10 Players Who Should Regret Turning Down Man Utd
It's hard to say no to Manchester United - but many have, only to regret it.
Tom Hevezi/PA Archive/Press Association ImagesOver the last two decades, Old Trafford has been the place to be for footballers with Manchester United sweeping up 38 trophies - including 13 Premier League titles and two Champions League crowns in an astonishing 26 year golden era for the club. Little wonder anyone whos anyone has wanted to play for the Red Devils, and trot out in front of 76,000 people every week at the self-styled Theatre of Dreams. A team used to getting their own way, United have successfully persuaded some of the games greatest players to sign on the dotted line, such as Eric Cantona, Wayne Rooney and Cristiano Ronaldo. But what of those who have said no? Down the years, one or two brave souls have rejected Uniteds advances in order to stay at their current club or join the Red Devils rivals instead, while some of Uniteds own players have snubbed contract extensions in order to move on with their careers, only to discover that the grass rarely gets much greener than that on offer at Old Trafford. In honour of the players who have spurned Uniteds advances, or have taken the difficult decision to leave the club behind, here we take a look at 10 Players Who Should Regret Turning Down Man Utd. Click 'next' to begin.
10. Paolo di Canio
Rebecca Naden/PA Archive/Press Association ImagesIn 2002, Paolo di Canio received a phone call from Sir Alex Ferguson asking if he would like to play for Manchester United, but the mad-cap forward decided he'd prefer to get relegated with West Ham United instead of winning titles at Old Trafford. "It was Christmas and I got a call on my phone, and it was Ferguson," Di Canio recently revealed. Though you can't fault the Italian on his loyalty, it was hardly a decision that benefited his playing career. 12 months later, West Ham were near the bottom of the league and battling against the drop. Despite scoring against Chelsea in the penultimate game of the season, Di Canio could not prevent his side's relegation and was released on a free transfer before signing for Charlton Athletic."You could tell from his voice that he had been drinking and he asked me if I wanted to join Manchester United. To begin with, I thought it was a joke from a friend and I told him where to go three times before I realised it really was him. I then said no. I was captain of West Ham and I couldn't accept."
9. Steven Gerrard
Media Image LtdAnother player who chose loyalty over glory is Steven Gerrard, still at Liverpool and still in pursuit of that ever elusive Premier League title. The Reds skipper revealed he rejected the chance to play for United on more than one occasion, because he couldn't bear betraying the Kop. "I went on trial at Manchester United when I was 13 and had a letter off them wanting to sign me on a seven-year-deal," Gerrard once said. Instead, he stayed at Anfield and the Red Devils soon came calling once more. "He tried to sign me in early 2002/2003, he tried to sign me again to play for United, I obviously refused, so I cant really take it to heart too much. But Im a bit gutted because Im a big fan of his." You can understand Gerrard's reluctance to turn his back on Liverpool to play in the red of United instead, considering the pandemonium that would cause. But had he done so, he would surely have won more than the three League Cups, two FA Cups and one Champions League crown he has at Anfield. On the final day of last season, Gerrard's attempt to win his first ever Premier League title was dashed by Manchester City. He would have won it at their derby rivals.
8. Lucas Moura
Andrew Matthews/EMPICS SportDuring the summer of 2012, both Manchester United and Inter Milan were interested in signing Lucas Moura, then of Sao Paulo. However, the midfielder rejected their overtures in favour of a move to Paris Saint-Germain. So far, it is not a decision that has worked out very well. The attacking midfielder has been given only limited opportunities to impress at the French side, and though he has won two Ligue 1 crowns, has had to settle with playing a bit-part role at the club. In his first year at PSG, he managed just 10 appearances and started one game all season. In his second campaign, the midfielder made just seven starts. Given United's desperate need for midfield reinforcements over the last two years, it would be fair to assume Moura would have walked straight into their first team and featured far more prominently than he has currently. Instead, his head was turned by the money in France and he has paid for it by warming the bench ever since.
7. Henrik Larsson
Neal Simpson/EMPICS SportIn 2007, when the Swedish league took a winter break, Henrik Larsson joined Manchester United on loan from Helsinborgs on a short-term contract in the January transfer window. It was a move that shocked many, considering the player was in his mid-thirties at the time, but it was ultimately a successful one with the striker finishing up winning a Premier League title with the Red Devils. And he wishes he had stayed longer. When the Swedish league resumed in March, Larsson returned to Helsinborgs, despite repeated pleas from Sir Alex Ferguson for him to extend his stay at Old Trafford. 'If there is one regret I have from my career, it is that I came home to Sweden when Mr Ferguson was trying to get me to stay at Manchester United," Larsson admitted in 2010. 'I should have stayed at United for longer because I had a great time there and everyone at the club was very keen to keep me. My time there was too short.
'The whole experience was fantastic and, although I was 35 at the time, I still felt that I had some good football in me. That is a regret.'
6. Andy Cole
Barry Coombs/EMPICS SportIn 2001, Andy Cole called time on his illustrious six-year spell at Manchester United, where he had scored 93 goals in nearly 200 appearances, winning five Premier League titles, two FA Cups and the Champions League. He later revealed the decision was the only regret of his career. Cole was a huge fan favourite at Old Trafford and manager Sir Alex Ferguson was desperate to keep him. However, with the 2002 World Cup in Japan and South Korea on the horizon, and having seen first-team opportunities begin to dwindle at United, he opted for a move to Blackburn Rovers to keep his dream of representing England in the tournament alive. It didn't work out. Cole failed to make the final 23-man squad for Japan and South Korea and would later rue not staying at United for longer. The striker admitted: When I left the club, I wanted to play more games and I saw the manager numerous times. He told me that I didnt have to go, he didnt want me to go, I could have stayed for as long as I could and I would get my games. But I was trying to force myself into the World Cup squad."In the end, he just said Okay, I understand and I know what you are like, I will let you go. The crazy thing is that he sold me for £7million, which is more than what he paid for me. He got me for £6m and sold me for £7m. So I remember that last meeting with him like it was yesterday.
I really enjoyed my time but I left far too early. That is my only regret. I could have stayed at the football club for a lot longer and, looking back, I wish I had.
5. Thiago Alcantara
Adam Davy/EMPICS SportIn July 2013, despite strong interest from Manchester United, Thiago Alcantara joined Bayern Munich and shunned the opportunity to play for the Red Devils. He was rewarded with a slap around the face from Bayern boss Pep Guardiola. Alcantra had just called time on his stay at Barcelona, seeking first team opportunities. He didn't find that at the Allianz Arena either. The midfielder made only eight starts in a troubled debut campaign for the Bavarians last season, and was badly at fault in Bayern's 4-2 defeat to Borussia Dortmund in the German Super Cup last July. Unimpressed with his team's performance, Guardiola delivered a rollicking at half-time and sensationally slapped Alcantara in the face. It did little to wake him up, because he would go on to give the ball away in the build-up to one of Dortmund's goals. Alcantara's season would later be wrecked by a knee ligament tear in March and he must be wondering if things would have been any better at Manchester United.
4. Cesc Fabregas
Manu Fernandez/AP/Press Association ImagesLast year, Barcelona midfielder Cesc Fabregas was at the centre of one of the most protracted transfer sagas of the summer as Manchester United made repeated attempts to lure him back to England following an eight-year spell at Arsenal. Fabregas rejected the overtures however, in favour of staying at the Nou Camp to fight for his place. The Spaniard had struggled to regularly oust the aging Xavi and Andres Iniesta from the starting berths in Barcelona's midfield and made only 14 starts in 32 appearances for Barca in 2012-13. However, he opted to remain at the La Liga club, though later came to regret it when Barca went on to stutter through their first trophy-less campaign in six years. Worse still, Fabregas still had to settle for limited appearances in 2013-14, starting just 13 of his 36 games. Fabregas would have surely walked straight into United's starting XI had he joined 12 months ago, and probably wouldn't have had to make do with being second-choice.
3. Paul Gascoigne
ROBERTO PFEIL/AP/Press Association ImagesIn the mid-to-late eighties, Paul Gascoigne was one of the biggest draws in world football, tipped to go on to become one of the modern day greats. Unsurprisingly then, Manchester United were keen on acquiring his services and signing him from first club Newcastle United. In an inexplicable moment of madness, however, the then-21-year-old opted to reject Sir Alex Ferguson in favour of joining Tottenham Hotspur. Though Gascoigne won the FA Cup with Spurs in 1991, his time at White Hart Lane was ruined by injury, and the eccentric Englishman later admitted he should have joined United, and that one of his greatest regrets was not doing so. 'Gazza' could have won untold trophies at Old Trafford, and may have gone on to become one of the club's all-time greats. Realising his mistake, he tried to resurrect a move to United later in his career, but by then Fergie was no longer interested. Many pundits have wondered if the former midfielder's well-documented problems with alcoholism could have been avoided had he joined United, and whether Ferguson could have guided him down a less destructive path than the one he would unfortunately end up taking.
2. Wesley Sneijder
Adam Davy/EMPICS SportYears before the on-again-off-again pursuit of Cesc Fabregas, Manchester United were desperate to sign Inter Milan midfielder Wesley Sneijder. Sneijder was considered by many to be one of the very best players in his position, and in 2010, United tried persistently to bring him to Old Trafford, though the Dutchman rejected their advances to remain at Inter under new manager Rafael Benitez. That decision would go on to blow up in his face in the most remarkable of fashions. A year later, in 2011, Inter realised they had to slash their wage bill to comply with Uefa's financial fair play regulations or face being chucked out of the Champions League. High-end earners like Samuel Eto'o and Maican were moved on, but the club's biggest earner, Sneijder, remained. Inter told the Holland star to either accept a pay cut to stay at the club, or never play again, and Sneijder ended up rotting away on the bench for four months as his contract dispute rumbled on. Eventually, he was sold to Galatasaray, but is wasted on the lesser Turkish league and must know he could have been a smash hit for Manchester United in the Premier League.
1. Alan Shearer
Mike Egerton/EMPICS SportAlan Shearer is the second player on this list to have twice rejected a move to Manchester United, and as the now-bald BBC pundit looks back at his trophy cabinet he may well feel a pang of regret for not joining the Red Devils all those years ago. The first instance of Shearer snubbing a move to Old Trafford came in 1992. The striker was about to leave Southampton and in spite of United's interest, decided to join Blackburn Rovers after growing impatient as Sir Alex Ferguson's side took time to raise the funds for his transfer. The second instance was 1996. United had finally coughed up £15 million for the England hitman, who had won the Premier League with Rovers, but so too had Newcastle United. After extended talks at Old Trafford, a last-minute meeting with Kevin Keagan persuaded persuaded Shearer to join the Mapgpies instead. In hindsight, it wasn't the worst decision in the world. Shearer became Newcastle's highest ever goalscorer and a firm fan favourite. But he didn't add to the Premier League title he won with Blackburn and his trophy cabinet remained as bare as his head. Shearer would only lift one major trophy in his 18-year playing career, and he could have had it all at Manchester United.