10 Chelsea Players Who Weren't Worth The Hassle

Chelsea put a lot of time into all their signings. Shame they aren't always worth it.

Signings at a major club are the result of months, sometimes years of extensive scouting and research. They are the result of collective agreements between the manager, board members and often a director of football over the needs and aspiration of the team and what one or more players can offer to bring those aspirations a little closer. Even when the player has been officially signed, the work is far from over. Even the right player needs to be carefully integrated into a team, given time to find their feet in new surroundings and the training to make the best of their talent and justify their cost. Sometimes players repay that trust with performances that elevate the club to heights never before imagined. Frank Lampard was deemed overpriced when he signed for Chelsea for £11 million from West Ham, yet his dedication in training and trust from various managers allowed him to flourish into perhaps the best midfielder of his generation and one of the best in Chelsea's history. Unfortunately, there are plenty of players who don't go on to achieve that same level of success and for various reasons never come close to fulfilling what was expected of them. Sometimes this is down to the player, often because of greed or arriving at the club under the wrong circumstances. For that type of player, check out my list of 10 Players Who Stole A Living From Chelsea. These are the players who, often through no fault of their own, just found Chelsea to be the wrong place at the wrong time despite all the club's effort in getting them there.

10. Jiri Jarosik

Jiri Jarosik was signed to bring a bit of power to Chelsea's midfield. As a youngster, the Czech enjoyed an extremely successful start to his career with Sparta Prague, where he scored 20 goals in 101 appearances. At 6ft 5, he had the presence and strength to dominate the middle of the field both aerially and on the ground, using his long stride to push his team forward after winning the ball. He left Prague for CSKA Moscow for $3.5 million, a record fee for a Russian club at the time and no doubt one of many factors which caught the watchful eyes of Chelsea's scouting team. Two years later, he was picked up by Jose Mourinho's Blues at a cost of £3 million, an inexpensive buy but one which was believed would provide a perfect middle man between Claude Makelele's total focus on defence and Frank Lampard's tendency to make expertly timed runs forward. He was expected to be a replacement for playmaker Tiago Mendes, an early Mourinho signing who, barring one thunderbolt against Manchester United, was solid but never truly hit his stride in the Premier League. Unfortunately, the situation proved even worse for Jarosik, who struggled greatly with the step-up from Russian football and looked consistently off the pace, technically ropey and poor in his decision making. Even at £3 million, Jarosik proved something of a disaster and was first shipped off on loan to Birmingham, then a permanent deal to Celtic, where he enjoyed slightly greater success over two years. With a total of just 20 appearances to his name in Chelsea blue, most of them dreadful, Jarosik must go down as one of the most misjudged signings of the Abramovich era and one of Mourinho's all-time worst.

9. Alexei Smertin

The Russian midfielder was picked up from Bordeaux in Abramovich's first transfer window amid a splurge on some truly top level talent. No-one really believed Smertin fit that category and apparently neither did Chelsea, shipping him off immediately on loan to Portsmouth and rather hilariously labelling him 'one for the future'. He was 28 at the time. Smertin nevertheless gave a decent show of himself at Pompey, proving himself an assertive presence in midfield and helping the newly promoted club to an unexpected 14th place finish. He subsequently demanded a chance to prove himself at his parent club and was welcomed under the wing of new manager Jose Mourinho, where he made 16 appearances as the club won the Premier League for the first time since 1955. Unfortunately, with Lampard, Makelele, Tiago and Scott Parker as competition, the Russian was mostly fielded from the bench and never looked likely to displace Lampard and Makelele, even with Tiago and Parker having similar difficulty adapting to the demands of the club. Smertin left the club on loan once again, with a season at Charlton seeing him hit good form once again and earning a transfer to Dynamo Moscow the following year for £1 million. The Russian was a hard worker and a solid midfield cog, but never looked like a player able to reach the level expected of a Chelsea player. The question of why he was signed in the first place persists, with many believing it may have been new Blues owner Roman Abramovich doing a favour for one of his mysterious oligarch mates. Chelsea didn't lose too much money on him and got a decent squad player in Mourinho's first season, so while he certainly wasn't a complete waste of time, it's just baffling why the club picked him up to begin with.

8. Lassana Diarra

Diarra, or Lass as he is now known, saw his reputation soar very early in his career thanks to a number of assured performances in Le Havre's midfield which saw him compared to Claude Makelele, who was proving himself instrumental in Chelsea's midfield. Chelsea swooped in and picked up the youngster, hoping that he would one day fulfill his destiny and one day take over the defensive midfield role which Makelele had locked down so successfully it was subsequently named after him. Diarra was still young at the time and was given limited opportunities in the first team, most of them coming off the bench. While Chelsea and Mourinho saw this as a gradual learning process, Diarra was less impressed at his manager's seeming refusal to share his firm belief that he was already good enough for the first team. Nevertheless, he was named Young Player Of The Year in 05/06 and saw more extensive playtime in his sophomore season, albeit most often as a right-back when a spate of injuries took their toll on the club's defensive options. Diarra still wasn't happy and with his contract about to expire, Chelsea sold him to Arsenal in 2007, citing a desire to work under Arsene Wenger, who had an excellent reputation for bringing youth prospects into his first team. Diarra's impatience got the better of him once again at Arsenal, leading to him being sold on to Portsmouth and then, incredibly, Real Madrid, where he finally started to look worthy of his early accolades. Mourinho's arrival at the Bernabeu signalled the end of his career there and he was shipped off to the newly flush Anzhi in Russia. Diarra was another player who didn't cost Chelsea much other than time, but his refusal to accept the need for time to convert potential into existing ability meant he never became the world beater expected of him.

7. Salomon Kalou

In contrast to Diarra, whose attitude was all wrong from the start and eventually led to his downfall, Ivorian forward Salomon Kalou was a hard worker who accepted the need for him to prove himself worthy of a first team place. He was a favourite among the Chelsea players and staff, enjoying a long stay at the club before eventually moving to Lille after six years. So what was the problem? Quite simply that despite both the club and the player doing more or less everything right, the early potential hinted at in his nascent years at Feyenoord, where he scored 35 goals in 69 appearances, never transformed him into the world class player many had expected. He actually scored some important goals for Chelsea, but was deeply inconsistent and never managed to hold down a first team place or score more than 10 league goals in a single season. It should be noted that despite struggling to produce the goods on a regular basis, he nevertheless ended up in double figures for goals and assists in his second and third seasons. His 60 goals and 40 assists across just over 250 appearances in all competitions for the Blues certainly isn't bad by any means, yet he never really looked like taking the step up from being a good player to a great one. Having cost the club £9 million in 2006, he left for a free in 2012. You won't find many fans bearing any grudges against him as he was likeable, professional and positive throughout, but his was one of those unfortunate instances where his talent peaked far earlier than expected.

6. Raul Meireles

Despite having the haircut of a Resident Evil villain, Meireles never made much of an impression at Chelsea. One of many caught in the collateral damage of Fernando Torres' abject failure, he was signed as another high profile player from Liverpool who would supposedly help the Spaniard feel at home at Stamford Bridge and recover his best form. Take a guess how well that turned out. The £12 million transfer fee was the second time Liverpool had taken Chelsea for a financial ride in six months, with the Portuguese supposedly intended to direct the play from deep but mostly ended up standing around looking utterly lost and perhaps wondering where the rest of his hair went. Perhaps he knew all along that he hadn't been the club's first choice, having pushed Tottenham hard but ultimately unsuccessfully to secure a deal for Luka Modric, or perhaps having to fill the huge boots of the severely injured club hero Michael Essien was just too much pressure for a player who was never particularly dynamic to begin with. Either way, while he had his moments, particularly an excellent performance in the second leg of the Champions League semi-final vs Barcelona, he was quietly shuffled off to Fenerbahce for £8 million at the end of the season. The kindest thing that can be said about Raul Meireles' Chelsea career is that he was utterly forgettable, never descending to the depths of a Jiri Jarosik, having the lousy attitude of Lassana Diarra, but also having plenty of chances to impress and rarely managing to assert himself in any meaningful way. And let's be honest, that haircut is probably one of the worst ever seen at Stamford Bridge... and we had Jason 'Pineapple' Lee.

5. Yuri Zhirkov

When Abramovich took over the running of the club, many (somewhat patronisingly) expected an influx of Russian players as a means of enhancing the prospects of the national team. Alexei Smertin's incomprehensible signing may have strengthened that impression, but he was one of only two so far - although we were linked with Alan Dzagoyev for a while - with the other being CSKA's highly rated left midfielder, Yuri Zhirkov. Picked up for £18 million in the same summer as Andriy Arshavin moved to Arsenal for a similarly lofty £15 million, neither Russian covered themselves in glory and failed to find a place in either team. Zhirkov's problem was that Chelsea already had strong options in both his chosen positions, with Malouda finally coming into his own in the left forward position of Carlo Ancelotti's 4-3-3 and Ashley Cole immovable as first choice left-back. Ultimately it was as backup to Cole where Zhirkov saw most of his action, particularly when the England full-back was ruled out for three months that Christmas. He still only managed 27 appearances in his first season and 21 in his second, playing reasonably well but often denied the opportunity to play in his preferred position further up the field. He finally moved back to Russia in 2011, signing for Anzhi for £13.2 million. He was a player Chelsea had reportedly been looking at for a long time and while it was clear that he certainly had plenty of talent, it just happened to be the wrong time for him to arrive in London and another strange case of the club making a big signing they clearly had no room for.

4. Hernan Crespo

A marquee early signing of the Abramovich era, Crespo reportedly took some convincing to leave Inter Milan, who seemingly only sold the player to pull off some rather shifty accounting tricks. The Argentine never looked or acted like he was particularly enthusiastic playing for his new club and despite arriving with a big reputation, only managed a disappointing 12 goals in his first season and didn't look too fussed about frequently losing his place to veteran striker Jimmy Floyd Hassebaink. His attitude off the field was reportedly no better than on it, with younger players becoming disillusioned at all the allowances that Crespo was given for his bad behaviour. That quickly changed once the avuncular Claudio Ranieri was shown the door and Jose Mourinho came storming back through it, immediately picking up the striker for his lack of professionalism. The legend goes that with Crespo called into his new boss' office and several players listening at the door outside, the Argentine feigned an inability to speak English as a way of mocking Mourinho, only for the Portuguese to immediately swap languages and continue his rant, twice as assertively, in Italian. While possibly an urban legend, it has been pinpointed as the moment Mourinho won the squad's respect and Crespo was shuffled off on loan to Milan, making room for Didier Drogba. With Drogba not fully convincing in his first season and drawing supporters' ire for repeated diving and unsportsmanlike behaviour, Crespo was given a second chance at Chelsea but despite scoring a barnstomer in the club's Premier League opener against Wigan, he looked just as disaffected in his second spell as his first, beating his original goal tally by only one despite managing eleven more appearances. Not many players have had two chances to prove their worth and looked so bored on both occasions. You'd think the club would've learnt their lesson about signing players based on reputation alone, but a certain Spaniard certainly disproved that six years later.

3. Deco

Deco was a player had supposedly been looking at since Jose Mourinho's first arrival at Chelsea, yet it took until 2008 for the club to finally secure his signature. The naturalised Portuguese playmaker was supposedly convinced to move from Barcelona by his former national team boss, Luiz Filipe Scolari, who had recently taken the reins at Stamford Bridge. Unfortunately, by that time Deco's form was already in decline and his age on the rise, reflected in the relatively cheap £10 million fee Chelsea paid to get him on their books. He started well, scoring some impressive goals - include a thirty yarder on his debut - as Scolari's Chelsea broke out of the blocks at full speed. Concerns about the Brazilian coach's slack training routines and lack of tactical variety soon arose as that early form began to crumble, with Deco's form mirroring his manager's fall from grace. After losing his place for much of the remaining season, he made public his unhappiness at the club and desire to leave, though Carlo Ancelotti convinced him to stay. His second season proved just as woeful as his first and he looked distinctly out of place as Ancelotti quickly instilled a sense of pride and confidence back in a Chelsea team which had faded badly from the unstoppable force of the Mourinho years. It was to little surprise and few tears when Deco finally said his farewells, joining Fluminense on a free in 2010. Having been on Chelsea's radar for so long, the player ultimately arrived in his twilight years and looked utterly lost once Scolari was deservedly shown the door after six months.

2. Juan Sebastian Veron

Juan Veron was very close to getting on my list of 10 Players Who Stole A Living From Chelsea. He cost a lot, barely played and left with his once stratospheric reputation brought decisively back down to earth. So why is he is on this list rather than that one? The first is that he actually managed a couple of decent performances for Chelsea, but saw his season cut short after picking up a particularly nasty injury. He bore the considerable brunt of manager Claudio Ranieri's abysmal decision to bring him on in a crunch Champions League game against Monaco when he was clearly unfit, resulting in the club crashing out of the competition despite being in a strong position with opposition Monaco down to ten men. More unpleasantly, in the middle of his stay in London, his family home was broken into and he and his children threatened with machetes by robbers, a traumatic event which supposedly spurred his desire to leave England. In other words, while he was undoubtedly a terrible signing, picked up for £15 million despite having failed abysmally at Manchester United the season before, it seemed rather unsympathetic to say he 'stole' a wage from the club when circumstances never gave him much of a chance to do any better. This one feels more like the result of the manager making a lousy call, with Ranieri specifically pinpointing the Argentine as a player he wanted and convincing him to try one more season in England after Sir Alex Ferguson expressed a willingness to let him go. While his first appearance proved a great success with a goal in Chelsea's 2-1 victory at bogey ground Anfield, that ended up being the only goal he scored during his time at the club and only one of seven league appearances before seeing out the remainder of his contract on loan at Inter and Estudiantes.

1. Andriy Shevchenko

Not too long after my first list was published, I received a text asking why Shevchenko hadn't been included. After all, he arrived at vast expense, with his £30.8 million transfer breaking the record for the highest amount paid for a single player by a British club. He was reportedly a long-term target for Roman Abramovich, who was friends with the Ukrainian striker and had reportedly made an astonishing bid of ‚75 million PLUS Hernan Crespo for the striker the previous season, with now former chief executive Peter Kenyon confirming him as the type of player Chelsea were looking to sign. They finally got their man in 2008 after the Ukranian put in a transfer request. Word on the street was that Mourinho had not been involved in the transfer and was unimpressed at having to accomodate the 30-year old in his squad. Nevertheless, Shevchenko was still considered one of the deadliest strikers on the planet despite his age, having scored 28 goals the preceding season. As with Veron, things got off to a good start with him scoring a real poacher's effort in an otherwise underwhelming 2-1 loss to Liverpool in the Community Shield. His first Premier League goal didn't take too long in arriving either, despite once again proving Chelsea's only goal in a 2-1 defeat, this time to Middlesbrough. Things went downhill from there as despite showing a truly outstanding work rate, he never looked a good fit for Mourinho's tactics and ultimately lost his place, an act of defiance from the manager which was rumoured to be one of the reasons for the growing discord between he and Roman Abramovich. Mourinho left the following season but with questions still lingering about the state of Shevchenko's fitness, the goals never came. The club agreed to loan him back to Milan, where despite his heroic status, he failed to score in eighteen league appearances. In 2009, he left permanently for Dinamo Kyiv, retiring three years later at the club where his incredible career had begun. No-one could deny that Shevchenko put in an enormous amount of effort at Chelsea, a fact which ensured supporters always applauded him even while he struggled to find the net. As a vanity signing by Abramovich, forced on a manager who didn't want him and placed in a system he didn't fit, it was never likely to end well. Personally, though, I'd put this disastrous transfer squarely on the club rather than the player.

Contributor
Contributor

28-year old English writer with a borderline obsessive passion for films, videogames, Chelsea FC, incomprehensible words and indefensible puns. Follow me on Twitter if you like infrequent outbursts of absolute drivel.