10 Serial Killer Crimes That Took Years To Solve

Evasive as they are infamous, these serial killers nearly slipped through police fingers.

BTK Killer
ABC

The genre of True Crime is booming at the moment with endless documentaries to devour. The gruesome subject has rocketed into popular culture of late even inspiring fictionalised TV shows about FBI profilers such as Mindhunter or film adaptations such as the Ted Bundy biopic Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil and Vile.

There are some crimes that shock people to their core, the truly horrific or particularly unnerving often are the focus of these explorations. Serial Killers such as the Coed Killer or Richard Ramierez are remembered for the horror of their actions but not necessarily the length of their reign of terror. Others are infamous for the complete mystery of their identity, the Zodiac Killer being the most well known of those.

However, there is a large number of serial killers who remained undetected for years, allowing the number of victims to grow and grow. Despite the efforts of the police at the time, these ten mass murderers managed to evade capture for a varying numbers of years.

Some were captured before they could cause any more harm, others were left lying low for years...

10. Harold Shipman

Harold Shipman
murderpedia.org

This unassuming doctor is often referred to as one of the most prolific serial killers in the world. He was an English General Practitioner who had a penchant for murdering the patients in his care, from 1995 to 1998 he murdered fifteen patients by giving them lethal doses of diamorphine (heroin).

In 1998, concerns were expressed to the coroner about the high mortality rate among Shipman's patients, this was investigated but ultimately dropped. After this Shipman continued his practice until the death of Kathleen Grundy. Grundy's daughter was suspicious of the will produced as it left everything to Shipman rather than the family, upon investigation the body was exhumed and found to contain traces of diamorphine.

This sparked an inquiry, known as The Shipman Inquiry, into his behaviour. It was discovered that many other patients had passed away in his care, he had then signed their death certificate and forged medical records to suggest they were in poor health.

He is the only medical practitioner ever to be convicted of murdering his own patients. Shipman later hanged himself while in prison sparking an inquest into prisoners mental health. In total, 459 patients died in his care from 1971 to 1998, however, we will never know how many of these were from illness or from Shipman's hand.


9. Albert Fish

Albert Fish
Wikipedia

Known by many names such as The Gray Man, The Boogeyman or the Brooklyn Vampire, Albert Fish as an American serial killer, cannibal and child rapist. Boasting that he had "had children in every state", it is believed he possibly attacked over 100 children. He was suspected of murdering at least 5 people, the main conviction coming from the disappearance of Grace Budd.

in 1928, After seeing a classified advert to hire her brother, Fish arrived at the Budd household under the pretence of hiring the young boy. He in fact intended to murder him but then switched targets to Grace, he convinced her family to let her leave with him and never returned her. Another man was arrested for the kidnapping and spent time in jail before being acquitted.

Then in 1934 Fish sent an incredibly creepy letter to the family informing them of Grace's passing. This letter was his downfall as they traced the paper back to him and consequently arrested him. After his arrest it was discovered there were other victims that could be link to Fish. Although he initially denied them, he did confess to at least two other murders. One case was from as early as 1924 meaning he had escaped capture for at least a decade.


8. Jeffrey Dahmer

Jeffrey Dahmer appears in Milwaukee County Circuit Court while hearing the charges being brought against him, in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Dahmer is charged with four counts of first-degree intentional homicide; however, police officials suspect him of as man
MARK ELIAS/AP

Over the course of his 13 year spree Dahmer murdered 17 young men. He avoided detection for all those years by choosing his victims from those living on the edges of society, often selecting people who were borderline criminal so their disappearances would be less noticeable.

Dahmer began in 1978 by murdering a hitchhiker who he had got drunk and brought back to his parents house, he buried the body behind the property. He didn't strike again until 1987 where he drunkenly killed a man in a hotel and brought the body back to his grandma's basement, in which he dismembered the body. After two more murders his grandma, unaware of his actions, threw him out.

In 1989, whilst facing a sexual assault charge he uses the basement once again to lure men in to rape and murder them. Over the next two years he claims his final 13 victims, during this time he develops rituals and experiments with cannibalism and chemical disposal of bodies.

Perhaps the saddest of all the Dahmer cases happened in 1991 when police were called to investigate the behaviour of a young man. Dahmer claimed he was his 19 year old lover but the boy was in fact 14. At the time the police only had a cursory look around the house before leaving. Dahmer went on to kill the boy.

On his arrest the police found body parts in his fridge and Polaroids of his victims. Pleading first not guilty, despite confessing, then changing to guilty by insanity. He was found guilty and sane, Dahmer was sentenced to 15 life sentences. Eventually, however, he was killed by a fellow inmate.


7. Fred And Rose West

Fred West
BBC

The Wests are possibly one of the most famous duos when it comes to serial killers. The English couple committed at least 12 murders during the 20 years they were at large.

Whilst an adolescent Fred impregnated his sister and admitted to molesting many young girls, his family effectively disowned him, however, he remained in touch with is parents. During his first marriage to Rena, Fred was constantly violent and controlling. This extended to sexually assaulting Rena's daughter Charmaine, the abuse continuing for years. Rena eventually escaped but left her daughter under the care of Fred and their nanny McFall. McFall later disappeared but was never reported missing.

In 1969, Fred met Rose and the pair began their relationship despite the protests of her parents. Rose quickly began beating the two daughters and is believed to have killed Charmaine. Rena sporadically returned to visit the children but after one visit was never seen alive again. The infamous pair got married and had children of their own who were also subject to excessive abuse.

They murdered and assaulted many people but eventually turned their attention to daughter Heather who they killed and "buried under the patio". This would prove to be their downfall as the family joke of ending up like Heather garnered attention from the police.

The police mounted a full investigation after their daughter Louise opened up about the abuse. The pair we eventually arrested in 1994 for the murders and abuse on multiple counts. Fred strangled himself in prison a year after his arrest.


6. Peter Sutcliffe

Peter Sutcliffe
BBC

Also known as the 'Yorkshire Ripper', Sutcliffe was apprehended in 1981 after a 5 year police investigation. He began attacking women in 1969, focusing on prostitutes which he would later claim he was instructed to do by God.

His first murder was in 1975, stabbing Wilma McCann 15 times. This resulted in an investigation involving 1500 police officers but came back with no concrete leads. Over the next 4 years he would continue to murder women in and around the Yorkshire area. He was prolific enough to be included on a list of 300 suspects but never seriously considered. The police even interviewed him nine times but didn't take any further action.

In 1980 he was arrested for drunk driving and killed two more women whilst awaiting trial. A year later he was apprehended with a prostitute in his car but was discovered to have false plates. He was then interviewed in connection to the ripper case, this lead to his arrest and incarceration. He was given a minimum of 30 year sentence.

On 16th July 2011 his sentence was changed to a whole life sentence meaning he will never be released. After the trial he admitted to two further attacks but the police have not released the names of the victims.


5. Ted Bundy

Ted Bundy Mugshot
Salt Lake County

One of, if not the, most well known serial killers in American history. Shocking the world with truly heinous acts towards women disguised behind a seemingly normal and often charming personality. His notoriety has brought him back into the public consciousness recently with a film starring Zac Efron depicting his crimes.

It is hard to pinpoint exactly when Bundy began murdering people as he himself would tell different stories or refuse to go into depth about his early crimes. Many officers believe that as a teenager he already had a taste for blood, possibly as early at 1969.

In 1974, he began attacking young women on campuses around him at the rate of around 1 per month. He then moved to Idaho and continued this spree until he was stopped in 1975 and his car was checked. They discovered a ski mask and other suspicious items but did not have enough to arrest him. The officers put a 24 hour surveillance in place, he was also high priority on a list of 100 suspects. After this Bundy sold his now infamous Volkswagen Beetle, which the FBI then dismantled and discovered hairs from victims in the upholstery. Bundy was brought in and identified by eyewitnesses, leading to his arrest.

Moving forward to 1977, Bundy decided to represent himself in court and the judge allowed him to be handcuff free. During a recess he escaped through the library window and evaded being recaptured for 6 days. Eventually he was recaptured, however, he mounted another escape plan and remained at large into early '78. In this period he attacked at least 6 more women, murdering some of them.

He was finally recaptured and stood trial in 1979, he was found guilty across multiple accounts and sentenced to death by electric chair. He postponed this by making many deathbed confessions but ultimately was executed on 24th Jan 1989.


4. John Cooper

John Cooper Bullseye
Challenge TV

Another recent and lesser known serial killer is John Cooper, also known as the Bullseye Killer due to his appearance on British game-show Bullseye in 1989. This TV debut was even used as evidence against him.

His criminal activity was well documented and included 30 robberies and an assault, however, in 1985 his minor crimes took a turn for the murderous. Escalating his criminal portfolio, he killed a brother and sister in their home which he later burned down. He did not commit another murder until after his Bullseye appearance. He attacked a couple while they were holidaying in Pembrookshire, he robbed them at gunpoint and then shot them both using his sawn-off shotgun.

This gun would later be part of the case against him. He was arrested for robbery in 1998 and served 14 years, however, whilst reviewing cold case files in 2009 the police linked the gun to Cooper and the murders. He was swiftly charged for the double murders and also sexual assaults in 2011. He was given a whole life sentence, which he appealed but was denied.


3. Leonarda Cianciulli

Leonarda Cianciulli
Wikipedia

A lesser known but no less dangerous killer from Italy. She is known sometimes as the Soap-Maker of Corregio due to her disposal of one victim's body.

During her life she had 17 pregnancies; 3 of these are miscarriages and 10 children died in youth. This left four children who she was very protective over. However, when WWII began her eldest son was called for duty. This fear of losing another child drove her to believe human sacrifices would protect him.

She had three victims, the first of which was a spinster seeking her help to find love. Cianciulli instead drugged her and killed her, hiding the body in a closet. She cut her into pieces, put these into a pot and dissolved the body. She then used the dried blood as an ingredient in tea cakes, which she served to the neighbours and ate some herself. The second victim was treated exactly the same as the first. The final victim in 1940 underwent the same process of drugging and murder, however, Cianciulli decided to use this final body for soap as well as cakes, giving her her nickname.

Cianciulli was not discovered until a family member of the final victim went looking into it. Initially she denied the alegations but confessed once the suspicion turned to her son. She was tried in 1946 and found guilty but remained unrepentant. She spent 30 years in prison and then 3 in a criminal asylum where she eventually passed away.


2. Dennis Rader

BTK Killer
ABC

This killer is better known by his alias BTK, which stands for 'bind, torture, kill', a name he creepily bestowed upon himself.

His first known crime is the murders of a family of 4 in Wichita in 1974. The bodies were discovered by their son as he came home from school, Rader later left a note in a library book detailing the exact method of the murders. He continued to send out letters including one to a television station that listed possible names from himself including the one that would eventually stick; BTK. Over the next 17 years he would attack many people, some of whom escaped but others were not so lucky.

The case went cold until 2004 when Rader began communicating with the police again. In these letters he confirmed that he murdered another woman which led to the reopening of the investigation and the use of modern DNA techniques to track him down. In another letter he asked if he would be safe to send things via a floppy disk, the police said it would. They used the metadata on this disk to find clues as to his identity, such as the last user to edit the document being named 'Dennis'.

Using this new information the police put a warrant out for Rader and arrested him in 2005. He was tried and found guilty on 10 counts of murder, although he is believed to have stalked many more potential victims.


1. Samuel Little

Samuel Little
ABC7 Chicago

Little is probably not a name you are yet familiar with as he was only convicted in 2012 and has been continuously confessing to murders, the most recent confession came in 2019.

His crimes began as early as 1961 with him breaking into a store, he was then arrested 26 times over the next 14 years. These were not yet murder charges though, his first murder charge would come in 1982 for the murder of a 22 year old. He was then passed to another investigation which was unfortunately thrown out due to distrust in the witnesses.

Upon his release he moved and began a series of attacks on women, he was arrested and served two years for these crimes but once released continued his reign of terror. It is believed he murdered at least 10 more women during this time.

He was arrested in 2012 for drug charges but then DNA evidence connected him to multiple murders from the 80s. Following this DNA trail he was charged in 2014 on multiple counts of murder and has been in prison since 2016. During his time in prison he has been slowly confessing to more and more violent acts, often drawing pictures of the women he's killed.


In this post: 
True Crime
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Danni Scott hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.