10 Outrageous Jack The Ripper Suspect Theories

Was he a children's author? A Satanist? German?

Some call him The Whitechapel Murderer. Some call him Leather Apron. Most call him Jack The Ripper. All we know is...well, actually, for a historical figure so famous and with so much ink spilt over, we really don't know a whole lot about the serial killer who stalked the sex workers of impoverished 1800s London. People can't even agree on how many people the guy killed, as some stick with the so-called "canonical five" whilst others lump in every gruesome murder of a prostitute they can think of (including one that happened in 1891...in New York). The most enduring mystery of all, however, is who Jack The Ripper actually was. It's one of the longest unsolved mysteries in the history of the Met, and not one they intentionally covered up for once - or did they...? Academics, historians and billy-no-mates on the internet alike all have their pet theories on who exactly "Jack" was, employing an alchemical blend of analysis, hearsay, and just grabbing random names out of the hat. The most recent fingered culprit is Polish barber Aaron Kosminski, whom some rich dude with too much time on his hands apparently confirmed with some dodgy-sounding DNA tests. There's a bunch of reasons the Kosminski evidence is probably crapola (for one thing, if he was serious - and serious about the "pioneering" technology used - he probably wouldn't have announced it in the Daily Mail), which is good for us, because it means we can keep wildly speculating about who the Whitechapel Murderer really was. Children's author? Satanist? German? All of those and more are included in our ten most outrageous Jack The Ripper theories. Which people actually believe. Seriously.

10. He Was A Milkman From Hartlepool

When it comes to these theories, they tend to fall into two brackets: one, the crackpot who has spent way too long down the rabbit hole and actually believes what they're saying; two, the hack who wants in on that sweet Jack The Ripper racket. Books speculating as to Jack's identity have sold pretty well since time immemorial (or, like, since he started killing people), and the best way to make yours stand out from the rest is by pushing some unique, new, preferably insane theory. The latter of which is the case with the Hartlepool resident who claimed to be a distant relative. Said €œrelative€ also claims that Jack was actually a milkman as his day job, allowing him to keep odd hours without arousing suspicion. He also claims that the Ripper fled London following the furore of him, y'know, ripping out people's internal organs for a laugh, and settled in Hartlepool with his wife and daughter and changing his surname to Williams. Forensic expert and ex-copper Norman Kirtlan said this suspect was his "favourite" to date. But then he would, since he co-wrote the book about it. And we're not buying it. The book nor the theory, we mean. If he was gonna beat the rap so successfully, he'd have to be driving fastest milk cart in the west or something. Our new theory: Benny Hill was Jack The Ripper?

9. Jack Was Actually Jill

In the fine tradition of Fiona And Cake, Dr Jekyll And Sister Hyde and the new Ghostbusters, some Ripper investigators have suggested that everyone else is on totally the wrong track - by gender swapping the infamous serial killer. There are many who suggest that the culprit may actually have been a woman, which necessitates changing her name to Jill The Ripper, we guess. Less offensive than her other nickname, the Mad Midwife, at least. Mary Pearcey was actually convicted of murder, albeit of her lover's wife and child, and executed around the time The Ripper's killings all but stopped. Depending on who you ask. This isn't just one of those fringe theories, by the way. She was actually the favoured suspect of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle - you know, the guy who created Sherlock Holmes, the greatest detective in history. Okay, so Doyle wasn't a detective himself, but there's plenty of people who agree with his assertion that a woman done it. She would have found it easier to avoid the police, for one thing, since they were always searching for a man. There's no contemporary physical evidence or eyewitnesses linking Pearcey to The Ripper, true, but a 2006 DNA testing of envelopes from letters thought to have been sent by the killer suggested it was a woman...

8. He Took Selfies

Much as we like the idea of Jill The Ripper, most of the more outrageous theories stick with the accepted idea that the murderer was a man. It usually is. Stupid men. One particularly stupid man may have been renowned painter Walter Sickert, who was a member of the avant-garde Camden Town Group in London during the 1800s. He may also have been Jack The Ripper, leaving behind a pretty compelling trail of clues that should probably have lead to a conviction. Maybe. We're not sure. That's what crime novelist Patricia Cornwell - very much the Conan Doyle of her day - reckons, to the point that she tore up a Sickert canvas to look for evidence of his involvement. It was an act of vandalism branded as €œmonstrous stupidity€ but, dammit, she got results. Cornwell was working of an already-established theory of Sickert as The Ripper, with existing evidence of his being in the right place at the right time, living for a period in a flat believed to have previously belonged to old Jack, and producing a painting of it called "Jack the Ripper's Bedroom". Cromwell apparently gained enough DNA from messing with one of Sickert's other paintings to compare to one of those Ripper letters and prove they were one and the same, but we're not sure we buy it. Guy would've had to have been pretty cocky to live in the same house as the murderer, and then effectively paint a self-portrait, identifying himself as the culprit. Apparently he did it all because of his weird willy though, so, anything's possible?

7. Servant Girl Annihilator

Not wishing to trail behind in comparison to their forefathers, the Americans got in on the serial killing lark soon after Jack started tearing up the streets of London with the so-called Servant Girl Annihilator, also known as The Austin Axe Murderer (not quite as elegant a nom de plume, you can see why he or she never caught on). During the years 1884 and 1885 eight people were murdered by - according to the New York Times - "some cunning madman, who is insane on the subject of killing women". Sounds kinda familiar, right? Kinda like someone who could be a painter, woman or milk man? Huh? Huh? Yes, of course there's somebody who reckons that this psychopath and Jack The Ripper are one and the same. We're not sure how he managed to get away from Whitechapel and emigrate to Texas without anybody catching on, but anyway. In her book Jack the Ripper: The American Connection, Shirley Harrison lays out her argument that Jack The Annihilator - ooo, good wrestling name - was one James Maybrick, a cotton merchant from Liverpool who was later convicted of poisoning his wife. Which he totally did do. Whether he also killed five London prostitutes and eight American civilians is a little more up for debate, although London authorities questioned several cowboys at the time. Then again all the evidence that implicated Maybrick (a supposed diary of his which acts like a confession, a pocket watch engraved with "I am Jack") turned out to be phonies, so.

6. It Was A Conspiracy

What if, instead of being one of the people we've already gone over, it was in fact the real answer was E - all of the above? One of the wilder ideas as to The Ripper's identity isn't that he or she was someone, but that the murderers were committed by multiple people. It's a legit conspiracy theory, as a group of people conspired to kill a bunch of people €“ and they got away with it! Kind of like the Neighbourhood Watch Alliance, this idea supposedly explains why nobody ever got arrested (because each murder was done by a different person, making the pieces impossible to put together), why reports of The Ripper are so dissimilar, and why the various notes €œhe€ sent to the police looked to be written by different hands. Author Stephen Knight who - yes - wrote a book called Jack the Ripper: The Final Solution, argued that the murders were a conspiracy involving multiple repeat offenders, but there are still others who think that the whole thing is just some absurdist joke. According to Peter Turnbull there's a very real chance that each murder was committed by unconnected individuals, acting completely independent of each other, and it just so happened that each of their modus operandi and killing styles perfectly matched up. In which case, Jack The Ripper wasn't a serial killer, but just a bunch of people doing one bad murder each. Which is, like, the darkest joke we've ever heard.

5. Lewis Carroll Did It

If you think that's weird, well, you don't know the half of it. Because there's a reasonably sizeable number of Ripper obsessives out there - and there's a lot of them, believe us - who think that the killer was actually Charles Lutwidge Dodgson, a mathematician, logician, Anglican deacon and photographer best known for writing Alice In Wonderland under the pen name Lewis Carroll. We are quite literally through the Looking Glass (snort) here, people. Could the man responsible for such nonsense as the Jabberwocky and The Hunting Of The Snark really be responsible for such barbaric crimes? There's already suggestion of his paedophilic tendencies, but this goes a fair way further than that. Dodgson was teaching at Christ Church up until 1881, again putting him in the right place at the right time. Richard Wallace's book Jack the Ripper, Light-Hearted Friend makes the case for Carroll as The Ripper, based on of anagrams found in passages in two of the author's works: an adaptation of Alice€™s Adventures In Wonderland for younger readers, and the first volume of his masterwork, Sylvie and Bruno. Yeah, apparently Dodgson not only found the time to do a bunch of killing on top of everything else he did, but got away with it, and nevertheless inserted a confession into two books of his, waiting for somebody to discover them some decades later. He did like his word games and tricks, though...

4. The Royal Connection

Stephen Knight was a busy guy. His book collected a whole bunch of scattershot ideas of Jack The Ripper's identity, with one suggesting that not only was the whole thing a conspiracy, but one perpetrated by the British Royal Family. It's the story told in Alan Moore and Eddie Campbell's brilliant graphic novel From Hell (and it's less-than-brilliant film adaptation starring Johnny Depp), which alleges that it was all done to cover up an illegitimate baby fathered by Prince Albert Victor, Duke of Clarence, with a lady of the night. Prince Albert Victor €“ Eddy to his mates €“ figures in no less than three theories regarding the Ripper, in fact. During the time of the Ripper murders, there were no actual theories presented linking Eddy to the crimes. Since then, however, there was Knight's suggestion that the whole thing was a pretty messy cover up €“ and one which would have been very, very difficult to keep quiet, especially if the Prince was as thick as reports of the time suggest €“ whilst another simply posits that the Duke of Bedford teamed up with him to commit the murders as a lark, or something. Or it may have been a cover up, and it was related not to Eddy being a baby daddy but being driven insane by syphilis, which is apparently something that can happen. There's basically no evidence of any of this, although if you think the monarchy may be have been involved in keeping hush-hush about the Jack The Ripper murders, that might be enough to tip you over into a €œyes€ vote in the upcoming Scottish Independence referendum.

3. It Was All To Do With Satanism

We suppose you do expect a degree of death and debauchery from the royal family; it's kinda their stock in trade. Or it used to be, anyway, now it's all sitting on chairs and sticking babies in floor-length gowns. You probably expect the same of Satanists, too €“ or at least, based on the popular conception of Satanists, with all the ritual sacrifices and goats and the like. In reality those who €œhail Satan€ are more just selfish dudes who like to wear black than actual murderers, but you try telling that to the people who think Jack The Ripper was a guy paying tribute to the dark lord by carving up innocent women on the rain-slicked streets of Whitechapel. They will not listen. This is a hill they are willing to die on. One such Satanist was Robert D'onston Stephenson, who allegedly swanned around in a cloak to prove how easy the Ripper's disguise would work, and kept five dress ties stained with blood under his bed. Woops. That's a story told by Aleister Crowley, pioneering devil worshipper and occultist, who may have just been trying to deflect attention from himself. He was an interesting chap, for sure, but we're pretty sure he never killed anyone. Regardless, historian Mark Beynon blamed him for six of unrelated murders (something to do with the Curse Of Tutankhamen, natch) and then, since he was in London at the time, suggested he was probably Jack The Ripper and all. Plus he'd already stuck his oar in by reporting Stephenson as a potential suspect, which obviously made him a suspect himself.

2. Van Gogh Cut Off More Than Ears

Vincent Van Gogh did not live a happy life. But hey, we don't need to tell you that - we've all seen his paintings, with the deep melancholic palettes and the self portrait depicting the artist missing an ear after he cut it off. Plus we've all seen the Doctor Who episode too, right? Good episode. Even with the Athlete song they played over the credits. Apparently he wasn't just a sick man in the literal sense (he suffered from anxiety and frequent bouts of mental illness, eventually killing himself) but also in the figurative. Because he murdered people. Because he was actually Jack The Ripper. Are you keeping up with this? People think that Vincent Van Gogh, in between painting sunflowers, he also murdered at least five women. In London. Whilst he was born in Holland and ended up in France, Van Gogh did spend some time in England, teaching at at Isleworth and Ramsgate and, yes, living in London for a bit too. According to painter and writer David Larner who - crucially - has yet to find a publisher for his book Vincent Alias Jack, Van Gogh was possibly in London around the right time, was known to consort with prostitutes and, yes, had already dabbled in self-mutilation - who's to say he wouldn't try out those skills on anyone else? Of course Larner's biggest piece of evidence is total boohockey (apparently the 1890 painting Irises has the "hidden" image of suspected Ripper victim Mary Kelly's police photo), and he stretches credulity further by claiming he was also responsible for the Thames torso murders of 1887, so we don't think any arty types should lose any sleep over this one.

1. Hitler

You know who has a slightly more convincing motivation to go around killing innocent people? Adolf Hitler. Nobody's surprised by that monster doing such horrible things. He committed mass genocide, so we can see why a few light murders around Whitechapel might serve as a suitable appetiser. It's just every other part of the theory that doesn't make sense, what with the Fuhrer not being old as balls, nor spending a heck of a lot of time in London during the 1800s, and also just why would you think Hitler was Jack The Ripper, that is ridiculous, oh wait it's somebody on the internet, of course they think that. Godwin's law: it applies to speculation over historical murderers too, apparently. Okay, so remember we mentioned that the Duke Of Clarence possibly teamed up with Prince Albert Victor to do the killings? That's our starting point. How could a Duke have managed to escape the rap for such horrible crimes? By travelling across Europe, settling in Austria, and changing his name, of course. Growing a silly moustache is pretty much de rigueur for disguises, too. That would put Adolf as a little bit of an older gent than we tend to think of, but hey, Eva Braun described him as €œelderly€ when they first met, to. Yeah, we don't buy it either. So how about the theory that Jose Rizal, Filipino national hero, was The Ripper, and he actually fathered Hitler whilst on a jaunt around Germany? Plenty of proof to support that. Like, erm, he had the initials JR. And could've been in London during the late 1880s. And liked the ladies. And was possibly pure evil. The Lewis Carroll one's starting to sound a lot more believable, actually...

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/