10 Incredible Premier League "What Ifs"
I swear, you'll never see anything like this...
The Barclay's Premier League is widely believed to be the most competitive, most viewed and most adored footballing competition in the world. Fans across the globe can be seen wearing replica kits bearing the names of their idols even if they will never have the opportunity to see them play live.
Many fans dream of managing Premier League clubs and invest hundreds of hours into management simulators to live out their own 'what if' scenarios. Some take the likes of Leyton Orient from the foot of the Football League to European glory and others slot themselves in at Man City to buy the biggest names and walk their way to the title.
Given that the 'what if' style of play is so engaging, what if the history of the Premier League were ever so slightly (or massively) different? Chaos Theory tells us that if the gunner on the Star Destroyer had shot down the pod containing R2D2 and C-3PO, Luke Skywalker would never have overthrown the Empire so surely the same theory can be applied to football.
With such a rich and varied history to the Premier League, not every avenue can be explored and much of what can be speculated on centres on the biggest and most successful clubs... but would they have always been the biggest and the most successful?
10. Man Utd sack Sir Alex in 1988
Back in 1986, Alex Ferguson was building quite a reputation for himself as a competent manager with Aberdeen - he led the club to three league titles and even European glory so it was never going to be long before he was touted for something bigger.
Replacing Ron Atkinson in November '86, Ferguson set about straightening out his inherited squad but failed to win a single piece of silverware until the now iconic FA Cup victory in 1989/90. Nowadays, this failure to succeed at such a big club would have spelt the end for the manager and if Manchester United had listened to the cries of their fans, things would be very different.
After two and a half seasons of misery, fans called for Alex Ferguson to be sacked, and then-Everton manager Howard Kendall was rumoured to be the club's preferred replacement. Had Kendall come in, Ferguson's squad would likely have returned to their drinking culture and depression would have set in amongst the group once more.
Kendall's style was in no way similar to Ferguson's attacking passion play and it is almost assured that United would've have fallen out of the First Division at the end of 88/89. A mass exodus of players would have ensued and you can all but forget about the Class of '92 ever breaking their way into footballing history.
9. Newcastle win the league in 95/96
Mind games are very common in modern football with the likes of Jose Mourinho employing the tactic to unnerve the opposition before anyone even sets foot on the pitch. Back in the 1990s, managers seemingly had quiet respect for one another and tended not to lash out as football retained something of a thuggish yet gentlemanly appeal.
However as the 95/96 season drew to a tense conclusion, Alex Ferguson's comments riled Newcastle United manager Kevin Keegan to such an extent that the red mist descended during a now iconic interview and he decreed that he would 'love it' if United were to lose to Middlesbrough and all but hand his side the Premiership title.
Had United lost to Middlesbrough and Newcastle beat Spurs on the final day, Keegan's rant would have gone down as one of the greatest rallying cries in football history - a passionate speech instead of a misguided tantrum. Newcastle would have joined the elite few to lift the Premier League trophy and Manchester United's plans would have been very, very different.
Alex Ferguson was believed to be very interested in signing Alan Shearer from Blackburn Rovers in 1996 and losing out on the title to Newcastle United would no doubt have seen the club go all out to sign the talismanic forward. Would Shearer have led Ferguson's side to success? Probably not; an exorbitant transfer fee would have heightened the pressure on him to perform.
As for Newcastle, much like Blackburn and Leicester City, you can only think that they would have been one season wonders and Keegan would have been dismissed after spending the title winning profits on lesser players than he already had at his disposal.
8. Joey Barton doesn't get sent off against Man City
One of the most iconic moments in Premier League history, Sergio Aguero's last minute winner against QPR secured Man City's first Premier League title and finally justified the club's massive spending habit since their takeover in 2008.
The game itself is hailed as one of the most competitive games ever in the Premier League but, in truth, that was only the case up until the 55th minute as QPR lost their chief enforcer (and former City midfielder) Joey Barton. The foul tempered QPR captain was dismissed for violent conduct following a challenge on Carlos Tevez and City went on to take advantage of their numerical advantage - but what if Barton had kept his cool?
Had Joey Barton kept his temper in check, QPR would have retained their intimidation factor that was causing so many issues for their flair players: David Silva & Samir Nasri. Both of City's creative midfielders were constantly under high pressure either from Barton himself or one of his teammates, spurred on by his aggressive encouragement.
Mario Balotelli joined the fray in the 76th minute and proved to be the one to slot the ball to Aguero but had Barton been on the pitch, the flamboyant Italian would have had a serious task on his hands to get past the QPR captain and it's entirely possible the game would have ended in a famous victory for Rangers.
Had City lost the title on the final day, Roberto Mancini almost certainly would have been given his marching orders and Barton would hold a place in Manchester United folklore as the man who quashed the noisy neighbours.
7. Eric Cantona captains Man Utd in 98/99
Eric Cantona's decision to retire at the end of the 96/97 season came as a shock to football fans worldwide. Just 30 years old, King Eric's interest in the beautiful game had waned and some believe United's defeat at the hands of Borussia Dortmund in the Champions' League semi-finals was the catalyst that led Eric to his decision.
Cantona had only captained the side for a single season, replacing Steve Bruce for the 96/97 season, but his mercurial presence was greatly lessened and his leadership of the young United squad was somewhat maverick and could have done more harm than good.
If Cantona had continued on and captained the team in the exceptional 98/99 season, the players around him wouldn't have benefited from Roy Keane's never-say-die attitude which was so important throughout the Treble winning year. Take the must-win Champion's League semi-final tie with Juventus as the prime example - Keano picked up a yellow card that meant he would miss the final (should United progress) and he did everything he could to ensure his team mates reached the Nou Camp.
Would Cantona have done the same if he knew he wouldn't play a part in the final? Would the Frenchman have spurred his colleagues on in the same emphatic style? You have to imagine not as no one could ever do what Roy Keane did that night.
As such, there would probably have been no treble, possibly not even a double or a single, and Eric Cantona's status as a United legend wouldn't be anything like it is in reality. The seagulls would definitely be following a different trawler.
6. Gareth Bale joins Man City
Back in 2006, Southampton left back Gareth Bale was starting to turn heads for his abilities at set pieces and the raw pace he has become so well known for - Tottenham Hotspur beat off their rivals to secure his services for a paltry fee but he had to wait for his chance at stardom.
Injuries and inconsistent form saw motormouth Benoit Assou-Ekoto preferred to Bale at left back and it wasn't until the South African suffered his own injuries woes that Harry Redknapp felt he could take a chance on the Welshman - fast forward to 2020 and Bale is a Galactico at Real Madrid... sort of.
However, in 2013, Real Madrid weren't the only party interested in signing Gareth Bale as the two Manchester clubs loomed over the transfer negotiations. In truth, Bale was closer to United than City but the financial firepower the Etihad side have at their disposal could have persuaded Bale to reject Madrid.
Had he opted to join City, he would have been the ultimate final piece in the City squad and the club's dominance of the Premier League and domestic cups would have been long lasting indeed. European glory is questionable but Bale's electric pace and inevitable cut backs to Sergio Aguero would have seen the pair leading City as talismans - Bale would no doubt have challenged Messi & Ronaldo for the Balon d'Or from the very beginning too.
We still might see Bale at City but his massive wages and his knackered ligaments mean we'll never see the best he could have offered.
5. Transfer Fees Were Capped After Rio Ferdinand Joins Man Utd
When adjusted for inflation, Andriy Shevchenko's move to Chelsea in 2006 is the most expensive Premier League transfer of all time - the deal would be worth £144.4 million in today's money and what a waste of time it turned out to be.
But this would never have come to pass if FIFA had stepped in when Rio Ferdinand crossed the great divide from Leeds United to Manchester United in 2002. The record breaking deal is actually worth roughly £121 million in modern money and things started to escalate massively after this deal went through.
Transfer fees in excess of £20/30 million became common and less than ten years after Rio joined United, Fernando Torres left Liverpool for Chelsea in the first Premier League £50 million deal. Fast forward to present day and £100 million is starting to look like chump change.
Had a transfer cap been installed in 2002, mega deals would still go ahead but wages would become the real currency in the transfer market. So instead of lavishing multiple millions on fees, the players would have the power demand whatever they wanted if clubs wanted to secure their services.
Inevitably, we would have seen a player earning £1 million a week way back in the early noughties and you can all but guarantee it would have been Goldenballs himself: David Beckham.
4. Sir Alex Retires One Season Later
Sir Alex Ferguson's decision to retire after the 2012/13 campaign shocked the footballing world and no-one more so than his squad of players - especially the newly arrived Robin Van Persie who spent just one season with the Scotsman despite assurances he would be sticking around for a little while longer.
Ferguson's legacy is unquestionably superb and one of the keys to the success he enjoyed was his ability to overhaul a squad and rebuild it with youth and a couple of shrewd signings. At least three times Ferguson took the decision to clear out his squad and restructure it but had he decided to go on for another year, it was the squad that would be destined to let him down.
Looking at the team United finished the 12/13 season with, it's safe to say that the days of the superstars had long since passed with only Wayne Rooney, Robin Van Persie and David De Gea standing out as being potentially 'World Class'.
With this in mind, Ferguson would have been tasked with replacing his ageing centre back pairing of Ferdinand & Vidic along with the retired Paul Scholes, positively ancient Ryan Giggs and the rest of the squad made for woeful reading.
Anderson, Bebe, Nani, Evans, Welbeck, Jones, Cleverly, Kagawa, Buttner, Young and Nick Powell were all still on the wage bill at United and none of them were ever going to cut it - Ferguson would have had no choice but to utilise them and things would likely have gone in exactly the same way they did for David Moyes.
Maybe Fergie might've squeezed a Champion's League place but his reputation would have been tarnished forever.
3. Arsene Wenger was sacked in 12/13
Never has a Premier League manager lived on borrowed time for longer than Arsene Wenger. Replacing Bruce Rioch in 1996, Wenger introduced a beautiful passing game to Arsenal that truly unstuck their rivals in the early 2000's as his side became the Invincibles in 2003/04 but things were never so good again.
Consistently securing Champion's League qualification and equalling Manchester United's record total of FA Cup victories weren't enough for the fiercely passionate Arsenal supporters and 2012/13 was almost the end for the Frenchman as the fans were desperate for change - they had gone seven years without a trophy and their beloved captain: Robin Van Persie had been sold to eventual champions Man Utd for a seemingly insultingly low fee.
Had the Arsenal hierarchy listened to their riotous supporters and dismissed Wenger, the most likely candidate to have replaced him would have been Borussia Dortmund manager Jurgen Klopp. The charming German coming to Arsenal would have broken new ground for the club as Klopp definitely would have raided his former club for some of his favourites: Robert Lewandowski and Mats Hummels topping the list.
Game changing goal threat and solidity at the back reinvigorates the squad and Jack Wilshere finally fulfils his potential under Klopp, seizing his chance to become the club's midfield general and emulate Patrick Viera's approach to leadership.
Would Arsenal have won the league under Klopp or challenged for European glory? Absolutely they would have and the German tactician would be hailed as one of the greatest in Premier League history... something that is becoming ever more likely in reality.
2. Abramovich didn't buy Chelsea
Roman Abramovich's £140 million purchase of Chelsea Football Club in 2003 set a precedent in the Premier League like no other financial transaction has since. Something of a surprise move, Chelsea were a club notorious for being 'nearly men' and huge investment in the squad and coaching staff converted an average side into league champions.
Had Abramovich set his sights elsewhere and never invested in the club, the course of Premier League history would have been changed to almost exactly the same magnitude, albeit it in a very different manner.
For starters, the stars who made moves to Stamford Bridge may never have moved at all - one who definitely would have joined the Premier League was Michael Ballack but his destination would have been Old Trafford to replace Roy Keane but the same cannot be said of Didier Drogba; it's probable he would have made waves in Spain instead as a Galactico.
Jose Mourinho was a key player in Chelsea's successes but the Special One would have found work elsewhere, possibly all around Europe before directly replacing Sir Alex Ferguson or even Arsene Wenger. As for Chelsea management, with lower ambitions at the club, Claudio Ranieri would have retained his position and you can say for certain that he would never have led Leicester City to the title with such a cushty role in the capital.
Mediocrity for life at Chelsea is almost assured had Roman Abramovich's takeover never come to pass.
1. Cristiano Ronaldo stays at Man Utd
Every one knows this story. A skinny Portuguese lad ripping apart Sir Alex Ferguson's first team in a friendly game resulted in a transfer and the road to stardom for one Cristiano Ronaldo. His debut against Bolton Wanderers changed the face of Premier League football for good but it was all over just as soon as it began.
Despite everything Ronaldo claims to owe to Manchester United and Sir Alex Ferguson, his feet started to itch in 2008 and he requested a transfer to Real Madrid amidst their persistent interest. Sir Alex convinced Cristiano to remain for one more year and he lifted the FIFA Club World Cup, the Balon d'Or, the FIFA World Player of the Year, the Puskas Award, the Premier League title and the League Cup trophies but that was that.
Had Ronaldo opted against a move to Real Madrid, Manchester United's subsequent seasons would have looked very differently indeed. The club would never have invested in the likes of Antonio Valencia, Michael Owen, Javier Hernandez, Robin Van Persie or any other player to replace Cristiano's immense goal threat.
Success would have been guaranteed as the club built team after team around Ronaldo but his chances of winning the Balon d'Or again would have been greatly diminished with Lionel Messi having no direct rival in Spain. Ronaldo's determination to win both club and individual trophies can never be questioned but Messi's exploits for Barcelona would look ever more impressive.
Did Ronaldo make his move to Real for selfish reasons? Almost definitely. He knew where he needed to be in order to secure his individual plaudits and he would never have reached the highs he has if he had remained in Manchester.