11 Newcastle Players Who Fell Out With Managers

Man management doesn't always end as it should.

The life of a modern football manager is a complex, difficult thing: it used to be that players knew their place, didn't question leadership and the most taxing part of the job was plotting victories and working out tactics. But then agents and advisors appeared and managers were forced to be walking PR companies for their owners, as well as businessmen, coaches, negotiators and man managers. Inevitably now and then the pressure starts to show: this is a game of millions and the strain on a single man can be horrendous. So it's not their fault that they sometimes say the wrong thing in public and incense one of their own players, is it? And it's not just down to them when a decision goes south and players start to kick off. But at the end of the day, it's them who the players square up to, and occasionally throw punches at. Inevitably, because we support the Soap Opera club to end them all, clashes between managers and players at Newcastle have been frequent and spectacular, and the fall-outs have usually been major...

11. Joey Barton Vs Alan Shearer

Joseph the philosopher warrior has previous with upsetting people: he has a rap sheet almost as long as the list of clever books he reads before taking to Twitter, and he chose his silliest target as Newcastle head for relegation in 2009. Facing the difficult prospect of playing Liverpool, the cause wasn't helped when Barton took it upon himself to assault VXabi Alonso with an embarrassingly poor tackle that laid the Spaniard out. He was fined £65,000 for his silliness, but then details emerged that the midfielder had gone toe-to-toe with manager Alan Shearer:
€œJoey shouted at Alan that he was the best player at the club, which was why he had to play him. Alan said he wasn€™t, called him s*** and Joey replied that he was a s*** manager with s*** tactics. €œAt that point, it looked like they were going to have a full-scale brawl and had to be dragged apart.
Shearer has previously said how much of an important player Barton could be in Newcastle€™s fight against relegation, so his reaction to the red card was understandable. Barton's decision not to back down was just as inevitable.

10. Paul Cannell Vs Bill McGarry

The former striker - more well known for his time in America than in his native Newcastle - has never been one to mince his words, and his autobiography makes Roy Keane's latest bitter account look like a Mr Men book. When publicising the book, Cannell gave an interview to Black And White Daft in which he explained that he had a fairly volatile relationship with Bill McGarry, who was in charge for a disastrous run at Newcastle. He had been brought in as a disciplinarian, as Player Power had been an issue, and that clearly clashed with Cannell, who got in trouble for telling everyone what he thought of the boss:
"F*cking Bill McGarry, the tw*t. I€™d been to America on loan in 1976 and did pretty well and came back and that€™s when Gordon Lee had taken over, so I played regularly for a couple of seasons. And then Bill McGarry came in, and I f*cking hated him. I was doing a talk-in and they asked what I thought of Bill McGarry. And I said 'Put it this way, if I was on the 50th floor of a sky scraper threatening to jump and he came to talk me down, I€™d f*cking dive!' I said that I hated him and someone went and told him. He pulled me and said 'We don't get on do we?'"

9. Alan Shearer Vs Ruud Gullit

When Shearer and Gullit sat next to one another as pundits recently for Match Of The Day, it was clear that there was an almighty elephant in the room. The Dutchman of course famously dropped Shearer for the derby game that spelled the end of his career as Newcastle boss, and though he resigned he claims he was forced out by a witch-hunt even though Freddy Shepherd supported his dropping of Shearer. Shearer meanwhile clearly wasn't impressed with Gullit for the dropping, though he hasn't particularly come out and said much about him. Allaegedly he took the treatment of Rob Lee badly, and didn't agree with the ostracising of Paul Dalglish, who Gullit apparently froze out because he didn't like his dad. Something came to a head and the pair's relationship grew frosty with Gullit publicly admitting Shearer was a waste of money and over-rated:
"It was plain he didn't want to play for me. I told him to his face he was the most overrated player I have ever seen." "He thinks about himself all the time. It's always about his goals and not about the team."

8. Remie Streete Vs Willie Donachie

Newcastle have had two youth team controversies in the recent past: Peter Beardsley and Kenny Wharton were accused of bullying youth players, and subsequently cleared, but not without attracting some unfair attention, and then more recently, Willie Donachie was forced to leave the club after another issue. The reserve team manager sensationally quit the club after he had been suspended on allegations that he had hit prospect Remie Streete after a defeat by Sunderland. Rather than go through the investigation, Donachie instead chose to walk away seemingly suggesting rumours were true. The pair clashed after Streete had given away a penalty during the game, and Donachie is said to have lashed out and connected with the defender.

7. Yohan Cabaye Vs The Club

Another huffy Frenchman. He might be remembered as a hero by Newcastle fans praying for a loan return this January from PSG, but it should not be forgotten that Cabaye had angled to get out of the club well before he was eventually sent to France by Joe Kinnear. On the eve of the season last year, Arsene Wenger was said to be sniffing round the player - choosing a typically inappropriate time as usual - and Cabaye reacted with grace by falling out with Alan Pardew and going on strike to try and force a move. Unfortunately for him, Arsenal wouldn't pay the valuation, and he was forced to tuck his tail between his legs, but not before taking some almighty stick from fans.

6. Craig Bellamy Vs John Carver

You have to have a pretty special brain to pick a fight with John Carver. The Geordie coach has a notoriously volatile temperament - as Newcastle fans found out at Southampton recently - and he's hardly the kind of man you'd mess with at the best of times. Clearly nobody told Craig Bellamy, who clashed with Bobby Robson's number two ahead of Newcastle's 2004 UEFA Cup match against Mallorca, after Bellamy wound Carver up, as the striker admitted:
€œI arrived at the training ground and he wasn€™t there. He€™s a coach. He should have been in before me so I parked in his space. I knew it would wind him up. I walked past him later that morning and said €˜hiya€™, all proud of myself because of my little stunt, and he just walked straight past me without saying a word. It made me smile. I thought €˜job done€™. €œMy problem sometimes is that I don€™t know when to stop. So I kept winding him up. I wouldn€™t let it go. So by the time we got to Newcastle Airport to get the flight to Majorca, he was at snapping point and we had a confrontation. I was talking to someone else and I mentioned €˜JC€™ loudly enough to make sure he heard me poking fun at him"
Inevitably, Carver snapped, and the pair almost came to blows, though reports that Bellamy threw a chair at Carver are off the mark.

5. Charles N'Zogbia Vs Joe Kinnear

The Frenchman was always a little volatile at Newcastle: he openly admitted wanting out a couple of times, and claimed Arsenal and Tottenham were definitely interested in him - before signing for Wigan. The final straw of his career at Newcastle came when Joe Kinnear rolled up into Newcastle for his first ill-advised stint, and with typical grace and class mispronounced the midfielder's name as Insomnia. Understandably N'Zogbia was upset, taking it as a personal slight and refused point blank to play for Kinnear again, who responded by claiming the player was using it as an excuse to engineer a move. N'Zogbia's agent confirmed how upset he was:
"When you respect somebody you don't make this sort of mistake in a public situation. It is clear what he meant. If he meant it as a joke, it is a good joke for Kinnear but to Charles, it is not.

4. Fabricio Coloccini Vs Alan Pardew

Despite coming out in support of Alan Pardew twice already this season - most recently to confirm that everyone was tight at the club and had confidence in the manager (misplaced at best) - the Argentinian defender was reportedly one of the upset parties when the rails came off Newcastle's season last year. According the Mirror, Coloccini kicked off at Pardew regarding the way the team had been performing in the run up to the loss to Stoke last season, and at how poorly he was "managing" the situation. In an uncharacteristic stand against the manager, the furious captain let all of his true feelings about Pardew flood out in a tirade that shocked team-mates and will come as a surprise to fans in light of his subordination this year.

3. Andy Cole Vs Kevin Keegan

Kevin Keegan has always been well-publicised in his adoration of Andy Cole and his praise of what the bargain superstar did for Newcastle United, but the relationship between the two wasn't always smooth. In October 1993, the team were struggling for form, with losses against Southampton in the league and Wimbledon in the League Cup, and during a training session, Cole wasn't his usual energetic self:
"We were having a training session in London and I felt a bit jaded that day. €œDon€™t fancy it, today, Coley?€ Keegan said. €œI€™m just a bit tired boss,€ I said. €œWell if you don€™t fancy it, you can eff off,€ he said. €œSo, I effed off. I just got a taxi and left, and spent a few days with my girlfriend (now his wife), who was living in London at the time.€
It's ironic to see a player walking out, and not Keegan himself, considering his fondness for grandstanding gestures, but the fractures didn't last.

2. Hatem Ben Arfa Vs Alan Pardew

Back in April the maverick midfielder allegedly ended his Newcastle career after months of being scapegoated by a manager who fundamentally failed to integrate his talent into the team. According to the Express, Ben Arfa was packed off to France after a heated row with manager Alan Pardew that some rumours suggest turned physical. After Newcastle succumbed to a loss against Stoke City, Ben Arfa lost his rag after being frustrated by his lack of first-team options. The club and manager downplayed rumours that the Frenchman had hit out at the under-performing manager, but he was nonetheless sent home, as the club claimed he was injured. Ben Arfa apparently also told Pardew that both Sylvain Marveaux and Mapou Yanga- Mbiwa were also unhappy, and surprise, surprise, both have now been moved out of the club. But we're not here to speculate.

1. Craig Bellamy Vs Graeme Souness

Few Newcastle players have quite as many clashes on their record as Craig Bellamy, and only the Welshman has fallen out with two separate managers at the same club and antagonised the club's record scorer and most beloved hero. Bellamy engineered his Newcastle exit, despite earning the adoration of the crowd with some incredible performances - and that Feyenoord goal - by failing out with dour, terrible manager Graeme Souness. Souness had apparently demanded that the Welshman play on the right side, because that's the kind of manager he was, and Bellamy flatly refused saying he would fake injury if forced to play out of position. Bellamy then called Souness a liar over that claim, and was fined £80,000 and told he would never play for Newcastle as long as he was manager. He then went to Celtic, where he decided to antagonise Alan Shearer, by texting him after Newcastle's defeat to Man Utd in the 2005 FA Cup semi-final and telling him €œyour legs are gone. You€™re too old. You€™re too slow.€ Whether he remains on Shearer's Christmas card list is unclear.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.