10 Things We Learned From Week Two Of WWE's XFL
Was that opening week a one-off, or could Vinnie Mac do it again?
Week 2 was always going to be the acid test for Vince McMahon's revamped XFL. The opening weekend was a winner that earned praise from all corners of the sporting globe (including NFL hardcores like Cris Collinsworth and Troy Aikman), but longevity will be key.
Nobody wants another AAF to stink up pro football's sphere.
WWE are gonna' have to last longer than other NFL alternatives if they want any hangover laughter from 2001's failure to disappear completely. That's just the way it is, and they can't complain about any doubters scoffing their way through the first few weeks. Cheerfully, things look good, and room for improvement shouldn't be viewed as some worrying alarm bells ringing in the distance.
This week, the league offered up another four dynamic games for football-hungry fans. New York Guardians travelled to take on the impressive DC Defenders and Tampa Bay Vipers were at Seattle Dragons on Saturday. Sunday's lineup was filled out by Dallas Renegades visiting LA Wildcats and St. Louis Battlehawks at Houston Roughnecks.
Here's everything one fan learned, and how the XFL's second week compared to the first...
10. Crowds Were Up & Down
Last weekend was a promising opening for the XFL. McMahon and company were able to boast about a combined total of 68,818 across all four games in DC, Texas and New Jersey. That pleasing number was slightly down for Week 2, but there's no reason to start chewing fingernails.
DC Defenders had 15,031 for their second home game in a row against the Guardians, and Seattle swept everyone away in football fever by logging an amazing 29,172 for their home opener against the Vipers.
Seattle was ready for some XFL, apparently.
These are good signs for the league's future, especially in NFL-rich markets like Washington. Other venues, like the Wildcats' Dignity Health Sports Park, may need a bit of papering to make them worthwhile. Then again, that place had been an atmosphere vacuum for the LA Chargers in recent years.
9. Tackling Was Much Improved Over Week One
Teams in the XFL had very little in the way of proper reps before the league's opening week kicked off. Training camps had been soft on tackling, and that (combined with the understandable lack of cohesion amongst new teammates) made for some soft play.
What a difference seven days can make.
Most teams didn't even practice tackling before Week 1 due to fears over injuries, and it showed. By Week 2, all that rust had been shaken off, and it was possible to see significant improvements in pass rush; QBs barely had time to think before they were facing the prospect of hazardous sacks, and that sped up some of the snaps.
The benefits of competitive football and practicing for plays against teams they'd watched was there for all to see. If last week sometimes felt like NFL pre-season, then Week 2 had an air of the Playoffs about it.
8. Games Are Still Long
This is the most minor of complaints from someone who loves football, but it might be an ongoing concern for some.
Generally, games still aren't much quicker in the XFL when compared to their NFL counterparts. That was something many spotted during the league's opening week, and it's not something McMahon, Oliver Luck or anyone else with power moved to fix before Week 2.
Most matchups are clocking in at around the three hour mark. This makes a mockery of pre-launch claims that the XFL would be “faster” than the established NFL TV format. Overall, when commercial breaks, timeouts and other stoppages are taken into consideration, the XFL is pretty standard.
If Vince wants to grab the attention of casual fans who don't care about analysis or want a quicker product, then this needs to change. There isn't going to be much sympathy for NFL bashing if his XFL is almost identical in terms of game time.
7. Coaching & Player Mics Have Been Tweaked
Last week, the commentary teams on ESPN and FOX had a tough time adjusting to all the mic'd up coaches, players and other sideline reporters. They were regularly interrupted mid-point, and that can't have been easy to deal with for those who are responsible for narrating the game.
It's a good thing the XFL tweaked their presentation and tightened some screws.
Overall, there was less chatter pre-snap in this second week. ABC made smart use of 'All Access' segments post-ad break to fill in any gaps, and the announcers made coaching banter part of their gig rather than abruptly shutting the hell up so fans at home could hear play-calling.
It'll take some time to get this bang on, but it was another step in the right direction. Better yet, this kind of thing isn't something the NFL can really steal. Coach communication cuts off with 15 seconds left on the play clock there.
6. Post-Play Insight Is Still A Winner
Here's something the NFL can (and should) definitely steal.
It feels totally unique that the XFL has roving reporters getting the scoop from players immediately after each game's biggest plays. Hearing from QBs after they throw interceptions, for example, is a riot. This adds so, so much to the viewing experience.
Post-play insight shouldn't be written off as some gimmick that'll die out by mid-season either. There's a humble joy that comes from listening to players describe their route with excitement or regret, and it's a guilty pleasure to know upset kickers will be grilled after missing field goals.
Everything moves along at a zippy pace in the XFL, and the producers are doing a wonderful job of killing time between plays. That dedication to content, along with the shorter play clock, makes every game an easy watch for newcomers and football veterans.
5. DC’s Coach Got A Funny Phone Call
This entry is a tad random, but it's too funny not to include.
DC Defenders head coach Pep Hamilton has become an early league highlight by constantly communicating with his team and the announcers when they chime in. This week, those commentators shared a little anecdote about the effect mic'd up play-calling has.
Hamilton received a hilarious phone call from his grandmother after last week's win over Seattle. She told him how much she loved his 'Boiler Maker' (a double reverse pass play that caught everyone, including the Dragons' defensive line) by surprise. It was only then that Pep realised his plays were previewed on ABC before they happened.
This could potentially be problematic as the weeks roll on. There's absolutely nothing to stop teams from scouting out plays on TV and feeding info back to coaches so they can adjust. Potentially problematic, sure, but funny nonetheless.
4. The Lack Of Holding Penalties Is Refreshing
An awful lot of the refereeing teams the XFL use come from the college game, and that's a good thing. They're prone to letting things slide for the betterment of the sport. There hasn't been quite as many senseless holding penalties in the XFL thus far, at least compared to the flag-happy NFL crews.
The officials overseeing Week 2's lineup let everyone play with a sense of freedom, and they only called out blatant holds or fouls. That's something anyone who hates the constant stoppages those little yellow flags cause can get behind - it'll hopefully stick as the league develops, because there's no need to get whistle-happy.
Ironically, this guy was jotting down notes on the lack of penalties just as Seattle were punished for two holding calls in the same play. That got a giggle, but at least they were deserved and weren't soft decisions that hurt the game's flow.
Tampa Bay might disagree.
3. The Only Semi-Branded WWE Team Suck
WWE deserve praise for resisting the temptation to name every team after a pro wrestler on Raw, SmackDown or NXT. There's only one quasi-crossover, and that's the Tampa Bay team sharing nicknames with one Randy Orton.
Unlike the proud purveyor of the RKO, these Vipers suck.
Marc Trestman's squad are crying out for some respite. Although that might come when they play their home opener against the Houston Roughnecks in Week 3, Tampa Bay are already looking like they could become the XFL's first real stragglers. They're 0-2 on the season after back-to-back road games at New York and Seattle, and the team are dropping few clues that they're about to turn things around. If you've bought tickets for the Vipers' first game at Raymond James Stadium, be worried.
There could be more Florida fireworks coming from the 2-0 Roughnecks than fans will see when WWE rolls into Tampa for WrestleMania 36.
2. There's Room For Some WWE Crossover
If critics were expecting to blast Vince McMahon for using the relaunched XFL as a vehicle to promote WWE, then it looks like they're out of luck. McMahon, uncharacteristically, has shown a lot of restraint. There's next-to-no WWE crossover with his new football project.
This is something that should change over the coming weeks.
It makes sense for the XFL to promote WWE programming, especially on FOX, and nobody should have a problem if wrestling inserts eventually get sprinkled throughout broadcasts. Why wouldn't McMahon cross-promote? He runs the risk of missing out on some new fans if he doesn't.
Maybe something simple, like having a handful of wrestlers in attendance for games, would suffice here. Or, if that seems like too much and would steal spotlight from the actual players pulling on helmets, then WWE could get by with some video packages hyping upcoming events.
1. WWE Should Stick With This League
Week 2 was living proof that McMahon is onto a winner here.
Forget the opening week's critical acclaim, impressive ratings and solid football. None of that would've mattered a jot had the second week been crap. It wasn't, and was in fact some seriously solid stuff that should give WWE hope that this XFL will be around for the long haul.
There will be some bad games here and there (New York Guardians posted the league's first shutout by losing 27-0 to DC), but that's what happens in real sport. Not every single match can be a 28-24 classic like Roughnecks' win over the St. Louis Battlehawks turned into.
Ups and downs are part and parcel of the growth process, and they shouldn't deter McMahon from sticking by what he's created. He can be even more proud of what his XFL achieved in Week 2 than he surely was after the opening four games.
Vince is fired...up for some more football, and so is everyone else.
What did you think of the XFL's second week? For more like this, check out 10 Things WWE Fans Need To Know About The XFL and FIFA 21: 10 Reasons To Be Worried!