FIFA 15: 11 Leaked Man Utd Player Ratings

The virtual Fellaini has taken a hammering after the real Fellaini's poor showings for United, according to these ratings leaks...

Manchester United endured a dismal season under former manager David Moyes last term, and have paid for their failings by missing out on European football after finishing seventh place. And their dire campaign under the Scotsman has been further punished by some less-than-flattering player ratings in FIFA 15. FIFA 15, the latest in EA Sport's long-running and popular football simulation series, isn't due on store shelves until September 26 here in the UK, but that hasn't prevented us from seeing player ratings for the likes of Arsenal and Liverpool. And now, ratings for some of United's flops have also been supposedly unveiled. Player ratings in the FIFA franchise are always a source of contention as, each year, the publishers attach a score value that dictates a player's overall performance levels and reflects on the season he has just had with his club. And after taking a look back in quiet reflection at United's season in 2013-14, EA have not liked what they've seen. How do the likes of Marouane Fellaini and Shinji Kagawa stack up in United's player ratings, and what of new signings Luke Shaw and Ander Herrera? Has Wayne Rooney improved on the 87 he managed in the previous instalment of the series? For the answer to these questions, click 'next' to get started.

11. David De Gea - 84

David de Gea is the most-improved goalkeeper in the Premier League of the last two seasons and that has been reflected in his apparent leaked rating in FIFA 15. In last year's iteration the Spanish shot-stopper racked up a rating of 82 and that has been boosted by two additional points following some impressive performances. Still only 23, de Gea is one of the youngest keepers in Europe and has enormous potential, and has been showing why those lofty expectations are justified by making a series of outstanding reflex stops last season - you need only watch replays of the block that denied James Chester in the closing moments of United's 3-2 Boxing Day win at Hull earlier this year for an example of this. There aren't too many United players who deserve an increase in rating in FIFA 15 following a series of dismal performances throughout the whole squad, however, if there is one player who deserves a boost right now it is most certainly the Spanish saver.

10. Rafael - 79

Another player who has apparently gone up is Rafael, who would seem to have risen one point from his rating of 78 in FIFA 14. Which is something of a surprise considering the fullback enjoyed a less-than-impressive season at Manchester United in 2013-14. The Brazilian endured an injury-stricken campaign and was limited to just 19 Premier League appearances last term, so we find this one a little odd. He may well be United's undisputed first-choice right-back when fit, however, that is owed to a lack of better options rather than to his ability as a defender. Rafael is apparently on a list of outcasts new manager Louis van Gaal is considering ditching this summer as he prepares an overhaul of his squad so this apparently-favourable rating may well benefit a club other than United by the time FIFA 15 hits store shelves. Whatever the case, a rating of 79 is certainly overly-generous and does not adequately reflect the fullback's performances throughout the course of the 2013-14 season, and it might have made better sense to keep his rating at 78 considering he scarcely played.

9. Chris Smalling - 78

One player who has stayed right where he is is Chris Smalling, which is quite fitting really considering the Manchester United defender's career hasn't progressed in quite the way he had hoped for when he moved to Old Trafford from Fulham in 2010. The centre-back was used sparingly under the Sir Alex Ferguson regime and again had limited playing time under his successor David Moyes last term, making just 19 Premier League starts. The defender was however still able to claw his way into England manager Roy Hodgson's 23-man World Cup squad this summer though made only one appearance for his country at the finals in Brazil with the Three Lions being knocked out at the group stage. At 24 it was hoped Smalling would have moved a little further down the line with his development by now but with veteran centre-halves Rio Ferdinand and Nemanja Vidic leaving the club this summer, the youngster could get more opportunities to prove himself in 2014-15. His performance levels don't warrant movement from his current rating of 78, however.

8. Phil Jones - 79

Phil Jones has also seen a rise in ratings if the leak is to be believed with the centre-half climbing one point from his value of 78 in FIFA 14. This would appear to be warranted considering Jones put in some encouraging performances last season, starting 23 of the 26 Premier League appearances he made last term. Jones is a brave centre-back and would throw himself on a live grenade for his team, such is his commitment for the cause. He puts his head where others would be afraid to put their feet and his occasionally-patchy injury record is a testament to his courageousness. With Rio Ferdinand and Nemanja Vidic gone and new manager Louis van Gaal favouring a 4-3-3 formation that places emphasis on defenders, we will likely see much more of the England star this season. However, though he showed promise last term with his dedication to the cause, that commitment can at times boarder on rash and there have been occasions where the 22-year-old has lost his head. Considering he is set to make the centre-half slot his own at Old Trafford over the next five years or so though, we think a gradual increase in rating is a fair enough reflection on his performances and potential.

7. Luke Shaw - 76

Luke Shaw however has been hard done by. Though his rating has risen sharply from the 72 he was awarded in FIFA 14, we don't believe a boost of four points adequately reflects just how far the former Southampton man has come over the last 12 months. Shaw became the world's fourth-most expensive defender in history when he joined Manchester United for £27 million earlier this summer and is one of the costliest teenagers in football. He excelled for the Saints, making 35 Premier League appearances and at one stage in the season helping the south coast club maintain the incredible record of having one of the meanest defences in Europe. Shaw also marshalled his side to their best ever league finish, helping them place eighth, and was named in the PFA Premier League Team of the Year for 2013-14 as reward for his performances. So we find it slightly ludicrous that United's new signing hasn't climbed closer to the 80 point margin than he has according to the leaked ratings, particularly as Rafael has risen to 79. If the Brazilian is worth that much then surely Shaw is as well?

6. Marouane Fellaini - 77

Oh dear Marouane Fellaini, how the mighty have fallen. 12 months ago, the midfielder commanded a rating of 81 - but that was 12 months ago. Now, following his disastrous move to Manchester United, Fellaini's virtual stock has plummeted by four points to a cringe-worthy 77 - according to the leak. Fellaini was impressive for Everton in 2012-13, scoring 11 goals in 31 appearances and finishing as the Toffee's highest goalscorer. This prompted United to make a £27 million bid last summer and the box-to-box star arrived at Old Trafford on transfer deadline day after some last-minute wrangling. But he might have wished he'd stayed on Merseyside because he's bombed for the Red Devils, failing to score a single goal for his new side and making just 16 Premier League appearances due to a combination of injury and poor form. So it's only right the Belgian's rating should nosedive in such a way, as he has been dire since leaving Everton. He will be hoping a better second season in 2014-15 will salvage his career but for the time being an alarming slump to 77 seems about right - in fact, he could have slid even further down the ratings to be fair.

5. Ander Herrera - 81

Manchester United's other new signing, Ander Herrera, has been given a much fairer rating according to the leaks. The former Athletic Bilbao man has stepped up two points from his previous rating in FIFA 14 from 79 to 81. Herrera joined United this summer from Bilbao and if his performance for his new club during their 7-0 pre-season thrashing of LA Galaxy is of any indication, that boost of rating is justified. Herrera provided three assists in the demotion of the MLS club and his range of passing is exquisite, making him look like the long-term successor to Paul Scholes the Red Devils have long been searching for. The 24-year-old also shone in La Liga last season, scoring five goals and providing the same number of assists to help Bilbao finish fourth and qualify for this season's Champions League play-off round. United paid big money to bring the boy from Basque to Old Trafford this summer - a reported £28 million - which shows they obviously see the potential in Herrera. And according to the leaks for FIFA 15, it would appear as though EA agree with those estimations.

4. Shinji Kagawa - 82

Shinji Kagawa admitted earlier this month that last season "was tough" for him and the Japanese playmaker hasn't settled since moving to Manchester United from Borussia Dortmund in 2012. That's probably one of the reasons why his rating has dipped from 83 in FIFA 14 to 82 in the newest instalment in the series - so say the leaks at least. Kagawa only started five full games in the Premier League last season and failed to score a single goal for the Red Devils. He did however provide three assists but that's still a paltry return, with the midfielder's game dropping alarmingly following his move from Germany. The Japan international scored 13 Bundesliga goals in 31 appearances in his final season with Dortmund in 2011-12 but hasn't been able to replicate those performance levels at Old Trafford thus far. There are concerns over whether Kagawa will manage to get in the United team this season with Juan Mata currently holding his favoured No.10 spot, and unless he gets the opportunity to prove himself on a more frequent basis we can only see his rating dip over the coming years.

3. Juan Mata - 87

Speaking of Juan Mata, Manchester United's January signing has stayed exactly where he was 12 months ago with his move to United doing little to increase his career prospects - on FIFA 15, at least. Mata was rated 87 in FIFA 14 and maintains that rating in its successor, according to the recent leaks. We're not sure if we entirely agree with EA's apparent estimation of the Spaniard. Mata has shone since moving to Old Trafford and scored six goals in 15 Premier League appearances for his new side - not bad considering he played only half a season. Perhaps EA feel his performances in the first half of last season for Chelsea - which saw him used sparingly and fail to score - cancel out his displays in the second half, thus arriving at the conclusion to keep him where he is. Whatever the case, 87 is still a handsome rating and should Mata continue to impress at United as expected over the coming seasons we may perhaps see his score raise closer to the 90 point margin you could argue he deserves in the FIFA series.

2. Robin van Persie - 87

Robin van Persie had a somewhat imperious rating of 89 in FIFA 14 but a poor personal season at Manchester United in 2013-14 has apparently seen that score drop by two points. RVP commands a still-respectable rating of 87 in '15 and it's only right that EA have taken measures to bring the virtual Dutchman down a notch. The real van Persie suffered with injury last season and endured a somewhat wretched campaign under David Moyes, making only 21 Premier League appearances after being sidelined with a knee injury at various intervals. To his credit, the Holland World Cup star was still able to net 12 goals in the league but that's a considerable drop from the 26 he managed in 2012-13. As such it makes a lot of sense seeing van Persie's rating take a gradual nosedive but with compatriot Louis van Gaal now in charge at Old Trafford we could be about to see the Dutchman flourish under his countryman, with the pair enjoying a good working relationship. If van Gaal can get the best out of RVP and return him to the levels he was at in his debut season at the club two years ago, van Persie will be back near the 89 point threshold before long.

1. Wayne Rooney - 88

Not only has Wayne Rooney seen an increase in his rating from FIFA 14, but he also becomes Manchester United's highest-rated player in its successor with a blockbuster score of 88. That puts the striker one point up on his score last year and it's deserved considering he has to carry United on his own back at times last season. With Robin van Persie's aforementioned injury woes and Javier Hernandez and Danny Welbeck's inconsistent performances, it was up to Rooney to bang the goals in and he duly obliged, putting away 17 in the Premier League to finish as United's top scorer for the 2013-14 campaign. It would seem a logical choice then to gradually raise the England man's performance rating and that's exactly what EA have done, according to the leaks. It remains to be seen if these player ratings prove legitimate and at this stage we must take them with a pinch of salt, but if they are accurate, then it's perhaps a good thing we haven't seen scores for the likes of Tom Cleverley and Ashley Young. Let us know what you think about these leaked ratings in the comments thread, below.

Contributor
Contributor

Joseph is an accredited football journalist and has interviewed nearly all of the current 20 Barclay's Premier League managers. He is also a correspondent for Bleacher Report and has written for Caught Offside and Give Me Football.