10 Worst Ever Premier League Panic Buys

If only these clubs had heeded the 'keep calm' advice of the famous posters!

Marouane Fellaini Man Utd
Mike Egerton/EMPICS Sport

Being in charge of a football club brings a lot of responsibilities, none more so important than being tasked with signing the best players.

Manchester United and Sir Alex Ferguson were often savvy in their dealings. They bagged themselves one helluva bargain in securing Eric Cantona from Leeds in 1992. Kevin Keegan also secured a coup in his first spell managing Newcastle when he somehow convinced Robert Lee the Toon was closer to London than Middlesbrough. Real Madrid even managed to make spending £80 million on Cristiano Ronaldo look like a steal when they purchased the Portuguese superstar in 2009.

However, for every top signing, there're plenty of grave errors that will go down in history as awful pieces of business. Since the introduction of the transfer windows, many clubs have found themselves void of a calm persona as time runs out and find themselves wasting millions by panic buying. Who was left with egg on their face after completing a dud deal? Which managers would have been better biting the bullet and sticking with what they already had?

Sometimes it's a case of better the devil you know, and that's certainly the deal in this list of stinkers.

10. Andy Carroll - Liverpool

Liverpool's Andy Carroll stands dejected
Peter Byrne/PA Archive

There was dismay on Tyneside as Newcastle fans watched Sky Sports News on Deadline Day in January 2011. They could only watch on as Liverpool had bid after bid rejected for the man who had fired the Toon back to the Premier League the season before.

However, little did they know it would turn out to be one of the best pieces of business Mike Ashley would conduct for the Magpies. Hours passed and as Liverpool kept knocking on the door with improved offers, Ashley finally got an offer too good to refuse - £35 million.

It was a deal which would see Carroll line up alongside Luis Suarez in a new-look front line at Anfield following Fernando Torres' departure to Chelsea for £50 million. With injuries and a lack of form threatening to derail his once promising career, Carroll could only watch as his Uruguayan strike partner received the plaudits.

Carroll eventually left Merseyside to join West Ham for less than half of the original outlay and will no doubt look back at his big-money move and think 'what if?'


9. Mario Balotelli - Liverpool

Liverpool's Mario Balotelli during the Barclays Premier League match at Anfield, Liverpool. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Saturday November 8, 2014. See PA story SOCCER Liverpool. Photo credit should read Peter Byrne/PA Wire. Editorial use on
Peter Byrne/PA Wire

With another failed striker purchase by Liverpool making the list, we promise this isn't a 'let's all laugh at Liverpool' post. The Italian famously brandished a shirt asking 'Why Always Me?' during his Manchester City days, but this signing had the Anfield faithful asking their club: 'why him?'.

It was seen as a risky signing when Brendan Rodgers forked out £16 million in 2014 on a man remembered as much for his off-field antics as those on the pitch in England. However, with striking options limited following Luis Suarez's departure to Barcelona, it was a risk the Northern Irishman was willing to take. A risk he must have sharp regretted.

With past Liverpool players including Michael Owen and Jamie Carragher branding the acquisition as a poor panic buy, the stats failed to provide an argument against their case. Time and time again the frontman looked disinterested and unsuited to Liverpool's style of play and it wasn't long before this unsuccessful relationship called for a break after a solitary Premier League goal.

After a loan spell with AC Milan, Balotelli left Merseyside for France to join Ligue 1's Nice on a free transfer, leaving the Kop licking their wounds after another bad bit of business.


8. Savio Nsereko - West Ham United

West Ham United's Savio Nsereko, seen on the pitch during their English Premier League soccer match against Manchester United at Upton Park stadium, London, Sunday Feb. 8, 2009. (AP Photo/Tom Hevezi) ** NO INTERNET/MOBILE USAGE WITHOUT FOOTBALL ASSOCIATIO
TOM HEVEZI/AP

You might be forgiven for asking 'who?'.

The German forward of Ugandan descent joined the Hammers in 2009 for £9 million and was supposed to be the man to fill the shoes of the departing Craig Bellamy. However, ten games later and without a goal to his name, he was shipped off to Fiorentina in a deal worth less than €3 million.

The striker also failed to hit the ground running in Italy, not registering a single first-team appearance for La Viola, and in 2012 he faced trial in Germany for staging his own kidnapping.

The 27-year-old has recently been announced by amateur German side FC Pipinsried as he continues his dramatic fall from grace.


7. Afonso Alves - Middlesbrough

Afonso Alves
Anna Gowthorpe/PA Archive/Press Association Images

Afonso Alves arrived at the Riverside in January 2008 with the reputation of being a prolific goalscorer. The £13 million-man was a striker in form in Holland, scoring 45 goals in just 39 games for Heerenveen - a record Cristiano Ronaldo would be proud of.

However, the player Gareth Southgate had pinned his hopes on being his struggling Middlesbrough side's saviour could not adapt to life in the Premier League. The Brazilian forward failed to find the net for his new team until April in his maiden season and only scored four times the following year - a season in which his club were relegated to the Championship.

With a poor return of only 10 goals in 41 games on Teesside, Alves was sent packing to Qatar with his reputation in tatters.


6. Marouane Fellaini - Manchester United

Marouane Fellaini
Martin Rickett/PA Archive/Press Association Images

It was 2013 and the Red Devils had just won the league once again, but their leader had decided to call it a day on his magnificent tenure in the hot seat at Old Trafford.

Sir Alex Ferguson placed his faith in David Moyes to be his successor at Manchester United, but his fellow Scot struggled to lure stellar names to the club. With big-money moves constantly being knocked back, most notably Gareth Bale, Moyes panicked and reverted to his old faithful at Everton, Marouane Fellaini.

The big-haired Belgian arrived late on in the summer transfer window for £27.5 million just weeks after his £20 million buyout clause had expired. Fellaini has rarely justified the big fee since making the switch, and the inflated price shows just how much of a panic buy he turned out to be.


5. Felipe Caicedo - Manchester City

Felipe Caicedo Espanyol
Daisuke Nakashima/AFLO/Nippon News/Corbis

Nowadays Manchester City are the moneybags who can afford to waste £5 million, but in 2008 that certainly wasn't the case.

Step up Felipe Caicedo. Jetting into Manchester on the final day of the January transfer window, the Citizens gifted money to Basel for their Ecuadorian striker. Netting only eight goals at City, the striker, once labelled as 'one of South America's top talents' by Sven-Göran Eriksson, was quickly loaned out to several clubs in a bid to get him off the books.

Now 28-years-old, Caicedo is plying his trade in Spain for Espanyol.


4. Andre Santos - Arsenal

Clarindo Andre Santos, Arsenal
Nick Potts/PA Archive

It's been argued that Andre Santos is possibly one of Arsene Wenger's worst ever signings. Cutting a chubby figure, the Brazilian who moved to the Emirates for £6.2 million in 2011 only managed 24 appearances for the Gunners.

But, if not cutting it on the pitch wasn't bad enough, Santos became public enemy number one in North London when he stupidly swapped shirts at half-time with Robin van Persie, after the Dutchman had put Manchester United ahead.

With the pairing certainly not a match made in heaven, Santos found himself exiled to Gremio on loan before making a permanent exit to Flamengo. As it turned out, their fans weren't too impressed by the player either. In 2014, the defender was on the receiving end of a few blows by angry Flamengo fans after watching their team get trounced 4-0 by Internacional.

Perhaps football just isn't for you, Andre?


3. Tal Ben Haim - Portsmouth

Tal Ben Haim Chelsea
Mike Egerton/EMPICS Sport

Portsmouth flashed the cash at Tal Ben Haim to make him join their cause on deadline day in 2009. Little did they know just how useless the former Manchester City player would turn out to be.

The Israeli must have laughed his way to the bank week in, week out when he was on the south coast, with his mammoth wages never being repaid by his on-field performances. At times his inept displays were that poor the Fratton Park crowd took to booing their own player.

And if it wasn't bad enough that he was a dud on the pitch, when Pompey were relegated for the second time to end up in League One, the former Chelsea man refused to take a pay cut in order to help the club stay afloat.


2. Chris Samba - QPR

Queens Park Rangers' Christopher Samba
Dominic Lipinski/PA Archive

At a time when Tony Fernandes was throwing money at the London club came the very poor decision to bring Chris Samba back to England.

After a successful stint at Blackburn, QPR must have forgotten to run the rule over the man mountain of a defender and chucked £12.5 million in Anzhi's direction for the by-then rather rotund centre-back - a deal they must surely have regretted quite quickly.

Signed for big money and on a massive contract, the 6'4" Congolese stopper managed only 10 appearance for the club before he packed his bags for a quick return to Russia.

So much for the saviour of the club eh, 'Arry?


1. Kim Kallstrom - Arsenal

Kim Kallstrom Spartak Moscow
Adam Davy/EMPICS Sport

Luckily for Arsenal, Kim Kallstrom's failed stint at the Emirates was only a loan move.

The veteran Swede arrived in north London in a bid to provide the squad with some much-needed steel in the centre of the park as they continued their bid for the Premier League title in 2014. However, with Kallstrom arriving from Spartak a month after the Russian winter break had started, the 31-year-old lacked match fitness. Not a big deal you may say? Add in the fact that he arrived with a damaged vertebrae in his back and this certainly wasn't one of Arsene Wenger's smartest moves.

Two months passed before he was able to pull on an Arsenal shirt and after a rather pathetic four appearances, the midfielder scurried back to Spartak with his tail firmly between his legs.


Contributor
Contributor

Geordie journalist with itchy feet having lived in Tenerife, France, Belfast and Australia.