20 Most Disgustingly Over-Paid Football Players

Over-paid and under-delivering.

PSG's Zlatan Ibrahimovic
Manu Fernandez/AP
Modern football is rubbish. Or at least that's how the nostalgics and retro-loving "proper" fans would have everyone would believe: it's poisoned by money, run by corrupt officials and spoiled by prima-donnas and cheat. At times it's hard to argue with that. It becomes especially difficult to understand the monster that the Beautiful Game has become when players who are on more than most people make in a year every couple of days and still cannot deliver on the pitch. They'll whinge at their poor treatment while driving away in super cars to their mansions, and there's a suspicion that they're all horribly out of touch with reality. But id it their fault? Or have the clubs contributed to their own downfall by giving silly amounts to players who simply are not worth it? Some players on astronomical wages are entirely worth it: Cesc Fabregas has already chipped in with 11 assists for his £200k a week, and Sergio Aguero is seriously good value even at £225k a week. But what about the overpaid ones?

20. Zlatan Ibrahimovic - PSG

Zlatan Ibrahimovic
Kin Cheung/AP/Press Association Images

Rating: £416,000

The exact details of the Swede's current deal at PSG are up for debate, but it would seem he's on something like £15-20m a year. That's an utterly jaw-dropping amount, and while he's a great talent, it's an obscene amount to pay anyone for anything.


19. Wayne Rooney - Man Utd

Manchester United's Wayne Rooney celebrates scoring the opening goal during the Barclays Premier League match at Old Trafford, Manchester.
Martin Rickett/PA Wire

Rating: £300,000

He might be England's most highly-rated talent but is anyone worth that kind of money? The short answer is no, particularly with United still struggling to find their Champions' form. But he would have left if he wasn't give this sort of money, so the club's hands were tied.


18. Falcao - Man Utd

Radamel Falcao Man Utd1
ManUtd.com

Rating: £265,000

On paper, Falcao's deal at United was staggeringly expensive considering it ended up with the Red Devils out of pocket without anything to show for it at the end of the season. He might well be the most expensive gamble ever (just ask Chelsea).


17. Yaya Toure - Man City

Yaya Toure Man City
Mike Egerton/EMPICS Sport

Rating: £240,000

Yes, he's reinvented City, but the Blues still struggle in the Champions League - the competition Toure was brought in to win - and despite his astronomical wages, he was involved in a ridiculous story in the summer about his unhappiness. The ultimate mercenary?


16. Robin Van Persie - Man Utd

Robin Van Persie Wayne Rooney Man Utd
Peter Byrne/PA Wire/Press Association Images

Rating: £225,000

Is 12 goals in a season worth almost a quarter of a million pounds a week? Van Persie at times looked a shadow of the player he was in his first season at United, and fans should have wondered why it took so long to move him on.


15. Mesut Ozil - Arsenal

Mesut Ozil Arsenal1
Kirsty Wigglesworth/AP/Press Association Images

Rating: £180,000

A brilliant signing on paper, Ozil initially flattered to deceive for Arsenal and he is once again being touted with a move away. There's no doubting his ability, but he blows hot and cold and £180k a week is way too much for that to be tolerated.


14. Fernando Torres - Chelsea

Chelsea's Fernando Torres looks dejected towards the end of the game
Anthony Devlin/Press Association

Rating: £175,000

At Liverpool, these wages would have been wholly justified, but Torres' career fell apart after the £50 million move to Chelsea and he's now back home with Atletico Madrid. Presumably to every Blues' fan's delight.


13. Robinho - Man City

Robinho man city
David Howarth/EMPICS Sport

Rating: £160,000

When Man City were boosted by billions of oil pounds, it was inevitable their wages would go up, and they duly obliged by spending an obscene amount of Robinho, who wasn't very good at all. Eventually he left, taking a pay cut, but even now, the Brazilian earns almost £80,000 to not play for AC Milan.


12. Alex Song - Barcelona

Alex Song Barcelona
SCOTT HEPPELL/AP/Press Association Images

Rating: £140,000

He found his feet at West Ham, and was highly rated at Arsenal, but Song's move to Barcelona simply didn't work out. He was reduced to cameos and stand-in appearances and simply isn't worth the high wages to the Spaniards, which is why they'll be delighted to see him leave permanently when he does.


11. Glen Johnson - Liverpool

Glen Johnson
Richard Sellers/PA Archive/Press Association Images

Rating: £139,000

The former Liverpool full-back hit the news recently when it turned out the club had offered him half of his current salary (set by the Mirror), forcing him to look elsewhere. He's a solid player, but Liverpool struggled last year at full-back and he didn't look a £100k a week plus player for a lot of that time.


10. Michael Owen - Newcastle

Newcastle's Michael Owen appears dejected during the Barclays Premier League match at St James' Park, Newcastle.
Owen Humphreys/PA Archive

Rating: £133,000

According to Derek Llambias, Newcastle unthinkably gave Michael Owen this huge amount when making him their record signing (and later tried to increase it), and were rewarded with injuries, a bad attitude and relegation. Good work all round.


9. Marco Borriello - Roma

Marco Borriello Roma
Paolo Giovannini/AP/Press Association Images

Rating: £85,000

From 2010 to 2015, Italian striker Borriello somehow managed to pick up somewhere between £80k and £100k a week for the Romans despite scoring a grand total of just 12 goals. He was also loaned out three times, and has had three clubs since leaving.


8. Riccardo Montolivo - AC Milan

AC Milan  Riccardo Montolivo
Antonio Calanni/AP

Rating: £100,000

AC Milan's financial problems are well documented, and it can't help them that misfiring Italian midfielder Montolivo - who has scored just 7 goals in almost 90 appearances and hasn't hit anything like his top form - is on around £100k a week according to Gazzetta Delo Sport.


7. Clint Dempsey - Seattle Sounders

Water comes off the head of Seattle Sounders' Clint Dempsey as he heads the ball against the Los Angeles Galaxy during an MLS soccer match, Saturday, Oct. 25, 2014, in Seattle. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)
Ted S. Warren/AP

Rating: £82,000

The American is the highest paid MLS player, picking up more in a year than 15 of the 19 teams in the league spend on total wages. Yes he's valuable but is that sort of structure breaking really worth 15 goals a season?


6. Philippe Mexes - AC Milan

French's defender of AC Milan Philippe Mexes enters the field at the start of his international friendly soccer match against Caen at the Michel dOrnano stadium in Caen, western France, Sunday, Oct. 13, 2013. (AP Photo/David Vincent)
David Vincent/AP

Rating: £76,000

For a long time Mexes was classed as one of Europe's top defenders, but for the past few years the Frenchman has been something of an embarrassment. And he's far from being good value for money at almost £80,000 a week.


5. Mateja Nastasic - Man City

Matija Nastasic Man City
Martin Rickett/PA Archive/Press Association Images

Rating: £75,000

When City brought the Serbian in it looked like they were signing a top young talent, but the reality was he barely made the first team squad.

He's now at Schalke, where he's actually valued and where he's presumably a lot richer than he used to be.


4. Park Ji-Sung - QPR

Queens Park Rangers' Ji-Sung Park
Alastair Grant/AP

Rating: £70,000

Another example of QPR's ludicrous transfer policy, the South Korean again failed to help the side stay up despite massive wages, and was loaned out to PSV before retirement. Unsurprisingly, he's now back at Man Utd working as an ambassador to help boost their Eastern market presence.


3. Alou Diarra - West Ham

Alou Diarra, West Ham United.
John Walton/EMPICS Sport

Rating: £60,000

Having played well at Euro 2012, West Ham picked up a bargain from Marseille, spending just £2m on the holding midfielder. Sadly, they also decided to take on his £60k wages, and watched as he got injured and lost form, and played just 6 times for the club before his contract was cancelled with a year still to run.


2. Shaun Wright-Phillips - QPR

Queens Park Rangers' Shaun Wright-Phillips
Alastair Grant/AP

Rating: £60,000

A relatively "normal" Premier League wage, but Wright-Phillips' move to QPR was indicative of the London club's foolish overspending ahead of their relegation, and he's still picking up the same amount despite not playing. Even in the Championship he only appeared 11 times.


1. Shay Given - Aston Villa

Aston Villa goalkeeper Shay Given
Chris Radburn/PA Archive

Rating: £55,0000

Given was once Newcastle's greatest asset, saving them tens of points a season, but since a move to Man City (where he was paid a massive £100k a week) he's steadily got less dependable and less fancied before falling out of the picture at Villa completely.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.