The money he had made executing that day helped him get off, but soon enough his financial problems caught up with him again and he ended up in prison. After a few months, he escaped with an accomplice after digging a tunnel through the prison wall.
He still didn’t learn his lesson once out of the slammer. In 1718, he murdered a man and attacked a woman who later died of her injuries. For his crime, he received the death penalty. From executioner, to criminal, to murderer, to being on death row himself – it seems John Price couldn’t keep himself away from capital punishment.