Liverpool Transfers: 10 Players They Should Sign

Who the transfer committee should be considering immediately.

File photo dated 02-05-2015 of Aston Villa's Christian Benteke celebrating scoring his side's first goal of the game during the Barclays Premier League match at Villa Park, Birmingham.
Nick Potts/PA Wire

The season is over, and the transfer season is about to start. 'Tis the time for countless unsubstatiated rumours and grinding sagas concerning which player is moving to which club, or which player wants a better deal from their current employers. And it's also the time for fans to watch Sky Sports nervously, hoping that their team will reinforce well and worrying that they might spend 20 million on another flop rather than buy the experience in midfield that they need.

One team that really needs to recruit well is Liverpool. Having received a lot of criticism for how they spent the money they got from Luis Suarez in the summer and having dropped four places in the league table, they urgently need to do something to turn things around to avoid being left behind by the likes of Chelsea and Manchester City. 

Furthermore, the end of the season seems to have left them with more holes in the team than ever before. Steven Gerrard is heading to America, Glen Johnson is out of contract leaving the team with minimal cover at right-back and they still need an efficient goalscorer to lead the line in light of Sturridge's injury problems.

Whether this is down to Brendan Rodgers - recently confirmed to stay on as manager - or the club's transfer committee is a moot point. They need to spend well this summer, and here's who they should be looking at - along with some concerns to keep in mind...

10. Jack Grealish

Aston Villa's Jack Grealish
Scott Heavey/EMPICS Sport

Why They Should Buy Him: 

Grealish is the flavour of the month at the moment, having broken onto the scene and into the public eye with his performance in Aston Villa's FA Cup semi-final win over Liverpool themselves. He's one of the most talented young  players of the moment, and at just 19 years of age he'd be a great investment for the future.

He's a flamboyant midfielder, able to attack well and go past people - his appearances so far suggest that he has the potential to become a real force. Buying him now would mean that he can start to gel with other young players coming through. The attacking thrust he provides means he'd be a suitable replacement for Raheem Sterling if the Merseyside club sell him.

Why They Shouldn't: 

Grealish doesn't have a lot of first-team experience, having only broken into Aston Villa's team towards the end of the season. Liverpool have spent a lot of money on a promising player with little Premier League experience before.

That was Andy Carroll for £35 million, and while there were a couple of good performances the transfer is widely regarded as one of the worst ever. It's something Liverpool would be careful to avoid doing again, and given his potential and Villa's likely unwillingness to part with him, Grealish would cost a lot of money.


9. Diego Godín

Atletico's Diego Godin celebrates after scoring during the Group A Champions League soccer match between Atletico de Madrid and Malmo at the Vicente Calderon stadium in Madrid, Spain, Wednesday, Oct. 22, 2014. (AP Photo/Andres Kudacki)
Andres Kudacki/AP

Why They Should Buy Him: 

One of the places where Liverpool were lacking this season was in defence; players like Sakho and Lovren didn't manage to offer solid defensive cover week in week out and for a large chunk of the season a midfielder (Emre Can) was filling in as a centre back. Diego Godín has been linked with the club on numerous occasions before, and he'd be the solid defender the Reds have been crying out for.

He's got a lot of experience of top leagues, having played in La Liga since 2007, for Villarreal then Atletico Madrid, so he'd add a steady hand for all the younger players, especially with Liverpool losing Gerrard's experience for next season. He's also got experience of Europe. something useful for the Reds as they try to clamber back into the Champions League.

Why They Shouldn't: 

While Godín would be a good signing for Liverpool, it's debatable whether he'd actually want to come. Atletico have been doing well in both La Liga and Europe in recent seasons, and have qualified for the Champions League, so it's unlikely that Godín will want to jettison that to play in the Europa League.

He wouldn't come cheap, either. He's an international reaching his peak, who's a key part of Atletico's team, so it would take a lot of money to prise him away.


8. Charlie Austin

Queens Park Rangers' Charlie Austin
Daniel Hambury/PA Archive

Why They Should Buy Him: 

Queens Park Rangers had a disastrous season; one which barely any of their multitude of veterans escaped with any credit at all. In fact, Austin is probably the only player to come out of it with his reputation enhanced by the experience. He managed to score 18 goals in 36 games for a team that were relegated, which remains an impressive record.

He's a powerful forward and a clinical finisher, and he'd be able to hold the ball up for the host of quick attackers that Liverpool have, allowing the likes of Sterling, Coutinho and Sturridge to tear apart opposing defences. He'd also provide a threat himself, and the support of the creative Liverpool players could help him take his goalscoring tally to the next level.

Why They Shouldn't: 

Despite his goalscoring tally, Austin isn't the most consistent player. While he is capable of scoring goals to win games, he can also go anonymous for long periods of play, a trait unnervingly similar to a lot of Liverpool's current attackers. This suggests that he might not be the dependable attacking threat that Liverpool crave up front.

Furthermore, QPR won't be willing to let one of their best players go without a fight, even if they were relegated. This will ramp up Austin's price, making him a more expensive option than he needs to be.


7. Mateo Kovačić

Inter Milan's Mateo Kovacic controls the ball during the Serie A soccer match between Inter Milan and Napoli at the San Siro stadium in Milan, Italy, Sunday, Oct. 19, 2014. (AP Photo/Antonio Calanni)
Antonio Calanni/AP

Why They Should Buy Him: 

Reports suggest that Liverpool are already making approaches for Inter Milan midfielder Mateo Kovačić, with numbers being suggested anywhere from £17- to £43 million. While the spread of numbers suggests this may only be rumour, he's a good target for the Reds. He's a highly promising player and reports suggest Inter would be willing to let him go for the right price.

He's a versatile midfielder who is able to play in both attacking and defensive roles, so he'd be able to fit in any holes in the Liverpool ranks and provide cover for the squad in case of injuries. That's not the main reason Liverpool should be after him, though. He's a skilful playmaker with excellent technical skills who maybe, just maybe, could be the long-term replacement for Steven Gerrard.

Why They Shouldn't: 

Kovačić has been part of the Inter Milan team for the past three seasons, and in that time they've slumped to some very disappointing finishes. If the Croatian can't carry one dozing giant in Inter Milan back into the limelight, there's no reason to believe he'll be able to do so for Liverpool.

Furthermore, midfield is not the most pressing concern for Rodgers. Kovačić is a talented midfielder, but Liverpool already have a number of those and fixing their defensive and attacking problems should be the priority.


6. Danny Ings

Burnley's Danny Ings celebrates
Lynne Cameron/EMPICS Sport

Why They Should Buy Him: 

Like Charlie Austin, Ings is a young English forward who bought himself widespread acclaim this season despite playing for a club that got relegated. He scored 11 in 35 Premier League appearance for Burnley, and while that's not on the same level as Austin, it's not to be sniffed at either. 

A mobile forward with an eye for goal and a lot of potential, Ings would fit well into Liverpool's high-energy squad. He's out of contract this summer, and while the Reds would still have to pay a compensation fee for him as he's under 24, he'd be a solid acquistion that wouldn't cost the earth.

Why They Shouldn't:

Ings has had some serious injury problems in the past, having had knee injuries that have kept him out for up to six months at a time. Given how Liverpools results and goal tally have suffered as a result of Daniel Sturridge's constant injury problems this season, they might not want to take the risk of buying another promising striker susceptible to serious injuries.

Additionally, his goal tally hasn't been as high as some of the other players on this list - scoring just 38 in 122 games for Burnley and given the disappointing scoring records of Lambert, Borini and Balotelli this season that has to be the main factor in Liverpool's recruitment.


5. Nathaniel Clyne

Nathaniel Clyne, Southampton.
Chris Ison/PA Archive

Why They Should Buy Him: 

The introduction mentioned that Glen Johnson's departure left Liverpool without many options at right-back: Emre Can has shown that he's better suited to midfield, and Jon Flanagan has been experiencing injury problems. Having received great acclaim as part of a Southampton team that finished seventh in the league, Nathaniel Clyne would be ideal for filling that void.

He's a fast, marauding full-back, able to get forward and hurt opponents like Johnson in his heyday. He'd add balance to Liverpool's team with the similarly-rampaging Alberto Moreno at left-back. Additionally, he's arguably better at defending than Johnson was which will come as a relief to a Liverpool defence with the disconcerting ability to ship goals.

He's also only 24, so he'd be a good investment for the future.

Why They Shouldn't: 

It'll be a struggle for the Reds to get Clyne. They've already had a £10 million bid for him rejected, so he's going to cost a lot. There'll probably be a prolonged transfer saga to boot, with other clubs sniffing around, and this clearly isn't an ideal scenario for the Anfield outfit.

Liverpool relied heavily on recruiting players from the Saints last season, too, and it didn't work out for them. That might give them reason to have second thoughts - what if Clyne didn't make the impact he's made for Southampton at Liverpool?


4. Edinson Cavani

PSG's Edinson Cavani, right, controls the ball in front of Barcelona's Javier Mascherano during the quarterfinal first leg Champions League soccer match between Paris Saint Germain and Barcelona at the Parc des Princes stadium in Paris, France, We
Christophe Ena/AP

Why They Should Buy Him: 

Liverpool still need a world-class striker to replace Luis Suarez, and Suarez' international teammate Edinson Cavani might be the best option. He'd offer varied threats; he's a fantastic goalscorer who can score thrilling goals from nowhere, and is a clinical dead ball specialist.

On top of being an established international with Uruguay, he's got a lot of experience playing with teams in top flights across Europe, having spent time at Napoli and winning the French Ligue 1 twice with Paris Saint-Germain. His scoring record for these two clubs is particularly impressive, scoring 78 in 104 games for Napoli and 34 in 65 for PSG.

Why They Shouldn't: 

Cavani has spent a lot of his career playing second fiddle in strike partnerships with superstars. He's been support for Zlatan Ibrahimovic at PSG and for Suarez with Uruguay. Even at Napoli it was arguably Ezequiel Lavezzi who was the main man. While this creates hope for a fantastic partnership with Daniel Sturridge or another forward, he might not be the man to carry the team in the manner of Suarez or Fernando Torres.

Additionally, he'd be expensive as PSG would want to recoup some of the 64 million euros they paid for him if they even wanted to sell him, and with Liverpool out of the Champion's League he might not even want to come.


3. Christian Benteke

File photo dated 08-02-2014 of Christian Benteke, Aston Villa.
Joe Giddens/PA Wire

Why They Should Buy Him: 

For the last couple of seasons Benteke has been one of the most sought after strikers in the Premier League. A powerful forward, he's basically unplayable when on form, able to batter defences into submission. He's a strong finisher and is deceptively mobile; a wide and varied set of attributes that make him ideal to lead the Reds forward line.

He'd also be available. It's been widely reported that he has a £32.5 million release clause in his contract with Aston Villa, and while that's a lot of money it'd mean no prolonged transfer saga or Villa rejecting all offers out of hand if the reds decided to go for him.

Why They Shouldn't: 

While Benteke did manage to hit form again when Villa needed him for their relegation battle, there was a long period this season where he just couldn't score. Given the amount of money they'd be spending on him, this is a concern the Liverpool management need to think about. They can't afford another striker struggling to put the ball in the net.

Benteke can also be a volatile character and can let his temper get the better of him when provoked. While not as bad in this respect as Balotelli and Suarez, Liverpool may decide they've had enough of such problem strikers.


2. James Milner

Manchester City's James Milner
Martin Rickett/PA Archive

Why They Should Buy Him: 

Of all the players on this list, Milner is apparently the one that Liverpool are the closest to signing. With his contract up at Manchester City he's looking to move onto the next phase of his career and is in talks with the Anfield club. If they do get him, he'd add a lot of experience - he's been in Premier League winning sides and is an England international.

Furthermore, he's versatile. He can play anywhere across the midfield, working well as a defensive midfielder and on the wings. He's also willing to put in a lot of graft; he's the kind of player who isn't showy, but who will battle until the final whistle.

Moreover, he'd free. And getting such a player without spending anything would be a real coup for Liverpool.

Why They Shouldn't: 

There aren't many downsides to signing Milner. There's maybe a concern with Liverpool's previous experience of signing a Premier League-winning England International on a free, with Joe Cole who didn't make the impact fans would hope for, so that's something for Rodgers and co. to keep in mind.

Liverpool also have a lot of midfielders already, with some deputising as attackers and defenders over the course of the season. Strengthening other positions is more urgent, but then getting Milner on a free won't stop them doing that.


1. Gonzalo Higuaín

Argentina's Gonzalo Higuain celebrates after putting the ball into the back of the net but the goal is disallowed for offside during the FIFA World Cup Final at the Estadio do Maracana, Rio de Janerio, Brazil.
Mike Egerton/PA Archive

Why They Should Buy HIm: 

When talking of clinical finishers throughout Europe, Gonzalo Higuaín is one of the first that come to mind. An international with Argentina, he's racked up impressive goal tallies for Real Madrid and Napoli, scoring 107 in 190 games and 35 in 69 respectively. He was even rivalling the likes of Lionel Messi for the player with the best goals-to-shots ratio in Europe's top leagues at one point.

He'd fit perfectly in Liverpool's current team. Not only is he a fantastic finisher, but he can hold up the ball to allow pacey midfielders like Coutinho time to get forward. Furthermore, he's quick on the counter-attack, so could be the perfect focal point for the Anfield outfit's high energy playstyle.

He's also got the profile to be a marquee signing for Liverpool; someone who can get fans excited about the team again.

Why They Shouldn't: 

Higuaín has spent a huge amount of his career playing in the Champion's League. While Napoli didn't quite manage to secure a place this season, if he does decide to leave the fact that Liverpool didn't make it either could be a critical mark against them.

He'd also be expensive, possibly more so than some of the others on this list. Top quality strikers don't come cheap, and Napoli aren't going to want to lose one of their remaining ones. 


Contributor

Adam Livermore hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.