10 Ridiculously Successful UFC Stars With Boring Fight Styles
Competitors whose entire approach is designed to lull the audience to sleep.
Gregory Payan/AP/Press Association ImagesMixed martial arts is one of the fastest growing sports in the world, both in scope and popularity, and a big reason for that is the sheer excitement caused by two competitors squaring off to throw hands and trade holds. UFC impresario Dana White is fond of saying that human beings are drawn to fights by nature, that our natural proclivities toward violence have helped make the sport the juggernaut that it is today. Athletes like Chuck Liddell, Wanderlei Silva, Anderson Silva and Shogun Rua have given the sport some of its most exhilarating moments in memorable clashes with game opponents. Who can forget epic brawls like Liddell vs. Silva and Rua vs. Henderson? Those are the kind of fights you show to a friend when trying to convince them of the awesomeness of MMA and convert them into lifelong fans. But for every one of those legendary rumbles, there are those fights that fail to capture the emotion and thrilling nature, whether its from a lack of effort or factors out of the hands of the men inside the cage. There are also those competitors whose entire approach is designed to lull the audience to sleep, from a style so snooze-inducingly boring that its impossible to root for them. Most of them wash out within a few years, because while yes, it is a sport, its primarily a business. And the goal of any business is to make money, which is hard to do when your athletes are driving away fans in droves. Occasionally men with that type of style slip through the cracks and hang around, and an even greater few have been known to be tremendously successful. Those are the mixed martial artists were going to focus on in this article. Here are 10 Ridiculously Successful UFC Stars With Boring Fight Styles
10. Randy Couture
wikiFormer heavyweight and light heavyweight champion Randy The Natural Couture is a legendary figure and unquestionably a Hall of Famer. Hes partaken in some of the biggest marquee fights in history, with his trilogy vs. Chuck Liddell, his comeback title win over Tim Sylvia and his loss to Brock Lesnar all being some of UFCs most anticipated matchups of all-time. For all the accolades we can toss Randys way, never let it be said that he set the world on fire with a barnstorming style full of fisticuffs and mayhem. Couture employed a very deliberate and focused attack, consisting mostly of grabbing a guy and leaning against the fence for 15 minutes, with occasional spurts of dirty boxing thrown in to make Joe Rogan lose his mind with enthusiasm. The most thrilling moments in Couture fights usually come with Randy on the losing end, such as Machidas front kick to the face or Lesnars bear-pawed beatddown. Thats not to disparage The Naturals lofty status amongst mixed martial arts lore, but he gets far more credit than he deserves when it comes to the quality of his fights. His popularity can never be questioned, however, and he earned his status one gruelingly-long 15 minute cage-hugging session at a time.
9. Frankie Edgar
David Becker/AP/Press Association ImagesIf I asked you to name a fighter who has tricked the fans into believing that his fights are exciting, The Answer should be Frankie Edgar. The featherweight from Toms River, NJ has managed to hang out at the top of his current division, as well as his former home at 155 by beating guys in close decisions, taking tremendous amounts of damage while dishing out very little in return. Dont let his most recent performance against a washed-up and always-overrated BJ Penn fool you: Edgar is all fancy footwork and speedy, flicking jabs. Hes a blur of constant movement, bouncing around all over the cage, bobbing and weaving while landing hardly anything of note. A 145-pound frenetic powerball. Hes the very definition of a point fighter-someone who looks to win via judges decision-rather than a finisher with a killer instinct. Look no further than his battles with BJ Penn and Gray Maynard for a prime example of his fighting skills pulling the wool over the eyes of the fans, convincing them that what they're seeing is heart-stopping action when in reality it's little more than sparring with the occasional full contact. Frankie's a winning fighter, but he isn't knocking or tapping dudes out very often.
8. Jake Shields
Matt Strasen/AP/Press Association ImagesHere's a guy so boring that he got booted from the UFC after going 3-1-1 in his last five fights, all against top competition. If that doesn't say all you need to know about Jake Shields then just watch a few of his fights. Shields has made a career out of pressing his body against his opponent and grinding against them on the mat to the point that it's surprising he hasn't gotten one of them pregnant yet. His 8 fight run in the UFC only saw one stoppage, and that was against him rather than by him. He earned his seat at the table through a succession of wins spanning 14 straight wins all the way back to 2005, and to be fair, there were some submissions sprinkled in throughout that streak. But the combination of his cottonball fists and his dry humping have placed him securely on this list.
7. Lyoto Machida
Felipe Dana/AP/Press Association ImagesHere's another choice that will inspire some debate, but if one has really been paying attention they'll realize that "The Dragon" is one of the more dull fighters in the octagon. Machida has long been been classified as "elusive", which is a polite way of saying he rarely engages his opponent in violence. He spends the majority of his bouts shifting around the cage effortlessly, dodging strikes and throwing a few counters here and there. Look at his recent title fight with Chris Weidman. Lyoto spent so much of the first three rounds avoiding contact that when crunch time hit he was so far down on the scorecards that he had to finish to win. He's technical and effective while bland and boring, kind of like an MMA version of Josh Groban: a fighter whose great for that particular style, but one who has a very niche fanbase that he appeals to, meanwhile the rest of us groan at the thought of having to watch him.
6. Tito Ortiz
A lot of thanks and praise should be given to Tito Oritz for everything positive that he did for the sport of mixed martial arts. He's the first UFC fighter to cross over into the mainstream and become an actual celebrity, and is the man who put the organization on the map as the first Zuffa-era star the company had. He's also responsible for drawing some of the biggest buyrates the industry has ever seen, with his wars with Chuck Liddell and Ken Shamrock being major moneymakers for the UFC. He's a Hall of Famer who has more than earned that right. But he's also not all that exciting to watch. Sure, in the very early days, when the sport had yet to fully evolve he was winning fights via TKO with elbow strike stoppages and tacking on a few submission wins. But the majority of his gameplan always consisted of double-leg, lay on top of the other guy and then do stuff. The Huntington Beach Bad Boy is a indeed a bad dude, one of the greatest champions in UFC history, and his record early in his career speaks for itself. But he was never popping viewers up out of their seats with any astonishing performances.
5. Tim Sylvia
wikimediaFormer UFC heavyweight champion Tim Sylvia wasn't always a boring fighter. In fact, early in his UFC career, during the height of his title run he was fairly exciting, at least for where the UFC heavyweight division was at the time. Standing a towering 6' 8" and tipping the HW scales at 265 lbs, the Maine-iac had an impressive streak of stoppages over such MMA legends as Cabbage Corriera (20-15) and Tra Telligman (7-5). It wasn't really until the rubber match in his trilogy of UFC title fights with Andrei Arlovski that he turned to the dark side. That match was one of the most excruciatingly tedious "fights" of all-time. There's been staring contests where people got hurt worse. They just looked at each other while square-dancing for 25 minutes. And thus began the run of awful Tim Sylvia fights. He followed that up with a crapfest against Jeff Monson, a complacent loss of his title to Randy Couture, and another dragging pattycake bout vs. Brandon Vera. After the Vera fight and a submission loss to Antonio Rodrigo Noguiera, the UFC sent Sylvia packing, where he spent his next several fights trying to test how fast he could lose consciousness. Which was only fitting since he had been causing fans to do so for a while.4. Chael Sonnen
Gregory Payan/AP/Press Association ImagesHe's one of the most popular and polarizing fighters ever, been a part of several of the best-selling cards the UFC has promoted, played a key role in the company's top feuds and made himself and his bosses tons of money. But when it comes down to brass tacks, his actions inside the cage aren't a fraction as entertaining as what he does when locked inside of it. When Chael Sonnen returned to the UFC in 2009, he lost his first fight by submission to Demian Maia in the opening round. Never one to give in to adversity, "The American Gangster" knuckled down and ground out three straight decision wins over Dan Miller, Yushin Okami and Nate Marquardt. None of those were pleasant to watch by any stretch, but that landed him a title shot against Anderson Silva, and thus the greatest rivalry in MMA began. No one will argue those two fights weren't thrilling just for the sheer spectacle, but sandwiched in between those were two snoozers with Brian Stann and Michael Bisping, where Sonnen used his superior wrestling to nullify his opponent's attack. The best thing you can say about Chael's fighting technique is that, while it often isn't pretty or even fun to watch, he does engage and go straight toward his opponent, which is more than can be said about some of the men on this list.
3. Michael Bisping
Gregory Payan/AP/Press Association ImagesLet's talk for a brief moment about one of the UFC's highest overachievers: "The Count" Michael Bisping. Here's a talented fighter who has fought some of the biggest names in each weight division he's competed in, yet with every few big wins comes a loss that pushes him back down the ladder. He's been "on the bubble" for a title shot for about five years now and isn't any closer than he was when the organization featured a much less talented roster. The problem is his approach. Michael Bisping is the MMA version of a substitute teacher: all busy work with no real substance. He moves around a lot, throws plenty of ineffective strikes and creates enough motion and delicate contact that people actually believe he's winning fights. But a close look at his record will show you that his only UFC finishes are over cans who were on their way back to the minor league circuit when Bisping beat them. There's not one impressive victory over a fighter of any note anywhere in his career. In fact, the only Bisping highlights have come from his mouth-either from him running it or being punched in it. It would be nice to see the talented UK competitor put all his tools together and realize his potential instead of continuing to unimpress by shadowboxing his way to decisions.
2. Jon Fitch
Eric Jamison/AP/Press Association ImagesIf you've seen one Jon Fitch fight, you've seen them all. You've also seen too many Jon Fitch fights. This is a man who Dana White absolutely could not wait to boot out of his company due to the monotous, mired-in-quicksand feel of watching him hug his opponents like he was trying to fight off hypothermia. Fitch's UFC record is an impressive 14-3-1, but his boss was so frustrated with his inability to finish that he was basically fighting for his job every time he stepped in the cage, because as soon as that third loss came (one of the three was against Georges St. Pierre in a title fight, ironically his best performance) he was jettisoned from the organization. That's because out of his 18 fights while under the Zuffa banner, 13 went to the judges. And the ones that did provide a finish were basically a gift of a mercy killing for the audience who had sat through what preceeded the endings. The former Purdue wrestler is very skilled at what he does, but unfortunately he's as good of an anesthesiologist as he is an MMA fighter.
1. Georges St. Pierre
Isaac Brekken/AP/Press Association ImagesLet's face it: there was only going to be one man to sit atop this list, and it's the same man who sat atop the welterweight throne for nearly six years before he vacated the title late last year. Arguably only two other gladiators who've ever graced the sport (Jon Jones and Anderson Silva) have been as naturally gifted as GSP. The man is a freak of nature, an athletic wonder who maintains a conditioning and training regimen head and shoulders above most of his peers. His work ethic is second to none and he's a beast inside the cage. Unfortunately that beast is content to play with its food rather than devour it, and that's the aspect of GSP's career that soured many fans on him. To witness someone so supremely talented fail to put away his foe time and time again was frustrating for us. This isn't some middle of the road guy we're talking about, it's the greatest welterweight in history. He had all the tools, it just felt like he refused to use them. Take the fight with Dan Hardy for example. GSP had "The Outlaw" in a deep armbar, but when Hardy didn't tap, rather than crank on a little more torque and potentially snap it, the champ relinquished the hold and changed positions. And his history has several of these nice guy moments. Once he forcefully exorcised the ghost of the Matt Serra fluke, his entire nine fight title reign was marred with decisions, except a TKO victory over BJ Penn where he was brought to tears and quit between rounds. The first few weren't such a big deal, but once the excuses started up it was hard to support the popular Canadian. "This was my toughest test, I tried my best and I will be even better in my next fight." And then we got a repeat of the previous outing. Georges St. Pierre is a legend, a future Hall of Famer, an amazing guy and one of the greatest MMA fighter to ever step into combat. But when it comes to putting on thrilling fights, we're not impressed with his performance.