16 Commonly Held Amish Myths Busted!
Is it all bibles, beards and butter or do the Amish have a few tricks up their homemade sleeves?
Ahh, the Amish. That peculiar unfamiliar American religious sect perceived by most as as simple folk enjoying a fancy-free lifestyle that predates the industrial revolution.
They're a group of Christian followers that enforce strict religious doctrine topped off with a small amount of Luddite craziness. Locally they're known for shunning technology, awful bowl-cut hair styles, birthing offspring on the hour, tireless agriculture and taking bi-annual showers.
Believing in literal interpretations of Biblical texts and possessing a desire to shy away from contemporary society, the Amish exist in a prosaic farming world all to themselves.
Their existence is rather similar to M. Knight Shyalaman's rather poor movie "The Village" - but without the unnecessary "it was all set in modern times" twist. The truth is the Amish are completely aware of current society and indeed as will be shown they sometimes take part in it. Yet many facets of their lives are a mystery to the general population and are often misunderstood.
So let's raise a barn, churn some butter and party like it's 1899 (thanks Weird Al) as it's time to dispel sixteen commonly held yet inaccurate Amish myths.
16. Myth - The Amish Don't Pay Taxes
Two things are certain in life - death and taxes and whilst the former will hit us all, the latter may only applicable to some.
Yet contrary to popular belief, Amish folk are not tax exempt on either a local or state level. They pay sales tax, income tax, federal, business and property taxes just like every other American Joe. That's VAT, inland revenue, poll tax, rates and more to us Brits.
Many Americans believe and indeed are sometimes very resentful that the Amish folk get off lightly regarding paying their dues when in reality they do not. This misconception probably stems from their lack of contribution to the United States Social Security fund which provides unemployment benefits, pensions and health care. However, they also do not collect such welfare, relying instead on their own financial collective to help fellow brethren out during hard times.
One of the biggest complaints levied against the Amish religion and its followers is this full on completely tax-free myth status and it's one that they simply do not have.
15. Myth - Tattoos And Vanity Are Forbidden
For a group of people who detest self-centered gratification it's no surprise that cosmetic make-up and tattoos are totally off the menu for the Amish. Tattoos and vanity are specifically unacceptable since they're mentioned in the Bible and so a tatted-up male Amish bloke or strumpet-painted Amish lass isn't something that is prevalent in their society.
Amish are human though and humans sometimes like bending the rules just a tad. Such as when young women folk put juice squeezed from wild berries on their lips and cheeks to add a little colour to their often pale faces.
Sun tan lotion applied to their skin in interesting swirly designs is sometimes used as well and thus when working in the fields under the extreme heat of the Pennsylvanian sun they get a hefty sun burn - except in the place where they put the lotion on.
A temporary solar tattoo created by blocking the sun isn't quite the spectacle as a full-blown tattooed back piece or sleeve but it is kind of awesome in its own quaint way. Rather clever if you ask me.
14. Myth - They Can Only Travel Using Horse And Carts
The Amish residing in the Pennsylvanian area of Lancaster County decided that chains and cogs were verboten for transport and so they actually use several interesting means of short-distance vehicular perambulation that forgoes the use of gears.
One of the most common being a pedal-less bike; a "Draisienne" that is straddled and then propelled by running. No chains, sprockets or gears, just a lump of wood and leather as a seat and two wheels to roll on. Like the Flintstones but with less industry.
It's also common to see young Amish men on scooters - home made wooden crate-like ones like Marty McFly broke, in turn inventing the skateboard in "Back To The Future". Not the easiest way of traversing ten miles but presumably preferable to walking.
But the coolest method of travel they use though is roller skates! Yes, witness the Amish at their most rad when a whole bunch of young men rocking straw hats race down the country lanes like they're participating in Pilgrim Rollerball.
It's one of the many strange anachronisms a visitor to Amish country can see that totally bursts the bubble of expected behaviour from these gentle antiquated folk.
13. Myth - Their Horses Are A Cute Tourist Attraction
When visiting historic cities like New York or Savannah, Georgia the sights can be enjoyed in luxury by riding in a fancy horse drawn buggy through the streets. One piece of horse livery that these high-end tourist equines have in common is they wear large nappies so the inevitable rear-end outpourings don't spoil the clean streets.
Horses for the Amish are mere tools; labour saving devices utilized solely to aid transportation or farming and are not intended to be tourist attractions for those eager to travel back to a simpler time. Unfortunately, therefore, in rural Amish areas, pony diapers are not enforced like they are in the big cities and so the horses just dump a fat load where ever they feel like it - many times a day.
Amish towns have scores of families each with at least two horses for transportation so with that amount of four legged beasts trotting about the roads are often coated in unpleasant stinky Sea Biscuits.
Despite horse dung being some of the more acceptable turds from the animal kingdom, the 40C degree heat often endured in lower Pennsylvania results in horse pooh pies getting a tad rank.
Not quite the idyllic image that pretty postcards of Amish horses may portray.
12. Myth - They Cannot Leave The Amish Society
Is it possible to break free from the biblical bonds of Amish jail?
Well, yes. An Amish person can leave at any time he or she chooses but on top of that they can actually be kicked out under severe circumstances.
They have internal laws beyond the scope of regular ones so while murdering someone, something almost unheard of in the Amish community, would obviously send them to real-world prison, committing other acts that wouldn't normally lead to criminal prosecution can end with something just as bad.
The rather unfortunately named "Meidung" is the result of Amish crimes such as adultery or not keeping the faith. It's a shunning of literally Biblical proportions where the person in question would be cast out never to see their house, friends or family again. Imagine a buddy dropping a hammer on his foot thus letting out some choice expletives surrounding the Lord and Saviour only for him to suddenly disappear forever.
The shun is permanent and rarely can it be undone. Once an Amish chap is sent to Coventry they don't come back.
11. Myth - No Booze, Parties Or Having Fun
In the US they have spring break; a giant nationwide piss-up where overly hormonal twenty somethings get wasted and for some reason they tip cars over and riot.
The Amish are not without their own very toned down version and that is known as Rumspringa. Being that becoming a member of the Amish is usually a lifetime commitment, the elders do realise such a choice cannot be made without incurring some curiosity about the big wild world out there. So for one single year, Amish younglings are free to join society, drink, drive cars and behave like regular folks in their late teens and see what the fuss is all about.
After Rumspringa is over though they then have to make a choice - join the church, get married and have half a dozen kids or alternatively get some fierce Meidung thrown at them in the shape a good old fashioned shun.
10. Myth - They Lack Education
The Amish have their own schools and as might be expected the curriculum does concentrate on simpler topics including teachings from the Good Book. However, the Amish are renowned for their excellent woodworking, building and architectural design skills as well as extended knowledge of raising animals, agriculture and farming techniques.
The Amish also speak English very well but when conversing with each other they communicate in what is known as Pennsylvania Dutch and so are at the very least bilingual. Therefore they're in some ways more educated than the majority of Americans in terms of language and basic survival.
Pennsylvania Dutch may sound like a strange, guttural language on hearing it but to some it might be very familiar. They're actually talking in a variation of German, the clue being the Dutch portion of the name (the word Dutch derives from Deutschland). UK school kids who opted to take a couple of years of German would therefore find it relatively easy to understand their native tongue despite some dialect differences.
As a footnote, it's more than a little ironic that a steadfastly pacifist people who choose a simple technology-free life should speak the language of a nation known for incredible technological advancements... and that whole repeatedly starting world wars thing.
9. Myth - They Don't Use Electricity
Ah the big one! If an American is asked what is so unique about the Amish people the most likely answer would be that they are not allowed to use electricity.
Surprisingly this is quite wrong.
Whilst it is true they are not on the electrical grid and therefore their houses do not have electricity, it is false that they don't use it. They do so in many forms, from generator driven water pumps to wind turbines to solar powered lighting. They use all manner of electrically juiced power tools and employ battery-powered equipment such as the running lights for driving their horse buggies at night.
The ethos is simply that they do not want to be part of the big system, part of the infrastructure of a modern society, but there's no problem with electricity that has been generated in-house.
Much like the tax issue covered in the opening item, this is one of the most common misconceptions about the Amish.
8. Myth - They Can't Use Cars
The Amish ride horse-drawn buggies and drive their horse-powered farming equipment on the roads but they do not drive cars. This much is true and is a situation not too dissimilar to the electrical issue where driving a car would require a license, insurance, inspections etc and thus would place them firmly on the grid and so is forbidden.
Riding as a car passenger is fine though and the Amish actually hire local folk to take them places too far to travel by conventional Amish transport. There are several civilian people near every Southern Pennsylvanian town who supplement their income by acting as a minicab service solely aimed at driving the Amish around.
But before anyone quits their day job to start Amish Uber Cab Service it's important to remember that these fine hard-working folk are indeed real farmers and are often covered in sweat, dirt and the previously mentioned horse droppings when they get in the car - bring some tarp.
7. Myth - Only Amish People Are Allowed In
Another very common myth is that only Amish people can join local communities, presumably from other Amish areas and thus inbreeding is rife due to this enclosed blue blood system.
Whilst I personally have indeed seen some rather... erm, strange looking young Amish men whose features do betray a life of family love, anyone can join an Amish society. That is if they're sufficiently determined and willing to leave material goods behind and put the requisite work in. It may take local elders some convincing of such a commitment but if successful, a married couple or even a single person can join the clan.
A person intending to convert to the Amish church should have cash to buy a farm as well as some serious farming chops so it's no cakewalk to regress to Amish life.
6. Myth - Kids Are Conceived For Free Farm Labour
From practically the moment they are born, Amish children are employees of the parental farm. They earn their keep and they work very hard doing so.
Educational studies are of course also part of growing up but so is milking cows, collecting corn or tobacco and tending to the animals. Each member of an Amish family has to pull their weight regardless of their age.
But the young ones are actually hired to work and aren't mere free labour. Not paid directly though - the money is put aside every year until they're an adult. It is then theirs so they have a nest egg at an early age to build on and use to put a down payment on an Amish farm of their own.
Contrast that to non-Amish Americans who coast through life for free until they're twenty-one and then suddenly incur massive almost unsurmountable debt the moment they step in to the US college system.
5. Myth - They Can't Cut Their Facial Hair
In many cultures there are visual ways of announcing a person's romantic status such as the very prevalent engagement and wedding ring system which many western countries use.
Not surprisingly the Amish do things a little differently and it's all down to facial hair or lack thereof. When an Amish man is clean shaven it indicates that he is not married. Amish partnerships are not pre-arranged, again contrary to popular belief, and an Amish bloke is free to marry whichever spinster will put up with his musky scent. So the lack of mutton chops is a good way of saying "Hey ladies, I'm single!".
Upon marriage however the man must indeed then grow a beard and never ever cut it - but this hairy face comes with a big caveat; no mustaches are allowed. This rule is a throwback from when the US military required that all enlisted men sport a mustache and, since the Amish are pacifists, they refused to grow one.
Even though this Army mandate was abolished over a hundred years ago, the conspicuously missing upper lip fluff continues to this day.
4. Myth - Local People Resent The Amish
Aside from the horse dung, the Amish also cause congestion on the roads as they travel in their slow buggies around the rural neighbourhood. This can result in accidents and sadly even sometimes fatalities as car and buggy collisions are a very real and unfortunate event.
Despite the inconvenience of sharing the roads with vehicles that sport a mere two horse power, most locals accept and welcome the Amish. Not only do they bring in tourism, they support local businesses and offer fresh produce and tours of their farms and facilities.
It's not unusual to see dedicated parking spots for horse and buggies found everywhere from outside small hardware stores to the local Post Offices. Add to that, the Amish do not attempt to recruit outsiders so no door-to-door knocking at eight in the morning, no judgment day style "The world is nigh!" signs on roadsides and no missionary desire to convert any one to their religious choices.
The Amish are indeed unusual and have a radically different lifestyle but they are welcomed by most modern towns' people.
3. Myth - It's Forbidden To Take Their Photo
A photo of the Amish can be taken without them feeling some evil device has swallowed their souls - but most of them would prefer just to be merely left alone.
Tourists are thus encouraged to use sound judgment when snapping a keepsake of them. The Amish are hard-working folk who desire privacy and respect hence the reluctance to have their photo willy nilly. Most people toiling at their job would find a noisy group of paparazzi sightseers clicking away to be an annoyance especially since the Amish's job is actually located on their homestead too.
But if politely asked there's a good chance permission would be granted. If the visitor buys a few shoo-fly homemade pies before they leave they may even get a tour of the place and the opportunity to get an inside look of the workings of a real old school farm.
2. Myth - They Construct Huge Churches For Worship
Many United States' religious organizations build quite obscene, extravagant churches that rival the largest of European cathedrals. On the beltway towards Washington DC there's a place so large and visible someone has spray painted "Surrender Dorothy!" on a flyover nearby.
But the Amish have no emerald city of Oz, no giant church compound in which to pray - in fact they have no churches at all. The Amish rotate from house to house every sabbath requiring each home to be able to accommodate the entire community. After the religious gathering the Amish eat, share stories and play in the summer sun, their game of choice often being volleyball.
It's quite a sight to see scores of brilliantly constructed and impeccably cleaned buggies parked in a line as the families play ball into the evening by gas light.
1. Myth - They Have Never Used TVs Or Cellphones
Obviously during their travels, especially during Rumspringa, the Amish witness commonplace technology that average folk take for granted, so their familiarity of things like phones, laptops and TVs is to be expected.
Naturally they don't own such devices and can't use them under their own rules... Well the Amish have a naughty little secret and that's many of them have hidden barns, trailers and sheds containing cellphones and computers and TVs. Yes despite their pious lifestyle and success in avoiding the techie trappings of today, they're not beyond falling from grace, however self-imposed, and some do indeed own the forbidden fruit.
Even Xboxes and Playstations and the porn-laden internet can be found in such private quarters. In all honesty though if all there was to do in life was play volleyball, plough fields and read the Bible surely most folks would fancy a cheeky game of Farming Simulator from time to time.
If the Amish folk are guilty of anything it's that they are merely human and so are susceptible to the same temptations put in front of every one... and if they slip from time to time, well really, who can blame them?
They're not so different from the rest of the world after all.