Every Premier League Club's Worst Ever Goalkeeper
Some fans suspected Massimo Taibi couldn't catch a cold.
The loneliest position on a football pitch, a goalkeeper serves as the last line of defence, and, according to more recent tactical developments, the first line of attack for any team. You only need to look at the teams that have found repeated success in the Premier League to see just how influential a top stopper can be.
Unlike other positions, mistakes as a number one are generally far more costly than anywhere else on the pitch, with only a momentary lapse of concentration enough to completely cancel out an otherwise excellent showing for a keeper.
Take for instance Massimo Taibi. The Italian stopper enjoyed an acclaimed career in his native country but will be forever remembered here for his ill-fated stint at Old Trafford.
With that in mind, it shouldn't be surprising that when a goalkeeper fails to perform at the standards expected of them that there are no shortage of fans, pundits, and managers waiting to let them know exactly what they think about their performance.
These keepers failed to live up to expectations and ultimately wrote their names into a club's history books for all the wrong reasons.
20. Arsenal - Vito Mannone
Historically, Arsenal has generally enjoyed a decent spell of shot-stoppers during its everpresent spell in the Premier League with David Seaman and Jens Lehmann enjoying lengthy stints between the sticks at Highbury. However, after the German's retirement in 2008, the club has seen a number of goalkeepers of various standards come and go, with none yet managing to instil the same kind of confidence in the Gunners' backline.
While at least the likes of Wojciech Szczesny and Lukasz Fabianski would go on to enjoy success elsewhere, the same could hardly be said about Vito Mannone who briefly looked set to take the reigns as the club's number one.
The Italian would ultimately be shipped out on several loans, and while undeniably decent, was never consistent enough to stake his claim at his parent club before later moving permanently to Sunderland.
19. Aston Villa - Peter Enckelman
Sometimes an entire club career can be boiled down to a single fatal error. This is perhaps most true for goalkeepers, where the consequences of a lapse of concentration almost always end up with the ball in the back of the net.
For Finnish international Peter Enckelman, his five years at Aston Villa are often boiled down to one embarrassing misstep.
After finally breaking into the first team after years of successive stints as understudy to David James and Peter Schmeichel, Enckleman finally made the first team in 2002 but would write himself into Villa infamy after allowing a seemingly innocuous throw-in from teammate Olof Mellberg trickle into his net. Enckelman would leave the club at the end of the season and never again managed to hold down a starting spot at an English club.
18. Bournemouth - Adam Federici
At the time of writing, unlike many of the other clubs on this list, Bournemouth hasn't suffered from employing a shaky stopper during their Premier League stint.
With that in mind, it feels a little harsh to give Australian keeper Adam Federici a place among some of the truly woeful goalies on this list. After all, Federici has been capped sixteen times by his native country and spent most of his time at Bournemouth on the substitutes bench.
However, having conceded 21 times in the eight games he was called upon for The Cherries in the Premier League there really could be no one else to occupy this spot.
17. Brighton & Hove Albion - David Button
Much like Bournemouth's Adam Federici, David Button is slightly unlucky to make this list with his inclusion probably more indicative of Brighton's brief Premier League stint than his own shortcomings as a keeper.
With that said, the former England youth international is probably just happy to have gotten any game time at the seaside club, having gone out on loan to a total of 13 times after coming through the ranks at Tottenham.
Despite being a capable backup, Button doesn't look set to challenge Seagulls number one Maty Ryan anytime soon which earns him his spot here.
16. Burnley - Brian Jensen
In recent years Burnely has been a hub of English goalkeeping talents with Tom Heaton, Nick Pope, and to a lesser extent, Joe Hart standing safe between the sticks, so Burnley's nominee to this cavalcade of crappy keepers instead comes from the Clarets ill-fated 2009/10 season.
Brian Jensen was the club's number one that year, playing in every game in what would perhaps unsurprisingly be his only ever Premier League appearances. Jensen's inclusion here is harsh as he was hindered by the equally poor defence in front of him, but with 82 goals conceded, including 5 before half time in a game against Man City, there really could be no one else.
15. Chelsea - Kepa Arrizabalaga
In years past, this position would be quite comfortably occupied by Mark Bosnich, after The Australian's time at the club ended unceremoniously when he was banned for failing a drug test. These days though, there is a new contender for the title of Chelsea's worst-ever Premier League goalkeeper.
Enter Kepa Arrizabalaga.
Signed for an eye-watering £71million in 2018 Kepa became the world's most expensive goalkeeper and was tasked with succeeding recently-departed Thibaut Courtois as the club's number one. Kepa quickly made himself a contentious figure at Stamford Bridge by defying then Blues-boss Maurizio Sarri's orders to be subbed off in the final minutes of the 2019 EFL Cup final, which the team went on to lose.
Kepa may not be the worst keeper to pay for the club in terms of technical ability, but when his frankly insane transfer fee is factored in, and the fact that he'd probably refuse to move if we tried to switch him with another goalie, his place here is secure.
14. Crystal Palace - Gabor Kiraly
Gabor Kiraly is probably best remembered by British football fans for always opting to play in grey joggers that made him look like he had just left Sports Direct, despite being a regular starter in one of the world's most lucrative sporting leagues.
Despite being revered for his international performances for his native Hungary, Kiraly failed to impress fans at Selhurst Park during his three years at Crystal Palace, often finding himself on the wrong side of errors during over 100 appearances with the club. In fact, the Hungarian's performances were so underwhelming in the 2004/05 season that he dropped in favour of Argentinan back-up Julian Speroni.
13. Everton - Paul Gerrard
Despite having a surname that would go on to become revered across the city, the blue half of Merseyside's Gerrard would not reach the same heights that his younger counterpart would go on to enjoy.
Paul Gerrard's career started brightly enough, making 18 appearances for England U21's before making the switch from his boyhood club Oldham to Everton for £1.5million, not a fee to scoff at for a young keeper in 1996.
However, despite the price tag, Gerrard failed to establish himself as Neville Southall's long-term successor and was often sent out on loan. His time at Goodison Park is probably best remembered for his injury that prompted Paulo Di Canio to complete his face turn by picking up the ball and refusing to score in the empty net.
Gerrard would go on to better things after leaving the club, but just 90 appearances across 8 years for the Toffees says it all.
12. Leicester City - Ricardo
Best known to fans on this part of the continent as the man who broke English hearts with his decisive penalty for Portugal in the Euro 2004 quarter-finals, then-Leicester boss Sven Goran Eriksson was presumably suffering from Stockholm syndrome when he decided to bring the goalkeeper to the King Power Stadium in 2011.
Despite Ricardo's impressive pedigree, he was ill-suited to the second tier of English football, often seeming uncomfortable with finding himself on the receiving end of stray elbows whilst rising to claim crosses. Just eight appearances followed, and the club ultimately decided not to renew the keeper's short-term deal at the end of the season.
11. Liverpool - Adam Bogdan
Current Liverpool goalkeeper Alisson may be one of the best between the sticks, but the current Premier League Champions haven't always been so lucky.
After falling out of favour at Bolton Wanderers, Hungarian international Adam Bogdan must have thought he was on the receiving end of an elaborate joke when Liverpool announced their intention to sign Bogdan to provide competition for their current crop of stoppers on the expiration of his contract in 2015.
Surprisingly, Bogdan earned an opportunity to prove himself in the first-team ranks at Anfield but it just wasn't to be. Conceding directly from a corner in a League Cup tie did little to inspire confidence among the Reds faithful and he moved to Hibernian last summer after making just two league starts in four years.
10. Manchester City - Andy Dibble
These days Manchester City can count on the safe hands and impressive distribution of Brazilian international Ederson between the sticks, but the goalkeeping situation in the blue side of Manchester hasn't always been so secure.
Back before City could count on their billionaire owners to sign some of the world's finest footballing talents, recruitment was well, less-than-stellar.
This is well-exemplified by the signing of Welsh goalkeeper Andy Dibble in 1988. Dibble ended up spending nine years at the club, but spent much of his time out on loan, and has the dubious honour of being best remembered for being on the wrong side of a controversial headed goal from Gary Crosby in a game against Nottingham Forest.
9. Manchester United - Massimo Taibi
There could only be one.
Perhaps the most infamous goalkeeper in the history of British football, Massimo Taibi was signed by Alex Ferguson in attempt to fill the Peter Schmeichel-sized hole that had remained in the club since the great Dane's departure in 1999.
The Italian's £4.5million fee was expensive for a goalkeeper by the turn of the Millennium standards, and big things were expected of Taibi at Old Trafford. Just four appearances later, including a notoriously gaffe-ridden performance against Southampton, and Taibi's status as United's worst-ever goalkeeper was cemented.
Despite his reputation with the Red Devils, its worth noting that Taibi would go on to enjoy a decent career in his native country, eventually hanging up his gloves in 2009.
8. Newcastle United - Jak Alnwick
Though Newcastle has often suffered from some regrettable transfer decisions, one area the Tyneside club long excelled in was between the posts.
The club enjoyed such a goalkeeping dynasty during the 2000s that the excellent Steve Harper was restricted to just 157 league appearances in two decades at the club, with longtime #1 Shay Given consistently ranked as one of the best keepers in the country during his prime.
Since then though, the Magpies shot-stopping fortunes have been mixed, to say the least. Academy graduate Jak Alnwick was tipped to do great things at St James' Park but failed to step up to the plate, looking shaky in six league appearances before being sold on to Port Vale in 2015.
7. Norwich - Michael Theo
Michael Theo was a talented goalkeeping prospect who had earned plaudits across his native Australia for his performances for a number of different A-League sides.
So when he signed for Norwich City as they were lingering in League One, most assumed that he would be able to successfully adapt to the English game.
Unfortunately for Theo, it wasn't to be. In his very first match between the sticks for the Canaries, he shipped five goals in the first half as the club ultimately sank 7-1 to Colchester United leading to boss Bryan Gunn's sacking. Unsurprisingly, the Aussie was promptly relegated to the reserves and never played for the club again.
6. Sheffield United - Steve Simonsen
Though all the players featured on this list will live on in infamy at their respective clubs for one reason or another, few will be able to encapsulate the failures of their respective stints in such a single moment as much as Steve Simonsen at Sheffield United.
In his first full season as Blades number one, the club suffered relegation to the third tier for the first time in over two decades but the worst was unfortunately yet to come for Simonsen.
The team narrowly missed out on automatic promotion but would get the chance to bounce straight back by reaching the League One Play-off Final. After keeping a clean sheet, the game went to penalties, with Simonsen sending his spot-kick over the bar to put an end to United's dreams of promotion.
5. Southampton - Tommy Forecast
Signed by the Saints in 2008, Tommy Forecast arrived from Tottenham in a deal that saw Southhampton waive the sell-on fee that they had for Gareth Bale.
With the deal presumably making sense to someone at the time, Forecast was expected to eventually contend for the number one shirt at St Mary's but he never even came close. A loan spell out at League Two Grimsby saw Forecast make a series of errors before embarrassingly being sent back prematurely to get him off the Mariner's wage bill.
Forecast would fail to leave an impression in Hampshire, being released without ever making a senior appearance in 2013. To make matters worse, the Gareth Bale sell on fee they waived as part of Forecast's deal would have eventually been worth in excess of £20million when the Welsh star moved to Real Madrid.
4. Tottenham Hotspur - Ben Alnwick
Okay, it may seem like I'm being a little harsh on the Alnwick clan here. After all, older brother Ben Alnwick only featured once for Spurs in the Premier League. However, in the solitary appearance, he shipped four goals to a less-than clinical, already relegated, Burnley side, a total that ultimately amounted for nearly 10% of the Clarets goals that season.
Though it appears he has now found his level at League One club Bolton Wanderers, his time at Spurs will probably not be one to remember for Alnwick.
Heurelho Gomes was also considered for this spot given his inconsistent, and often erratic performances at White Hart Lane, but the Brazilian's incredible shot-stopping ensured he does not feature in our hall of shame.
3. Watford - Jack Bonham
In fairness to Jack Bonham, his solitary appearance for Watford must have come as a shock to just about everyone at the club. Initially not even set to be part of the squad in the final game of the season against Leeds United, the former Republic of Ireland youth international was brought in to sit on the bench after Manuel Almunia suffered an injury during the warmup.
Then with less than half an hour remaining, an further injury to Jonathan Bond meant that the teenager would make his league bow in the crucial game. Two fatal mistakes leading to goals from Bonham followed, with Watford ultimately losing 2-1.
Though he would be released at the end of the season, Bonham has since cemented himself as number one at League One Gillingham.
2. West Ham United - Roberto
One of the more recent gaffing goalies on this list, Roberto was poised to enjoy success in the Premier League after establishing himself in Greece with Olympiacos, but it just wasn't to be.
After arriving at the London Stadium on a free transfer at the beginning of this season, Roberto was given a chance to make his mark on the club when Hammers first-choice Lukasz Fabianski suffered an injury that ruled him out for two months.
Unfortunately, the Spanish youth international failed to adapt to English football, making a series of basic errors leading to Manuel Pellegrini ultimately preferring reserve stopper David Martin to provide cover in Fabianski's absence.
1. Wolves - Emiliano Martinez
Unlike some of the other clubs on this list, Wolves have actually been pretty lucky when it comes to goalkeepers in recent years. However, Emiliano Martinez deserves a dishonourable mention for his brief spell with the club.
With Carl Ikeme having established himself as the club's longtime number one, many fans questioned the decision to bring Argentinian youth international Martinez to the club on loan in 2015.
Martinez is developing into a capable understudy at the Emirates these days but in 2015 his confidence just wasn't quite there yet. During his single season at Molineaux Martinez failed to maintain his form and a shoddy showing against QPR sounded the death knell for his time in the West Midlands.