9 Most Ridiculous Panic Buys On Transfer Deadline Day

Never EVER buy a striker on deadline day.

Strange things can happen on transfer deadline day. Jim White pretends to be on the phone in the middle of broadcasting and is somehow proclaimed a legend; Julian Faubert somehow convinced Real Madrid to sign him, and Alan Pardew once stood flanked by Javier Mascherano and a particularly bemused looking Carlos Tevez with West Ham shirts. It's also a day for frantic phone calls, ludicrous over-valuations and the kind of deals that must have had everyone involved beetroot red with embarrassment in the years since. But the end of the transfer window is called silly season for a reason, and it's all down to the lack of logic that meets over-excitement and hype in a perfect storm to lead to the likes of Fernando Torres moving to Chelsea for approximately £40m more than he turned out to be worth. With that in mind, and with the current window closing, we're looking back at the silliest last minute moves of silly season. Here's hoping this window yields some more for our entertainment...

9. Afonso Alves - Middlesbrough

The Deal: From Heerenveen For £13m Somehow, Middlesbrough made themselves a reputation for signing supremely talented players, from the likes of Juninho (about 12 times) and Fabricio Ravinelli, to Gaizka Mendieta and Jonathan Woodgate. The last one aside, none of these players could ever possibly have picked up a Welcome To Boro brochure before signing their contracts. The club also had a habit of over-spending, and making bad decisions - like thinking Paul Merson was right for them - which led to the high-profile, hugely excessive signing of Brazilian "ace" Afonso Alves.

He came with high-billing, but it is an unfortunate truth that most strikers signed on transfer deadline day fail to live up to their fees, and he scored just 10 league goals in 42 games before he left for Al Sadd for an unthinkably high £7m in 2009.

The Warning Sign: He had scored a lot of goals, but they were in Holland, which is a surefire indication that he was never going to replicate the form in the Premier League.

8. Robinho - Man City

The Deal: £32.5m Once Man City were the mega-bucks entity they are now, it was always inevitable that there would be some huge transfers, and the Abu Dhabi United Group duly obliged, turning the 2008 transfer market into a squawk of silliness. The acquisition of the club only happened in late August, and the owners went about quickly making a statement of intent, looking for premium deals before the September 1st transfer deadline. The biggest of course came last minute, with the £32.5m deal for Real Madrid's Robinho, and City fans went wild. The trouble was, the deal was no more than an exercise in muscle-flexing - hence the inflated fee - and Robinho (who famously said he was excited to be moving to Chelsea) failed massively at City, costing £2m for every goal he scored. The Warning Signs: He cost an absolute fortune, and was Brazilian - which for a while there meant he wasn't suited to the Premier League.

7. Paul Konchesky - Liverpool

The Deal: Swap Deal From Fulham. Despite a successful reign at Fulham that earned him an auspicious move to Liverpool as boss, Roy Hodgson did not have the expected impact at Anfield. In fact, his time at Liverpool was nothing short of a disaster, and it was down to ludicrous decisions like signing Paul Konchesky. The full-back had been a key player for Fulham under Hodgson, so the future England manager decided to ignore the fact that he was no more than a middling talent and bring him to Anfield as his first choice left-back. He came in as a response to Hodgson's dire need for a left-back, and unfortunately his time at Liverpool was laughably poor. The Warning Signs: First off, Roy Hodgson signed him, and then there's the small fact that he was never the right quality of player by any stretch of the imagination.

6. Roman Pavlyuchenko - Spurs

The Deal: £13.7m From Spartak Moscow Proving once more the maxim that deadline day strikers are usually un uninspiring lot, Russian striker came in to Spurs on the last day of the summer window in 2008, with a price tag that suggested he was the real deal. Sadly, that wasn't the case, and stories of a bad attitude and a petulant demeanour meant his first-team opportunities were limited, and his scoring record consequently restricted. He blamed that on the arrival of Harry Redknapp, who he said didn't like him from the start. He was also apparently a lazy trainer, as Redknapp had told the press, and left the club eventually after 4 years and just 21 goals. The Warning Signs: 69 goals in 141 games for Spartak was not exactly worthy of more than £13m.

5. Andy Carroll - Liverpool

The Deal: £35m From Newcastle When it became clear that Liverpool were about to lose Fernando Torres to Chelsea for an eye-watering £50m, they needed to invest that money quickly to make sure they weren't left with limited options up front. For some reason they turned their attention to Newcastle's large hairy centre-forward, and cajoled Mike Ashley into parting with him for £35m. Newcastle fans took to the streets to wail at the time, but it became very obvious very quickly that he wasn't worth close to half of that, and Liverpool were shown to have had their pants royally pulled down over the deal. The Warning Signs: He had had less than a season of good form, and had something of a rap sheet when it came to bad behaviour. And in its own way, this deal led to another very late transfer move by Newcastle - or in fact a series of them...

4. Shefki Kuqi - Newcastle

The Deal: Free The deal to bring Kuqi to Newcastle as Andy Carroll's replacement wasn't the entirety of the story, and in honesty actually happened after the deadline, but what came before that was some of the most desperate "attempts" to sign a striker in transfer history. With time running out after Carroll's move - which Alan Pardew had categorically stated would not happen mere hours beforehand - Newcastle tried to sign Thierry Henry on loan, and more hilariously to sabotage Bryan Ruiz's move to Fulham. Eventually it became painfully clear that all the doors were closed and Newcastle were forced to turn to the Finnish hulk, who subsequently failed to score in 6 substitute appearances. The Warning Signs: He had failed to earn a permanent move to Derby after a loan in 2010. And he was Shefki Kuqi.

3. Benjani - Man City

The Deal: £3.87m From Portsmouth (Rising To £7.6m) Not long before Man City became a European super-power with the financial clout of a medium sized country, they were making difficult work of signing Portsmouth's Zimbabwean striker. The 29-year-old wasn't exactly prolific on the south coast, despite Sven-Goran Eriksson's attempts to call him a "quality player". The really questionable element is why City even went back in for the striker, having already pulled out after a knee injury came to light that initially made them turn their attentions elsewhere. But something changed, and City were so keen that they fought to ratify the deal after it went on after the deadline. For the fee, and his reported £50k a week wages, he scored a mere 4 goals before leaving, and proved to be no more than a last minute bad decision. The Warning Signs: His fitness, for a start, and the fact that his career goal-scoring record was largely terrible.

2. Marouane Fellaini - Man Utd

The Deal: £27.5m From Everton When Sir Alex Ferguson hand-picked David Moyes to take over from himself, he could scarcely have imagined that Manchester United would be facing the situation they currently are after the decision spectacularly back-fired. The Scot made tactical errors and was badly let down by the failure of the club's transfer team to do much of the necessary business. After an uninspiring summer, marked by wll-publicised failures the club finally splurged almost £30m on Everton's Belgian midfielder, which had more than the faintest whiff of desperation, and naturally it back-fired as well. Fellaini looks like half the player he was at Everton in his heyday, and if he weren't currently injured there's a good chance he wouldn't be there anymore. The Warning Signs: His form had already tailed off at Everton, and there was no way he was worth that much.

1. Kim Kallstrom - Arsenal

The Deal: Loan From Spartak Moscow There was never any doubt that Kim Kallstrom was no matter than a desperate attempt by Arsene Wenger to look busy in the transfer market. At the time of the move, the Swede was 31, and his medical had uncovered a back problem that would subsequently limit his appearances for the Gunners to just four. Regardless of that, Wenger decided to bring him in last minute in January of the 2013/14 season, as the club's only incoming business of that window. Kallstrom was never going to be a real first team option, and it looked like another wayward last minute decision by Wenger, who had over-spent on Mesut Ozil at the tail-end of the summer window. The Warning Signs: He was 31, injured and well past his best. Which other last minute deals do you think were desperate and ill-advised? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.